Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout2026-04-21 Town Council Afternoon Meeting Agenda and Support Documentation1.Call to Order (3:00pm) 2.Executive Session (3:00pm) (45 min.) Executive Session pursuant to C.R.S. § 24-6-402(4) (b) to hold a conference with the Town Attorney, to receive legal advice on specific legal questions on the topic of: 1. Reggie D. Delponte Residence Trust No. 1. a California trust; and Reggie D. Delponte Trust No. 2, a California trust vs Town of Vail, Case number 2025CV30066; and 2. West Lionshead Pre Development Agreement and 3. COLORADO MOTOR CARRIERS ASSOCIATION v, TOWN OF VAIL and POLICE CHIEF RYAN KENNEY Civil Action No.: 1:23-cv-02752-CNS-STV. 3.Presentation/Discussion (3:45pm) 3.1 Strategic Plan Update (3:45pm)30 min. Listen to presentation and provide feedback. Presenter(s): Russell Forrest, Town Manager Background: The purpose of the work session is to request feedback from the Town Council on the strategic plan and at the Council’s direction we will bring the plan back for approval on May 5, 2026. 3.2 Waste Diversion Update (4:15pm)30 min. Listen to presentation and provide feedback. Presenter(s): Beth Markham, Environmental Sustainability Manager Background: This memorandum and presentation provide the annual update to the Vail Town Council on waste diversion initiatives and the progress toward community waste diversion goals. 4.DRB/PEC (4:45pm) VAIL TOWN COUNCIL MEETING Afternoon Session Agenda Vail Town Council Chambers and virtually by Zoom. Zoom meeting link: https://vail.zoom.us/webinar/register/WN_1_I03FdjTzqTAX2PElxvKA 3:00 PM, April 21, 2026 Notes: Times of items are approximate, subject to change, and cannot be relied upon to determine what time Council will consider an item. Strategic Plan Memo 042126.docx Town of Vail Strategic Plan 2026 -040326 final draft (2).docx 2026 Strategic Plan Actions.pdf Waste Diversion Update Memorandum- 042126.pdf Recycling and Compost Update Presentation- 042126.pdf 1 4.1 DRB/PEC update (5 min.) 5.Information Update (4:50pm) 5.1 Update on Dark Sky Community Designation 5.2 Update on Vail Nature Center In-Stream Project 5.3 March 2, 2026 AIPP Meeting Minutes 5.4 March 10, 2026 VLHA Meeting Minutes 6.Matters from Mayor, Council, Town Manager and Committee Reports (4:50pm) 6.1 Matters from Mayor, Council and Committees (15 min.) 6.2 Town Manager Report (20 min.) 6.3 Council Matters and Status Update 7.Recess 5:25pm (estimate) 04-13-26 PEC Meeting Minutes.pdf 04-15-26 DRB Meeting Minutes.pdf Dark Sky Memo- Updated New Guidelines 042126.pdf Staff_Memorandum_VNC_In-Stream_Project_TC042126.pdf March 2, 2026 Minutes.pdf 2026-03-10 VLHA Meeting Minutes.pdf TM Update 042126 (1).docx Berlaimont Project Timeline Town Council 42126 .docx Edwards Easement Scoping Notice - Dec 2008.pdf Eagle County USFS Berlaimont Response 3.12.18.pdf Public Input.pdf 260421 Matters.docx Future Topics.docx Meeting agendas and materials can be accessed prior to meeting day on the Town of Vail website www.vail.gov. All Town Council meetings will be streamed live by High Five Access Media and available for public viewing as the meeting is happening. The meeting videos are also posted to High Five Access Media website the week following meeting day, www.highfivemedia.org. Please call 970-479-2460 for additional information. Sign language interpretation is available upon request with 48 hour notification dial 711. 2 AGENDA ITEM NO. 3.1 Item Cover Page DATE:April 21, 2026 TIME:30 min. SUBMITTED BY:Stephanie Bibbens, Town Manager ITEM TYPE:Presentation/Discussion AGENDA SECTION:Presentation/Discussion (3:45pm) SUBJECT:Strategic Plan Update (3:45pm) SUGGESTED ACTION:Listen to presentation and provide feedback. PRESENTER(S):Russell Forrest, Town Manager VAIL TOWN COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM REPORT ATTACHMENTS: Strategic Plan Memo 042126.docx Town of Vail Strategic Plan 2026 -040326 final draft (2).docx 2026 Strategic Plan Actions.pdf 3 To: Vail Town Council From: Russell Forrest, Town Manager Date: April 21, 2026 Subject: 2026 Strategic Plan __________________________________________________________________________ 1. PURPOSE AND INTRODUCTION On January 19 and 20, 2026, the Town Council met for two days to update the Town’s Strategic Plan that was last updated in 2024. Attached is that draft Strategic Plan. Also, Town Staff have created an action plan that is also attached to implement over the next five years to achieve the Town Council’s desired results. The purpose of the work session on April 21 is to request feedback from the Town Council on the strategic plan and at the Council’s direction we will bring the plan back for approval on May 5. 2. WHY DO A STRATEGIC PLAN? The purpose of a strategic plan is to identify the issues that are most important to Vail’s residents and guests. The Town Council’s role is to synthesize the feedback they have received and articulate the critical issues. The Town will then focus time and resources to address those issues in the next 1 to 5 years. A strategic plan will be used to develop future budgets (including the 2027 budget), creating departmental business plans, defining goals for Town personnel, and provide a framework of accountability for the organization. Both dollars and human resources will be aligned and targeted towards achieving the strategic results in this plan. Also with a strategic plan, a metric (a means of showing progress on goals/results) will be developed and communicated to the community. This plan will help ensure accountability for the organization, departments, and individual employees in achieving the Town’s strategic results. By creating a focus on addressing the most important issues over a 1- to 5-year time frame, significant results can occur that have measurable benefits for the community. While a strategic plan provides a level of discipline for budgeting and management, short-term actions that support strategic initiatives can still occur, allowing the Town to be opportunistic even if a strategy is not specifically in this plan. In addition, staff may propose different and/or amended actions to achieve Council results as implementation of this overall plan occurs. This Strategic Plan is intended to be a dynamic plan that is reviewed and updated at least every two years or more frequently if the need arises. The Town Manager, at least quarterly, will review progress on the strategic plan with the Town Council. 4 Town of Vail Page 2 3. ACTION PLAN The action plan, which is an attachment to the Strategic Plan, is a product staff has created to achieve the Town Council results. This is a dynamic document that will evolve and be updated. The costs for actions are still being developed and will be completed as part of the annual budget process. 2026 costs that staff can anticipate includes completing a Recreation Master Plan that would be matched with funds from the Vail Recreation District that that the VRD has already budgeted. The 50% cost the Town would fund is approximately $75,000. The actual cost would be determined after receiving actual proposals as the result of a request for proposals. This action will support the following result: “B.4 By December 2027, the Town Council will make a decision regarding the development of a community-anchored recreation center. Staff will be looking for savings as well to fund a internship to complete a number of the goals in the Governance action. An intern is also considered as a resource need to complete a number of actions related to the Governance priority. Staff will first see if savings can be found to obtain this resource before requesting new funding for this resource. 4. ACTION REQUESTED OF THE TOWN COUNCIL Council is requested to review the strategic plan and use the link that has been provided to include edits in the plan. Also, Council can simply share suggested edits at the meeting on April 21. Staff will then bring the f inal draft back to Council on May 5 for your approval. Council will note two questions in the draft strategic plan related to results on pages 5 and 6 of the draft: (specifically A.3 and B.1). Staff would also note that this plan does not address the day-to-day operations of the Town except for the strategic result in the Governance Section regarding creating Departmental business plans to enhance customer service. Staff has created the action plan in consideration of available resources. The action plan considers available resources to maintain a high level of service in daily operations and to successfully execute the Council strategic goals/results. New actions from the Council are always possible but they will compete for time and resources to achieve the Council’s strategic goals and provide daily services. Attachments: A. Draft 2026 Strategic Plan B. Draft Action Plan 5 1 WORKING DRAFT to Town Council on April 7, 2026 6 2 Executive Summary – 2026 Five Year Strategic Plan Vision: To be your favorite mountain town. Purpose: The purpose of the strategic plan is to identify and address the most important issues the Town of Vail is facing in the next five years. This plan will be used to align resources around measurable goals to address those critical strategic issues. Trends/Issues Council Considered: Key trends and issues considered in this plan include:  Value and Vibrancy: Commercial rental rates are pushing unique/locally owned businesses (retail, food and beverage) out of Vail and impacting the vitality and vibrancy of Vail’s commercial areas. Unpredictable winters, varying service levels and increasing costs on and off the mountain are also trends impacting the perception of value for our guests.  New Residents: With new homes for approximately 1,000 new residents coming becoming available in the next three years, does Vail have the amenities to support new younger residents? Continuing to enhance our sense of community for both existing and new residents will be critical to Vail’s success and creating new leaders in the future.  Financial Sustainability: Financial sustainability is critical as the town completes three large capital projects (Timber Ridge Village, Southface Vail, and Dobson Arena). Poor snow, potential for wildland fires, significant global turmoil and economic uncertainty, along with the need to add to the town’s fund balance make financial discipline important in the foreseeable future. Desired Results/Goals; Given the above-mentioned trends the Vail Town Council identified three goal areas supported by a fourth (Good Governance) which is an ongoing goal. • Create a Vibrant Vail Experience. Town policies, incentives, and special events will support year-round vibrancy and entrepreneurial initiatives from locally owned business so that guests and residents want to be in Vail’s commercial areas because they are fun, inviting, and aesthetically attractive. • Build a Strong Community. Successfully completing Timber Ridge, and Southface affordable housing developments, providing adequate childcare opportunities, creating places for our community to connect (library, recreation center) and cultivating our next generation of residents and leaders will be critical in building our sense of community. • Protect Our Mountain Environment: Reducing greenhouse gas emissions, protecting Gore Creek and the natural environment in and around Vail will continue to be priorities for the Town. In addition, being resilient to natural and manmade emergencies along with climate change will be critical to protecting our community and economy. The Town of Vail must continuously work on good governance to support the above-mentioned goals and to provide a high level of customer service. In the next several years there will be a focus on ensuring our land use and housing policies will be clear and understandable and of course achieve community goals. Departments will identify opportunities to measurably improve customer service. The town will also work on ensuring financial sustainability and that we are communicating proactively and transparently with the Vail community. 7 3 2026 Five Year Strategic Plan 1. PURPOSE AND INTRODUCTION This Strategic Plan’s purpose is to create real and meaningful results for our residents, businesses, and guests to address the most important issues identified in community surveys, plans and community conversations. This Strategic Plan, once approved, will provide a framework to align both human and financial resources to achieve critical results in addressing our community’s most important issues. On January 19 and 20, 2026, the Town Council met and updated the Town’s strategic plan that was created in 2024. This update includes a vision statement, mission, priority issues, and strategic results/goals. This plan is focused on how issues and goals will improve the lives of our customers who are our residents, guests, businesses, and employees that live, work, and play in Vail. To ground the Town Council on our customers’ perspectives, the planning session in January of 2026, started with a review of feedback received by five focus groups, as well as feedback from community and guest surveys. The Strategic Plan is intended to be updated every two years after a Town Council election. Town Council members in creating this plan are asked to consider long-term strategic issues but focus on creating meaningful results for our customers in the next two to five years. 2. MISSION AND VISION The mission or purpose of the Town of Vail defines why we exist as a local government in serving our residents, businesses, and guests. Our vision provides a direction and destination of where, as a community, we want to move towards in the future. After two days of reviewing stakeholder feedback and strategic issues, the Town Council created the following aspirational vison statement, which is premised on being a strong, vibrant community so that we can provide exceptional service and value for our guests. The Town of Vail’s vision is: To be your favorite mountain town. This vision:  Is about your connection and devotion to the place, whether you live, work or play here.  Being the best is rankings-oriented and hard to define, so we have set our sights on being your favorite, i.e. your go-to answer when someone asks, “What is your favorite mountain town?” Vail. No brainer.  Are we a resort or a community? Both, at the same time. We are a mountain town, here for all to enjoy what Mother Nature gave us. In February 2024, the Town Council articulated the following purpose: The purpose of the Town of Vail and the services we provide is to provide exceptional public services, to people who live, work, and play here so they can connect to the community and to nature, create memories, find opportunities to thrive, and have the time of their lives. 8 4 3. PROGRESS FROM 2024 STRATEGIC PLAN The Town Council completed a strategic plan in 2024, and we are still actively implementing this plan. Significant resources have been committed to the execution of three major capital projects including Dobson Arena, Timber Ridge and Southface. The 2024 Strategic Plan can be found on the town’s website. The last update on progress was presented to Town Council on Oct. 21, 2025. The public dashboard is available at https://performance.envisio.com/dashboard/Vail. Plan progress highlights include: Create a Strong Community and Create Affordable Housing Opportunities  570 homes for locals are currently under construction, including the town’s first Habitat for Humanity homes. Support Our Workforce  Significant council contributions to the Minturn Family Enrichment Center and new Early Childhood Education Center in Avon. Provide an Authentic Vail Experience  Launched the new early winter season “Stoke Sessions” concert series.  $55 million Dobson Ice Rink renovation is being created to enhance town events and continue a tradition of ice programs including Yetti games. Transportation  Year-round managed parking, creation of the Transit Route Optimization and Arrive Vail plans, and pedestrian improvements in West Vail.  Residents and employees are using transit more with improved CORE and Town services. The number of days on the Frontage Rd has been reduced. Environmental Sustainability  Initiating, after receiving a $1.8 million grant, the initial node of a geothermal district and finalized the town’s first car share program. This update will supersede the 2024 plan and build upon it. 4. 2026 STRATEGIC PLAN The following section includes the mission, priority Issues, and results from the January 19 and 20, 2026 planning sessions. Mission: The mission describes our purpose and the fundamental services we provide to the community and the desired impact of those services. The mission of the Town of Vail is to provide exceptional public services to people who live, work and play here so they can connect to the community and to nature, create memories, find opportunities to thrive, and have the time of their lives. Issues and Results: The following critical issues and results tie back to the feedback the Town received from the community. The 2026 Strategic Plan recognizes that completing three of the largest capital projects in Vail history including Timber Ridge Village, Southface Vail, and the 9 5 Dobson Arena remodel is critical and must be successfully completed with applicable development partners (Triumph, Corum, VRD respectively). It is also recognized that with each significant development project, there are inherent risks that will need to be managed and mitigated as with any development. These projects will continue to require significant human and financial resources in the next two to three years. The issues and results mentioned below reflect the necessity to successfully complete these three projects. It should be acknowledged that are is strong interconnectivity between the issues mentioned below. Goals related to community also support creating a vibrant guest experience. Environmental resiliency supports guests, residents, and employees by responding to the changing environment of the Rocky Mountains. The Town Council worked toward consensus in developing the following issues and strategic results. The following issues respond to trends and feedback the Town Council considered and the results reflect what our customers (residents, guests, and employees) will experience in addressing the following issues. A. Strategic Priority – Create a Vibrant Vail Experience: The Town of Vail has experienced an escalation in commercial rents that makes being a local entrepreneur with a brick-and- mortar store, particularly for food and beverage operations challenging. The trend of more exclusive national/international brand businesses pushing out unique locally owned businesses creates the risk of homogenizing Vail Village and Lionshead. At the same time with an increase in employee housing, there will be a greater demand for locally serving businesses, particularly in food and beverage. Another trend the Town must directly face is providing value and vibrancy to our guests and residents whether we have good snow years or not. Providing and communicating opportunities to have fun and an incredible experience in Vail regardless of snow conditions will be increasingly important in the future. Desired Results: A.1 By December 2028, realize a net 5% increase in locally owned and operated store front businesses. A.2. By December 2028, create polices, programming and organizational culture for the local business community to embrace and promote vibrancy and an environment of fun A.3 By March 2027, create policies and an organizational culture where community members and/or groups can utilize Town facilities. (Is this more of a “Build Community Topic”) A.4 By December 2027, residents and visitors will have access and utilize a playbook of diverse and compelling activities that are available in the TOV throughout the year. B. Strategic Priority – Build a Strong Community: With the Residences of Main Vail now completed, along with Timber Ridge Village and Southface Vail, the Town will have created 642 new homes for our community between the three projects. This new housing will provide homes totaling 1021 bedrooms. Creating a strong community that supports a world class guess experience was seen as being a critical issue in 2024 and continues to be an ongoing need and opportunity in the future. 10 6 Desired Results: B.1 By December 2026, the Town Council will receive and approve a development agreement to accomplish the community goals outlined in the West Lionshead Master Plan. (Creating community is a goal with the West Vail Master Plan. However, does this align better in Vibrant Vail Experience) B.2 By December 2029, parents/caregivers working in Vail needing childcare have access to affordable childcare located where they need it. B.3 By December 2031, Vail residents will experience an 820 unit increase in locally owned and occupied homes in residential neighborhoods, with construction beginning on the East Vail parcel by 2028. (Note: 820 includes the 570 units being built now and 250 new homes in the next 5 years) B.4 By December 2027, the Town Council will make a decision regarding the development of a community-anchored recreation center. B.5 By February 2028, the Town of Vail will begin intentionally developing the next generation of leaders within our community. C. Strategic Priority - Protect Our Mountain Environment: The high alpine natural environment of Vail and the Gore Valley as whole makes the Town and Vail Mountain a truly magical place for the Vail community and our guests. Our future as a community and local economy is very much tied to how we care for and live in harmony with our natural environment. With climate change, Vail also must be resilient to the changes that affect our valley and surrounding region. Both reducing our impact on the natural environment while also being resilient to a change in the environment will be increasingly important in the future. Desired Results: C.1 By December 2027, Vail and its partners will have a cohesive wildlife/environmental management plan for the Gore Valley to continue to promote, protect and enhance our natural habitat. C.2 By December 2029, Gore Creek will meet the requirements to no longer be a 303(d) listed impaired waterway which would reduce near term risk of losing the gold medal fishery status. C.3 By December 2027, the Town Council will receive and approve a community resiliency plan including economic, environmental, wildfire and organizational resiliency, including evacuation and continuity of operations plans. C.4 By December 2030, the Town will achieve a 50% reduction in carbon emissions and by December 2050, the Town will achieve an 80% reduction in carbon emissions against the 2014 baseline. D. Strategic Priority – Ensure Good Governance: There is both the need and opportunity, while the Town is financing three large capital projects to focus on improving the efficiency and 11 7 effectiveness of its services, policies, and customer service. Given there is limited capacity for new capital projects, particularly while Timber Ridge is being completed and sold out, there is the need to solicit customer feedback at a Departmental level and identify areas of improvement in day-to-day operations. The Town has added sections and provisions to the Town Code particularly the land use and housing regulations so that the current land use code is challenging to understand and lacks clarity. The Town is committed to excellent customer service but there is the need to be able to define what excellent customer service means and how to measure it. Desired Results: D.1 By December 2027, the Town of Vail will simplify and streamline communications to ensure information is transparent and accessible to the community. D.2 By July 2027, to better serve the current and future needs of the community, the Town will experience a complete overhaul of land use, housing, and design codes. D.3 By December 2027, the community will experience a customer focused organization and culture through the development of customer-focused strategic departmental business plans. D.4 By December 2027, the Town will pursue and implement innovative financial strategies to ensure the viability of our community for the next 50 years and deliver best-in-class services. 5. NEXT STEPS Staff would propose approving this plan via resolution as a next step after the language for vision, mission, priority issues, and results are acceptable to the Town Council. Attached is an action plan to support the completion of the above-mentioned results (Attachment B – still being developed). This strategic plan is focused on the next 2 to 5 years. Moving forward, staff will provide quarterly updates on progress related to results. A dashboard is envisioned that will be on the Town’s website and used in updates. It is recommended that after a Council election (every two years) the Strategic Plan is reviewed and updated as necessary. Finally, staff will create business plans for each Town Department to ensure that the Council strategic results are effectively implemented, and the Town Manager, department heads, and individual staff members are aligned and accountable to achieve the results. The business plans for departments would also speak to the day-to-day services that Departments provide for their customers. Feedback from departmental customers will be solicited and used to develop goals and actions to ensure the highest level of customer service based on available resources. Attachment A: Trends and Feedback Considered ATTACHMENT A: TRENDS AND FEEDBACK INCORPORATED INTO PLAN 12 8 I. BACKGROUND ON TRENDS CONSIDERED Staff synthesized the current state of implementation of existing strategic priorities, community survey information, previous discussions in the community and with Council, local, state-wide, and national trends and would acknowledge the following trends/issues for Council’s consideration: A. Big Three Capital Projects: With the Residences of Main Vail now complete, along with Timber Ridge Village and Southface Vail, the Town will have created 642 new homes for our community between the three projects. This new housing will provide homes totaling 1,021 bedrooms. In addition, the remodel of Dobson Arena is underway. The following is a summary of those three projects.  Timber Ridge Village: The Town is in the shoes of a developer, and we are actively managing risk in selling out Timber Ridge and then we will be leasing up Southface in two to three years. If Timber Ridge sells out the Town will recoup $38,614,769 of the $40,523,046 cash contribution it invested into the project and will have adequate resources to pay for the $25,449,948 million the Town has committed to purchasing homes in the project.  Southface Vail: Construction at Southface started in May 2025 and is expected to be completed in the Fall of 2028. There are a total of 268 units including studios, 1, and 2, bedrooms. The construction cost of this project is $164 Million. At the time this plan was prepared Southface is on time and budget.  Dobson Arena: Dobson is an approximately $55 million remodel of the 45-year- old Dobson ice rink. The project is being paid for from tax increment financing funds generated through the redevelopment of Lionshead. At the time this plan was written, this project is on budget and schedule. An operating agreement has now been executed between the Town of Vail and the Vail Recreation District. Dobson will be an important opportunity to continue to have incredible ice programs and increase our ability to have concerts, special events, and host large group events in conjunction with our lodging community. These three projects will continue to absorb significant staff and financial capacity for the next two years. They also will create new opportunities for addressing our housing challenges and improving economic vitality. This plan contemplates that significant resources continue to be committed to the completion of the above projects. Specifically, the Housing and Finance Departments will be actively managing the housing projects. The Public Works Director and Facilities Manager are managing construction and completion of the Dobson project, along with the Economic Development team’s involvement in curating the process around special events and corporate events at Dobson. Fortunately, we have the Cumming Group to help support project management for all three projects. B. Operational/Policy Enhancements: As we have experienced complex Special Development District (SDD) applications and closely examined our current housing policy, staff has concluded that our town code needs to be updated, clarified, in some places fixed to effectively implement the policies of the Town and provide improved customer service. The Land Use Code and interconnected housing regulations are the 13 9 best examples of where policy changes over time have created a hard-to-understand and inefficient policy structure. Examples of areas of specific change include: a SDD process that does not provide for an opportunity to examine and debate a conceptual plan from a developer (without the developer spending significant money on design). The housing code has four different sections interwoven into the land use code. It’s complex and hard to understand even for staff. There are also operational actions that need to be addressed. The good news is that the Town has invested in technology in the last year to fix a broken permit tracking system and better manage deed restrictions. However, to be a world class resort community the Town needs clear, effective municipal codes and operational tools to manage our complex land use and housing processes. Also, there is the opportunity and need for our departments to actively solicit feedback from customers, just like the Council did to create this strategic plan, to improve day-to- day operations and create Departmental business plans to ensure alignment to council priorities and improve the efficiency of day-to-day operations. C. Housing Strategy: The existing goal set in 2017 is to create 1000 additional homes for Vail employees. With the projects mentioned above and other projects the Town is now on track to create 850 of the 1000 new homes by 2027. Staff believe it is critical to complete the Timber Ridge and Southface projects in combination with redeveloping internal housing policy, processes and data before initiating any significant new housing projects. Staff and the Vail Local Housing Authority have begun working on this and an updated housing strategy is at Memo_2026_Housing_Strategies_SemiAnnualUpdate.pdf. D. Vibrancy and New, Younger Demographic: A trend we are continuing to see in Vail and other mountain resorts is ever-increasing commercial rents (which is counter to the national trend of decreasing commercial demand) which make unique, locally owned retail and food and beverage businesses less economically viable. In their place, we have seen more private clubs, ski lockers, and high end international/national retail stores. Of particular concern is the loss of food and beverage businesses that cater to locals and our employees. A notable exception to this trend is Avanti, which is a wonderful example of a creative food and beverage business that caters to both locals and guests. Another trend which is positive (but we need to be prepared for it) is with the new housing mentioned above, the Town may experience 800-1200 new residents. Some may certainly be relocating from free market units in Vail, but there will be a significant increase in employees and younger people living and working in Vail. This trend in the next 5 years requires the Town and the community to assess whether we have the services and amenities to support this new population. An example of an opportunity to address these trends is the Vail Public Library that is increasingly providing a diversity of programs and spaces for residents and employees to connect with each other, learn, have fun, and make new friends. We will need additional programs and facilities to address this positive trend resulting from the Town executing on its housing goals. A recreation or fitness facility has been discussed as a need. Staff would recommend that we update a recreation plan with the Vail Recreation District to evaluate the need for new recreational and community amenities. E. Value and Defining What a Premier Mtn. Resort Community Means Today: The Town’s longtime vision was to be the “premier mountain resort community in the world.” Historically, Vail could gauge its value to its customers by ratings in Ski Magazine. When “Vail, Colorado” shows up in the most recent (last ~12 months) resort rankings, it 14 10 generally lands top-tier but not #1. Vail is strong in “best overall destination” lists, a little lower in skier-survey performance lists, and punished in value/affordability lists. Across the two major “best resorts” lists where Vail is actually ranked recently, it sits between #6 and #12 (average #9) with excellent brand strength, while affordability- focused rankings flag it as expensive. After COVID and with the evolution of the Epic Pass, the Town of Vail now must market itself in both the winter and summer. We must also consider that the number of people skiing is not growing so we are facing increased competition for fewer skiers. The key leader in international growth is Mexico, which represents approximately 10% of our destination trips. As we review information on net promoter scores we are concerned about the perceived loyalty to Vail by our guest.  Summer NPS (likelihood to recommend) was 74 which exceeded both prior summer and prior winter. Detractors in summer see Vail as expensive, which leaves some feeling the overall value of the experience doesn’t justify the cost.  Winter NPS (likelihood to return) was 64, decreasing from 70.8 in winter 23/24. Guests perceived cost concerns as the biggest perceived barrier to future visitation. Staff would suggest that instead of chasing ratings in magazines that we focus on improving and enhancing our net promoter score and ensure that we are providing the very best experience we can to our guests. F. Aging Infrastructure: Vail is now 60 years old, and the Town has aging infrastructure nearing the end of its useful life. Dobson Arena was identified in the 2024 strategic plan as a facility that needed renovation and that is occurring. Town Hall is aging but recent capital investment in its HVAC system has provided another 5-10 years of life for the building. Currently the most significant capital need is continuing to maintain the Village and Lionshead parking structure. Arrive Vail has provided a concept of how to both address the infrastructure needs of the Village Parking structure, improve the guest arrival experience, and provide additional transit capacity current and future needs. The Civic Area may also provide opportunities for community gathering spaces and/or a municipal complex. G. Revenue: The Town has grown significantly in terms of programs, while also increasing the number of employees needed to support these expanded services. In addition, costs have increased substantially in terms of both operating and capital expenditures and the town has spent down reserves on major capital projects over the last several years. Additional revenue sources may need to be considered to support solutions for aging infrastructure, marketing Vail year-round, attracting, and retaining outstanding employees, aggressively competing as a resort, and providing an excellent level of customer service. H. Changing Climate: Ski seasons are becoming shorter, water availability will be more constrained, energy costs will rise, and we will see an increase in wildland fires and extreme weather. The 2025/2026 winter season was the worst snowpack recorded in Colorado. The Town will need to be increasingly resilient to address these trends and is actively creating solutions in addressing its significant greenhouse gas emissions 15 11 communitywide and in town operations. Core Transit provides an opportunity to reduce vehicle miles travelled (and the associated emissions) and the cost to employees to live and work in the Valley. Future mobility initiatives are also needed to achieve the town’s emissions and sustainability goals. The McKinstry/Geothermal project has the potential to be a groundbreaking project for renewable energy and provide a pathway for significantly reducing the Town carbon emissions for snow melt and to be more resilient in the future. In addition, the Town needs to develop and market non ski activities both in good and poor snow season to improve our economic resiliency. I. Redevelopment Opportunities: The Town of Vail and Vail Resorts have completed an update to the Lionshead Redevelopment Plan for West Lionshead. The demand for retail and commercial areas have evolved rapidly in the last five years, particularly after COVID. Maintaining a competitive resort community requires evaluating what our residents and guests need in the future for amenities and ensuring the Town has the highest quality built and natural environment. West Vail is a significant opportunity to create a retail and housing opportunity to meet the Town’s needs in the future. West Lionshead also could address parking on the Frontage Rd and improving skier drop off to a major portal. West Vail is also an opportunity to improve retail and food and beverage offerings for locals. This requires cooperation from property owners. Additional incentives may be needed to achieve the vision of the West Vail Master Plan – like the DDA that is being considered for West Lionshead. II. FEEDBACK AND ISSUES Staff compiled themes from the town’s most recent Vail Community Survey, last fielded in the spring of 2024, and post-visit guest surveys from winter 2024/2025 and summer 2025. Respondents were asked to rank their priorities for the town, with the top five including: 1. Creating a continuum of housing for locals, ranging from seasonal employees to retirees 2. Protecting wildlife habitat and restoring habitat connectivity 3. Improving the health of the Gore Creek Watershed 4. Increasing access to childcare for those who work in Vail, where workers want it 5. Creating and enhancing annual events that are consistent with Vail’s unique vibe (ex: GoPro Mountain Games, Bravo!) As part of both summer and winter post-visit guest surveys, overall affordability was of greatest concern, with parking as a factor affecting likelihood of returning to Vail and recommending Vail to others. For guests, parking is a pain point. Parking received the lowest satisfaction scores from all visitor groups at 3.3 overall last winter – this is consistent with the past three years. Nearly 1 in 5 open-ended comments called out parking specifically, with many asking for cheaper or more convenient options. Guests cite both cost and availability as concerns, especially with the introduction of summer paid parking and confusion over public versus private parking. Guests asked for lower rates, cheaper or validated options, clearer signage/shuttle loops and a simpler parking experience. Finally, in preparation for this strategic plan the Town’s facilitator and Town Staff conducted several focus groups including: 16 12  Town residents  Young business leaders  Town staff and Directors  Business leaders in the Vail Economic Advisory Committee  Interviews with Town Council members and the Town Manager Notes from these focus groups were shared with the Town Council on February 19, 2026. 17 2026 Strategic Plan – Proposed Actions to Achieve Council Results A. Issue: Create a Vibrant Vail Experience Action/Strategy Timing Point of Contact Budget Needed in 2026 A.1 By December 2028, realize a net 5% increase in locally owned and operated store front business. Define locally owned and operated store front businesses. Q2 26 MV/KH Create inventory of locally owned and operated store front businesses. Q4 26 MG Develop a communications model to improve relationships with commercial real estate brokers. Q4 26 MG/MV Develop strategies to fill storefronts: determine code opportunities to incent locally owned and operated store front businesses. Q3 28 MG/MV Narrow to three to five key strategies to achieve net increase by 2028. Q2 28 MG/MV A.2 By December 2028, create polices, programming and organizational culture for the local business community to embrace and promote vibrancy and an environment of fun Define vibrancy and fun for local businesses. Q4 26 MV/JG Establish baseline – inventory of vibrancy and fun in businesses. Q3 26 MV/JG Complete an inventory of vibe in Vail’s villages. Q4 26 MV/JG Align land use, housing and design codes to achieve vibrancy goals. Q3 28 MG A.3 By March 2027, create policies and an organizational culture where community members and/or groups can utilize town facilities. Complete inventory of town facilities, parks, other entity uses (school district), publicly used/privately owned spaces for supporting community programming. Q3 26 KLM TBD Complete financial analysis for each town facility or space (P&L) and evaluate usage and capacity of those fa cilities. Q4 26 Determine needs of community for additional public uses via a new Recreation Master Plan. Q3 26 KLM TBD Complete a management plan that could also be part of the Recreation Master Plan. Q1 27 KLM TBD A.4 By December 2027, residents and visitors will have access to and will utilize a playbook of diverse and compelling activities that are available in town throughout the year. Develop a playbook of activities and amenities by season for distribution to the local community and businesses. Q3 26 (winter) Q2 27 (summer) MV/LG/ AZ 18 B. Issue: Build a Strong Community Action/Strategy Timing Point of Contact Budget Needed in 2026 B.1 By December 2026, the Town Council will receive and approve a development agreement to accomplish the community goals outlined in the West Lionshead Master Plan. The partners (Town of Vail, Vail Resorts and East West Partners) will identify topics to discuss in the pre-development agreement. Q1 26 RF, MG The partners will complete a public financing plan and update needs for public parking. Q2 26 RF, MG Consultant budgeted The partners will complete a development agreement. Q3 26 RF, MG B.2 By December 2029, parents/caregivers working in Vail needing childcare have access to affordable childcare located where they need it. Work with Eagle County to update the demand study for childcare and where that demand is needed. 3Q 27 KM / RF Identify sites for future childcare center in conjunction with land inventory for future Recreation Master Plan update. Q4 26 Rec Plan / TK Assess and ensure the sustainability of current childcare facilities and programing and develop recommendations to improve sustainability. Q4 27 KM Facilitate proposed new childcare facility in West Vail. Q2 27 RF Create micro enterprise opportunities for in-home childcare. Q2 28 KM B.3 By December 2031, Vail residents will experience an 820 unit increase in locally owned and occupied homes in residential neighborhoods, with construction beginning on the East Vail parcel by 2028. (Note 820 includes the 570 units being built now and 250 new homes in the next 5 years) Establish integrated housing inventory and analytics system with full deed-restricted unit lifecycle tracking and AI-assisted tools. Q4 26 JD $60,000 budgeted Redevelop policy, data and decision-making infrastructure. Q4 28 JD Expand deed restriction purchase program product offerings. Q4 27 JD Create a financial catalyst for affordable housing. Q2 27 JD $25,000 VLHA Complete Southface Vail . Q4 28 JD Complete Timber Ridge Village. Q4 26 JD Initiate construction on the East Vail CDOT site. Q2 28 JD B.4 By December 2027, the Town Council will make a decision regarding the development of a community-anchored recreation center. Assist VRD with issuing an RFP for the Recreation Master Plan Update. Q2 26 TK/VRD $75k TOV $75k VRD 19 Internally evaluate existing spaces and land that may be used for Community/Recreation opportunities; share information for use with Recreation Master Plan update. Q4 26 TK Complete Recreation Master Plan which will include a land analysis that supports other actions in this plan. Q 2 27 TK/VRD Present recreation center options to Council for decision regarding the development of a community-anchored recreation center. Q4 27 TK/VRD B.5 By February of 2028, the Town of Vail will begin intentionally developing the next generation of leaders within our community. Develop a mentorship program and speaker series where the “Old Guard” can impart wisdom to the “New Guard.” The speaker series should be a combination of a formal session and informal networking opportunity in the same event. Q2 27 RF Formalize the Next Generation group, while keeping the meetings organic, to allow the group to provide direct feedback to the Town Manager and Town Council to promote growth, innovation, and excitement for the future. Q2 27 RF Work regionally with Vail Valley Partnership and other local governments to support local entrepreneurs and young leaders. Specially support VVP program to connect younger people in the community and provide leadership and basic life skills. Q2 27 RF/VVP C. Issue: Protect the Mountain Environment Action/Strategy Timing Point of Contact Budget Needed in 2026 C.1 By December 2027, Vail and its partners will have a cohesive wildlife/environmental management plan for the Gore Valley to continue to promote, protect and enhance our natural habitat. Complete the biodiversity study including inventory, land management, habitat improvement and policy. Q2 26 KB Bring partners together to present findings of the study and collaborate on recommendations. Q4 26 KB Utilizing the results of the biodiversity study, develop and release RFP to develop biodiversity habitat plan and policy for town-owned land. Q1 27 KB Present findings to PEC/Council, develop budget. Q2 27 KB Begin project planning and implementation of recommendations. Q4 27 KB C.2 By December 2029, Gore Creek will meet the requirements to no longer be a 303(d) listed impaired waterway which would reduce near term risk of losing the gold medal fishery status. Launch new Restore the Gore branding and campaign. Q3 26 KB/PW 20 Improve stormwater infrastructure and operational activities ensuring the town employs best management practices to prevent, capture, and treat pollution. Q4 28 KB/PW Advance statewide policy, update town regulation and increase enforcement to ensure compliance with existing laws and broaden the ability of the town to reduce pesticide impacts on Gore Creek. Q1 27 KB/PW Implement site specific restoration and research projects (Golf Course revegetation plan). Q4 29 KB/PW Complete instream trout habitat enhancement project at eastern end of Ford Park. Q2 27 KB/PW C.3 By December 2027, the town council will receive and approve a community resiliency plan including economic, environmental, wildfire and organizational resiliency, including evacuation and COOP plans. Develop a scope of work for phase one of the resiliency plan. Q2 26 RK Budget $125,000 for 2027 Prepare and issue an RFP for phase one of the resiliency plan. Q3 26 Complete draft plan. Q4 27 C.4 By December 2030, the Town will achieve a 50% reduction in carbon emissions and by December 2050, the Town will achieve an 80% reduction in carbon emissions against the 2014 baseline. Present for adoption the Exterior Energy Offset Program, a policy to mitigate and offset energy use (heated driveways, pools/spas). Q4 26 KB/CM Complete Phase 2 Design of the broader Civic Area Geothermal district, establish governance and financial structure, and partnerships for implementation. Q3 27 KB/CM Complete Energy Performance Contract on town facilities, geothermal district at library. Q4 27 KB/CM Increase utilization of mobility programs (ShiftBike, ZipCar, SolePower +) by a minimum of 25%. Q4 28 KB/BM Propose an Electric Vehicle (EV-first) procurement policy for town vehicles. Q1 27 KB/CM Implement the town’s EV Readiness Plan actions to reach 30% transition by 2030. Q4 30 KB/CM Achieve 50% waste diversion rate through an increase in composting, plastic waste reduction, and construction and demolition diversion. Q4 29 KB/BM Drive local, statewide, regional and national climate policy and programs through the adopted CC4CA policy objectives and the Climate Action Collaborative 2030 Plan. Q3 30 KB Implement targeted climate education and capacity building, reaching at least 25% of town employees while also increasing community education and outreach by 25%. Q4 28 KB 21 D. Issue: Ensure Good Governance Action/Strategy Timing Point of Contact Budget Needed in 2026 D.1 By December 31, 2027, the Town of Vail will simplify and streamline communications to ensure information is transparent and accessible to the community. Centralize website update functions within the Communications Department. Q1 27 KW FTE/other resource in 2026-27 Launch a new, comprehensive website at vail.gov as a one-stop shop for the information needed by all constituents. Q4 27 KW D.2 By September 1, 2028, to better serve the current and future needs of the community, the town will execute a complete overhaul of land use, housing, development and design codes. Amend Town Code Chapter 12-9A to include a new Sketch Plan step in the Special Development District review process. Q2 26 MG, JD Select a finalist from the respondents to the RFQ for the comprehensive rewrite of Town Code Titles 12 and 14. Q1 26 MG, JD Administer public engagement and implement communication plan as a component of Phase 1. Q4 26 MG, JD Complete Phase 1 of the comprehensive rewrite of Town Code Titles 12 and 14. Q4 26 MG, JD, GR $100,000 budgeted Complete Phase 2 of the comprehensive rewrite of Town Code Titles 12 and 14. Q2 27 MG, GR D.3 By December 2027, the community will experience a customer focused organization and culture through the development of customer-focused strategic departmental business plans. Develop a customer service training program for Town of Vail employees. Q3 26 RF Implement a community-wide customer service training program. Q4 27 RF Town of Vail staff trained to facilitate department-wide strategic business plan. Q3 26 RF, KH $42,000 budgeted Department strategic business plans completed over next three years. Q4 29 RF $200,000 budgeted Create a communications framework for departmental plan messaging and building culture and legacy of customer service. Q4 26 RF, KW, KH Develop metrics to measure success. Q1 27 RF, KH D.4 By December 31, 2027 the Town will pursue and implement innovative financial strategies to ensure the viability of our community for the next 50 years and deliver best-in-class services. Determine where town operations are financially sustainable and where they are not. Q4 26 CS 22 Engage InnoVail team to solicit internal ideas for revenue generation. Q2 27 CS Solicit crowd sources and community feedback along with focus groups with financial leaders in the community. Q4 27 CS Engage an intern/fellow to support research and implementation of this goal area. This would include looking at innovative strategies for supporting public operations and projects. Q3 26 RF / HR $20,000 Release first round of accurate, real stories of how the town works to receive an ROI on initiatives and investments. Q1 27 CS Inventory of what we can sell, trade, collateralize. (i.e. selling RMV) Q4 26 CS/JD 23 AGENDA ITEM NO. 3.2 Item Cover Page DATE:April 21, 2026 TIME:30 min. SUBMITTED BY:Beth Markham, Environmental Sustainability ITEM TYPE:Presentation/Discussion AGENDA SECTION:Presentation/Discussion (3:45pm) SUBJECT:Waste Diversion Update (4:15pm) SUGGESTED ACTION:Listen to presentation and provide feedback. PRESENTER(S):Beth Markham, Environmental Sustainability Manager VAIL TOWN COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM REPORT ATTACHMENTS: Waste Diversion Update Memorandum- 042126.pdf Recycling and Compost Update Presentation- 042126.pdf 24 To: Vail Town Council From: Environmental Sustainability Department Date: April 21, 2026 Subject: Community Wide Waste Diversion Update I. Purpose This memorandum provides the annual update to the Vail Town Council on waste diversion initiatives and the progress toward community waste diversion goals. II. Background In 2010 baseline recycling studies show area diversion rates as follows: • Town of Vail: 9% (residential) and 19% (commercial) • Eagle County: 14.7% • National Average: 34.5%` In 2014, Town of Vail passed a universal recycling ordinance, requiring all businesses and residents to recycle by law. This ordinance also included a volume-based pricing structure, known as Pay as You Throw, encouraging residents to adopt smaller trash containers, maximizing recycling, and reducing landfill bound waste while saving the residents money on their bundled trash and recycling bill. Following the adoption of this ordinance, the town achieved the 25% waste diversion goal established in the 2009 Environmental Sustainability Strategic Plan in 2020. In support of the Vail Town Council’s strategic focus on sustainability and reducing greenhouse gas emissions, the town’s adopted 2024 Strategic Plan establishes the following goal: Reduce greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) from the 2014 baseline 50% by 2030 and 80% by 2050. To help achieve these GHG emissions reduction goals, the Town’s Strategic Plan includes a strategy to achieve a townwide 50% waste diversion rate by 2030 with the following milestones: • Divert 80% of organics through a town-wide compost program. • Develop policy prohibiting single-use plastics. • Divert 100% of all locally recoverable construction and demolition materials from the landfill. 25 Town of Vail Page 2 III. Recycling and Compost Program Outreach and Initiatives Several outreach efforts and recycling and compost initiatives have been implemented. These include partnering with Vail Honeywagon to offer the West Vail Curbside Composting Pilot program, offering the Business Compost Program, educating Town of Vail staff on recycling, providing recycling education to local students, and providing businesses with information and resources on the expansion of the Kick the Bag Habit program and development of the Forget the Foam program. Compost Programs • Free Composting for Town of Vail Employees: The Town of Vail encourages town employees to compost and allows them to bring organic waste from home and compost it at the town for free as a benefit. • West Vail Curbside Compost Program: Town of Vail partnered with Vail Honeywagon to offer a curbside composting pilot program for West Vail residents in 2021. This was the first curbside compost program in Eagle County. Participants receive a 5-gallon bucket and weekly curbside service. Town of Vail is subsidizing the program cost per household by 50% up to $8/month and per HOA by 50% up to $50/month. Currently there are 90 households, including two HOA’s participating, and 10.4 tons of compost was collected in 2025. Vail Valley Waste is planning to launch a curbside compost program in May 2026 to any resident in the Town of Vail. • Residential Subscription Drop-off Program: In partnership with Vail Honeywagon, the residential subscription drop off composting program is also available in Vail at the Vail Recycling Center. There are 33 residents participating in the drop-off program. • Business Compost Program: Twelve local businesses have participated in the Business Compost Program to start or improve a compost program since its inception in 2023. Businesses can receive between $500 - $2,000 in rebates for starting or improving an existing compost program. $4,000 in rebates was distributed to participating businesses in 2025. Participating businesses diverted an estimated 97 tons of organic material in 2025. Hard to Recycle Events One free recycling event was held in May in 2025 to collect electronic, yard and household hazardous waste, vinyl banners, tires, scrap metal, soft plastics, Styrofoam, gently used outdoor gear, yard and food waste to be composted and to provide paper shredding services. Over 20 tons of materials were collected and recycled or composted from 443 residents and employees in Vail. This was largest single day collection event held in Vail. The event was funded by fees from the “kick the bag habit” program in which 10-cents of the 25-cent per bag 26 Town of Vail Page 3 fee collected by retail stores in Vail for customers who choose to opt out of reusable bags is remitted to the Town to fund waste diversion efforts. Town of Vail Community Recycling Center: In partnership with Eagle County, the Town of Vail operates the Vail Recycling Center located behind the Community Development Building. The town manages the site and is reimbursed by Eagle County for hauls each month. In addition to collecting comingled, paper, and cardboard recycling the site also collects used clothes and shoes for the Thrifty Store and offers a free ski and snowboard swap which is heavily used by the community. In 2025, 100 tons of recycling were collected at the recycling center and additional social media posts were run to help reduce contamination and illegal dumping at the recycling center. Plastic Pollution Reduction Act Implementation • Kick the Bag Habit: In accordance with HB1162- the Plastic Pollution Reduction Act (PPRA), in 2023 the Town of Vail expanded the Kick the Bag Habit program from the two major grocery stores to all retailers in town and increased the disposable bag fee to 25-cents per bag, with 10-cents per bag remitted to the Town of Vail, which can be used only for waste diversion programs. On January 1, 2024, single-use plastic bags were prohibited from being distributed at all retailers in Vail. Following the state’s exemption, restaurants are exempt from the single-use plastic bag ban and the disposable bag fee. Training resources for staff and signage for customers were created and distributed. Information and resources are available on lovevail.org. In 2025, $88,552 was generated from remitted bag fees designated for waste diversion programs. The town used the bag 27 Town of Vail Page 4 fees in 2025 to fund the Hard to Recycle event and the zero waste program for special events. Bag fees collected over the past several years are below in Figure 1. Year Fee Collected Number of Paper Bags Sold 2025 $88,526 885,260 2024 $82,578 825,780 2023 $72,786 727,860 2022 $46,955 469,550 2021 $43,047 430,473 2020 $31,547 315,470 2019 $32,923 329,230 2018 $33,381 333,810 2017 $31,920 319,200 Figure 1: Bag fees remitted to the Town of Vail per single use carry-out bag distributed at retailers. • Forget the Foam: As part of HB21-1162, PPRA, on January 1, 2024, all restaurants, grocery stores, convenience stories and schools were prohibited from distributing polystyrene to go containers and service ware. Back stock purchased before January 1, 2024 can be distributed until it is gone. A Guide to Sustainable Serviceware was developed in partnership with Eco-Cycle and distributed to all impacted businesses. The guide and additional information can be found on the town’s website. • PPRA Compliance Checks: During the summer of 2024 an intern with the Environmental Sustainability department conducted friendly compliance checks with local businesses. About 90% of retailers were found to be in compliance with the plastic bag ban and 87% of restaurants, schools and grocery stores were in compliance with the polystyrene ban. Those who were not were provided with education on the requirements. Follow up indicates that most are now compliant, but another round of compliance checks is required. Single-Use Plastic Reduction: Following local high school student Declan Cunningham’s presentation on human and environmental health impacts of single-use plastics and Council’s direction, in 2025 staff worked with Lotus Engineering and Sustainability to conduct research and robust public outreach regarding the development of a single-use plastics reduction policy in Vail. Rather than adopting policy prohibiting specific single-use plastic items, Council directed staff to focus on adding water bottle filling stations throughout town in 2026. Staff are currently working to identify viable locations and develop a plan for installation. In addition, Council supported providing education and signage around single-use plastics reduction. A Better than Bottled campaign was launched with signage at the Eagle County Regional Airport and through Discover Vail guest communications to educate the public on the benefits of using reusable water bottles and drinking the quality tap water in Vail. 28 Town of Vail Page 5 Celebrate Green!: Special Event Zero Waste Program Any special event hosted in Vail that has received funding from the town or has 500 or more attendees and has at least one food or beverage vendor must comply with the town’s zero waste program. This includes providing recycling and composting at the event, distributing only fully recyclable or compostable serviceware and cups, prohibiting distribution of any single-use plastic items, educating event attendees and sorting all waste to ensure the highest diversion rates and limited to no contamination. Staff developed and distributed a special events resource guide and special event guidelines to all event producers who host events in town. The guide provides details on sustainability requirements for events as well as information on how to execute a successful zero waste and sustainable event, including details on acceptable cups and serviceware for events for vendors, how to create and deploy a green team for the event or hire a third party zero waste provider, how to calculate the event diversion rate, sustainable transportation options for event attendees and more. Staff also developed a shorter Zero Waste Event Guidelines and Requirements document for event producers and vendors as well. The full Resource Guide can be viewed here, the Guidelines and Requirements document can be viewed here, and both are available on Lovevail.org. IV. Community Recycling Rates Recycling rates throughout the Town of Vail have steadily increased since adoption of the 2014 ordinance. In 2025, the Town achieved a 34% recycling rate with organic waste (compost) recycling factored in (Figure 2), which dropped from 37% in 2022. While 2025 data is not yet 29 Town of Vail Page 6 available, in 2024, Eagle County’s recycling rate was 30.1%. In 2025, Colorado's statewide recycling and composting rate was just 16%, which is half the current national recycling and composting rate of 32%. The 2025 Vail recycling rate data includes municipal solid waste (MSW) or material that is collected on regular residential and commercial routes, recycling, and organic material diverted through composting. It does not include materials generated through construction and demolition activities. These numbers are an aggregate of self-reported hauler data submittals collected through sampling periods over the course of the year. Vail Recycling Rate Estimates 2025 34% 2024 33% 2023 36% 2022 37% 2021 35% 2020 29% 2019 27% 2018 26% 2017 22% 2016 20% MSW (Landfill)- tons 9,524 7,979 6,938 6,840 6,772 8,369 11,487 10,871 9,832 8,995 Recycling- tons 4,173 3,266 3,312 3,676 3,411 3,201 3,897 3,597 2,755 2,224 Organics- tons 755 624 598 378 319 243 350 155 50 37.5 Recycling Rate 30% 29% 32% 35% 33% 28% 25% 25% 22% 20% Recycling Rate w/ Organics 34% 33% 36% 37% 35% 29% 27% 26% 22% 20% Figure 2. Town of Vail Recycling Rates Over the Years 2025 Diversion Rates with Construction and Demolition Debris Construction and demolition debris (C & D) data has been collected since 2019. When factored in with municipal solid waste (MSW), the overall Vail diversion rate in 2025 dropped from 34% to 32% (Figure 3). Based on 2025 hauler data, approximately 15% of all landfill-bound waste from Vail in was construction and demolition debris. Of the total C & D debris generated in Vail, about 20.8% was diverted from the landfill, up from 17% in 2023. Less C & D debris was created in 2025 than previous years with a higher percentage being diverted. However, there is an 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 16,000 18,000 2025 34% 2024 33% 2023 35% 2022 37% 2021 35% 2020 29% 2019 27% 2018 26% 2017 22% 2016 20% To n n a g e Recycling Rate Vail Recycling Rates MSW (Landfill)- tons Recycling- tons Organics- tons 30 Town of Vail Page 7 opportunity to further increase the C & D material being diverted from the landfill with education, resources, and policy. Figure 3. Town of Vail Diversion Rates with Construction and Demolition 11,247 11,878 12,309 10,952 10,447 1,723 3,899 5,371 4,112 3,674 4,626 4,078 4,418 4,248 3,698 453 812 1,106 572 288 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 2025 tons- 32% Diversion Rate 2024 tons- 28% Diverson Rate 2023 tons- 29% Diversion Rate 2022 tons- 30% Diversion Rate 2021 tons- 28% Diversion Rate TOV Tonnage Estimate with C & D Total MSW w/ C & D C & D (Landfill) Total Recycling w/ C&D C & D (Recycled) 31 Town of Vail Page 8 The Construction and Demolition Program at the Eagle County Landfill was initiated in 2018 and accepts clean dimensional lumbar, concrete with rebar, and concrete without rebar. Tipping fees at the C&D site are $15/ton, versus $58/ton tipping fee for C&D waste at the landfill. Scrap metal can also be recycled locally. Staff working with the Climate Action Collaborative’s Materials Management Task Force has helped to create a resource toolkit for C&D diversion for contractors. Given the C&D recycling site at the landfill, there is an opportunity to divert additional waste. Next steps include staff developing and implementing a voluntary Construction & Demolition diversion program for contractors and construction and demolition projects in Vail to divert as much C&D waste from the landfill as possible. Ideally, Town led projects, such as workforce housing projects, demonstrate leadership in C&D diversion and opt divert materials recoverable in Eagle County during the projects. Organics Diversion In 2025, 755 tons of organic material, or compost, was diverted from the landfill (Figure 4), which reduced an estimated 286 metric tons of GHG emissions calculated using the EPA WARM Emissions factors. Currently compost comprises nearly 5% of all Vail residential and commercial waste diverted from the landfill. Compost service is available commercially through Vail Honeywagon and EverGreen Zero Waste. Approximately 30 commercial businesses compost in Vail which diverted 658 tons of organic waste in 2025. Town of Vail municipal operations provide compost at several town facilities. Town of Vail employees can bring their food waste from home and compost through the municipal compost program for free. The Town’s chipping program and landscape operations compost diverts additional material from the landfill. Combined these municipal efforts diverted an estimated 60.4 tons of compost. Residential compost is available through the subscription compost drop at the Town of Vail Recycling Center, which diverted 20 tons and through the West Vail curbside compost pilot, which diverted 10.4 tons of organic material from 90 participants in 2025. In 2026 curbside compost will be offered throughout Vail through a program launching by Vail Valley Waste in May 2026. Compost collection at special events diverted 6.44 tons of organic material in 2025. Figure 4. 2025 Organics Diversion- 755 tons total 32 Town of Vail Page 9 Zero Waste Events Since 2012, the Town of Vail has partnered with Walking Mountains Science Center to provide Zero Waste services at the weekly Farmer’s Markets throughout the summer. Through the partnership, six Sustainability Interns provide Zero Waste services at events in Vail. In addition to the Vail Farmer’s Market, 14 other town events utilized Walking Mountains Science Center to provide Zero Waste services in 2025, including the John Summit concerts, Après at the Amp, GoPro Mountains Games, GoPro Mountains Games concerts at the Amp, Craft Beer Classic, Wine Classic, TOV Community Picnics, Vail Social, Artisan Rhapsody, Oktoberfest, Shakedown Throwdown, Stoke Sessions Concert Series, Sofi Tucker, and Kris Kringle Market. Springback Bluegrass hired Minimal Impact Services for zero waste services. The average diversion rate for all events in 2025 was 85.9% (Figure 5). Figure 5. Zero Waste Diversion Rates for 2025 Events V. Extended Producer Responsibility Act Signed into law on June 3, 2022, HB 22-1355 Producer Responsibility Program for Statewide Recycling Act, requires companies that sell products in packaging or paper products to fund a statewide recycling system to recycle those materials. The Act shifts the cost of recycling packaging and paper products away from local governments and consumers, placing that responsibility on the producers who introduce these materials into the marketplace. These companies have formed an independent nonprofit organization, called a Producer Responsibility Organization (PRO), to coordinate, fund, and manage the statewide recycling system. Colorado appointed Circular Action Alliance as the designated PRO in May 2023. Each producer will pay into the system. Annual fees will be eco-modulated meaning materials that are harder or more expensive to recycle (ex. polystyrene) have higher fees while materials with strong recycling markets (ex. glass, certain paper grades) have lower fees. The funds collected by producers will be used to: 1. Expand Recycling Access in Colorado: Funds are used to subsidize convenient curbside recycling for households, schools, small businesses, hospitality locations, and government buildings. 33 Town of Vail Page 10 2. Support Local Recycling Providers: Reimbursements cover the costs of local haulers, recyclers, and nonprofits, enabling them to offer services without relying on municipal budgets. 3. Standardize Materials Collected & Education: Funds support a consistent list of required and readily recyclable materials and statewide education campaigns. What this means for our community: The program will provide recycling access to all Coloradans with no added cost to consumers or local governments. Local governments and waste haulers across Colorado can formally express interest in participating in the program and begin the reimbursement request process. Town staff are working on this process now. Starting in 2026, the program will reimburse costs for recycling to waste haulers, who in turn will pass that reimbursement onto the residents to provide them with free recycling. Community recycling centers and education and outreach associated with recycling will also be eligible for reimbursement. While Eagle County pays for the hauling costs for Vail’s recycling center, Town of Vail can request reimbursement for any maintenance, upkeep, and capital costs for the recycling center and as well as for recycling education and outreach. Schools, churches, municipalities, and some small businesses will also be eligible for reimbursement for recycling costs by 2030. When that phase is reached, the Town of Vail will be able to be reimbursed for all internal municipal recycling as well. The program is projected to more than double the state's recycling rate for packaging and paper by 2035 and supports and grows local end markets for recycled packaging and paper by ensuring reliable, producer funded collection and processing. Current Status: Producers must pay their annual responsibility dues on covered materials beginning in January 2026. The Circular Action Alliance's program plan has been approved, and implementation must begin by June 9, 2026. Reimbursements are expected to start after that date. Town staff are working on required documentation to ensure Town of Vail is eligible for reimbursements. Local haulers are planning to submit required documentation to ensure eligibility for reimbursement for recycling and associated costs, including education and outreach. VI. Discussion The Town of Vail’s adopted goal of 25% waste reduction from the landfill was achieved by the end of 2019. In 2025, Town of Vail achieved a 34% recycling rate including organics and a 32% diversion rate including Construction & Demolition (C & D) material. The Town of Vail is just above Eagle County’s 2024 recycling rate of 30.1%, well ahead of the statewide recycling rate of 16%, and has surpassed the national recycling rate of 32%. As a national and global leader in sustainability, the Town of Vail continues to work towards more ambitious zero waste goals, especially with organics diversion. The Vail Town Council strategic plan has established a goal to reduce GHG emissions by 50% by 2030 and 80% by 2050. To help work towards this goal in the waste sector, the strategic plan includes a 50% waste diversion goal by 2030 with the following strategies identified as the highest impact actions to achieve this goal: o divert 80% of organics from the landfill by 2030, o divert 100% of recoverable construction and demolition debris from the landfill by 2030, o and develop policy to support single-use plastics reduction. 34 Town of Vail Page 11 The Town of Vail is working on several waste diversion programs and education initiatives to work towards achieving these GHG reduction goals and high impact targets. A combination of programs and policy will be needed to achieve the established waste diversion targets. Currently Planned and Potential Initiatives for 2026-27: A. Annual waste reduction education In 2025, the Environmental department collaborated with the Discover Vail Destination Marketing Organization to rebrand the Love Vail campaign to include not just the town’s sustainability initiatives, but to incorporate more robust destination stewardship marketing and education for guests coming to Vail through a combined campaign. In 2026, staff will update the Love Vail recycling and waste reduction campaign with the updated brand and provide outreach and materials to residents, guests, and businesses. With the assistance of summer interns with Walking Mountains as part of the town’s zero waste contract, the staff will take inventory of residential, multi-family, and commercial recycling compliance and provide hangtags to identify how entities can improve recycling and reduce contamination. Some costs associated with education and outreach will be reimbursable through the Colorado Producer Responsibility program. B. Curbside compost and business compost program expansion Based on the 2017 Northwest Colorado Waste Diversion Study1, 37% of all waste entering the Eagle County Landfill is comprised of organic waste, 30% of which is food waste. Anaerobic decomposition of organic material in a landfill contributes to the release of methane gas, which accounts for 12% of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions. Methane is over 28% more potent of a greenhouse gas than carbon dioxide over 100 years and 84% more potent over 20 years, according to the Environmental Protection Agency2. In 2026, access to the curbside compost program will expand town-wide through a curbside compost program offered by Vail Valley Waste starting in May. There is limited budget remaining to extend the current subsidy offered to those participating in the West Vail Curbside Compost program to anyone who signs up for the program through Vail Valley Waste. Vail Honeywagon is also considering expanding curbside compost in Vail. Staff will work to increase participation in 2026 in both the residential curbside and business rebate programs and use data collected to help inform future policy decisions and/or incentives to residents and businesses, which will be needed to achieve an 80% reduction in organic waste going to the landfill by 2030. C. Construction and demolition waste diversion pilot program development Based on the 2017 Northwest Colorado Waste Diversion Study, approximately 13% of all waste entering the Eagle, Garfield, Moffat, Rio Blanco and Route County landfills is construction and demolition debris (C&D). Vail’s average is higher with approximately 15% of landfill bound waste comprising of C&D debris (based on 2025 hauler data). Of the total C&D debris generated in Vail, about 20.8% was diverted from the landfill, up from 17% in 2024 and 2023, 12.2%in 2022, and 7.2% diversion in 2021. Staff are developing a voluntary C&D waste diversion pilot program for materials that can be recycled in Eagle County to be implemented in 2027. The voluntary program will provide 1 Northwest Colorado Waste Diversion Study: https://www.co.routt.co.us/DocumentCenter/View/7184/Northwest-CO-Waste-Diversion-Study 2 Environmental Protection Agency: Importance of Methane: https://www.epa.gov/gmi/importance- methane#:~:text=Methane%20is%20more%20than%2025,trapping%20heat%20in%20the%20atmospher e. 35 Town of Vail Page 12 resources and training to contractors on what materials can be diverted in Eagle County, planning templates to guide successful C&D diversion, and a reporting document to account for C&D diversion rates throughout the project. This pilot will identify challenges and opportunities for the development of C&D diversion standards for construction projects in the Town of Vail. This project is currently unfunded. D. Single Use Plastics Reduction Globally only 9% of all plastic created is recycled3. Through state legislation HB1162- the Plastic Pollution Reduction Act, the local government pre-emption on plastic bans is lifted and municipalities and counties can enact, implement, and enforce more stringent laws on single use plastics. In 2025, staff conducted extensive research and will explore opportunities to reduce single use plastics such as water bottles and cutlery through programs and/or policy. While no policy was adopted in 2025, staff are pursuing the following initiatives to support a reduction in single-use plastics. 1. Installation of additional water bottle filling stations in town in conjunction Better than Bottled Campaign. Council has directed staff to pursue this initiative, and it is currently funded at $60K plus an additional $12K available for signage and education in the 2026 budget. 2. Single-Use Plastic Fee: Staff and the town attorney’s office have researched the option of developing a fee on single-use plastic bottles and other items being sold or distributed. The fees would be remitted to the town, similar to the bag fees, and used to fund waste diversion initiatives. Single-use packaging fees have been implemented in other places around the world, such as in Tübingen, Germany4. 3. Plastic Free July: In response to a Council suggestion, staff recommend joining the Plastic Free July5 global initiative to encourage residents and guests to “choose to refuse” single-use plastics during the month of July. 4. Town of Vail Policy could be formally established prohibiting the use and distribution of single-use plastics for internal town operations, town-run events and town-owned buildings. Towns of Frisco 6and Breckenridge7 have similar requirements codified. Staff are looking into developing a similar policy for Town of Vail. 5. Codify Special Event Policies for events hosted by external event producers in the Town of Vail. Currently all event producers who receive funding from the Town of Vail or any special event that has 500 or more attendees with at least one food vendor are required to host Zero Waste 3 Eco-Cycle: Reduce Your Plastic Use - https://ecocycle.org/eco-living/refuse-and-reduce/how-to-reduce- plastic/#:~:text=While%20some%20plastics%20are%20recyclable,persists%20in%20our%20natural%20 environment. 4 The German City That Defied McDonald’s and Dumped “To-Go” Waste- https://reasonstobecheerful.world/tubingen-germany-defied-mcdonalds-dumped-to-go-waste/ 5 Plastic Free July: https://www.plasticfreejuly.org/ 6 Town of Frisco Code: https://library.municode.com/co/frisco/codes/code_of_ordinances?nodeId=CH124PUHESA_ARTVPRSA DISIUSPL_S124-42PRSADISIUSPLPO 7 Town of Breckenridge Code: https://breckenridge.town.codes/Code/5-12-9 36 Town of Vail Page 13 events. This is currently monitored through the Event Review Committee. While the zero waste requirements, in particular prohibition of using and distributing single-use plastic items at events, are incorporated into the special event permitting process, the requirements are not currently town policy within the town code. 6. Reusable Cup Program: Retrocycle, a Colorado non-profit, is conducting outreach to local cafes in Vail to identify those interested in participating in a reusable cup program that would eliminate single-use hot and cold cups. Currently, there are five interested. Retrocycle is hoping to launch a program in Fall 2026. While there is currently no funding available to support local businesses implementing this program, staff are collaborating with Retrocycle to try to secure grant funding to help ease the purchase of the cups and help kick start this waste diversion initiative in Vail. The Town of Breckenridge is piloting the Retrocycle reusable cup program starting in May 2026 and the town of Steamboat Springs and Frisco are launching a program in Fall 2026. Retrocycle is also piloting a reusable cup program for special events this summer in Breckenridge and Boulder and is interested in potentially partnering with Town of Vail as an option for special events in 2027. VII. Staff Recommendations To achieve the Town Council’s Strategic Plan goal of a 50% diversion rate by 2030, a combination of programs and policy will be required. Staff will move forward with these high impact initiatives to help achieve the goal. 1) Solidify locations and installation plan for water bottle filling stations and release RFP. 2) Further the Better than Bottled campaign with guests and locals to reduce usage of single-use plastic water bottles and pursue the Plastic Free July campaign. 3) Revitalize the Love Vail education campaign with the rebranded logo and updated website. 4) Expand the curbside compost pilot program and business compost pilot program and bring results back to Council with policy recommendations. 5) Develop a voluntary C&D diversion pilot program to implement in 2027 and bring results back to Council with policy recommendations. Staff further recommends returning to Council with proposals for the following strategies: 1) Brief Council on policy options to develop a fee on single-use plastics. 2) Develop an internal town policy prohibiting the use and distribution of single-use plastics for internal town operations, town-run events and town-owned buildings. 3) Formalize the current special events policies requiring zero waste requirements and prohibition of using and distributing single-use plastic items at events as policy within the town code. 4) Should a critical number of Vail businesses (5 or more) want to pursue the Retrocycle reusable cup program, staff would propose a partnership using bag fee dollars during a future supplemental. Does the Town Council agree that the outlined initiatives are the direction staff should continue moving to increase waste diversion? 37 PRESENTATION BY Beth Markham Environmental Sustainability Manager Community Wide Recycling and Compost Update 38 Waste Diversion Goals Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability Environmental Sustainability Strategic Plan Goal #1: Solid Waste Stream Reduction and Recycling: Reduce the amount of Town of Vail landfill contributions by 10% within 5 years and 25% within 10 years. Achieved by end of 2019. 2010 Baseline Data: ➢Town of Vail: 9% (residential) and 19% (commercial) ➢Eagle County: 14.7% ➢National Average: 34.5% Town Council’s Strategic Plan Goals: Reduce greenhouse gas emissions (GHG) 50% by 2030 and 80% by 2050. ➢Achieve a 50% waste diversion rate by 2030. •Divert 80% of organics from the landfill by 2030. •Divert 100% of recoverable construction and demolition debris from the landfill by 2030. •Develop policy prohibiting single-use plastics. 39 Recycling Ordinance Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability 2014 community-wide recycling ordinance established: ➢Recycling rates embedded with trash hauling rates ➢Residential volume-based pricing (Pay as You Throw) ➢Prohibition on recyclable materials discarded as trash ➢Waste hauler registration and data reporting ➢On-site recycling requirement ➢Equal service rate requirement (residential recycling collected as frequent as trash) 40 Public Outreach and Education Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability ➢Compost Programs: •West Vail Curbside Compost Program •Subscription Drop-off Program •Business Compost Program •Municipal Compost Program ➢Hard to Recycle Event •May 8, 2026 10 am- 3 pm ➢Community Recycling Center ➢Kick the Bag Habit and Forget the Foam ➢Better than Bottled Campaign ➢Celebrate Green! Special Event Zero Waste Program 41 Bag Fees Collected Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability Year Fee Collected Number of Paper Bags Sold 2025 $88,526 885,260 2024 $82,578 825,780 2023 $72,786 727,860 2022 $46,955 469,550 2021 $43,047 430,473 2020 $31,547 315,470 2019 $32,923 329,230 2018 $33,381 333,810 2017 $31,920 319,200 42 Town of Vail Recycling Rates Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability recycling + composting _______________________________________________________________________________ (recycling + composting + landfill bound municipal solid waste) *Data includes residential and commercial municipal solid waste, including recycling and organics, only. Recycling rate = Vail Recycling Rate Estimates 2025 34% 2024 33% 2023 36% 2022 37% 2021 35% 2020 29% 2019 27% 2018 26% 2017 22% 2016 20% MSW (Landfill)- tons 9,524 7,979 6,938 6,840 6,772 8,369 11,487 10,871 9,832 8,995 Recycling- tons 4,173 3,266 3,312 3,676 3,411 3,201 3,897 3,597 2,755 2,224 Organics- tons 755 624 598 378 319 243 350 155 50 37.5 Recycling Rate 30%29%32%35%33%28%25%25%22%20% Recycling Rate w/ Organics 34%33%36%37%35%29%27%26%22%20% 43 Recycling Rates Over Time Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 16,000 18,000 2025 34%2024 33%2023 35%2022 37%2021 35%2020 29%2019 27%2018 26%2017 22%2016 20% To n n a g e Recycling Rate Vail Recycling Rates Organics- tons Recycling- tons MSW (Landfill)- tons 44 Diversion Rate with Construction and Demolition Debris Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability 15% of landfill waste = construction and demolition debris in 2025 20.8% construction and demolition debris recycled in 2025 11,247 11,878 12,309 10,952 10,447 1,723 3,899 5,371 4,112 3,674 4,626 4,078 4,418 4,248 3,698 453 812 1,106 572 288 0 2,000 4,000 6,000 8,000 10,000 12,000 14,000 2025 tons- 32% Diversion Rate 2024 tons- 28% Diverson Rate 2023 tons- 29% Diversion Rate 2022 tons- 30% Diversion Rate 2021 tons- 28% Diversion Rate Total MSW w/ C & D C & D (Landfill)Total Recycling w/ C&D C & D (Recycled)45 Organics Diversion 755 total tons of organic material diverted •90 Curbside compost participants •33 Subscription drop site participants •30 Commercial businesses composting 46 Zero Waste Events Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability *Data includes 16 Zero Waste Events 47 How Vail Measures Up Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability 34% 30% 63% 45% 16% 32% 80% 68% 63% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% Vail Eagle County (2024) Aspen Boulder (2024) Colorado United States San Francisco Germany Slovenia 2025 Recycling Rates 48 Extended Producer Responsibility Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability HB 22-1355 Producer Responsibility Program for Statewide Recycling Act ➢Companies that sell products in packaging or paper products will fund a statewide recycling system to recycle those materials. ➢Shifts the cost of recycling on the producers who introduce these materials into the marketplace. ➢Producer Responsibility Organization (PRO) formed. •Coordinate, fund, and manage the statewide recycling system •Circular Action Alliance appointed as PRO in May 2023 ➢Annual fees are eco-modulated, and all producers must pay into system starting January 1, 2026. ➢Estimated $267 million to be collected in year 1. ➢Goal: double state recycling rate by 2035. ➢Supports and grows local end markets for recycled packaging and paper by ensuring reliable, producer funded collection and processing. 49 Extended Producer Responsibility Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability The funds collected will be used to: 1.Expand Recycling Access in Colorado ➢Subsidize convenient curbside recycling for households, schools, small businesses, hospitality locations, and government buildings. ➢Free and equitable access 2.Support Local Recycling Providers ➢Reimbursements cover the costs of local haulers, recyclers, and nonprofits. 3.Standardize Materials Collected & Education ➢Consistent list of required and readily recyclable materials and statewide education campaigns. 50 Extended Producer Responsibility Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability What this means for Town of Vail: ➢Recycling will become free for residents, lowering trash and recycling bills starting in 2026 •May require code adjustments. ➢Community recycling centers eligible for reimbursement. ➢Town of Vail can be reimbursed for a portion of recycling education and outreach. ➢Schools, churches, municipalities and some small businesses will be eligible for reimbursement for recycling costs by 2030. ➢Staff and local haulers are working on documentation for a service agreement with CAA to ensure eligibility for reimbursements. 51 2026 Waste Diversion Initiatives Town of Vail | Environmental Sustainability High impact strategies to achieve a 50% waste diversion goal by 2030 ➢Love Vail waste reduction education ➢Expand curbside and business compost programs ➢Develop voluntary C & D diversion pilot Program ➢Single-Use Plastics Reduction ❑Water bottle filling stations ❑Better than Bottled education campaign ❑Single-use plastic fee ❑Plastic Free July ❑Town of Vail internal policy ❑Codify special events policy ❑Reusable cup program- Retrocycle 52 Staff Recommendations Based on potential effectiveness to increase waste diversion in the Town of Vail, staff is moving forward in implementing the following: 1)Solidify locations and installation plan for water bottle filling stations and release RFP. 2)Further the Better than Bottled campaign with guests and locals to reduce usage of single -use plastic water bottles and pursue the Plastic Free July campaign. 3)Revitalize the Love Vail education campaign with the rebranded logo and updated website. 4)Expand the curbside compost pilot program and business compost pilot program and bring results back to Council with policy recommendations. 5)Develop a voluntary C&D diversion pilot program to implement in 2027 and bring results back to Council with policy recommendations. 53 Staff Recommendations Staff further recommends returning to Council with proposals for the following high impact strategies: 1)Policy options to develop a fee on single-use plastics. 2)Internal town policy prohibiting the use and distribution of single -use plastics for internal town operations, town-run events and town-owned buildings. 3)Formalize the current special events policies requiring zero waste requirements and prohibition of using and distributing single-use plastic items at events as policy within the town code. 4)Should a critical number of Vail businesses want to pursue the Retrocycle reusable cup program, staff would propose a partnership using bag fee dollars during a future supplemental. Does the Town Council agree that the outlined initiatives are the direction staff should continue moving to increase waste diversion? 54 Thank you! Beth Markham Environmental Sustainability Manager bmarkham@vail.gov 970-479-2333 55 AGENDA ITEM NO. 4.1 Item Cover Page DATE:April 21, 2026 SUBMITTED BY:Greg Roy, Community Development ITEM TYPE:DRB/PEC Update AGENDA SECTION:DRB/PEC (4:45pm) SUBJECT:DRB/PEC update (5 min.) SUGGESTED ACTION: VAIL TOWN COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM REPORT ATTACHMENTS: 04-13-26 PEC Meeting Minutes.pdf 04-15-26 DRB Meeting Minutes.pdf 56 Planning and Environmental Commission Minutes Monday, April 13, 2026 1:00 PM Vail Town Council Chambers Present: John Rediker William A Jensen Lauren Wallace Brad Hagedorn Margaret H Brown Craig H Lintner Jr 1. Virtual Link Register to attend the Planning and Environmental Commission meeting. Once registered, you will receive a confirmation email containing information about joining this webinar. 2. Call to Order 3. Swearing in New Members 4. Election of Officers 5. Main Agenda 5.1 A request for review of a variance from Section 12-6D-6, Setbacks, pursuant to Chapter 17, Variances, Title 12, Vail Town Code, to allow for a reduction in the required setback, located at 816 & 826 Forest Road, Vail Village Filing 6, Block 1, Lot 14 & Lot 15 (PEC-26-4) The applicant has requested this item to be tabled to the April 27, 2026 PEC meeting. Planner: Greg Roy Applicant Name: Mexamer Forest Road LLC, represented by Mauriello Planning Group Time: 2 Mins John Rediker made a motion to Table to the April 27, 2026 Planning Environmental Commission meeting. ; William A Jensen seconded the motion Passed (6 - 0). 5.2 A request for the review of a Conditional Use Permit, pursuant to Section 12-6D-3, Conditional Uses, Vail Town Code, to allow for a Funicular pursuant to Section 12-16, Conditional Use Permits, Vail Town Code, located at 816 & 826 Forest Road, Vail Village Filing 6, Block 1, Lot 14 & Lot 15 (PEC-26-3) The applicant has requested this item to be tabled to the April 27, 2026 PEC meeting. Planning and Environmental Commission Meeting Minutes of April 13, 2026 1 57 Planner: Greg Roy Applicant Name: Mexamer Forest Road LLC represented by Mauriello Planning Group Time: 2 Mins John Rediker made a motion to Table to the April 27, 2026 PEC meeting; William A Jensen seconded the motion Passed (6 - 0). 5.3 A request for the review of a variance from Section 12-6D-6 Setbacks, Vail Town Code in accordance with the provisions of Section 12-17, Variances, Vail Town Code, to allow for a below grade addition beneath the garage within the front setback, located at 327 Rockledge Rd E / Lot A, Vail Village Filing 1, Block 7, a Resubdivision of Parcel A, Vail Village Filing 1, Block 7, and a Resubdivision of Lots 14 & 17. (PEC-26-5) Planner: Heather Knight Applicant Name: Nieve Vail LLC, represented by Pierce Austin Architects Time: 45 Min 327 Rockledge Variance Staff memo.pdf Attachment A. Vicinity Map.pdf Attachment B. 327 Rockledge Rd. - Applicant Project Narrative - Title Report.pdf Attachment C. 327 Rockledge Plan Set.pdf 327 Rockledge Joint Property Owner Letter.pdf (Recording timestamp: 00:03:56) Haggedorn opened Agenda Item 5.3 regarding a request for a variance from Section 12-6D-6 (Setbacks), Vail Town Code, to allow for a below-grade addition beneath the garage within the front setback at 327 Rockledge Road. Knight presented the application on behalf of staff. Knight began with a vicinity map and explained the location of the property, noting it is along Forest Road as it loops into Rockledge Road and is the first developed property in that area. She stated that the lot is a duplex and that this request applies to the east side of the property. Knight explained that the request is for a variance to allow an addition beneath the existing garage within the front setback. She stated that the proposed area is approximately 64 square feet and would be located below an existing garage encroachment that was originally approved through a variance in 1987. Knight provided background on the 1987 variance, stating that it was granted at that time due to a desire to protect existing trees and address the challenges of the sloped site. She noted that staff at that time indicated some of the hardship may have been self-imposed but the variance was still approved. Knight clarified that while the site does have slope, it is not considered a “steep slope” under current code because it does not exceed 30 percent. Knight stated that in March 2024, the property came before the Commission with a request for a second-story addition above the garage, which was denied because it increased bulk and mass within the front setback and did not meet the variance criteria. Knight explained that the design was later revised, removing the second-story encroachment and instead proposing a deck in that location. That deck encroachment was approved because it did not increase bulk and mass and helped resolve what had been described as an awkward design condition. Knight stated that the current request is different in that it is for approximately 64 square feet below grade beneath the garage. She noted that while this would not increase bulk and mass, it would increase the amount of enclosed square footage within the setback. Planning and Environmental Commission Meeting Minutes of April 13, 2026 2 58 Knight reviewed zoning for the property and stated that the site is already over its allowable site coverage, noting that the maximum allowed is 3,026 square feet and the property currently has approximately 3,676 square feet. She explained that the proposal does not increase site coverage but does increase GRFA within the setback area, although the property remains within its allowed GRFA overall. Knight reviewed the variance criteria. She stated that Criteria 1 is met because the addition is below grade and does not impact adjacent properties or increase bulk and mass. Knight stated that staff does not believe Criteria 2 is met. She explained that staff does not find a sufficient hardship unique to the property and that the request is more of a voluntary improvement to gain additional square footage rather than something necessary due to site constraints. She also noted that challenging construction methods do not constitute a hardship and described the request as somewhat self-imposed. Knight added that staff had not found examples of similar below -grade variances being approved in residential areas and raised concern about setting a precedent, noting this could become a “slippery slope.” Litner asked about comparison to commercial projects where underground variances have been allowed. Knight responded that she has seen that in commercial zones but not in residential districts. Knight stated that Criteria 3 is met, as the proposal would not impact light, air, public facilities, or safety since it is entirely below grade. Knight stated that staff recommends denial of the variance due to not meeting Criteria 2. Rediker asked how staff determines whether a property is considered steep slope. Knight explained that the code defines steep slope as greater than 30 percent and that this property does not meet that threshold based on slope analysis. Rediker asked whether the analysis would change if the property were considered steep slope. Knight stated that the code allows for certain encroachments such as a single-story garage in steep slope conditions but does not address below-grade improvements. Rediker followed up asking if a below-grade condition would be treated differently under steep slope provisions. Knight clarified that the code specifically references above-grade garage encroachments and does not speak to below-grade space. Wallace asked whether the basement could be shaped differently to comply with setbacks. Knight confirmed that if the space were pulled out of the setback, it would comply. Wallace asked about the existing crawl space and whether additional excavation would be required. Knight stated that she would defer to the applicant to explain the construction details and their argument regarding practical difficulty. Wallace asked about potential precedent and impacts if this were approved in residential areas. Knight responded that one concern is increasing GRFA within setbacks and questioned why setbacks would exist if that were allowed, even if below grade. She emphasized the need to be careful with that standard. Planning and Environmental Commission Meeting Minutes of April 13, 2026 3 59 Haggedorn moved the meeting to the applicant presentation. Reed Kildow and Kit Austin, representing the applicant, introduced themselves. Kildow explained the site conditions, stating that while the property may not meet the technical definition of steep slope, there is a significant grade change across the lot. He described the garage as being at grade on one side and dropping off significantly toward the back. Kildow explained that due to the slope, the garage is built on a structural slab with foundation walls extending down to frost depth, creating a deep crawl space beneath the garage. Austin confirmed that the garage is not slab-on-grade and that there is an existing crawl space beneath it, with portions already having over four feet of clearance. Kildow stated that the proposal does not increase site coverage and that the property remains under its allowable GRFA regardless of whether this space is used. Kildow stated that the project meets Criteria 1 and 3 and focused on Criteria 2, arguing that strict interpretation of the code creates a practical difficulty. Kildow referenced code language regarding practical difficulty and hardship, stating that the existing structure and site conditions qualify under those provisions. Kildow stated that the existing foundation and crawl space already create the volume, and that excavating and using that space would not impact the intent of the code or surrounding properties. Kildow explained that without the variance, they would need to construct a new interior wall and effectively leave a portion of the existing space unusable, describing this as unnecessary and not aligned with the purpose of the code. Kildow stated that this would result in building a wall that serves no real purpose other than meeting a strict interpretation of the code, which he described as a practical difficulty. Austin added that the condition is unique, noting that the volume already exists and that this is not a typical case of creating new space but rather using space that is already there. Jensen asked about special privilege and how approving this would not set a precedent for future applicants. Kildow responded that this situation is unique due to the existing structural conditions and that it is not comparable to creating new below-grade space under a typical slab-on-grade garage. Hagedorn asked for clarification on the code language regarding existing structures. Kildow cited Section 12-17-1 and stated that hardship can result from the location of existing structures. Rediker asked whether the hardship is truly present or if the request is voluntary, noting that development could still occur without the variance. Kildow responded that the practical difficulty is the need to construct additional structural elements and fill space unnecessarily when the volume already exists. Rediker asked about the depth of the foundation walls. Austin stated that the walls extend approximately 12 feet below the garage level, creating a significant existing volume beneath the structure. Planning and Environmental Commission Meeting Minutes of April 13, 2026 4 60 Kildow continued regarding how the space would be treated if the variance were denied, including options such as filling the space with dirt or constructing interior walls, which the applicant described as impractical. Kildow reiterated that strict application of the code would require filling or blocking off an existing 12- foot-deep space, which he described as not making practical sense. Jensen asked about access to the proposed space. Kildow and Austin explained that due to the slope, there is approximately a 12-foot drop across the property, allowing access from the lower side into the basement level. Rediker asked how far into the setback the encroachment extends. Austin responded that it is approximately seven and a half feet at its furthest point. Rediker asked about utilities within the setback. Austin stated they were not aware of any utilities in that specific area but noted that they would need to verify. Knight added that there are no known utility easements in the front setback and noted the difference between commercial and residential setback standards. Litner asked whether there is a definition of “practical difficulty” in the code. Knight stated that there is not a specific definition provided. Haggedorn opened public comment. No public comment was received. Haggedorn closed public comment and moved to Commissioner discussion. Jensen stated that he agreed with the applicant and other Commissioners that this was a truly unique situation. He referenced the original 1987 Planning and Environmental Commission approval of the garage encroachment into the setback and noted that while it is unclear whether the Commission at that time considered buildout below the garage, the fact that the variance was unanimously approved carries weight. Jensen stated that the space already exists and that requiring the applicant to wall off approximately 67 square feet does not seem practical. He noted that the Commission had previously reviewed the property in March and worked through a number of concerns, ultimately arriving at a solution he felt comfortable with. Jensen acknowledged that the applicant had previously appeared to be maximizing development potential but stated that the current request felt reasonable. He concluded that he would be supportive of the variance. Rediker stated that he viewed this as a unique situation and that while he agreed with staff’s strict interpretation of the code, particularly with respect to the second variance criterion, he focused on how that criterion is applied in this case. He referenced the language regarding relief from strict interpretation to achieve compatibility and uniformity without granting special privilege. Rediker noted that when the variance was granted in 1987, it allowed for construction of structural walls extending approximately 12 feet into the setback, which created the existing condition being discussed. He stated that while he shares concerns about setting precedent and allowing GRFA within setbacks, this situation differs because the space is entirely below grade and not visible. He emphasized that many of the purposes of Title 12, including impacts to light, air, and neighborhood character, are not affected in this case. Rediker stated that he would be concerned if this involved new construction or excavation beneath a typical slab-on-grade condition, but because the structure and 12-foot-deep walls already exist, he felt more comfortable supporting the variance. He concluded that he did not believe similar situations would arise frequently elsewhere in town due to the unique construction conditions. Planning and Environmental Commission Meeting Minutes of April 13, 2026 5 61 Litner stated that he agreed with the previous comments and that the issue largely comes down to interpretation of “practical difficulty.” He noted that in this case, there appears to be a clear practical difficulty in requiring the applicant to wall off or otherwise not utilize existing enclosed space. Litner stated that he also viewed this as a very unique situation and supported granting the variance based on those circumstances. Wallace stated that she did not believe denying the variance would help achieve the objectives of the setback regulations, particularly given the existing condition of the space. She noted that the lack of a clear definition of “practical difficulty” leaves room for interpretation and judgment by the Commission. Wallace stated that given the unique nature of the site and the history of the existing variance, she did not believe approval would constitute special privilege. She also noted that the property is not exceeding its allowable GRFA and that this fact contributed to her support of the request. Brown stated that she was persuaded by what she described as the illogical outcome of requiring the applicant to wall off existing enclosed volume. She noted that the space is already constructed and that prohibiting its use does not seem to further the intent of the code. However, Brown expressed concern that approval of the variance could be cited as precedent in future cases involving GRFA within setbacks. She stated that while she appreciated that the space is below grade and already enclosed, she believed the Commission would likely see similar arguments in the future. Brown noted that the situation is influenced by the unusual history of the approximately 67 square foot area and the original 1987 variance. She stated that she could support the variance but described it as a close call and noted that it feels close to granting special privilege. Haggedorn stated that he agreed with the comments made by the Commission. He noted that historically, the Commission has taken a strong position regarding GRFA within setbacks and that this has generally been treated as a clear standard. He stated that this situation is different and wanted to clearly articulate why for the record. Haggedorn explained that his initial understanding of the request was that it involved new excavation, in which case he would not have supported it. However, after further discussion, he recognized that the structure, including the walls extending approximately 12 feet below grade, already exists as a result of the previously approved variance. He emphasized that this existing condition is a critical distinction and that future applications without similar existing structural conditions would not be viewed the same way. Haggedorn also stated that he did not view this request as contradictory to the Commission’s prior denial of the 2024 application for an above- grade addition, noting that the previous request increased bulk and mass within the setback, whereas the current proposal does not create those impacts. He concluded that, given the unique circumstances and the existing structure, the request meets the variance criteria. Jensen asked for clarification regarding the motion language and findings referenced in the staff report. William A Jensen made a motion to Approve with the findings on pages 8-9.; Lauren Wallace seconded the motion Passed (6 - 0). 5.4 A request for review of a Floodplain Modification Permit pursuant to Section 12-21- 11(2), Floodplain Modification Permit, Vail Town Code, to allow for an instream habitat restoration project to improve aquatic habitat and stream function at the Vail Nature Center, located at 841 Vail Valley Drive (Unplatted – Ford Park). (PEC-26-6) Planner: Cole Michaelsen Applicant Name: Town of Vail, represented by Peter Wadden Time: 30 PEC-26-6 Staff Memo.pdf Attachment A. Vicinity Map.pdf Planning and Environmental Commission Meeting Minutes of April 13, 2026 6 62 Attachment B. Gore Creek Floodplain Memorandum Attachment C. Gore Creek Habitat Enhancement Plans (Recording timestamp: 00:55:55.50) Haggedorn introduced Agenda Item 5.4, a request for review of a floodplain modification permit pursuant to Section 12-21-11-2 of the Town Code to allow an in-stream habitat restoration project at the Vail Nature Center. Michaelsen provided a staff presentation and overview of the request. He stated that this type of application is relatively uncommon before the Planning and Environmental Commission, noting that while floodplain use permits are more typical, floodplain modification permits are less frequently reviewed. Michaelsen explained that the request pertains specifically to work occurring within the floodplain rather than the overall project scope. Michaelsen oriented the Commission to the project location, explaining that the work would occur between the Vail Nature Center and Ford Park, including the area near the amphitheater. He noted that the surrounding parcels are largely Town-owned and that the project would be staged primarily from the Nature Center property. He also identified the mapped floodplain area and clarified that portions of the proposed work fall within the 100-year floodplain. Michaelsen explained that the floodplain modification permit is required for any work occurring within the 100-year floodplain under Town Code. He stated that the review process includes two components: a technical engineering review conducted by the Floodplain Administrator and a separate review by the Commission based on the applicable code criteria. Michaelsen noted that the Floodplain Administrator, identified as the Town Engineer, had reviewed the applicant’s hydrologic and engineering materials and determined that the proposal met all technical criteria. Michaelsen further explained that the intent of the floodplain regulations is to protect life and property and to maintain floodplain function. He stated that the Commission’s role is to evaluate whether the proposed work would function safely within the floodplain and avoid negative downstream impacts, particularly with respect to flood risk and safety. Haggedorn asked for clarification on whether the request involved an amendment to the floodplain boundary. Michaelsen clarified that no map amendment was proposed and that the request only pertained to work occurring within the existing floodplain. Haggedorn then opened the floor to the applicant. Wadden introduced himself as a Watershed Specialist with the Town’s Environmental Sustainability Department and provided an overview of the project. He stated that the project is funded in part through settlement funds from the 2021 snowmaking spill on Gore Creek and supplemented by grant funding obtained in partnership with Eagle Valley Trout Unlimited. He described the project as an approximately $600,000 in-stream restoration effort. Wadden explained that the purpose of the project is to improve aquatic habitat, restore riparian conditions, and address hydrologic issues within the creek. He noted that some of these issues stem from historic upstream modifications to the stream channel that occurred prior to current regulatory standards. He stated that the project is designed to increase floodplain capacity and connectivity while enhancing habitat for trout and aquatic macroinvertebrates. Wadden explained that the purpose of the floodplain modification permit is generally to prevent activities that could negatively impact downstream properties, such as filling within the creek. He emphasized that this project is designed to have the opposite effect by improving flood capacity within the reach. He Planning and Environmental Commission Meeting Minutes of April 13, 2026 7 63 stated that based on the submitted studies and engineering review, the project will not increase flood elevations and is expected to improve overall floodplain function. He noted that no external boulder material would be introduced and that work would primarily involve rearranging existing material within the creek, along with the addition of some woody material. Jensen asked about the effectiveness of the project in restoring the creek to pre-2021 conditions and whether the habitat would return to prior levels. Wadden responded that the 2021 incident was a discrete aquatic life mortality event and that fish and insect populations in the affected reach have already largely recovered through natural processes. He explained that the settlement funding provides an opportunity not only to restore conditions but to improve them beyond pre -2021 levels. He noted that this aligns with broader Town goals, including improving water quality in Gore Creek and working toward removal from the state’s impaired waterways list. Rediker asked about the construction schedule and whether the work would occur within a single season. Wadden explained that in- stream construction is limited by environmental regulations related to trout spawning and is generally restricted to a window between approximately August 15 and the end of September. He noted that Colorado Parks and Wildlife has allowed an earlier start date of August 1 for this project. Wadden stated that all in-stream work, including excavation and placement of materials, is planned to occur between August 1 and September 30, 2026. He added that some vegetative restoration work may continue beyond that timeframe into late fall or subsequent years, but that work would not involve heavy equipment or in-stream disturbance. Rediker asked for clarification regarding construction methods and whether the project would involve excavation to create deeper pools within the stream. Wadden confirmed that heavy equipment, including excavators, would be used during construction to reshape the stream channel. He explained that the existing condition is characterized by a shallow, wide channel with limited habitat diversity due to sediment deposition from upstream flows. He stated that the project aims to create a low-flow, deeper channel with defined pools and riffles, improving habitat conditions. He explained that sediment transported from upstream currently fills in existing pools, creating poor habitat conditions. Haggedorn asked whether this condition is influenced by the upstream “shotgun” reach near the golf course. Wadden confirmed that the upstream straightened reach contributes to higher flow velocities and increased sediment transport into the project area. Rediker asked whether ongoing maintenance, such as periodic dredging or excavation, would be required after construction. Wadden explained that the project is designed to be self-sustaining and that no future excavation is anticipated. He stated that the design incorporates features such as three upstream boulder veins that establish grade control and direct flow, as well as an existing boulder vein near the pedestrian bridge that anchors the downstream end of the reach. He explained that these features, along with strategically placed point bars and woody material, are intended to use the stream’s natural energy to transport sediment through the reach rather than allowing it to accumulate. He noted that addressing upstream sediment sources, particularly near the golf course, will be important over time and referenced future improvements associated with the golf course enhancement plan. Rediker asked how reduced streamflow’s in drier years could affect the performance of the project, particularly with respect to sediment transport. Planning and Environmental Commission Meeting Minutes of April 13, 2026 8 64 Wadden responded that while low flows present challenges, they also provide favorable construction conditions. He stated that lower water levels make it safer and easier to operate equipment within the channel. He explained that the project is designed to improve habitat resilience during low-flow conditions by creating deeper pools that provide refuge for aquatic species. Wadden acknowledged that current conditions reflect a drier and warmer trend and stated that the project is designed to function under those conditions by improving sediment transport efficiency relative to upstream inputs. Rediker asked about sediment control during construction and how impacts downstream would be minimized. Wadden indicated that best management practices would be implemented and deferred to Scarbrough to provide additional detail. Brent Scarbrough introduced himself as the owner of Frontier Environmental Services and described the construction approach. He explained that a silt curtain system would be used, consisting of a floating boom across the creek with a submerged curtain to capture sediment. He stated that construction would also involve temporarily channelizing the creek to one side, allowing work to occur in a dry or isolated portion of the channel, and then shifting flow to the completed side to continue work. He noted that while some turbidity is expected during certain phases, much of the work will occur outside of active flow conditions. Rediker asked how the silt curtain would be maintained during periods of high turbidity and whether accumulated sediment would need to be removed. Scarbrough responded that the intent is for the curtain to remain in place for the duration of the project but noted that it can be removed and replaced if necessary. He explained that removal may cause temporary disturbance but that such events would be limited and short in duration. Hanlon asked about the log placement (sheet 23 of 24), specifically whether the structures are 20 feet tall. Wadden confirmed that the logs are approximately 20- foot sections and are driven into the creek bank. He explained that the design mimics a natural system, using large woody material similar to fallen trees to stabilize banks and prevent erosion. Hanlon asked whether the logs are part of the permanent installation. Wadden confirmed that they are intended to remain in place long-term. Hagedorn asked for clarification, comparing the installation to driving piles. Scarbrough confirmed that the installation method is similar to pile driving, using specialized equipment adapted for logs. Jensen asked about the budget implications for the golf course project and whether funding adjustments impacted timing. Wadden explained that there is currently no Town funding available for full construction of the golf course project, but design work for the first phase is anticipated in 2026, potentially extending into early 2027 depending on grant funding. He noted that he has pursued additional grant opportunities and is continuing to seek outside funding sources. Wallace asked whether the woody installations pose a safety hazard, particularly for stream users and potential strainers. Planning and Environmental Commission Meeting Minutes of April 13, 2026 9 65 Wadden responded that the structures are not loose within the channel but are embedded directly into the bank, unlike naturally fallen trees. He stated that because of this design, they are less hazardous to whitewater users than typical debris in a natural stream system. Wallace asked about the expected lifecycle of the materials used in the project. Lucas Babbitt introduced himself and explained that when wood is submerged and not exposed to direct sunlight, it can last approximately 20 years before significant decay occurs. He noted that during this time, the structures will function to capture sediment and promote bar formation. He further explained that vegetation—particularly willows—will establish during this period, and root systems will ultimately provide long-term stabilization beyond the lifespan of the wood itself. Wallace asked about the proposed accessible fishing platform and expressed concern about balancing habitat restoration with increased public access. Wadden provided an overview of the project history and funding sources, including a Natural Resource Damage Fund award and matching funds through Colorado Parks and Wildlife’s “Fishing is Fun” program. He explained that the accessible fishing platform is intended to improve recreational access for anglers with disabilities, which helped secure grant funding. Wadden acknowledged that increased access presents challenges in an already heavily used corridor. He described strategies to manage impacts, including concentrating access at designated entry points, discouraging use of sensitive areas, and using signage, physical barriers, and vegetation (including thorny plantings) to guide public behavior and protect restored habitat. Wallace asked about potential redevelopment in the Ford Park and amphitheater area and whether future development poses concerns for the restoration project and floodplain criteria. Wadden responded that the current timing is favorable due to both water conditions and available grant funding. He stated that he intends to remain engaged with future development efforts in the area to ensure protection of the creek corridor. Hagedorn asked whether the project represents the best use of funds compared to addressing upstream sources of sediment and degradation in the “shotgun” reach. Wadden responded that some limitations are driven by funding requirements, which prioritize projects accessible to the public and tied to the original incident. He acknowledged that addressing upstream sources is important and stated that while this project will provide significant ecological benefit, additional upstream work will still be needed to fully resolve watershed issues. Hagedorn emphasized that the upstream source of the problem must ultimately be addressed. Wadden agreed and noted that there is a regulatory timeline requiring improvements to water quality conditions in the watershed by approximately 2029–2031. Haggedorn opened public comment. Haggedorn moved commissioner comments. Rediker summarized the applicable review criteria from the staff memorandum, noting that the project is intended to improve floodplain function and stream health rather than degrade it. He stated that, based on the criteria, the project satisfies the required standards. No additional commissioner comments were offered. Planning and Environmental Commission Meeting Minutes of April 13, 2026 10 66 John Rediker made a motion to Approve with the findings on pages 16 -17 and with the condition that the Town of Vail Floodplain Modification Permit is dependent upon receipt of and Army Corps of Engineers Nationwide permit.; Craig H Lintner Jr seconded the motion Passed (6 - 0). 6. Approval of Minutes 6.1 03-23-26 PEC Minutes 03-23-26 PEC Minutes.pdf John Rediker made a motion to Approve ; William A Jensen seconded the motion Passed (5 - 0). 7. Information Update 8. Adjournment John Rediker made a motion to Approve ; William A Jensen seconded the motion Passed (6 - 0). Planning and Environmental Commission Meeting Minutes of April 13, 2026 11 67 Design Review Board Minutes Wednesday, April 15, 2026 2:00 PM Vail Town Council Chambers Present: Rys Olsen Mary C Egan Roland J Kjesbo Anthony J Grandt Herbert B Roth 1. Virtual Meeting Link Register to attend Design Review Board Meetings. Once registered, you will receive a confirmation email containing information about joining this webinar. 2. Call to Order 3. Main Agenda 3.1 DRB-26-31 - Concert Hall Plaza Final review of a redevelopment of Concert Hall Plaza Address/ Legal Description: 616 West Lionshead Circle/Lot 1, Vail Lionshead Filing 4 Planner: Heather Knight Applicant Name: Beaver Capital SPE LLC, represented by Mauriello Planning Group CHP DRB Plan Set.pdf Concert Hall Plaza Applicant Narrative.pdf CHP Public Comment 041526.pdf 4.15.26 2nd DRB Challenge Ltr.pdf CHP Conditions of Approval - DRB.pdf Roland J Kjesbo made a motion to Approve with Conditions with the findings that the application meets the requirements of Sections 14-10-3, 14-10-4, 14-10-5, 14-10-6 of the Town Code and the following conditions: 1. Prior to the issuance of the first building permit for the project, the Applicant shall mitigate the employee housing impact for 327.65 new net square feet of commercial and residential development in accordance with the provisions for chapter 12- 23 commercial linkage and 12-24 inclusionary zoning VTC. 2. Prior to the issuance of the first certificate of occupancy for the project, the applicant shall have executed a snowmelt system operations and maintenance agreement in a form approved by the Town Attorney for a new snowmelt system to cover operating costs of the Town's snowmelt system located on private property and Town owned property leased to the property owner for any encroachments (public easement, public stairs, etc.). Impacts to the Town's snowmelt system will need to be replaced by the full zone at the project's cost, splicing the snowmelt tubing will not be accepted. 3. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, any use of town property required for construction access or staging must be approved by the Vail Public Works Department. Vail Town Council approval is required for any variance from the Vail Village and Lionshead Village Construction Information Handout. 4. A detailed construction management and staging plan will be required prior to the issuance of any building permit. This includes impacts to TOV infrastructure such as lighting/electrical and Design Review Board Meeting Minutes of April 15, 2026 1 68 snowmelt system (no splicing of snowmelt tubing allowed). The plan also includes allowable work hours in the public Right-of-Way; the management plan shall adhere to the Vail Village and Lionshead Village Construction Information Handout. Variances from these restrictions require Vail Town Council approval. 5. Existing street lighting and any other public wayfinding or furniture (benches for bus stop, etc) impacted by the proposed improvements will need to be relocated at the applicant’s expense to a location approved by Town of Vail Public Works Department. 6. Prior to the issuance of a building permit, the applicant shall receive approval from the Vail Town Council for the modifications to the documented pedestrian easement. 7. The applicant shall receive approval for the amended plat or other legal instrument showing the modification to the easement and record the plat prior to the issuance of a Certification of Occupancy. 8. The applicant for this project is required to submit a framing improvement location certificate (ILC) showing ridge and eave elevations in compliance with the approved development plan in conjunction with the building permit inspection process. 9. Any outstanding review comments from TOV staff will need to be resolved prior to building permit submittal. 10. Applicant to resolve trash pickup area with TOV Public Works department prior to building permit submittal. If significant design changes need to be made, a DRB Change to Approve set of plans must be submitted and approved prior to building permit submittal. 11. Applicant to meet with the Town of Vail Fire Department regarding the parking automation system prior to building permit submittal. ; Rys Olsen seconded the motion Passed (5 - 0). 4. Staff Approvals 4.1 DRB24 -0411 (Change to Approved Plans 2) - Edwards Residence Final review of a changed to approved plans (roof) Address/ Legal Description: 281 Bridge Street 14/ Lot D & E, Block 5C, Vail Village Filing 1 Planner: Greg Roy Applicant Name: Daniel Edwards, represented by Pierce Austin Architects 4.2 DRB25-0207 (Change to Approved Plans 1) - Ferguson Residence Final review of a changed to approved plans (exterior materials, windows, deck, door, lights) Address/ Legal Description: 1700 Lions Ridge Loop/Lot 18, Dauphinais-Moseley Subdivision Filing 1 Planner: Cole Michaelsen Applicant Name: Andrew & Raechal Ferguson, represented by KH Webb Architects 4.3 DRB25 -0280 (Change to Approved Plans 1) - Stolzer Vail Forest LLC Final review of a change to approved plans (windows) Address/ Legal Description: 416 Forest Road B/Lot 3, Block 1, Vail Village Filing 3 Planner: Heather Knight Applicant Name: Stolzer Vail Forest LLC, represented by Sipes Architects INC. 4.4 DRB25 -0457 (Change to Approved Plans 1) - Potato Patch Condos Final review of a change to approved plans (siding/roof/railing) Address/ Legal Description: 770 Potato Patch Drive/Lot 6, Block 2, Vail Potato Patch Filing 1 Planner: Heather Knight Applicant Name: Potato Patch Condos, represented by Pierce Austin Architects 4.5 DRB-26-19 - Village Inn Plaza Condominiums Design Review Board Meeting Minutes of April 15, 2026 2 69 A final review of an exterior alteration (landscaping) Address/ Legal Description: 68 East Meadow Drive/Lot O, Block 5D, Vail Village Filing 1 Planner: Greg Roy Applicant Name: Village Inn Plaza Condominium Association, represented by Mac Design, Inc. 4.6 DRB-26-40 - Simba Run Condos Final review of an exterior alteration (roof) Address/ Legal Description: 110 North Fontage Road West/ Simba Run Subdivision Planner: Greg Roy Applicant Name: Simba Run Condos, represented by Turner Morris Roofing 4.7 DRB-26-42 - Suszynski Residence Final review of an addition Address/ Legal Description: 1481 Aspen Grove Lane/Lot 1, Block 2, Lion's Ridge Subdivision Filing 4 Planner: Greg Roy Applicant Name: Conrad & Kristina Suszynski, represented by Martin Manley Architects 4.8 DRB-26-51 - Potato Patch 17 LLC A final review of an exterior alteration (two windows) Address/ Legal Description: 770 Potato Patch Drive/Lot 6, Block 2, Vail Potato Patch Filing 1 Planner: Heather Knight Applicant Name: Potato Patch 17 LLC, represented by Pierce Austin Architects 4.9 DRB-26-54 - Timber Falls Condos Final review of an exterior alteration (reroof) Address/ Legal Description: 4459 Timber Falls Court/Timber Falls Condominiums Planner: Cole Michaelsen Applicant Name: Timber Falls Condos, represented by Bear Brothers Roofing 4.10 DRB-26-65 - Pinos Del Norte A final review of a tree removal Address/ Legal Description: 600 Vail Vaelly Drive/Tract B,Vail Village Filing 7 Planner: Heather Knight Applicant Name: Pinos Del Norte, represented by Elevated Arborist LLC 4. 11 DRB-26- 72 - Vail East Townhomes And Condominiums A final review of a tree removal Address/ Legal Description: 5020 Main Gore Place 18/Vail East Townhomes And Condominiums Planner: Cole Michaelsen Applicant Name: Vail Corp DBA Vail Assoc Inc | The Fixed Assets Department, represented by Eagle River Water and Sanitation District 4. 12 DRB-26- 81 - Vail Point Townhome Assoc | Daryl Brady A final review of a exterior alteration (deck) Address/ Legal Description: 1881 Lions Ridge Loop/Tract C, Block 3, Lion's Ridge Subdivision Filing 3 Planner: Cole Michaelsen Design Review Board Meeting Minutes of April 15, 2026 3 70 Applicant Name: Vail Point Townhome Assoc | Daryl Brady, represented by Carlson Construction Company, Inc. 5. Staff Denials 6. Adjournment Anthony J Grandt made a motion to Adjourn ; Roland J Kjesbo seconded the motion Passed (5 - 0). Design Review Board Meeting Minutes of April 15, 2026 4 71 AGENDA ITEM NO. 5.1 Item Cover Page DATE:April 21, 2026 SUBMITTED BY:Kristen Bertuglia, Environmental Sustainability ITEM TYPE:Information Update AGENDA SECTION:Information Update (4:50pm) SUBJECT:Update on Dark Sky Community Designation SUGGESTED ACTION: VAIL TOWN COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM REPORT ATTACHMENTS: Dark Sky Memo- Updated New Guidelines 042126.pdf 72 TO: Vail Town Council FROM: Environmental Sustainability Department DATE: April 21, 2026 SUBJECT: Town of Vail Outdoor Lighting and Dark Sky Community designation I. PURPOSE The purpose of this memorandum is to provide an updated overview of the Town of Vail’s outdoor lighting standards, summarize current DarkSky International guidelines, and evaluate options for strengthening local regulations and pursuing designation as an International Dark Sky Community. This memo builds upon prior Town Council discussions and staff analysis conducted in 2016 and 2017, incorporating current best practices and evolving standards in lighting technology and policy. II. BACKGROUND In 2016 and 2017, the Town Council reviewed Vail’s outdoor lighting regulations and explored potential alignment with the International Dark-Sky Association (now DarkSky International) certification program. At that time, staff identified that Vail had a strong regulatory foundation, but also noted several gaps related to brightness limits, color temperature, monitoring, and community-wide implementation. The Town’s current lighting standards were adopted through Ordinance No. 21, Series of 2008, codified in Section 14-10-7 of the Vail Town Code. These standards emphasize: • Fully shielded (full cutoff) lighting • Directional lighting to minimize glare and trespass • Limits on fixture height and placement • Prohibition of certain high-impact lighting types These provisions remain consistent with core DarkSky principles and continue to provide a strong baseline. III. CURRENT DARKSKY INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS (2026) Since the Town’s initial review, DarkSky International guidelines have evolved in response to widespread adoption of LED lighting and increasing awareness of ecological impacts. Key current standards include: 1. Light Shielding and Direction • All outdoor lighting should be fully shielded • Light must be directed downward and not emitted above the horizontal plane 2. Color Temperature • Maximum recommended: 3000 Kelvin 73 Town of Vail Page 2 • Current best practice: 2700K or lower, particularly in environmentally sensitive areas 3. Brightness (Lumens) • Regulation based on total lumens per site, rather than number of fixtures • Use of lighting zones to tailor standards by land use 4. Lighting Controls • Required use of: o timers o motion sensors o dimming technology • Implementation of curfews (e.g., reduced lighting after evening hours) 5. LED Lighting Standards • Increased emphasis on limiting blue-rich light emissions • Requirement for fully shielded LED fixtures • Avoidance of retrofitting high-output LEDs into non-compliant fixtures 6. Monitoring and Reporting • Ongoing tracking of sky brightness (e.g., Sky Quality Meter (SQM) measurements) • Annual reporting on community progress 7. Community Commitment • Public education programs • Demonstrated community support • Municipal leadership through retrofit of public lighting IV. COMPARISON TO CURRENT VAIL LIGHTING STANDARDS Based on the 2016–2017 review and updated standards, Vail’s existing code remains a strong foundation but would require updates to meet current designation criteria. Strengths • Full cutoff/shielding requirements • Directional lighting standards • Existing design review process • Longstanding policy commitment to reducing light pollution Gaps (Updated) • No codified color temperature limit • No lumen-based brightness caps • Limited requirements for adaptive controls or curfews • No formal monitoring program • Limited framework for municipal retrofit and compliance tracking • Insufficient regulation of LED retrofits and spectral impacts V. PATHWAY TO DARKSKY DESIGNATION To pursue designation, the Town would need to: 1. Update Lighting Code • Establish maximum color temperature (≤3000K, with lower targets recommended) • Implement lumen-based limits and lighting zones • Require controls such as timers and dimming 74 Town of Vail Page 3 • Strengthen provisions addressing LED technology 2. Demonstrate Municipal Leadership • Retrofit Town-owned lighting to meet updated standards • Develop a compliance and retrofit plan 3. Expand Community Engagement • Public education and outreach programs • Partnerships with local organizations and utilities 4. Implement Monitoring • Establish a sky brightness monitoring program • Track progress and submit annual reports VI. POLICY CONSIDERATIONS Strengthening outdoor lighting standards offers multiple co-benefits: • Protection of wildlife and ecological systems • Preservation of night sky visibility and community character • Reduction in energy use and greenhouse gas emissions • Improved public health and safety through reduced glare Given Vail’s alpine environment and proximity to sensitive habitats, updated standards would align with broader environmental and sustainability goals. VII. POLICY DIRECTION While pursuing a DarkSky designation is not currently in the staff work plan, staff recognizes the alignment between adopted strategic environmental and sustainability goals, promotion of biodiversity, climate, the mountain experience, etc. Staff invites Council to provide direction on next steps. The Town Council may consider the following options: 1. Maintain current lighting standards (status quo) 2. Implement targeted updates (e.g., color temperature, controls) 3. Pursue comprehensive code updates aligned with DarkSky standards and initiate designation process. Council is also asked to consider if implementation of DarkSky designation is directed, staff would then bring back actions for Council’s consideration from the 2026 Strategic Plan to delay or not pursue, or add resources to ensure the Town has adequate resources to implement Council’s direction. VIII. ATTACHMENTS A. US Dark Sky Communities List 75 Town of Vail Page 4 Attachment A Community State Year Designated Flagstaff Arizona 2001 (First) Sedona Arizona 2014 Thunder Mountain Pootsee Nightsky Arizona 2015 Borrego Springs California 2009 Breckenridge Colorado 2023/2026 Crestone Colorado 2021 Norwood Colorado 2019 Nucla & Naturita Colorado 2021 Old Snowmass Colorado 2024 Paonia Colorado 2022 Ridgway Colorado 2020 Westcliffe & Silver Cliff Colorado 2015 Palos Preserves Illinois 2021 Ketchum Idaho 2017 Cosmic Campground New Mexico 2015 Oregon Outback Oregon 2024 Blanco Texas 2022 Jonestown Texas 2023 Lakewood Village Texas 2019 Wimberley Valley Texas 2018 Bluff Utah 2025 Springdale Utah 2023 Torrey Utah 2018 Table 1- US Designated Dark Sky Communities 76 AGENDA ITEM NO. 5.2 Item Cover Page DATE:April 21, 2026 SUBMITTED BY:Pete Wadden ITEM TYPE:Information Update AGENDA SECTION:Information Update (4:50pm) SUBJECT:Update on Vail Nature Center In-Stream Project SUGGESTED ACTION: VAIL TOWN COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM REPORT ATTACHMENTS: Staff_Memorandum_VNC_In-Stream_Project_TC042126.pdf 77 TO: Vail Town Council FROM: Environmental Sustainability Department DATE: April 21, 2026 SUBJECT: Vail Nature Center In-Stream Project – Response to Council Questions I.PURPOSE On April 7, 2026, Staff met with members of the Vail Town Council at the Vail Nature Center to discuss construction staging, access, restoration and overall management of the Vail Nature Center In-Stream Habitat Project. Staff have further investigated questions about construction access and changes to visitor use patterns: 1.Can a crane be used to lower the 280 logs for the project from Vail Valley Drive to the Nature Center Project site to avoid disturbance to the hillside between Vail Valley Drive and the Vail Nature Center? 2.Can the proposed handicap accessible fishing platform be moved out of the project reach? 3.How will angling be managed after the project and will increased angler use lead to a proliferation of social trails, trampled streamside vegetation and eroding streambanks? II.BACKGROUND/SUMMARY In late 2023, the state attorney general’s office and Vail Resorts had agreed upon a settlement to be paid resulting from a 2021 snowmaking spill and subsequent aquatic life mortality event on Gore Creek. The approximately $250,000 in Natural Resource Defense (NRD) funds were allocated to Eagle Valley Trout Unlimited (EVTU) through a unique, non-competitive grant process on the conditions that EVTU secure matching funds and complete a project near where the original spill had occurred. Town and Trout Unlimited staff secured $200,000 in grant funds from the Colorado Parks and Wildlife (CPW) Fishing is Fun (FIF) program as the necessary match for the NRD settlement funds. Town Council allocated $100,000 in the 2025 budget and EVTU raised an additional $67,000 in contributions from their members for a total project budget of $617,000. Colorado Parks and Wildlife aquatic biologists and Town staff identified a reach of Gore Creek at the east end of Ford Park as the optimal project location. This reach of stream is near the section of creek that was impacted by the 2021 spill and is in need of in-stream 78 Town of Vail Page 2 habitat improvement. The reach has high potential to become outstanding habitat for trout and aquatic invertebrates because of its robust riparian buffers and mature tree canopy, but in-stream habitat has been degraded by hydrological factors caused by modified sections of creek upstream. The stated goals of the project in the contract for the Colorado Parks and Wildlife FIF grant are: •Improve in-stream adult trout habitat and increase fishing opportunities by using natural channel design techniques and construction using boulders and large woody debris. •Match Vail Resorts settlement by matching with FIF and other project funds targeted for Gore Creek restoration •Improve access, including accommodations for disabled anglers on pathways and fishing locations •Mitigate stormwater management issues where needed. EVTU, in partnership with the town, posted a request for proposals for a qualified design- build firm for the project in early 2025 and the team of Frontier Environmental and WaterVation was selected through a competitive bid process. The design-build team has completed 100% designs and obtained floodplain modification permits from the Town. Construction is planned for August 1- September 30, 2026. III.DISCUSSION Using a crane to get wood material to the project site Council members expressed concern that the proposed method of getting woody material onto the project site would impact the vegetation on the hillside between Vail Valley Drive and the Vail Nature Center. The project team has proposed protecting a 50-foot wide portion of the hillside from impact with mats and plywood and using skid rail logs to roll/slide the 280 logs from Vail Valley Drive to the project site. Following the project, impacts to the area would be restored and rehabilitated to better-than current condition with new native trees, shrubs, grasses and wildflower seed. Following the request from Council, staff asked the design/ build team to provide a quote for the use of a crane to lower the 280 twenty-foot long logs onto the project site. The estimated cost of the crane, required traffic control, and labor for this task is between $81,000 and $100,000 and would require the closure of Vail Valley Drive for 10-15 days. Traffic control alone is estimated to be $51,035. This cost is not included in the current project budget and is much greater than the $5,000-10,000 in restoration costs for mitigation of impacts of the originally proposed method. 79 Town of Vail Page 3 Staff recommends using the originally proposed methods to import logs over a limited portion the hillside between Vail Valley Drive and the VNC site and fully restore the area to a condition better than that seen today for less than $10,000. Moving the handicap accessible fishing platform off the project site The handicap fishing access proposed as a part of this project design will provide a low impact, rare opportunity for anglers with limited mobility to enjoy a high-quality fishing opportunity on a mountain trout stream on an already-degraded and impacted section of the stream front trail. Most handicap fishing access in Colorado is on lakes, so the proposed access on a trout stream was a very important component of the project for the Fishing is Fun grant reviewers. Town Council expressed concern that the handicap accessible fishing platform proposed near the Vail Nature Center pedestrian bridge at the far west end of the project site would be used by amphitheater concert-goers as a location to drink beer and listen to music. Council asked if the handicap fishing access could be moved off the project site. Staff reached out to grantors and partners at Colorado Parks and Wildlife with this question. While CPW FIF staff were open to discussions about moving the fishing access within the project reach, the access must remain within the project reach to meet the parameters of the grant. Staff have investigated whether there are other feasible locations for the accessible angler access within the project site. The originally proposed location is close to handicap parking spaces and is the best available spot for a wheelchair-accessible fishing access within the project reach. The proposed location is a flat area of trampled streambank within 50 yards of the pedestrian bridge. The proposed design involves leveling an already-degraded approximately 8 foot by 6 foot area with compacted gravel and stabilizing the area with boulders to prevent erosion. Staff does not recommend relocating the fishing platform. 80 Town of Vail Page 4 Managing fishing access and social trails post project Project partners and sponsors identified the proliferation of social trails along the project reach as a major contributor to the degradation of riparian areas at the Vail Nature Center. Unmanaged access by nature center visitors of all user types has contributed to the current condition of the streambanks at the site. One goal of this project is to reduce the number of social trails and gathering areas along the streambank by closing some trails and designating access points in strategic locations. A shared goal of the two state grants and generous private donations which, combined, have contributed $517,000 of the $617,000 total project budget was to improve fishing opportunities and angler access on this reach of creek. The NRD settlement that initiated this project was calculated based on the value and number of trout lost in the 2021 snowmaking spill. A primary goal of those funds and a reason they were allocated to a project in the Gore Creek Watershed without a typical competitive grant process was the desire to restore trout populations and fishing opportunities on Gore Creek. The Colorado Fishing is Fun program exists to provide “funds to improve angling opportunities in Colorado.” Members of Eagle Valley Trout Unlimited donated a total of $67,000 in private funds because of their enthusiasm for this project and its potential to enhance trout and aquatic invertebrate communities and fishing access for handicapped anglers on Gore Creek. Given the project goals, town staff does not recommend planning an official fishing moratorium following project completion, however, staff will work with CPW to enforce any fishing closures due to low-stream flows or high temperatures that aquatic biologists recommend enacting in this or future low-water years. IV.NEXT STEPS Handicapped-accessible fishing platform on the Yampa River in Steamboat Springs 81 Town of Vail Page 5 Unless there is different direction from the Town Council, staff will work with the contractors to ensure the protections and protocol outlined above are implemented properly, and will be onsite daily beginning August 1st to monitor all activities. The project will be completed by October 1st, 2026, and revegetation plans will begin to be implemented before the project is completed. 82 AGENDA ITEM NO. 5.3 Item Cover Page DATE:April 21, 2026 SUBMITTED BY:Stephanie Bibbens, Public Works ITEM TYPE:Information Update AGENDA SECTION:Information Update (4:50pm) SUBJECT:March 2, 2026 AIPP Meeting Minutes SUGGESTED ACTION: VAIL TOWN COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM REPORT ATTACHMENTS: March 2, 2026 Minutes.pdf 83 1 Art in Public Places Board Meeting Minutes March 2, 2026 AIPP Board members present: Lindsea Stowe, Susanne Graff, Tracy Gordon, Ramsey Cotter, Kathy Langenwalter Also present for Dobson site visit: Jared Biniecki & Kirk Hansen representing VRD for Dobson Art Selection Committee, Courtney St. John Community Member – Dobson Art Selection Committee; Scott O’Connell – Deputy Executive Director, Vail Recreation District; John King, Town of Vail; Steve Sego and Chris Knight, Cummings Group; Cortney Stell and Jenna Meachem – Black Cube Nomadic Art Museum. Others present: Molly Eppard - AIPP Coordinator 1. Call to Order 2. Citizen Participation Ian Grask – Requests amendment to public comment from Feb. minutes requesting the inclusion of Vail Symposium was present at Jen Stark event and NY Times critic was in town who would have enjoyed the event. He remarks that the landscape space by the Art Studio be kept open with opportunities for art, be mindful of excessive water use and impacts of riparian zone. 3. Main Agenda 3.1 Approval of Feb. 2, 2026 meeting minutes. Susanne approves minutes with inclusion of Ian Grask’s edited public comments, Tracy seconds and all in favor. February 2, 2026 Minutes.pdf 3.2 AIPP & Vail Art Studio program and calendar discussion. Amy Dose and Pamela Olson are making progress on the mud room installation in the Art Studio. Ramsey motions for an April 20 completion date for the installation; Susanne seconds and all in favor. The Vail Drawing Club is activating the space well and connecting with new creatives in the community. The Art Studio will be closed for a period in May due to scheduled maintenance. Tentative dates of June 12-22 for the first residency of the summer. Details are being confirmed for activations. Potential development and marketing initiatives are being discussed. Molly reminds the Board of existing documents around the Art Studio including Guidelines and Expectations. The Board believes in this initial year of the Art Studio being open invitational residencies are appropriate as we develop operations. Kathy motions to explore opportunities with an additional residency in July, Tracy seconds and all in favor. The Board will also look at pop-up events like the Jen Stark event. 3.3 Vail Art Studio adjacent landscaping update. Art Studio North Lawn - Drawings and Rendering.pdf Molly shares the DRB landscape design which was approved with the condition that studio architect Harry Teague is consulted for feedback. 84 2 3.4 Vail Valley Charitable Fund 30th Anniversary mural as funded by Discover Vail on Town of Vail property. Molly reminds the Board the VVCF received funding by Discover Vail to create a mural celebrating their 30th Anniversary. The Board agrees that the mural site on the east pedestrian entrance of the Vail Village Parking Structure can be repainted with another mural by a local non-profit. The VVCF will present a proposal for the mural at a future AIPP Board meeting. 3.5 Dobson Arena Art Selection Committee site-visit at 9:30 a.m. The committee convenes for a site visit led by Cummings Group to view At the conclusion of the site-visit, Black Cube inquires if the Dobson Art Selection Committee would like to request a refined rendering/proposal for the West Vestibule Entry by artist Alejandro Pereda. The committee agrees to review an additional proposal by the artist for consideration. 4. Adjournment 85 AGENDA ITEM NO. 5.4 Item Cover Page DATE:April 21, 2026 SUBMITTED BY:Robyn Smith, Housing ITEM TYPE:Information Update AGENDA SECTION:Information Update (4:50pm) SUBJECT:March 10, 2026 VLHA Meeting Minutes SUGGESTED ACTION: VAIL TOWN COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM REPORT ATTACHMENTS: 2026-03-10 VLHA Meeting Minutes.pdf 86 Vail Local Housing Authority Meeting Minutes of March 10, 2026 Page 1 | 4 Vail Local Housing Authority Minutes Tuesday, March 10, 2026 3:00 PM Vail Town Council Chambers and virtually by Zoom Zoom Meeting 1 | Pre-Executive Session | https://vail.zoom.us/j/83110634258 Zoom Meeting 2 | Post-Executive Session | https://vail.zoom.us/j/86898705642 Present: Steve Lindstrom Christine Santucci Craig Denton Kristin Kenney Williams Absent: Dan Godec Staff Present: Jason Dietz, Director of Housing Robyn Smith, Senior Housing Coordinator Anna Bengtson, Housing Development Specialist Melissa Johnson, Housing Coordinator 1. Call to Order (3:00pm) 2. Citizen Participation (5min.) None. 3. Approval of Minutes (5 min.) 3.1 February 10, 2026 Meeting Minutes Time: 2 mins 2026_02_10 VLHA Meeting Minutes.pdf Kristin Kenney Williams made a motion to Approve ; Craig Denton seconded the motion Passed (4 - 0). 3.2 February 17, 2026 Special Meeting Minutes Time: 2 mins 2026_02_17 VLHA Special Meeting Minutes.pdf Kristin Kenney Williams made a motion to Approve ; Christine Santucci seconded the motion Passed (4 - 0). 4. Information Update 4.1 Housing Project Update Listen to update on Housing Development Projects. Presenter(s): Anna Bengtson, Housing Development Specialist Time: 15 mins 87 Vail Local Housing Authority Meeting Minutes of March 10, 2026 Page 2 | 4 Bengtson provided an update on active housing development initiatives. Staff reported continued progress on Timber Ridge Village construction and coordination related to upcoming occupancy milestones - final modular box has been set. Work on the South Frontage Road (SouthFace) project continues through early construction and site preparation activities - vertical construction commencing. Staff also noted continued advancement of surveying, entitlement preparation, and planning activities associated with the East Vail CDOT parcel. The update was informational only and no action was taken. 5. Main Agenda 5.1 Resolution No. 1, Series of 2026, A Resolution Approving an Exemption from Audit for the Fiscal Year 2025, for the Vail Local Housing Authority in the State of Colorado. Listen to the 2025 VLHA Year End Financial Update, and Approve Resolution 1 2026. Presenter(s): Jake Shipe, CPA Finance Budget Manager Time: 20 mins. 2025 VLHA Year-End Financial Update.pdf Resolution Audit Exempt 25.pdf FLAT_LocalGOVExemptionForm.pdf Shipe presented the Vail Local Housing Authority’s 2025 year-end financial update and the application for exemption from audit pursuant to C.R.S. §29-1-604. Financial results indicated that VLHA revenues and expenditures remained below the statutory audit threshold, qualifying the Authority to apply for exemption. Discussion included a review of the income statement, balance sheet, and fund balance for fiscal year 2025, along with confirmation that the exemption application had been prepared by a qualified governmental accounting professional. Kristin Kenney Williams made a motion to Approve ; Christine Santucci seconded the motion Passed (4 - 0). 6. Executive Session (estimated 80 mins) Kristin Kenney Williams moved to adjourn to Executive Session pursuant to: C.R.S. §24-6-402(4)(b) and (4)(e), to hold a conference with legal counsel for the purpose of receiving legal advice on specific legal questions, and to determine positions relative to matters that may be subject to negotiations, develop strategy for negotiations, and instruct negotiators, regarding the formation of a charitable organization and the potential engagement of legal counsel related to the formation of a charitable organization. C.R.S. § 24-6-402(4)(c) to consider matters required to be kept confidential by state law, namely the review of a housing files containing personally identifiable information related to waiver requests for the deed-restricted units located at 1063 Vail View Drive Unit 4, Bighorn Road Unit 7R, 430 South Frontage Road East Unit RU-L, 430 South Frontage Road East Unit RU-M, and 2897 Timber Creek Drive D23, under the Employee Housing Guidelines, Section V.C. The executive session is necessary to prevent disclosure of confidential information protected under the Colorado Open Records Act (C.R.S. § 24-72-204) and related privacy protections. Christine Santucci seconded the motion Passed (3 - 0). 88 Vail Local Housing Authority Meeting Minutes of March 10, 2026 Page 3 | 4 Denton absent from vote. 7. Any Action as a Result of Executive Session The Authority reconvened the public meeting at approximately 4:41 PM. 7.1 Compliance Waiver Requests Approve or deny compliance waiver requests. Time: 5 mins MEMO_VLHA_Waiver Action Language_2025_03_10.pdf Kristin Kenney Williams made a motion to Approve that Vail Local Housing Authority grant a limited waiver of deed-restriction compliance for calendar year 2025 for 1063 Vail View Drive Unit 4; recommend staff not to pursue enforcement for the 2025 compliance period; and affirm that all deed- restriction requirements remain fully enforceable beginning in 2026, with this action limited to the specific circumstances presented.; Christine Santucci seconded the motion Passed (4 - 0). Kristin Kenney Williams made a motion to Approve move that the Vail Local Housing Authority grant a limited waiver of deed-restriction compliance for calendar year 2025 for BIGHORN ROAD UNIT 7R; recommend staff not to pursue enforcement for the 2025 compliance period; and affirm that all deed- restriction requirements remain fully enforceable beginning in 2026, with this action limited to the specific circumstances presented.; Christine Santucci seconded the motion Passed (4 - 0). Kristin Kenney Williams made a motion to Approve move that the Vail Local Housing Authority grant a limited waiver of deed-restriction compliance for calendar year 2025 for 430 SOUTH FRONTAGE ROAD EAST UNIT RU-L; recommend staff not to pursue enforcement for the 2025 compliance period; and affirm that all deed-restriction requirements remain fully enforceable beginning in 2026, with this action limited to the specific circumstances presented.; Christine Santucci seconded the motion Passed (4 - 0). Kristin Kenney Williams made a motion to Approve move that the Vail Local Housing Authority grant a limited waiver of deed-restriction compliance for calendar year 2025 for 430 SOUTH FRONTAGE ROAD EAST UNIT RU-M; recommend staff not to pursue enforcement for the 2025 compliance period; and affirm that all deed-restriction requirements remain fully enforceable beginning in 2026, with this action limited to the specific circumstances presented.; Christine Santucci seconded the motion Passed (4 - 0). Kristin Kenney Williams made a motion to Approve move that the Vail Local Housing Authority grant a limited waiver of deed-restriction compliance for calendar year 2025 for 2897 Timber Creek Drive D23; recommend staff not to pursue enforcement for the 2025 compliance period; and affirm that all deed- restriction requirements remain fully enforceable beginning in 2026, with this action limited to the specific circumstances presented.; Christine Santucci seconded the motion Passed (4 - 0). 8. Matters from the Chairman and Authority Members No additional matters were discussed. 9. Staff Update (5 mins) • Town of Vail Community Meeting from 5-7:00pm today, March 10, 2026 at Donovan Pavilion Habitat for Humanity Events Carpenter's Ball | Saturday, March 14, 2026 at 6:00pm, The Hythe Vail 89 Vail Local Housing Authority Meeting Minutes of March 10, 2026 Page 4 | 4 Finding Our Way Home with The Civic Canopy | Thursday, March 26, 2026 from 5-7:30 PM | Berry Creek Middle School, 1000 Miller Ranch Road, Edwards, CO 81632 Finding Our Way Home with The Civic Canopy | Wednesday, June 24, 2026 from 5-7:30 PM | Berry Creek Middle School, 1000 Miller Ranch Road, Edwards, CO 81632 ZipCar Ribbon Cutting | 12:00pm March 17, 2026 at International Bridge near Checkpoint Charlie. Sandwiches provided. Staff has no additional update. 10. Adjournment Chairman Steve Lindstrom adjourned the meeting at approximately 4:45 PM 90 AGENDA ITEM NO. 6.1 Item Cover Page DATE:April 21, 2026 SUBMITTED BY:Stephanie Bibbens, Town Manager ITEM TYPE:Matters from Mayor, Council, Town Manager and Committee Reports AGENDA SECTION:Matters from Mayor, Council, Town Manager and Committee Reports (4:50pm) SUBJECT:Matters from Mayor, Council and Committees (15 min.) SUGGESTED ACTION: VAIL TOWN COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM REPORT ATTACHMENTS: 91 AGENDA ITEM NO. 6.2 Item Cover Page DATE:April 21, 2026 SUBMITTED BY:Stephanie Bibbens, Town Manager ITEM TYPE:Matters from Mayor, Council, Town Manager and Committee Reports AGENDA SECTION:Matters from Mayor, Council, Town Manager and Committee Reports (4:50pm) SUBJECT:Town Manager Report (20 min.) SUGGESTED ACTION: VAIL TOWN COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM REPORT ATTACHMENTS: TM Update 042126 (1).docx Berlaimont Project Timeline Town Council 42126 .docx Edwards Easement Scoping Notice - Dec 2008.pdf Eagle County USFS Berlaimont Response 3.12.18.pdf Public Input.pdf 92 Town Managers’ Update April 21, 2026 1. Spirit Award The next iteration of a community recognition program has been envisioned by Town Council as the Vail Spirit Award. An award recognizing selfless contribution to Vail, for the love of Vail; someone who has an authentic love of our community, a steward of our lifestyle and environment, or an innovative entrepreneur taking an ethical and inclusionary path. Staff recommends a les s formal process for accepting nominations: for the first year, Town Council could propose names; however, we could also encourage nominations by email sent to Public Input. The two Council representatives, Kevin and Barry currently serve on the selection committee. 2. SDD Sketch Plan At the April 7th Town Council meeting, staff shared two alternatives for creating a sketch plan step in the review process for Special Development Districts (SDD). Alternative one is essentially a work session with the Town Council to review and receive feedback on conceptual level drawings and a narrative of a proposed SDD development. Alternative 2 involved is an application for a sketch plan that would be reviewed by the PEC, and a recommendation provided to Council by the PEC followed by a review and vote by Council. On May 5th, staff will provide Council with examples of alternatives 1 and 2 along with an example of a hybrid sketch plan process that attempts to blend the concepts in alternatives 1 and 2. 3. Berlaimont Development Project See attached materials on Berlaimont. This project does have a long history and is not in or adjacent to the Town of Vail. On March 17, 2026, staff shared a draft letter to Eagle County expressing opposition to the requested variance from Eagle County’s dual-access road requirement for the Berlaimont development. At that meeting, the Council debated the wisdom of taking a position on this proposed development and asked for a timeline and additional background on the project. Staff has searched in the Town records for previous communication from the Town of Vail on this project and we could not find that the Town has taken a position on this topic with either Eagle County or the U.S. Forest Service. Should staff or the Town take any further action on this topic? 93 Town of Vail Page 2 4. Park City Leadership Visit A group from Park City will visit Vail May 27 – 29, including town officials, county commissioners and management, town staff, and resort representatives as part of a 30-year plus leadership program. Town Council participation is requested for the following:  Wednesday, May 27: Dinner with Vail Resorts and Town Leadership 6:30pm at Cucina Rustica  Thursday, May 28: 8:45am Donovan Pavilion. Formal welcome of the Park City group, with opening remarks from Mayor and Town Manager. Council is welcome to attend the breakout discussions beginning at 10:30am – 1:30pm (lunch included). Topics: o Infrastructure/lifestyle amenities for 1,100 new Vail residents by 2028 o Advances in Housing o Medical Tourism o Arrive Vail, Transit Center, Free bus system o Next Generation Leadership o Environmental Programming  Thursday, May 28: Council is also invited to attend a “dine-around” event – 6pm; meet at Lodge at Vail. Nine groups of 10 individuals will be dispatched to various restaurants Please RSVP council member attendance to Abby Oliveira aoliveira@vail.gov 5. Mobility Task Force Members The Parking and Mobility Task Force (P&MTF) recently experienced the departure of three members who were unable to continue their service. The P&MTF, composed of Town Council members, citizens, business representatives, and representatives from partner organizations, is dedicated to reviewing and recommending parking and mobility programs for the Town of Vail. A key goal of the Task Force is to ensure diverse community representation, providing valuable insights and perspectives to guide the development of effective parking and mobility programs. The Task Force would like to welcome three new members—Tiffany Boeh, Colbey Lefabvre, and Lana Makina—who bring unique experiences and perspectives to the Task Force. Their contributions will help strengthen the group’s ability to serve the Vail community effectively. 94 Town of Vail Page 3 6. Other Topics 95 Town of Vail Page 4 Attachment: Council Strategic Plan: 96 Berlaimont Project Timeline Approvals & Decision Points PHASE 1 — PROJECT SETUP (2008–2014) 2008: Current owners acquired the 680-acre parcel of land north of Edwards, CO, that is entirely surrounded by US Forest Service land. The parcel was originally patented for grazing under the 1916 Stock Raising Homestead Act. Purchasers promptly requested approval from the U.S. Forest Service for a permanent easement across National Forest lands to accommodate development of the parcel. Developers claimed a right to improved access under the Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act (ANILCA) of 1980. In December of 2008, the Forest Service issued a scoping notice and solicited public comments on the proposed easement, but review of the project stalled after agency officials realized Eagle County regulations required dual access to the parcel. Forest Service officials said ANILCA may require adequate access via one road, but the agency was under no obligation to grant two roads across sensitive public lands in the area. Purchasers were redirected to Eagle County to request a variance from the dual access requirement in the County land use code. The Berlaimont parcel is owned by Berlaimont Estates LLC, an entity controlled by Florida -based investors Petr Lukes and Jana Sobotova, originally from the Czech Republic. 2011: Purchasers subdivide the 680-acre parcel into 19 separate 35-acre parcels, proposing one luxury home (with accessory units) per 35 acres. Subdividing the parcel into 35-acre lots exempted this development from subdivision review pursuant to Senate Bill 35 (1972). 2013–2014: Eagle County BOCC approves road variances, including waiver of dual access, emergency vehicle turnaround areas, and certain other road improvement standards (e.g., those for turn radii). Note: This approval is no longer valid because it is not the road alignment or proposal ultimately approved by the USFS. PHASE 2 — FEDERAL PROCESS (2016–2023) 2016: U.S. Forest Service restarts National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) review. 2018: Draft Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) released; significant public opposition based on wildlife migration and important winter habitat, particularly for elk and mule deer, water availability, watershed health, safety, fire risk, etc. The Vail Daily reported that thousands of people signed a petition to oppose the Berlaimont plan and more than 700 comments were submitted on the proposal. District Ranger, Aaron Mayville, acknowledged that his decision to label the proposed use as reasonable is “not a very popular decision.” Eagle County submitted comments saying this: “In 2014, 97 the County conditionally approved a request from Berlaimont for a variance from the improvement standards contained in the Eagle County Land Use Regulations pertaining to dual access, emergency vehicle turnaround areas and certain road improvement standards, including those for turn radii. The standards for approval of this variance are technical in nature; consequently, the County did not have the opportunity to consider the social and environmental impacts of a permanent access road to the Berlaimont property. The County’s role was limited to deciding whether to grant a variance to roadway standards. Therefore, the road variance approved by Eagle County should not be interpreted as approval for this type of land use as suggested in the DEIS. The variance simply dictates the standards that a road would need to meet if the proponents of Berlaimont were to develop the parcels as proposed.” The letter went on to note the County’s “concerns regarding the potential environmental and social impacts of a permanent road to access the Berlaimont inholding.” 2020: Final EIS; Eagle County submits comment letter to the USFS during the formal objection period noting future approvals required, and expressing concern over:  Impacts to adjacent residential properties from noise, dust, and traffic.  Impacts to recreational experiences for hikers, bikers and others.  Impacts on local wildlife populations and habitat.  Impacts from the new multi-use recreation trail.  Impacts on natural resources and the possible impact on the water quality of nearby creeks and streams through runoff and sedimentation. The County letter also included significant pushback on the US Forest Service analysis, asking “the NFS to engage in a more thorough analysis and vetting of Alternative 1, the ‘no action’ alternative, and to further examine whether Alternative 1 would provide adequate access...” The County noted the proposal’s “adverse impact on wildlife in the area, particularly given the high-quality winter habitat in the area of the property.” The County asked “the NFS to reevaluate its consideration of similarly situated parcels when determining what constitutes reasonable use and enjoyment of the Berlaimont property.” The County noted that other inholdings in Eagle County are accessed via dirt roads, including Deep Creek, Fulford, and Piney Lake, and the County questioned the US Forest Service’s comparison of the Berlaimont inholding to other existing “up-scale” developments in the Edwards to Vail area that are not inholdings. 2023: Forest Service approves access road across federal land. Note: Federal approval relies on the contested Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act (ANILCA) is a 1980 federal law that, says, in part: 98 Owners of private land surrounded by federal land must be provided “adequate access” to their property. This has been interpreted to include year-round, motorized access. Opponents interpret this law to not only not apply in Colorado, but also to include seasonal and non-motorized access. PHASE 3 — CURRENT STATUS (2023–Present) 2023: Wilderness Workshop and Rocky Mountain Wild file litigation to stop the Berlaimont Estates Access Road Lawsuits ongoing challenging federal approval. Eagle County must still review new road alignment and safety compliance. 2026: A federal court ruled that the Alaska law applies in the Lower 48, but other claims, including whether the Berlaimont proposal is a “reasonable use” of the inholding, whether the existing road must be upgraded for “adequate access”, and questions about the adequacy of the agency’s impact analysis remain unresolved. Note: Berlaimont is not fully approved. Federal access does not override local safety standards, and Eagle County retains critical authority over the road and infrastructure. CRITICAL FUTURE DECISION POINTS Eagle County dual access road variance approval Engineering + emergency access compliance Potential 1041 permits (water/infrastructure) LEGAL, ADVOCACY & POLICY NOTES  Senator Bennet introduces Forest Resources Accountability Act 2026 (bill to: - Prohibit the use of federal funds for the issuing of permits to open, improve, authorize, permit, or construct a year-round road on public land for Berlaimont; - Clarify the definition of “adequate access” to the Berlaimont Estates inholding as the existing unpaved, seasonal road currently in use; and - Subject to a willing, voluntary landowner, direct the Secretary of Agriculture to purchase for fair-market value the inholding and incorporate it into the surrounding Forest Service lands.  Single-access road in wildfire-prone terrain  New alignment requires new variance findings  Federal vs local authority conflict  Ongoing litigation over federal access approval 99 100 101 Resources and Press Articles: White River National Forest approves access road to proposed 19 -home Berlaimont Estates community above Eagle River Valley https://coloradosun.com/2023/03/10/white-river-forest-berlaimont-estates-road/ Bennet, Neguse introduce legislation to block federal funding for road to luxury community in the Eagle River Valley https://coloradosun.com/2026/03/30/bennet-legislation-berlaimont/ In win for Berlaimont developers, judge rules federal Alaskan conservation law section applies in Colorado https://www.vaildaily.com/news/colorado-national-forest-federal-alaskan-conservations- law-berlaimont- estates/#:~:text=Ryan%20Spencer%20Follow&text=%E2%80%9CThat%20Congress% 20was%20principally%20concerned,applies%20to%20land%20in%20Alaska.%E2%80 %9D Forest Service Project Summary, Record of Decision, Access to All Project Documents: https://www.fs.usda.gov/r02/whiteriver/projects/archive/50041 102 18-CV-887-20406 103 18-CV-887-20407 104 18-CV-887-20408 105 18-CV-887-20409 106 Board of County Commissioners 970-328-8605 970-328-8629(f) eagleadmin@eaglecounty.us www.eaglecounty.us 500 Broadway, P.O. Box 850, Eagle, Colorado 81631 March 12, 2018 Scott Fitzwilliams Forest Supervisor c/o Matt Klein Realty Specialist White River National Forest United States Forest Service (USFS) P.O. Box 190 Minturn, CO 81645 VIA EMAIL: matthewklein@fs.fed.us RE: Berlaimont Estates’ Access Route Draft Environmental Impact Statement Dear Mr. Fitzwilliams: Eagle County appreciates the opportunity to make formal comment on the Berlaimont Estates draft Access Route Environmental Impact Statement (“DEIS”). The DEIS was prepared to analyze and disclose the estimated environmental effects of the provision of adequate access to the Berlaimont Estates’ private property that is fully surrounded by the White River National Forest (“WRNF”). Berlaimont Estates (“Berlaimont” or the “Applicant”) is proposing to improve segments of existing National Forest Service (“NFS”) Road 774 and NFS 780, as well as construct a new road segment across additional NFS lands in order to provide year-round access to portions of their property further north (the “Proposed Action”). The NFS will determine whether or not to implement the Proposed Action through one of four (4) alternative routes for accessing the Berlaimont inholding. As part of its decision, the NFS will also require the implementation of site-specific management practices and/or mitigation measures. In 2011, Berlaimont subdivided the property into nineteen (19) 35-acre lots for the development of single family homes. Such subdivision was exempt from the County’s subdivision regulations, as provided for in the Colorado Revised Statutes. Accordingly, Eagle County was not able to analyze the impacts of, nor approve the development of the subdivision (as it would through a typical subdivision process). In 2014, the County conditionally approved a request from Berlaimont for a variance from the improvement standards contained in the Eagle County Land Use Regulations pertaining to dual access, 107 Board of County Commissioners 970-328-8605 970-328-8629(f) eagleadmin@eaglecounty.us www.eaglecounty.us 500 Broadway, P.O. Box 850, Eagle, Colorado 81631 emergency vehicle turnaround areas and certain road improvement standards, including those for turn radii. The standards for approval of this variance are technical in nature; consequently, the County did not have the opportunity to consider the social and environmental impacts of a permanent access road to the Berlaimont property. The County’s role was limited to deciding whether to grant a variance to roadway standards. Therefore, the road variance approved by Eagle County should not be interpreted as approval for this type of land use as suggested in the DEIS. The variance simply dictates the standards that a road would need to meet if the proponents of Berlaimont were to develop the parcels as proposed. During the public open house held by NFS on February 15, 2018, the County confirmed that if infrastructure is proposed to be installed for the purpose of providing domestic water to more than nine homes in the Berlaimont development, Berlaimont will be required to apply for and obtain approval of a 1041 Permit for a new domestic water and wastewater treatment system. Many of the standards for approval of a 1041 Permit involve consideration of impacts to the quality and quantity of recreational opportunities, animal life and their habitats, plant life, and impacts on land use patterns. Because this development may come back to the County for 1041 Permit review, we must maintain our objectivity with regard to the evaluation of these types of impacts. However, we have concerns regarding the potential environmental and social impacts of a permanent road to access the Berlaimont inholding and therefore ask that the NFS consider our concerns as part of the DEIS process. The County asks that the NFS generally consider: • Impacts to recreational experiences for hikers, bikers and others. Improvements to NFS 774 and 780 could be beneficial to some types of recreational activities, while having a detrimental effect on others. • Impacts on local wildlife populations and habitat. The NFS lands surrounding the property are identified in the WRNF’s Land and Resource Management Plan as deer and elk winter range and an important migration route for deer. Historically, these NFS roads have been closed seasonally due to wildlife. Full time residential occupancy at Berlaimont will necessitate year- round access through sensitive wildlife habitat. • Impacts on natural resources and the possible impact on the water quality of nearby creeks and streams through runoff and sedimentation. • Impacts to nearby residential properties from noise, dust, traffic and scenic disturbances. 108 Board of County Commissioners 970-328-8605 970-328-8629(f) eagleadmin@eaglecounty.us www.eaglecounty.us 500 Broadway, P.O. Box 850, Eagle, Colorado 81631 Specifically with regard to wildlife, as set forth in the DEIS, the proposed upgrading and new construction of a road under any action alternative would result in loss of elk winter range, elk winter concentration area, and elk severe winter range, which would add to the declining habitat availability, due primarily to winter range lost to development, habitat fragmentation and year-round recreational impacts. Relative to Alternatives 3 & 4 cited within the DEIS, it appears as though the “elk habitat” will be most disturbed in Alternative 3, with impacts to winter concentration and severe winter range, yet this was chosen as the preferred Alternative in the DEIS. Otherwise both are similar Alternatives. We could not find substantial reasoning for this preference, especially given the additional adverse effects of this alternative. We therefore encourage a more thorough analysis and vetting of the impacts of Alternative 3 on the local wildlife populations and habitats. Please also recognize Eagle County’s commitment to protecting important wildlife habitat, and that each of the action alternatives necessitates amendment of the Forest Plan and elimination of winter closures that currently protect deer and elk in the area. Deer and elk populations in the County are in decline and elimination of winter closures could be detrimental. In addition, we have a general concern regarding the numerous impacts identified within the DEIS which are anticipated to occur from the construction, maintenance and operation of a permanent, year-round access road. It appears as though the DEIS analysis relies upon a comparison of a number of historic/existing developments in the general area to support a finding that the Berlaimont proposal “is not a departure from the nature of existing human activities within the I-70 corridor” (item “a”). We encourage reconsidering this conclusion. The proposed development of this property is different from the development of other inholdings in the County, particularly because the Berlaimont property sits outside the discrete location of the I-70 corridor, thousands of feet above and miles away from the highway and other development. For example, pumping domestic water for a distance of almost 6 miles through an elevation gain of 1800+ vertical feet appears to be unusual to achieve development in this area, where currently no further extensive water supply infrastructure exists to support residential development. This departure from the I-70 corridor area does distinguish the subject area from existing development supported by such infrastructure/delivery system. Lastly, the County is aware that Alternative 3, the identified preferred Alternative, presents significant visual impacts to public lands. The DEIS states that a “viewshed analysis” should be conducted. Regarding such an analysis, we would be interested to further understand the methodology, consultant selection process, timing of analysis (which season) and what would be considered an acceptable or unacceptable outcome from such analysis relative to the Proposed Action. 109 Board of County Commissioners 970-328-8605 970-328-8629(f) eagleadmin@eaglecounty.us www.eaglecounty.us 500 Broadway, P.O. Box 850, Eagle, Colorado 81631 Finally, in the event the Proposed Action or other alternative is approved by the NFS and the proposed development moves forward, the developer would be required to comply with all applicable permitting necessary to develop proposed lots, including, but not limited to, building permits, grading permits, and waste water system permits. Again, thank you for this opportunity to provide comments. In closing, we want to make clear that the road variance approved by Eagle County was not an approval for this development or for this type of land use. We hope that any approved action will adequately balance a need for adequate access to private property with the critical need in Eagle County to preserve the quality of public lands and natural resources, including wildlife habitats. We look forward to having the County’s concerns adequately addressed in the Final Environmental Impact Statement. Sincerely, Kathy Chandler-Henry Jeanne McQueeney Jill H. Ryan Chair Commissioner Commissioner 110 FACT SHEET BERLAIMONT ESTATES January 2026 What: Berlaimont Estates is moving forward with its planning to construct a recreational trail and a paved road to access its 680-acre private property inholding within the White River National Forest (WRNF), located north of Edwards in Eagle County and adjacent to I-70. The family ownership group, in wanting to minimize impacts, has purposefully clustered the building of just 19 homes pursuant to the existing subdivision plat recorded in 2011, and will protect more than 85% of the property with an open space easement. The property, acquired by Berlaimont in 2008, is an original land grant for grazing and development under the 1916 Stock Raising Homestead Act. Berlaimont applied to the U.S. Forest Service (USFS or Forest Service) for a special use authorization to improve and extend an existing road to provide safe, year-round vehicular access to its property. The road will comply with an Eagle County requirement that the entire length of the road be paved. The USFS was legally required to provide Berlaimont with adequate access to its property. The Alaska National Interest Lands Conservation Act (ANILCA) requires that the Secretary of Agriculture “shall provide such access to non-federally owned land within the boundaries of the National Forest System as the Secretary deems adequate to secure to the owner the reasonable use and enjoyment thereof.” Berlaimont is very appreciative of the significant Forest Service work performed over the course of a 12-year public NEPA process that included multiple opportunities for public comment and extensive environmental review resulting in the issuance of a Final Record of Decision (ROD) in 2023 approving year-round paved access. Additionally, the Forest Service issued access permits for the new road alignment in November of 2025. It is worth noting that as the USFS has already issued the ROD and granted Berlaimont special use permits for road access, any remaining burden on the USFS (primarily for construction permitting) will be minimal. Berlaimont reimbursed the USFS for all costs related to reviewing and issuing permits for the roadway and therefore, there was no financial burden to the public. Likewise, Berlaimont will reimburse the Forest Service for all future costs, again eliminating any financial cost to them and the public. Where we are today: 111 The project is a use by right under Eagle County’s land use and zoning regulations. In addition, subdivision of land into lots of 35 acres or larger is exempt from county subdivision laws and regulations guaranteeing such large parcels to be developed with residential and other uses. The Berlaimont Estates Subdivision, creating 19 lots was recorded in 2011. The Berlaimont Estates neighborhood will have a significantly lower density than all other housing developments in the immediate area. Before road construction commences, Berlaimont seeks several variances from the Eagle County Land Use Regulations with regard to access and roadway standards, including the dual access standards, emergency vehicle turn-around area spacing, and other road design standards. The roadway will comply with nationally-recognized American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials (AASTHO) standards. Similar variances from these improvement standards have been approved for other residential developments within Eagle County and are not uncommon. Notably, the majority of the Beaver Creek PUD (access to hundreds of homes, businesses, and a ski resort) and more recently the Hell’s Gate Ranch Subdivision (2022 access approval with a single access to 22 35-acre parcels) are just two examples of these many dual access approvals. And in fact, in 2014, Eagle County approved, in a unanimous vote by the BOCC, similar variances for Berlaimont from Improvement Standards. 112 The Eagle County Attorney’s Office has interpreted that the prior 2014 variance approvals expired after three years. Berlaimont does not agree with this interpretation but has decided to engage in the county process for a new approval for the entirety of the proposed roadway consistent with the Forest Service ROD, the approved single roadway, and its modified location to avoid an elk winter concentration area. 113 Wildlife: 114 The area affected by the access road is not undeveloped wilderness: it is adjacent to I-70, surrounded to the south, east and west by existing residential development, and is crossed by high-voltage power lines and accompanying access roads. While this land has habitat and recreational value (which are often at odds with one another), it is far from being pristine, wilderness or untouched. Wildlife concerns (and especially the impact to ungulates) went through a rigorous evaluation that lasted more than a decade and involved local, state and federal wildlife expert biologists. The modified road alignment approved by the USFS, with formal CPW input, mitigates impact to wildlife to the extent possible: o No impact to lynx; o No impact to downstream aquatic life – one of the reasons for paving the road was to decrease sedimentation in the streams; o Minimal impact to deer and elk population – the road is carefully located to avoid the identified habitat polygons and minimize impact to Federal resources. The largest impacts to winter range are dispersed recreation and, in particular, dog walking, not vehicles. Further, project design criteria address concerns with deer and elk mortality on the roadway. The new road and recreational trail required by the Forest Service should decrease overall impact of dispersed recreation and improve the overall habitat value and quality of the land. A side benefit of Berlaimont coming to fruition will be the elimination of illegal and rogue hunting on the 680-acre Berlaimont land, which will almost certainly make the private land function as a refuge for deer and elk. Berlaimont will remain engaged with Colorado Parks & Wildlife regarding off site mitigation and extensive homeowner education. Safety: Issues relating to safety based on a single point of egress/ingress are mitigated by traffic safety experts, representatives of the first responder community, wildland fire experts, and others. More importantly, the improved access will also provide highly-desired entry for wildland fire suppression in the area that currently does not exist. Nearby scale comparisons: To provide some scale for stark comparison of 680 acres and Berlaimont’s ultra low- density neighborhood (at 0.028 units per acre), the nearby Cordillera Valley Club neighborhood on the north side of I-70 is approximately 354 acres with about 175 units/lots (or 0.5 units per acre), while the Singletree neighborhood, also in Edwards, is approximately 755 acres with approximately 1,000 units/lots (or 1.3 units per acre). The Wildridge Subdivision in Avon is developed on 685 acres with ~850 units/lots (or 1.24 units per acre) and the Mountain Star Subdivision is developed on 1,120 acres with ~93 115 units/lots (or 0.083 units per acre). It should be noted that Cordillera Valley Club, the Singletree Subdivision, the Wildridge Subdivision (prior to annexation to Avon), and the Mountain Star Subdivision (prior to annexation to Avon) were all previously zoned Resource by Eagle County only allowing one unit per 35-acres. These neighborhoods were all significantly up-zoned, something not being proposed by Berlaimont Estates at just 19 homes in a clustered development. 116 Caution: This is an external email. Please take care when clicking links or opening attachments. When in doubt, contact Vail IT Department From:Christie Hochtl To:Public Input Town Council Subject:Berliamont Date:Tuesday, April 21, 2026 7:21:44 PM Vail Town Council, Please urge Eagle County not to grant a dual access variance. Fire danger is extreme and a fire in that location would put the county and its residents at risk. Dual Access is important for the safety of first responders and residents. Also please support Senator Bennett and his proposed legislation to not allow federal money to build the road to Berliamont. Federal money should not be spent to benefit private development. The existing road has adequate access. Thank you for considering these important issues. Christie and Karl Hochtl 890 Red Sandstone Circle Vail CO 81657 cjbhochtl@gmail.com 970 476 1125 landline 117 Caution: This is an external email. Please take care when clicking links or opening attachments. When in doubt, contact Vail IT Department From:Michael Browning To:Public Input Town Council Subject:Opposition to Berlaimont development Date:Tuesday, April 21, 2026 10:42:58 AM Attachments:Browning - BERLAIMONT IS STILL A BAD IDEA_ph.docx Dear Council Members, As your Town Manager’s report confirms, there is broad based opposition in the Vail Valley to the Berlaimont Estates subdivision. The subdivision implicates public resources of significant value to Vail Valley residents including public lands that we use and enjoy for recreation, wildlife populations, and mutual aid first responders. Developers are currently requesting a variance from the dual access road requirement in the County land use code that requires two points of access to the proposed subdivision. The dual access requirement was added to the code to ensure that residents and first responders aren’t trapped if one access road is compromised by fire or another emergency event. The dual access requirement was incorporated into the code with broad support from local governments and first responders. The Berlaimont development is a bad idea because of the impacts it will have on public lands and local wildlife. Waiving the dual access requirement is a bad idea because it will put public servants in a dangerous situation. The Berlaimont subdivision is proposed on a Forest Service inholding. While the parcel may be appropriate for less intensive development, like other inholdings in Eagle County (e.g., Fulford and Piney River Ranch), the potential impacts and access challenges make it inappropriate for the development currently proposed. This development should concern the TOV even though it is not adjacent to the Town because (a) any resulting wildfires or public safety emergencies may well draw firefighter and first responders from Vail, (b) it would reduce our local USFS staff’s capacity to protect and maintain our local National Forests which draw many tourists into our local economy, and (c) it sets a bad precedent. Please also see the attached Guest Opinion I recently submitted to the Vail Daily on the issue. Other towns in the Vail Valley have recognized this and passed their own Resolutions opposing the project and/or supporting Senator Bennet’s proposed legislation that would prevent the USFS from spending its limited funds on it, including Avon, Minturn, Eagle, and the Edward Metro District. Please do the same. 118 Thanks for your service to our community. Mike Browning 4229A Nugget Lane Vail 119 BERLAIMONT IS STILL A BAD IDEA Like recurring nightmares, some bad ideas never seem to go away. This is certainly true of the proposed Berlaimont development, surrounded by National Forest land above Edwards. In 2008, Florida developers Petr Lukes and Jana Sabatova bought 680 acres of undeveloped land on a hillside across I-70 above Edwards. Even though the land was surrounded by National Forest with gravel road access, they bet that they could use their money and influence to pave a road across public lands and make millions. The citizens of Eagle County were not impressed and have fought the project for over a decade. Several years ago, thousands signed a petition opposing the project. Locals helped fight the project to a standstill, but the developers are once again trying to push it through. Eagle County needs to push back. The parcel involved already has residents. For centuries it has been the home and key migration route for elk and deer herds, including a migratory deer herd that used to be the second largest in Colorado—the herd’s numbers have decreased due to increasing pressures. Warm, relatively snow-free south-facing slopes provide critical winter habitat for deer, elk, and other wildlife that are being evicted from the Vail Valley. The Berlaimont developers don’t want to develop desperately needed affordable housing. They want to develop 19 luxury second (or possibly third or fourth) trophy homes for the rich. Like most such homes, these are unlikely to be used for more than a few weeks a year, unlike the native wildlife for which it is their year-round home. Moreover, to provide luxury access to these new luxury mansions, the developers desire to build a new paved road across the parcel and the surrounding National Forest to provide year-round access. This road would zig-zag across our public lands and require road cuts tens of feet high. This would effectively prevent the movement of animals along their historic migration routes; one more cut in the death by a thousand cuts we have inflicted on local wildlife. The developers also don’t want to provide two means of ingress and egress, which is the normal requirement for this type of isolated parcel. That would cut into their profits. But the requirement exists to save lives not money. Firefighters and paramedics need primary and secondary means of access in the event one is cut off by wildfire, landslides, or other natural disasters. Lack of secondary access puts first responders’ lives in danger, as well as residents and staff who would serve the development. 120 And because the road(s) will cut through National Forest lands, this will require local Eagle/Holy Cross Ranger District staff to spend hours and precious resources to oversee design, construction, and operation of private road(s). Our Forest Service staff is already under-staffed, under-funded, and overworked. Despite dedication and hard work, they already struggle to perform their basic duties, like maintaining trails, fighting fires, maintaining public campgrounds, emptying latrines, and managing the hundreds of thousands of acres of National Forest in Eagle County. Requiring USFS staff to put aside these duties to allow wealthy developers to make more money on a private development that offers no public benefits makes no sense. Senator Bennet and Representative Neguse have introduced legislation to block this waste of federal resources. On this eve of what may be the worst wildfire season ever, I urge all citizens of Eagle County to oppose this development. At a time when local wildlife populations are plummeting, Forest Service funding is at critically low levels, and we face a mega drought, plummeting wildlife populations, and unprecedented wildfire risk, the Berlaimont development is ill advised. 121 AGENDA ITEM NO. 6.3 Item Cover Page DATE:April 21, 2026 SUBMITTED BY:Stephanie Bibbens, Town Manager ITEM TYPE:Matters from Mayor, Council, Town Manager and Committee Reports AGENDA SECTION:Matters from Mayor, Council, Town Manager and Committee Reports (4:50pm) SUBJECT:Council Matters and Status Update SUGGESTED ACTION: VAIL TOWN COUNCIL AGENDA ITEM REPORT ATTACHMENTS: 260421 Matters.docx Future Topics.docx 122 COUNCIL MATTERS Status Report Report for April 21, 2026 Council Comments at April 7th meeting:  Town Council thanked Public Works staff for the early street sweeping!  Council requested gathering a recap of the season from businesses and employees.  Council directed staff to proceed with a cleanup of the Vail Nature Center area as budgeted, and begin a public process by August. Important Dates______________________________________________________ Town Events May 8 Hard to Recycle Event May 28 Park City Leadership visit June 23? Community Picnic at Donovan July 14 Community Picnic at Bighorn August 23 TOV Employee 60th Birthday Dance/Reunion September 8 Vail Social Municipal Partner Events June 22-25 Annual Colorado Municipal League (CML) Conference August 27-28 CAST -Meeting Carbondale Social Media Listening Here is the Listening link for 4/1 - 4/15: https://share.sproutsocial.com/view/af71fa36- 72fc-433d-b1fa-3672fca33d08 Unsurprisingly, volume and engagements have dropped significantly compared to the previous two weeks. Top engaged content included Vail's closing day announcement, a 123 few last John Summit weekend recaps, Vail Daily speed camera article post to Facebook as well as local groups messaging adjustments around the unusually warm spring conditions and how they effect things like drought and trail openings. In the News______________________________________________________ April 2 Speed Cameras https://www.vaildaily.com/news/vail-speed-camera-citations-glitches/ April 6 Summer Parking Program https://www.vaildaily.com/news/vail-summer-parking-council-discussion/ April 7 Closing Parties https://www.vaildaily.com/news/vail-mountain-closind-day-2026-parties/ April 8 Low Snow Budget Adjustments https://www.vaildaily.com/news/town-of-vail-makes-budget-cuts-following-announcement-of- early-end-to-ski-season/ April 9 Good Deeds Partnership with Eagle County https://www.vaildaily.com/news/good-deeds-vail-partnership-with-eagle-county-looks-to-bring- more-locals-back-into-town/ Water Restrictions https://www.vaildaily.com/news/vail-area-water-district-declares-water-shortage-approves-new- restrictions/ April 10 State Land Board Parcel https://www.vaildaily.com/news/state-land-board-moves-dowd-junction-housing-proposal- forward-in-negotiations-with-avon/ April 14 Climate Action Week https://www.vaildaily.com/news/socialize-in-the-vail-valley-while-learning-about-sustainability- for-earth-day/ 124 Future Topics, May 2026 TOPIC DEPARTMENT  VLHA Board interviews Housing  Timber Ridge site visit Housing  Joint Meeting with BOCC Town Manager  Joint Meeting with VLHA Council/Housing  Re-Zoning Subdividing East Vail CDOT Parcel Housing  EHU Exchange Proposal Housing  Senior Scholarship Awards Council 125