The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutDRB120131 Design Review Board ACTION FORM Department of Community Development • 75 South Frontage Road, Vail, Colorado 81657 ��f�� tel: 970.479.2139 fax: 970.479.2452 oo�..,nrrs� ra�. web: www.vailgov.com Project Name: REMMERT REROOF/GARAGE ADDITION DRB Number: DRB120131 Project Description: NEW GARAGE ADDITION. REPAIR/REPLACE EXISTING DECK. REPLACE EXISTING SHAKE ROOF WITH LIFETIME WARRANTIED ASPHALT COMPOSITION SHINGLES (CLASS A), OWENS-CORNING "TRU DEF" DRIFTWOOD COLOR. Participants: OWNER REMMERT, STEVEN 04/27/2012 1545 SUNSET BLVD BOULDER CO 80304 APPLICANT TNT SPECIALTY CONSTRUCTORS 104/27/2012 Phone: 970-328-1689 THOMAS A. BECK PO BOX 1508 EAGLE CO 81631 License: C000003159 CONTRACTOR TNT SPECIALTY CONSTRUCTORS 104/27/2012 Phone: 970-328-1689 THOMAS A. BECK PO BOX 1508 EAGLE CO 81631 License: C000003159 Project Address: 5147 GORE CR VAIL Location: Legal Description: Lot: 14 Block: 3 Subdivision: BIGHORN 5TH ADDITION Parcel Number: 2099-182-0301-1 Comments: BOARD/STAFF ACTION Motion By: Action: STAFFAPP Second By: Vote: Date of Approval: 07/16/2012 Conditions: Cond: 8 (PLAN): No changes to these plans may be made without the written consent of Town of Vail staff and/or the appropriate review committee(s). Cond: 0 (PLAN): DRB approval does not constitute a permit for building. Please consult with Town of Vail Building personnel prior to construction activities. Cond: 201 (PLAN): DRB approval shall not become valid for 20 days following the date of approval, pursuant to the Vail Town Code, Chapter 12-3-3: APPEALS. Cond: 202 (PLAN): Approval of this project shall lapse and become void one (1)year following the date of final approval, unless a building permit is issued and construction is commenced and is diligently pursued toward completion. Planner: Bill Gibson DRB Fee Paid: $300.00 ((:f ' TOWN of van t Dep rtment of Community Development " 75 South Frontage Road / //�� '2 Vail, CO 81657 Tel: 970 -479 -2128 U www.vailgov.com UVVI� Development Review Coordinator �C:. -SAIL Application for Design Review Additions - Residential or Commercial General Information: This application is required for all proposals involving the addition of any floor area, in- cluding net floor area and/or gross residential floor area (GRFA). This also includes proposals for'residential 250 additions' and 'interior conversions'. Applicable Vail Town Code sections can be found at www.vailgov.corn under Vail Information - Town Code Online. All projects requiring design review must re- ceive approval prior to submitting a building permit application. An application for Design Review cannot be accepted until all required information is received by the Community Development Department, as outlined in the submittal requirements, The project may also need to be reviewed by the Town Council and /or the Plan- ning and Environmental Commission. Design review approval expires one year from the date of approval, unless a building permit is issued and construction cornmences. Fee: $300 ✓ Single Family Duplex Multi- Family Commercial Description of the Request: 1).Gar addit 2). R epa ir f deck - 3). Repaint/stain exterior Garage to be 14'X 22'= 308 sq. ft. Addition of 43 2 sq ft of GRFA (Residential) or Physical Address: 005147 Gore Circle sq ft of net floor area (Commercial/ Office) Parcel Number: 209918203011 (Contact Eagle Co. Assessor at 970 - 328 -8640 for parcel no.) Property Owner: Mr. Stephen Remmert Mailing Address: 1545 Sunset Blvd., Bou C 80304 Owner's Signature: Primary Contact/ Owner Representative: Toni B eck- TNT Spec Constructors Mailing Address: P. O. Box 1508, Eagle, CO. 81631 E -Mail: tnt- s- c @hotma}t.com Phone: 303 - 302 -8812 Phone: 970- 328 -1689 Fax: None For Office Use Only: Cash_ CC: Visa / MC Last 4 CC # Exp. Date: Auth # Check # 95n9 Fee Paid: _ 3O0 ° t7Q Received From: 'r S CiALtY COAu5rR. r— Meeting Date: DRB No.: Planner: Project No: RS I a — Zoning: Land Use: Location of the Proposal: Lot: Block: 3 Subdivision: Ri At0P_ & St kbb O y I S 1 Q H Property Information Property Address 5147 Gore Circle, Vail, Co. 81657 Development Standards Parcel # 209918203011 Existing Legal Description 1r 81GM Rh Sill hDOrt ?0 8b JLM 148K0NPG 22w M]e -]a BK OZev FG06dIX061- .- ]B&4291 PG -0s] WD 09 zz NBK MPGO521N M22- nM-37P 1p W i Development Site Area sq ft sir acres C. S) q Secondary sq ft buildable sq T_ ft Zone District / SDD # c� ( � i t L 1" _ - 31 Of °N T C �n N�_ 101 -3 1 , Hazard Zones Sections 12 -21 & 14 -7 Snow Avalanche High S verity Moderate Severity A Debris Flow U High Flow Moderate Flow nHigh Avalanche WIA Rockfoll OHigh Severity edium Severity A Excessive Slopes >30% /A Floodploin 100 year floodplain nFloodway OWetlands N/A Creeks, Streams Section 12 -14 -17 Gore Creek (>n site UadjacentTosite /A Other tributary: Don site Oadjacent to site a/A Project Information -4 l V� Project Description 1).Garage addition 2). Repair front deck 3). Repaint/stain exterior Garage to be 22'= 398`sq. ft. AA.Z Development Standards Allowed Existing Proposed Gross Residential Floor Area (maximum) Chapter 12 -15 Primary sq ft 4' (,' ( c ) 4 � P) Secondary sq ft , EHU sq ft TOTAL sq ft 0250 Addition nterior Conversion Credits: Setbacks (minimum) Section 14 -10 -4 Front ft Side ft (2 t4 15' I r' Side ft Rear ft Watercourse ft Site Coverage (maximum) see definition Section 12 -2 -2 d a I r jo 11F 11F 6 �Z�1- _ /' `�' , 5Q S/ Building Height (maximum) see definition Section 12 -2 -2 Sloping ft Flat ft (� Landscaping See definition Section 14 -2 -1 Section 14 -10 -8 Softscape sq ft Hardscape sq ft TOTAL sq ft Driveway Sections 14 -3 -1 & 14 -3 -2 Max Curb -cuts Max Grade @ cen- terline Min Width Heated drive? OYes 0 No OYes 0 N Snow Storage % Parking Sections 12 -10 & 14 -5 #Enclosed Spaces #Unenclosed TOTAL Outdoor Lighting (maximum) Section 14 -10 -7 # fixtures Account Account: R012075 Location Owner Information Parcel Number 2099 - 182 -03 -011 Owner Name REMMERT, Tax Area SC103 - VAIL (TOWN) - STEPHEN SC103 Owner Address 1545 SUNSET Situs Address 5147 GORE CIR BLVD Legal Summary Subdivision: BOULDER, CO 80304 BIGHORN 5TH ADDITION Block: 3 Lot: 14 BK -0234 PG -0622 WD 04 -26 -74 BK -0269 PG -0828 QCD 04 -14 -78 BK -0292 PG -0520 WD 09 -22 -79 BK -0292 PG -0521 WD 09 -22 -79 BK -0437 PG -0359 WD 12 -27 -85 BK -0471 PG -0150 WD 09 -01 -87 BK -0474 PG -0885 QCD 11 -19 -87 BK -0542 PG- 0542 -4 QCD 10 -18 -90 BK -0581 PG -0137 QCD 10 -18 -90 BK -0584 PG -0292 QCD 06 -17 -92 BK -0706 PG -0363 QCD 09 -21 -96 R836825 EAS 06 -16 -03 Transfers Sale Price Sale Date $580,000 12/16/2011 09/04/2009 $550,000 05/29/2003 $130,000 07/03/1992 Images • Photo • GIS lssessment History Page 1 of 1 Actual (2012) $809,330 Primary Taxable $64,430 Tax Area: SC 103 Mill Levy: 46.9000 Type Actual Assessed Acres SQFT Units Improvements $136,010 $10,830 0.000 1458.000 0.000 Land $673,320 $53,600 0.514 0.000 0.000 Reception Number 201123682 200922235 836827 Book Page B: 0584 P: 0293 http: / /property.eaglecounty.us /assessor /taxweb /account jsp ?accountNum= RO12075 4/25/2012 PROPOSED MATERIALS Building Materials Type of Material Color hTl' Ac.Ni" 0) Roof Match House (previously approved R Permit) OC True Def. Driftwood Siding Vr= R`T t (f4 (- 1--, Lr o Q RS C- FAArJr Sikkens: Cetol:Merlot -,O_C - ran �t Other Wall Materials Fasc 1 X 8 RS � (X t2- S Sikkens: Cetol:Merlot Soffits RS plywood Sikkens: Cetol:Merlot Windows Window Trim Doors 8'X T garage door Match house Door Trim Exterior RS Sikkens: Cetol:Merlot Hand or Deck Rails PT wood Natural seal Flues Flashing Chimneys Trash Enclosures Greenhouses Retaining Walls Exterior Lighting Othe Deckboards: Tamko Evergrain Weatherwood Notes: Please specify the manufacturer's name, the color name and number and attach a color chip. PROPOSED LANDSCAPIN l �✓ Bouff, l Name Common Name Quantity Size AM SHRUBS EXISTING TREES TO BE REMOVED Minimum Requirements for Landscaping GROUND COVER SOD SEED IRRIGATION TYPE OF EROSION CONTROL Deciduous Trees — 2" Caliper Coniferous Trees — 6' in height Shrubs — 5 Gal. Type Square Footage Please specify other landscape features (i.e. retaining walls, fences, swimming pools, etc.) NO E: THIS PERMIT MUST BE POSTED ON JOBSITE AT ALL TIMES MWN OF YAIL Town of Vail, Community Development, 75 South Frontage Road, Vail, Colorado 81657 p. 970.479.2139, f. 970.479.2452, inpsections 970.479.2149 COMBINATION BLDG PERMIT Permit #: B12 -0086 Project #: Job Address: 5147 GORE CR VAIL Location......: Parcel No....: 209918203011 OWNER REMMERT, STEVEN 04/04/2012 1545 SUNSET BLVD BOULDER CO 80304 APPLICANT TNT SPECIALTY CONSTRUCTORS 104/04/2012 Phone: 970 - 328 -1689 THOMAS A. BECK PO BOX 1508 EAGLE CO 81631 License: C000003159 CONTRACTOR TNT SPECIALTY CONSTRUCTORS 104/04/2012 Phone: 970 - 328 -1689 THOMAS A. BECK PO BOX 1508 EAGLE CO 81631 License: 0000003159 Description: REPLACE EXISTING SHAKE ROOF WITH LIFETIME WARRANTIED ASPHALT COMPOSITION SHINGLES (CLASS A). OWENS- CORNING "TRU DEF" DRIFTWOOD COLOR. BRONZE COLORED SNOW CLIPS TO BE USED. Occupancy: Type Construction: Applied.....: Issued... PRJ12 -0126 04/04/2012 04/09/2012 Valuation: $16,938.00 DECLARATIONS I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application, filled out in full the information required, completed an accurate plot plan, and state that all the information as required is correct. I agree to comply with the information and plot plan, to comply with all Town ordinances and state laws, and to build this structure according to the town's zoning and subdivision codes, design review approved, International Building and Residential Codes and other ordinances of the Town applicable thereto. REQUESTS FOR INSPECTION SHALL BE MADE TWENTY -FOUR HOURS IN ADVANCE BY TELEPHONE AT 970.479.2149 OR AT OUR OFFICE FROM 8:00 AM - 4:00 PM. Sign ature of 0 e or Contractor Date Print Name combination permit-012811 Building Permit - —> $279.25 FEE SUMMARY ,,,. «. , «« ,,, «> , «««. ,,,,, «« , .« ,, .« ,,,,, ,,,,,,,, Bldg Plan Check - - - - -> $181.51 Use Tax Fee--------- ,,,,,,,,,,,, «,,.«,,,,,,,,..,,.. Electrical Permit - - - - - -> $0.00 Elec Plan Check - - -- - - -> $0.00 ---- Restuarant Plan Review -> $1 $0.00 Mechanical Permit - - - - - -> $0.00 Mech Plan Check - - -> $0.00 - Additional Fees - -> Plumbing Permit --- - - - - -> $0.00 Plmb Plan Check - - -> $0.00 - -- - -> Recreation $0.00 Fee---- - - - - -> $0.00 Investigation ---- --- - - - - -> $0.00 Will Call - -- — - - - - - -- -- - > $5.00 TOTAL PERMIT FEES------ - - - - -> $604.52 Payments-------- - - - --- - ----> $604.52 BALANCE DUE - --- - - - --> $0.00 DECLARATIONS I hereby acknowledge that I have read this application, filled out in full the information required, completed an accurate plot plan, and state that all the information as required is correct. I agree to comply with the information and plot plan, to comply with all Town ordinances and state laws, and to build this structure according to the town's zoning and subdivision codes, design review approved, International Building and Residential Codes and other ordinances of the Town applicable thereto. REQUESTS FOR INSPECTION SHALL BE MADE TWENTY -FOUR HOURS IN ADVANCE BY TELEPHONE AT 970.479.2149 OR AT OUR OFFICE FROM 8:00 AM - 4:00 PM. Sign ature of 0 e or Contractor Date Print Name combination permit-012811 sikkens Wood Finishes Semi Transparent Stain Semi Transparent Stain Penetrating Alkyd /Oil Protection for Wood NATURAL Semi Transparent BALANCE TI Wood Stain ME ■ Cetol SRD C etol G N A TU RAL I BA TI Colo t , 100 White 234 Pale Wheat 233 Warm White 236 Rye 261 Moonglo 272 Aspen Green 265 Buttercup 274 Moss Green 266 Corn Silk 275 Sagebrush 268 Ginger Root 283 Silver Birch s 1'. 231 Navajo White 273 Bayberry 200Almond 408 Woodland Green 204 Sandstone 414 Forest Green 244 Coral Mist 245 Burnt Clay 246 Terra Cotta 052 Navajo Red I ,X m . AV I Natur.1 Rey 402 Russet 201 Chestnut Brown 214 Hickory 210 Sahara Sand 276 Spruce 058 Oxford Brown -.s .�� ti _ �. i' e � 4 OR; 111 1x6 5W' 2x6 ",..M Skirting Extruded 11.^ (two- sided) 11 Nominal Size Actual Size 1 "x6" x(12', Tor 20') 15/16" x 51/2" 2 "x6" x (16' or 20') 17/16" x 5 1/2" Skirting (12') 1/2" x 11 Note: Vibrance Collection - is available in 1" x 6" x (16' or 20') and skirting only. All Tolerances +/- 1/16" Maximum recommended center -to- center spans with a minimum of three joists EverGrain® Residential commercial Decks, Playground Size Decks & Light- Boardwalks Equipment Duty Decks & Marinas 1 " x 6" 16" 12" 16" or less 1 2" x 6" 24" 20 20" or less Note: These decking products should not be used in a structural manner, including use as joists, load - bearing columns, stringers or beams. Hand Rail Post Sleeve" 1'/P x 314' 4 %.. 2.6" x 2.4" Universal Rail Nominal Size 2 "x 4" x (12) Extruded 2" x 6" x (16' or 20') 2"x2" x (12') Skirting (12') 4" x 4" x (104 ") Post Sleeve" Post Cap & Ring Actual Size 17/16" x 31/2" 17/16" x 51/2" 1V2 x 11/2" 112" x 117/8" 43/8" x 43/8" Fits Post Sleeve 6 FT Designer Rail Kit 70" Hand Rail, 70" Predrilled Universal Rails, 8 Crush Block, Hardware Pack 6 FT Designer Stair Rail Kit 74" Hand Rail, 74" Universal Rails, 8 Crush Block, Hardware Pack Baluster Kit (Presized for 36" or 42" Railing Heights) 27" or 33" Predrilled Oval Balusters (13), Hardware Pack Post Sleeve Kits (38 ", 48" or 116" Post Sleeve) 4" x 4" x 38" or 48" Post Sleeve, Post Cap & Ring 4" x 4" x 116" Post Sleeve (Cap and Ring Not Included) All Tolerances +/- 1/16" Post Sleeve is a nonstructural, ornamental accessory. Wood post is not included. Note: 4" x 4" x 104" Post Sleeve is special order only. Straight & Stair Rail Kits 36" kits available in nominal 6', 8' and 10' lengths with your choice of square or colonial balusters. 42" rail kits available in nominal 6', 8' and 10' lengths with square balusters Post Mount Kit Post sleeve, pyramid post cap, post ring, post mount and hardware for use in either wood or masonry applications Post Sleeves Available in 38'; 48" and 116" heights Post Caps and Post Ring New England cap and post ring or pyramid cap available Bracket Kits Straight rail bracket kit for use with standard 6', 8' and 10' straight rail kits. Stair rail bracket kit accommodates stairs with a 30° to 41 o slope. Multi -angle and extended stair slope application kits are available for special angle requirements. Handling For product care, handling and installation information, visit evergrain.com or call 1- 800 - 641 -4691. TAMKO® gives you the whole package TAMKO makes it easy to stock and inventory decking and railing products. TAMKO also offers the merchandising displays and support you need to convey the strength and beauty of TAMKO products to your customers. Front cover main photo is of an actual deck in Evergreen, Colorado. Deck color is Redwood. Information included in this brochure was current at the time of printing. To obtain a copy of the most current version of this brochure, visit us online at evergrain.com or call us at 1- 800 -641 -4691. 02010 TAMKO Building Products, Inc. TAMKO and Tam -Rail are registered trademarks of TAMKO Building Products, Inc. EverGrain and Vibrance Collection are registered trademarks of Epoch Composite Products, Inc. U.S. Patent Nos. 6,827,995, D461,914 and 0547,461 S. ' Iota TAMKO Building Products, Inc. Distributed b P.O. Box 1404 • Joplin, MO 64802 RW Customer Service: 1 -800-253-1401 Warranty Services: 1- 800 - 441 -7190 IIII II IIIII I1III 1I) 11 4 0 0 0 0 4 2 4 TAMKO BUILDING PRODUCTS tamko.com evergrain.com Post Cap Post Sleeve" Skirting Extruded (two- sided) �. 4& Oval Baluster 2 x 2 2 x 4 Extruded (two - sided) eecc Post 2-PiHm 9 r 114" Ya" i „ 1 1 �„ r AIN" 2x6 3W' 4Va" 1 /s' 514' Nominal Size 2 "x 4" x (12) Extruded 2" x 6" x (16' or 20') 2"x2" x (12') Skirting (12') 4" x 4" x (104 ") Post Sleeve" Post Cap & Ring Actual Size 17/16" x 31/2" 17/16" x 51/2" 1V2 x 11/2" 112" x 117/8" 43/8" x 43/8" Fits Post Sleeve 6 FT Designer Rail Kit 70" Hand Rail, 70" Predrilled Universal Rails, 8 Crush Block, Hardware Pack 6 FT Designer Stair Rail Kit 74" Hand Rail, 74" Universal Rails, 8 Crush Block, Hardware Pack Baluster Kit (Presized for 36" or 42" Railing Heights) 27" or 33" Predrilled Oval Balusters (13), Hardware Pack Post Sleeve Kits (38 ", 48" or 116" Post Sleeve) 4" x 4" x 38" or 48" Post Sleeve, Post Cap & Ring 4" x 4" x 116" Post Sleeve (Cap and Ring Not Included) All Tolerances +/- 1/16" Post Sleeve is a nonstructural, ornamental accessory. Wood post is not included. Note: 4" x 4" x 104" Post Sleeve is special order only. Straight & Stair Rail Kits 36" kits available in nominal 6', 8' and 10' lengths with your choice of square or colonial balusters. 42" rail kits available in nominal 6', 8' and 10' lengths with square balusters Post Mount Kit Post sleeve, pyramid post cap, post ring, post mount and hardware for use in either wood or masonry applications Post Sleeves Available in 38'; 48" and 116" heights Post Caps and Post Ring New England cap and post ring or pyramid cap available Bracket Kits Straight rail bracket kit for use with standard 6', 8' and 10' straight rail kits. Stair rail bracket kit accommodates stairs with a 30° to 41 o slope. Multi -angle and extended stair slope application kits are available for special angle requirements. Handling For product care, handling and installation information, visit evergrain.com or call 1- 800 - 641 -4691. TAMKO® gives you the whole package TAMKO makes it easy to stock and inventory decking and railing products. TAMKO also offers the merchandising displays and support you need to convey the strength and beauty of TAMKO products to your customers. Front cover main photo is of an actual deck in Evergreen, Colorado. Deck color is Redwood. Information included in this brochure was current at the time of printing. To obtain a copy of the most current version of this brochure, visit us online at evergrain.com or call us at 1- 800 -641 -4691. 02010 TAMKO Building Products, Inc. TAMKO and Tam -Rail are registered trademarks of TAMKO Building Products, Inc. EverGrain and Vibrance Collection are registered trademarks of Epoch Composite Products, Inc. U.S. Patent Nos. 6,827,995, D461,914 and 0547,461 S. ' Iota TAMKO Building Products, Inc. Distributed b P.O. Box 1404 • Joplin, MO 64802 RW Customer Service: 1 -800-253-1401 Warranty Services: 1- 800 - 441 -7190 IIII II IIIII I1III 1I) 11 4 0 0 0 0 4 2 4 TAMKO BUILDING PRODUCTS tamko.com evergrain.com TAMKO® Railing Systems Add the Ultimate Finishing Touch Our four coordinating railing systems lend themselves to endless customization options and creativity. They're made of durable composite materials that have the same advantages as EverGrain decking. All TAMKO railing systems' Limited Warranties come with a 5 -year Full Start Period? Designer Railing System al llllllllllll IIIII • Extruded hand rail, universal top and bottom rails • Injection molded post cap and post ring and patented oval balusters • Comes with a 20 -year Limited Warranty • Available in 6' straight rail and stair rail kits along o Limited Warranty comes with a 5 -year Full with baluster kits and post sleeve kits Start Period • Accommodates 36" or 42" railing heights Classic Collecliaa Colors Whraoce Coliectlen® Colors 61111111116milit _ Redwood Weathered Wood �fape cod 6my Golden Oak CherryWood Charcoal Traditional Railing System r .�1 2 x 4 Traditional Railing System • Compression molded 2x6 hand rail, 2x4 side rails • Comes with a 20 -year Limited Warranty and extruded square balusters • Limited Warranty comes with a 5 -year Full • Wood posts can be wrapped with skirting for a Start Period completed look Compression Molded 1 x 6 Cape Cod Grey Weathered Wood Redwood fxlruded 1 x 4 Cedar Cape Cod Grey Weathered Wood Redwood Cedar fxlruded 1 x 4 y . _ y � Cape Cod Grey Weathered Wood Redwood • Extruded 2x4 hand rail, 2x4 side rails, post sleeve and square balusters • Injected molded post ring and post cap • Comes with a 20 -year Limited Warranty Cedar . Limited Warranty comes with a 5 -year Full Start Period' • Patented triple -layer design provides excellent strength • Features improved bracket and post mount construction Tam4ail Grey Taupe • Choice of square or colonial balusters • Convenient kits for quick and easy installation • Comes with a 25 -year Limited Warranty' • Limited Warranty comes with a 5 -year Full Start Period m Step 1 Add smooth, sleek beauty to your EverGrain deck. EGI ,2,J EG 1.2.3 Hidden Fasteners enable you to create a smooth deck surface for a whole new level of style and sophistication. There's no better way to dramatize the deep compression grain beauty that can only come from EverGrain® decking. t • Designed exclusively for EverGrain composite decking \ • Anticorrosive coated steel for decreased visibility and enhanced performance tStep • Excellent stability without the bounce and squeak of other hidden fasteners • Provides excellent hold -down power against wind uplift • Tested to ASTM E 330 • Easy installation —no special tools required' • Formulated for use with EverGrain 1 x6 or 2x6 deck boards • Comes with a 15 -year Limited Warranty Step 3 EG 1.2.3 Hidden Fasteners can be installed in three easy steps. Refer to installation instructions included in each package for complete details. Tam -Rail Railing Systems Create deeper satisfaction. Nothing enhances the enjoyment of outdoor living quite like EverGrain composite decking. It's made with an exclusive compression molding process that creates deep grain beauty' in a strong board with outstanding durability and consistency. EverGrain comes with a 20 -year Limited Warranty, including a 5 -year Full Start Period, to underscore its lasting performance .2 20 -YEAR �'ANTY 5 -YEAR FULL START PERIOD CherryWood —Photo of actual deck in Grove, Oklahoma. i Al 1�