HomeMy WebLinkAboutB14-0025 CommCheck Report �:_`
COMcheck Software Version 3.9.2
��c���ec�� �� ��e���� �e���fic��e
Zo�z e�cc
Section 1: Project Information
Project Type:Alteration
Project Title:Vail Summit Orthopedics
Construction Site: Owner/Agent: Designer/Contractor:
US Bank Building WMC
Vail,CO
Section 2: General Information
Building Location(for weather data): Vail,Colorado
Climate Zone: 6b
Section 3: Il�echanical Systems List
uantit Svstem Type&Description
1 Fan Powered 1 (Multiple-Zone):
Heating: 1 each-Other,Electric,Capacity=7 kBtu/h
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Fan System: FAN SYSTEM 1 �Second Level--Compliance(Motor nameplate HP method):Passes
Fans:
FAN 1 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,335 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 2 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,225 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 3 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,685 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 4 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,340 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 5 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,225 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 6 Supply,Multi-Zone VAV,6000 CFM,5 motor nameplate hp
1 Fan Powered 2(Multiple-Zone):
Heating: 1 each-Other,Electric,Capacity=10 kBtu/h
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Fan System: FAN SYSTEM 1 �Second Level--Compliance(Motor nameplate HP method):Passes
Fans:
FAN 1 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,335 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 2 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,225 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 3 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,685 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 4 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,340 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 5 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,225 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 6 Supply,Multi-Zone VAV,6000 CFM,5 motor nameplate hp
1 Fan Powered 3(Multiple-Zone):
Heating: 1 each-Other,Electric,Capacity=9 kBtu/h
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Fan System: FAN SYSTEM 1 �Second Level--Compliance(Motor nameplate HP method):Passes
Fans:
FAN 1 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,335 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 2 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,225 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 3 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,685 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 4 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,340 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 5 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,225 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 6 Supply,Multi-Zone VAV,6000 CFM,5 motor nameplate hp
1 Fan Powered 4(Multiple-Zone):
Heating:1 each-Other,Electric,Capacity=9 kBtu/h
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Fan System: FAN SYSTEM 1 �Second Level—Compliance(Motor nameplate HP method):Passes
Project Title:Vail Summit Orthopedics Report date: 02/27/14
Data filename:\\bece-rsnas\data\BGProjects\8739.41 Vaill Summit Orthopedics Tenant Finish\Engineering\873941
COMck.cck Page 1 of 5
Fans:
FAN 1 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,335 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 2 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,225 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 3 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,685 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 4 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,340 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 5 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,225 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 6 Supply,Multi-Zone VAV,6000 CFM,5 motor nameplate hp
1 Fan Powered 5(Multiple-Zone):
Heating: 1 each-Other,Electric,Capacity=10 kBtu/h
No minimum efficiency requirement applies
Fan System: FAN SYSTEM 1 �Second Level--Compliance(Motor nameplate HP method):Passes
Fans:
FAN 1 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,335 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 2 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,225 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 3 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,685 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 4 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,340 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 5 Terminal Unit,Constant Volume,225 CFM,0 motor nameplate hp
FAN 6 Supply,Multi-Zone VAV,6000 CFM,5 motor nameplate hp
1 Water Heater 1:
Electric Storage Water Heater,Capacity:66 gallons w/Circulation Pump
Proposed Efficiency:0.90 EF,Required Efficiency:0.84 EF
Section 4: Requirements Checklist
Requirements Specific To: Fan Powered 1 :
� 1. Minimum one temperature control device per zone
� 2. Systems serving more than one zone must be VAV systems
Exception(s):
� Where pressure relationships must be maintained
� Zones or supply air systems with at least 75%of reheating/recooling energy site recovered or site solar
❑ Zones with humidity requirements for special processes
� Zones with cfm<300 and flow rate<10%of total design flow rate
� Outside air needed to meet IMC Chapter 4
� 3. Single-duct VAV terminals reduce primary air before reheating
� 4. Controls capable of resetting supply air temp(SAT)by 25%of SAT-room temp difference
Exception(s):
� Systems that prevent reheating,recooling or mixing of heated and cooled supply air
� Seventy five percent of the energy for reheating is from site-recovered or site solar energy sources.
❑ Zones with peak supply air quantities of 300 cfm(142 L/s)or less.
� 5. VAV fans with static pressure sensors are located so that controller setpoint is no more than one-third of the total design static pressure.
For ducts with major splits,at least one sensor is located on each major branch.
� 6. Systems with DDC of individual zone boxes reporting to the central control panel has static pressure setpoint reset based on the zone
requiring the most pressure.
Requirements Specific To: Fan Powered 2 :
� 1. Minimum one temperature control device per zone
� 2. Systems serving more than one zone must be VAV systems
Exception(s):
� Where pressure relationships must be maintained
❑ Zones or supply air systems with at least 75%of reheating/recooling energy site recovered or site solar
� Zones with humidity requirements for special processes
� Zones with cfm<300 and flow rate<10%of total design flow rate
❑ Outside air needed to meet IMC Chapter 4
� 3. Single-duct VAV terminals reduce primary air before reheating
� 4. Controls capable of resetting supply air temp(SAT)by 25%of SAT-room temp difference
Exception(s):
� Systems that prevent reheating,recooling or mixing of heated and cooled supply air
� Seventy five percent of the energy for reheating is from site-recovered or site solar energy sources.
❑ Zones with peak supply air quantities of 300 cfm(142 L/s)or less.
Project Title:Vail Summit Orthopedics Report date:02/27/14
Data filename:\\bece-rsnas\data\BGProjects\8739.41 Vaill Summit Orthopedics Tenant Finish\Engineering\873941
COMck.cck Page 2 of 5
� 5. VAV fans with static pressure sensors are located so that controller setpoint is no more than one-third of the total design static pressure.
For ducts with major splits,at least one sensor is located on each major branch.
� 6. Systems with DDC of individual zone boxes reporting to the central control panel has static pressure setpoint reset based on the zone
requiring the most pressure.
Requirements Specific To: Fan Powered 3 :
� 1. Minimum one temperature control device per zone
� 2. Systems serving more than one zone must be VAV systems
Exception(s):
� Where pressure relationships must be maintained
� Zones or supply air systems with at least 75%of reheating/recooling energy site recovered or site solar
� Zones with humidity requirements for special processes
� Zones with cfm<300 and flow rate<10%of total design flow rate
❑ Outside air needed to meet IMC Chapter 4
� 3. Single-duct VAV terminals reduce primary air before reheating
� 4. Controls capable of resetting supply air temp(SAT)by 25%of SAT-room temp difference
Exception(s):
� Systems that prevent reheating,recooling or mixing of heated and cooled supply air
� Seventy five percent of the energy for reheating is from site-recovered or site solar energy sources.
� Zones with peak supply air quantities of 300 cfm(142 L/s)or less.
� 5. VAV fans with static pressure sensors are located so that controller setpoint is no more than one-third of the total design static pressure.
For ducts with major splits,at least one sensor is located on each major branch.
� 6. Systems with DDC of individual zone boxes reporting to the central control panel has static pressure setpoint reset based on the zone
requiring the most pressure.
Requirements Specific To: Fan Powered 4 :
� 1. Minimum one temperature control device per zone
� 2. Systems serving more than one zone must be VAV systems
Exception(s):
� Where pressure relationships must be maintained
� Zones or supply air systems with at least 75%of reheating/recooling energy site recovered or site solar
� Zones with humidity requirements for special processes
� Zones with cfm<300 and flow rate<10%of total design flow rate
� Outside air needed to meet IMC Chapter 4
� 3. Single-duct VAV terminals reduce primary air before reheating
� 4. Controls capable of resetting supply air temp(SAT)by 25%of SAT-room temp difference
Exception(s):
❑ Systems that prevent reheating,recooling or mixing of heated and cooled supply air
� Seventy five percent of the energy for reheating is from site-recovered or site solar energy sources.
� Zones with peak supply air quantities of 300 cfm(142 L/s)or less.
� 5. VAV fans with static pressure sensors are located so that controller setpoint is no more than one-third of the total design static pressure.
For ducts with major splits,at least one sensor is located on each major branch.
� 6. Systems with DDC of individual zone boxes reporting to the central control panel has static pressure setpoint reset based on the zone
requiring the most pressure.
Requirements Specific To: Fan Powered 5 :
� 1. Minimum one temperature control device per zone
� 2. Systems serving more than one zone must be VAV systems
Exception(s):
� Where pressure relationships must be maintained
� Zones or supply air systems with at least 75%of reheating/recooling energy site recovered or site solar
� Zones with humidity requirements for special processes
� Zones with cfm<300 and flow rate<10%of total design flow rate
� Outside air needed to meet IMC Chapter 4
� 3. Single-duct VAV terminals reduce primary air before reheating
� 4. Controls capable of resetting supply air temp(SAT)by 25%of SAT-room temp difference
Exception(s):
� Systems that prevent reheating,recooling or mixing of heated and cooled supply air
Project Title:Vail Summit Orihopedics Report date:02/27/14
Data filename:\\bece-rsnas\data\BGProjects\8739.41 Vaill Summit Orthopedics Tenant Finish\Engineering\873941
COMck.cck Page 3 of 5
❑ Seventy five percent of the energy for reheating is from site-recovered or site solar energy sources.
� Zones with peak supply air quantities of 300 cfm(142 L/s)or less.
� 5. VAV fans with static pressure sensors are located so that controller setpoint is no more than one-third of the total design static pressure.
For ducts with major splits,at least one sensor is located on each major branch.
� 6. Systems with DDC of individual zone boxes reporting to the central control panel has static pressure setpoint reset based on the zone
requiring the most pressure.
Requirements Specific To: Water Heater 1 :
� 1. Water heating equipment meets minimum efficiency requirements: Electric Water Heater efficiency: 0.84 EF(304 SL,Btu/h(if>12
kW))
� 2. All piping in circulating system insulated
� 3. Hot water storage temperature controls that allow setpoint of 90°F for non-dwelling units and 110°F for dwelling units.
� 4. Manual or time control of heat trace and recirculating systems present
Generic Requirements: Must be met by all systems to which the requirement is applicable:
� 1. Plant equipment and system capacity no greater than needed to meet loads
Exception(s):
❑ Standby equipment automatically off when primary system is operating
� Multiple units controlled to sequence operation as a function of load
� 2. Minimum one temperature control device per system
� 3. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system
� 4. Load calculations per ASHRAE/ACCA Standard 183.
� 5. Automatic Controls:Setback to 55°F(heat)and 85°F(cool);7-day clock,2-hour occupant override,10-hour backup
Exception(s):
� Continuously operating zones
❑ 2 kW demand or less,submit calculations
� 6. Automatic start controls that can automatically adjust the daily start time of the HVAC system are provided for each system.
� 7. Outside-air source for ventilation;system capable of reducing OSA to required minimum
� 8. R-6 supply and return air duct insulation in unconditioned spaces
R-S supply and return air duct insulation outside the building
R-S insulation between ducts and the building exterior when ducts are part of a building assembly
Exception(s):
� Ducts located within equipment
� Ducts with interior and exterior temperature difference not exceeding 15°F.
� 9. Ducts sealed-longitudinal seams on rigid ducts;transverse seams on all ducts;UL 181A or 181 B tapes and mastics
� 10.Operation and maintenance manual provided to building owner
� 11.Demand control ventilation(DCV)present for high design occupancy areas(>25 person/1000 ft2 in spaces>500 ft2)and served by
systems with any one of 1)an air-side economizer,2)automatic modulating control of the outdoor air damper,or 3)a design outdoor
airFlow greater than 3000 cfm.
Exception(s):
� Systems with heat recovery.
� Multiple-zone systems without DDC of individual zones communicating with a central control panel.
� Systems with a design outdoor airflow less than 1200 cfm.
� Spaces where the supply airflow rate minus any makeup or outgoing transfer air requirement is less than 1200 cfm.
� Ventilation for process loads only.
� 12.Motorized,automatic shutoff dampers required on exhaust and outdoor air supply openings
Exception(sJ:
� Gravity dampers acceptable in buildings<3 stories
� 13.Automatic controls for freeze protection systems present
� 14.Each fan system has an energy recovery system when one of the following conditions are met:
30%>=POA<40% AND DAF>=11,000 cfm
40%>=POA<50% AND DAF>=5,500 cfm
50%>=POA<60% AND DAF>=4,500 cfm
60%>=POA<70% AND DAF>=3,500 cfm
70%>=POA<80% AND DAF>=2,500 cfm
80%>POA AND DAF>=1,500 cfm
where POA=Percent outdoor air at full design airFlow rate and DAF=Design supply fan airflow rate
Exception(s):
� Laboratory fume hood systems with a total exhaust rate<=5000 cfm.
� Systems serving spaces that are not cooled and heated to<60°F.
Project Title:Vail Summit Orthopedics Report date:02/27/14
Data filename:\\bece-rsnas\data\BGProjects\8739.41 Vaill Summit Orthopedics Tenant Finish\Engineering\873941
COMck.cck Page 4 of 5
❑ Systems with more than 60%of the outdoor heating energy is provided from site-recovered or site solar energy.
❑ Systems exhausting toxic,flammable,paint,or corrosive fumes or dust.
❑ Systems requiring dehumidification with cooling coil energy recovery in series with the cooling coil.
� Systems expected to operate<20 hrs per week when outdoor air percentage>=30%.
❑ Where the largest exhaust source is less than 75%of the design outdoor airflow.
� 15.Mechanical systems shall meet commissioning and completion requirements in Section C408.2.
Section 5: Compliance Statement
Compliance Statement: The proposed mechanical design represented in this document is consistent with the building plans,specifications
and other calculations submitted with this permit application.The proposed mechanical systems have been designed to meet the 2012 IECC,
Chapter 8,requirements in COMcheck Version 3.9.2 and to comply with the mandatory requirements in the Requirements Checklist.
'��� �aS��.,� -C����+F-�- � �'c��'� 3�3-�°r
Name-Title Signature Date
Section 6: Post Construction Compliance Statement
� HVAC reeord drawings of the actual installation,system capacities,calibration information,and performance data for each equipment
provided to the owner.
� HVAC 0&M documents for all mechanical equipment and system provided to the owner by the mechanical contractor.
� Written HVAC balancing and operations report provided to the owner.
The above post construction requirements have been completed.
Principal Mechanical Designer-Name Signature Date
Project Title:Vail Summit Orthopedics Report date: 02/27/14
Data filename:\\bece-rsnas\data\BGProjects\8739.41 Vaill Summit Orthopedics Tenant Finish\Engineering\873941 COMck.cck Page 5 of 5
: ..t �, :_ .� . .. �_.. . .:.
-.�,,.w.�"�� u� £y��wx 3^ > "�°�'`i��� "��;����,. �r.�.�-�" �.-.r r��h.'! ��Z x�'y,"""` � ��... ca "-x,,�� �s'�' .. �..'�"��.�r��x�.'^i'�-.'�-�.w �"a^S� � � �:
^�z-�` '"„"�-��M �--"�a�� � � .,��,,,s�'-��...,.a�xhr'i�,�`�-�-_'�'.'���'��";�.'�� �^„�.-�;'s���-.`��s',�"^;�a""'x ���-�"�,�` �::
M.
...'. .. :..� i��. ....�� .. yr .i:a _ '1 �^^ .>�..:'
�. 'F '-Ei ..;� y '� �... F 1::.,. 3 .'R':
_ ... ..� .. .. -.
=. =
4i
. . . �' . _ . ... :. . ^. .,.. . ..- ...
.. .
. -
4�'��R.���„ __ .... , . _ _ _ "_, ... _ .: _ . _.,_ ..... .. . .... ., . �... . . . . . ..... ,.._._ ._ ._... ... . n. ,"` _'" __.....
_ � .. �� _
COMcheck Software Version 3.9.�
��t�rio� Lic�l�tin� +�om��iance
- �e��fica��e
2012 IECC
Section 1: Project Information
Project Type:Alteration
Project Title :Vail Summit Orthopedics
Construction Site: Owner/Agent: Designer/Contractor:
Vail,CO 81657 Marc Sacconi
Beaudin Ganze Consulting Engineers
P.O.Box 9650
Avon,CO 81620
9709496108
masacconi@bece.com
Section 2: Interior Lighting and Power Calculation
A B C D
Area Category Floor Area Allowed Allowed Watts
(ft2) Watts/ft2 (B x C)
Vail Summit Orthopedics(Healthcare Clinic/Hospital:Exam/treatment) 3775 1.7 6418
Total Allowed Watts= 6418
Section 3: Interior Lighting Fixture Schedule
A B C D E
Fixture ID:Description/Lamp/Wattage Per Lamp/Ballast Lamps/ #of Fixture (C X D)
Fixture Fixtures Watt.
Vail Summit Orthopedics(Healthcare Clinic/Hospital:Exam/treatment 3775 sq.ft.)
LED 1:F1:2'x4'RECESSED LED TROFFER:Other: 1 41 48 1968
LED 2�F2:2'x4'RECESSED LED TROFFER:Other: 1 6 48 288
LED 3�F3:2'X4'RECESSED LED TROFFER:Other: 1 3 30 90
LED 4:F6:WALL MOUNTED LED VANITY:Other: 1 1 24 24
Linear Fluorescent 1:F7:4'FLUORESCENT WRAP AROUND:48"T8 32W:Electronic: 2 2 62 124
LED 5:R1:RECESSED LED DOWNLIGHT:Other: 1 11 25 275
LED 6:R2:RECESSED LED WALL WASH:Other: 1 2 40 80
LED 8:U1:LED UNDERCABINET LT.:LED Undercabinet Unit 24W: 1 3 28 84
Incandescent 1:P1:DECORATIVE PENDANT:Incandescent 30W: 1 4 30 120
Total Proposed Watts= 3053
Section 4: Requirements Checklist
Lighting Wattage:
� 1. Total proposed watts must be less than or equal to total allowed watts.
Allowed Wattage:6418 Proposed Wattage:3053
Complies:YES
Mandatory Requirements:
� 2. Dwelling units(complete independent living facilities)within commercial buildings are not required to comply with interior lighting
requirements of this code provided that>=75 percent of the permanently installed fixtures other than low voltage lighting contain only
high efficacy lamps.
� 3. Manual Controls:Each enelosed space has manual lighting control.Remotely located manual controls are labelled for area of service
and indicate on/off status.
Exception(s): '
Project Title:Vail Summit Ort#�opedics Report date:03/03l14
Data filename:S:\BGProjects18739.41 Vaill Summit Orthopedics Tenant Finish\Engineering\Lighting\Calcs\VSO COMCHECK
MAS.cck Page 1 of 3
❑ Security/emergency areas with 24-hour operation.
� Stairways/corridors that are means of egress.
� 4. Light Reduction Controls:Each space required to have a manual control also allows for reducing the connected lighting load by at least
50 percent by either controlling all luminaires,dual switching of alternate rows of luminaires,alternate luminaires,or alternate lamps,
switching the middle lamp luminaires independently of other lamps,or switching each luminaire or each lamp.
Excepfion(s):
� Only one luminaire(lamp<100 W)in space.
� An occupant-sensing device controls the area.
� The area is a corridor,equipmenUstore rooms,restrooms,public lobby.e�ec.lmech.room, or sleeping unit.
� Areas that use<0.6 Watts/sq.ft.
� Daylight spaces having automatic daylighting controls.
� 5. Automatic time switching controls are installed and have an override switching device.The override switching device allows for<=2
hour operation cycle within spaces<=5000 sq.ft.,manual operation,and is readily accessible and located where the operation of the
connected lights are visible or communicated to the switch.
Exception(s):
� Sleeping units,patient care areas;and spaces where automatic shutoff would endanger safety or security or where lighting is
intended for 24-hour operation.
� Emergency egress lighting.
❑ Spaces where lighting is controlled with occupancy sensors.
� Malls,arcades,auditoriums,single tenant retail spaces,industrial facilities and arenas that are<=20,000 sq.ft.are permitted
exceed the 2-hour operation cycle limit when a captive key device override switch is installed.
� 6. Occupant sensors are installed in the following spaces and automatically turn lighting off within 30 minutes of all occupants leaving the
space:Classrooms,conference/meeting/training rooms,employee lunch and break rooms,private offices,storage/janitorial rooms,
restrooms,and other spaces<=300 sq.ft.Automatic-on sensors set power on <50 percent power.
Exception(s):
� Full power automatic-on controls are permitted where manual-on operation would endanger the safety or security of the room or
building occupants.
� 7. Daylight zones have either individual lighting controls independent from that of the general area lighting that are either manual or
automatic and serve zones<=2,500 sq.ft.Zones under skylights more than 15 feet from the perimeter have lighting controls separate
from daylight zones adjacent to vertical fenestration.
Exception(s):
❑ Contiguous daylight zones spanning no more than two orientations are allowed to be controlled by a single controlling device.
� Daylight spaces enclosed by walls or ceiling height partitions and containing two or fewer light fixtures are not required to have a
separate switch for general area lighting.
� 8. Automatic daylight zone controls are capable of reducing power to<35 percent using continuous dimming ballasts and
daylight-sensing controls OR,are capable of automatic power reduction using step-dimming multi-level switching and daylight-sensing
controls having at least two control channels per zone and at least one control step in the 50-70 percent range and another<=35
percent of design power.
� 9. Medical task lighting or art/history display lighting claimed to be exempt from compliance has a control device independent of the
control of the nonexempt lighting.
� 10.Separate control device for display/accent lighting,case lighting,task lighting,nonvisual lighting,under-shelf/cabinent lighting,lighting
for sale,and demonstration lighting.
� 11. Hotel/motel sleeping units and guest suites have control device(s)at the entry door that control all permanent luminaires and switched
receptacles.
� 12. Exit signs 5 Watts or less per sign.
� 13.Tandem wired one-lamp and three-lamp ballasted luminaires(No single-lamp ballasts).
Exception(s):
❑ Electronic high-frequency ballasts.
� Luminaires not on same switch.
� Recessed luminaires 10 ft.apart or surface/pendant not continuous.
� Luminaires on emergency circuits.
.
Section 5: Compliance Statement
Compliance Statement: The proposed lighting alteration project represented in this document is consistent with the building ptans,
specifications and other calculations submitted with this permit application.The proposed lighting alteration project has been designed to meet
the 2012 IECC,Chapter 8,requirements in COMcheck Versian 3,9,2 and to comply with the mandatory requirements in the Requirements
Checklist.
�Q�� SaccoH�, Pro��.+�.�e�r `�'�;,� �- 03-c93 -�y
r
Project Title:Vail Summit Orthopedics � Report date:03/03I14
Data filename:S:\BGProjects\8739.41 Vaill Summit Orthopedics Tenant Finish\Engineering\Lighting\Calcs\VSO COMCHECK
MAS.cck Page 2 of 3