The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutMEP Report & Comcheck.pdf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check Software Version 4.0.0 Envelope Compliance Certificate Project Title: 2012 IECC Project Type:New Construction Vertical Glazing / Wall Area:9% Location:Vail, Colorado Climate Zone:6b Construction Site: Vail, CO 81637 Owner/Agent:Designer/Contractor: Chuck Langston AEC Avon, CO 81620 970-748-8520 charles@aec-vail.com Project Information Energy Code: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse Building Area Floor Area 1-Dining: bar lounge/leisure : Nonresidential 23275 Envelope Assemblies Assembly Cavity R-Value Cont. R-Value Proposed U-Factor Budget U- Factor(a) Gross Area or Perimeter Roof 1: Insulation Entirely Above Deck, [Bldg. Use 1 - Dining: bar lounge/leisure] 14475 ---38.0 0.026 0.032 Exterior Wall 1: Wood-Framed, 24" o .c., [Bldg. Use 1 - Dining: bar lounge/leisure] 11727 25.0 6.0 0.039 0.051 Window 1: Wood Frame:Operable, Perf. Type: Energy code default, Double Pane with Low-E, Clear , SHGC 0.70, PF 1.00, [Bldg. Use 1 - Dining: bar lounge/leisure] 718 ------0.550 0.430 Door 1: Glass (> 50% glazing):Nonmetal Frame, Entrance Door, Perf. Type: Energy code default, Double Pane with Low-E, Clear , SHGC 0.70, PF 1.00, [Bldg. Use 1 - Dining: bar lounge/leisure] 357 ------0.550 0.770 Door 2: Insulated Metal, Non-Swinging, [Bldg. Use 1 - Dining: bar lounge/leisure] 66 ------0.300 0.300 Floor 1: Concrete Floor (over unconditioned space), [Bldg. Use 1 - Dining: bar lounge/leisure] 14475 ---8.0 0.090 0.064 Additional Efficiency Package On-site renewable energy. (a)Budget U-factors are used for software baseline calculations ONLY, and are not code requirements. Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 231 ofPage Envelope Compliance Statement Compliance Statement: The proposed envelope design represented in this document is consistent with the building plans, specifications, and other calculations submitted with this permit application. The proposed envelope systems have been designed to meet the 2012 IECC requirements in COMcheck Version 4.0.0 and to comply with the mandatory requirements listed in the Inspection Checklist. Name - Title Signature Date Envelope PASSES: Design 1% better than code Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 232 ofPage MARTIN ZOUREK 07/13/2015 COMcheck Software Version 4.0.0 Mechanical Compliance Certificate Project Title: 2012 IECC Project Type:New Construction Location:Vail, Colorado Climate Zone:6b Construction Site: Vail, CO 81637 Owner/Agent:Designer/Contractor: Chuck Langston AEC Avon, CO 81620 970-748-8520 charles@aec-vail.com Project Information Energy Code: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse On-site renewable energy. Additional Efficiency Package Mechanical Systems List Quantity System Type & Description Heating: 1 each - Central Furnace, Gas, Capacity = 72 kBtu/h Proposed Efficiency = 80.00% Et, Required Efficiency = 80.00% Et Cooling: 1 each - Split System, Capacity = 33 kBtu/h, Air-Cooled Condenser, No Economizer, Economizer exception: None Proposed Efficiency = 13.00 SEER, Required Efficiency = 13.00 SEER Fan System: FAN SYSTEM F-1 | SEE FLOOR PLAN -- Compliance (Motor nameplate HP method) : Passes Fans: FAN 1 Supply, Constant Volume, 1389 CFM, 0.8 motor nameplate hp 1 HVAC System F-1 (Multiple-Zone): Heating: 1 each - Central Furnace, Gas, Capacity = 202 kBtu/h Proposed Efficiency = 80.00% Et, Required Efficiency = 80.00% Et Cooling: 1 each - Split System, Capacity = 116 kBtu/h, Air-Cooled Condenser, No Economizer, Economizer exception: None Proposed Efficiency = 11.00 EER, Required Efficiency = 11.00 EER Fan System: FAN SYSTEM F-2 | SEE FLOOR PLAN -- Compliance (Motor nameplate HP method) : Passes Fans: FAN 2 Supply, Constant Volume, 4818 CFM, 5.0 motor nameplate hp 1 HVAC System F-2 (Multiple-Zone): Heating: 1 each - Central Furnace, Gas, Capacity = 101 kBtu/h Proposed Efficiency = 80.00% Et, Required Efficiency = 80.00% Et Cooling: 1 each - Split System, Capacity = 36 kBtu/h, Air-Cooled Condenser, No Economizer, Economizer exception: None Proposed Efficiency = 13.00 SEER, Required Efficiency = 13.00 SEER Fan System: FAN SYSTEM F-3 | SEE FLOOR PLAN -- Compliance (Motor nameplate HP method) : Passes Fans: FAN 3 Supply, Constant Volume, 1555 CFM, 0.8 motor nameplate hp 1 HVAC System F-3 (Multiple-Zone): Heating: 1 each - Hydronic or Steam Coil, Hot Water, Capacity = 304 kBtu/h No minimum efficiency requirement applies Cooling: 1 each - Split System, Capacity = 170 kBtu/h, Air-Cooled Condenser, No Economizer, Economizer exception: None Proposed Efficiency = 11.00 EER, Required Efficiency = 10.80 EER Fan System: FAN SYSTEM AH-1 | SEE FLOOR PLAN -- Compliance (Motor nameplate HP method) : Passes 1 HVAC System AH-1 (Multiple-Zone): Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 233 ofPage Quantity System Type & Description Fans: FAN 4 Supply, Constant Volume, 10382 CFM, 7.5 motor nameplate hp Heating: 1 each - Hydronic or Steam Coil, Hot Water, Capacity = 20 kBtu/h No minimum efficiency requirement applies Fan System: FAN SYSTEM ERV-1 | SEE FLOOR PLAN -- Compliance (Motor nameplate HP method) : Passes Fans: FAN 5 Supply, Constant Volume, 1955 CFM, 2.0 motor nameplate hp 1 HVAC System ERV-1(HC-1) (Multiple-Zone): Heating: 1 each - Unit Heater, Hot Water, Capacity = 78 kBtu/h No minimum efficiency requirement applies Fan System: FAN SYSTEM UH-1 | SEE FLOOR PLAN -- Compliance (Motor nameplate HP method) : Passes Fans: FAN 6 Supply, Constant Volume, 1600 CFM, 0.1 motor nameplate hp 1 HVAC System UH-1 (Unknown): Heating: 1 each - Unit Heater, Hot Water, Capacity = 78 kBtu/h No minimum efficiency requirement applies Fan System: FAN SYSTEM UH-2 | SEE FLOOR PLAN -- Compliance (Motor nameplate HP method) : Passes Fans: FAN 7 Supply, Constant Volume, 1600 CFM, 0.1 motor nameplate hp 1 HVAC System HC-2 (Unknown): Heating: 1 each - Unit Heater, Hot Water, Capacity = 78 kBtu/h No minimum efficiency requirement applies Fan System: FAN SYSTEM UH-3 | SEE FLOOR PLAN -- Compliance (Motor nameplate HP method) : Passes Fans: FAN 8 Supply, Constant Volume, 1600 CFM, 0.1 motor nameplate hp 1 HVAC System 1HC-3 (Unknown): Heating: 1 each - Unit Heater, Hot Water, Capacity = 31 kBtu/h No minimum efficiency requirement applies Fan System: FAN SYSTEM UH-4 | SEE FLOOR PLAN -- Compliance (Motor nameplate HP method) : Passes Fans: FAN 9 Supply, Constant Volume, 630 CFM, 0.0 motor nameplate hp 1 HVAC System UH-4 (Unknown): Heating: 1 each - Unit Heater, Hot Water, Capacity = 31 kBtu/h No minimum efficiency requirement applies Fan System: FAN SYSTEM UH-5 | SEE FLOOR PLAN -- Compliance (Motor nameplate HP method) : Passes Fans: FAN 10 Supply, Constant Volume, 630 CFM, 0.0 motor nameplate hp 1 HVAC System UH-5 (Unknown): Heating: 1 each - Unit Heater, Hot Water, Capacity = 31 kBtu/h No minimum efficiency requirement applies Fan System: FAN SYSTEM UH-6 | SEE FLOOR PLAN -- Compliance (Motor nameplate HP method) : Passes Fans: FAN 11 Supply, Constant Volume, 630 CFM, 0.0 motor nameplate hp 1 HVAC System UH-6 (Unknown): Gas Storage Water Heater, Capacity: 120 gallons, Input Rating: 533 Btu/h w/ Circulation Pump Proposed Efficiency: 96.00 % Et, Required Efficiency: 80.00 % Et 3 Water Heater 1: Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 234 ofPage Mechanical Compliance Statement Compliance Statement: The proposed mechanical design represented in this document is consistent with the building plans, specifications, and other calculations submitted with this permit application. The proposed mechanical systems have been designed to meet the 2012 IECC requirements in COMcheck Version 4.0.0 and to comply with the mandatory requirements listed in the Inspection Checklist. Name - Title Signature Date Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 235 ofPage Inspection Checklist Requirements: 0.0% were addressed directly in the COMcheck software COMcheck Software Version 4.0.0 Text in the "Comments/Assumptions" column is provided by the user in the COMcheck Requirements screen. For each requirement, the user certifies that a code requirement will be met and how that is documented, or that an exception is being claimed. Where compliance is itemized in a separate table, a reference to that table is provided. Energy Code: 2012 IECC 2012 IECC Plan Review Complies?Comments/Assumptions C103.2 [PR1]1 Plans and/or specifications provide all information with which compliance can be determined for the building envelope and document where exceptions to the standard are claimed. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C103.2 [PR2]1 Plans, specifications, and/or calculations provide all information with which compliance can be determined for the mechanical systems and equipment and document where exceptions to the standard are claimed. Load calculations per acceptable engineering standards and handbooks. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C103.2 [PR3]1 Plans, specifications, and/or calculations provide all information with which compliance can be determined for the service water heating systems and equipment and document where exceptions to the standard are claimed. Hot water system sized per manufacturer's sizing guide. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C406 [PR9]1 Plans, specifications, and/or calculations provide all information with which compliance can be determined for the additional energy efficiency package options. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.3.1 [PR10]1 Vertical fenestration area <= 30 percent of the gross above-grade wall area. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.3.1 [PR11]1 Skylight area <= 3 percent of the gross roof area. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.3.2. 2 [PR15]1 Areas with obstructions that block direct beam sunlight on >= 1/2 of the roof over the enclosed area for more than 1,500 daytime hours per year between 8 am and 4 pm. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable Additional Comments/Assumptions: 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 236 ofPage 2012 IECC Footing / Foundation Inspection Complies?Comments/Assumptions C403.2.7, C408.2.8, C404.5 [FO6]1 Exterior insulation protected against damage, sunlight, moisture, wind, landscaping and equipment maintenance activities. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 5 [FO9]3 Freeze protection and snow/ice melting system sensors for future connection to controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.2.8 [FO12]3 Bottom surface of floor structures incorporating radiant heating insulated to >=R-3.5. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Envelope Assemblies table for values. Additional Comments/Assumptions: 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 237 ofPage Section # & Req.ID Framing / Rough-In Inspection Plans Verified Value Field Verified Value Complies?Comments/Assumptions C402.4.1, C402.4.2 [FR16]1 The building envelope contains a continuous air barrier that is sealed in an approved manner and either constructed or tested in an approved manner. Air barrier penetrations are sealed in an approved manner. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.4.3, C402.4.4 [FR18]3 Factory-built fenestration and doors are labeled as meeting air leakage requirements. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.4.7 [FR17]3 Vestibules are installed on all building entrances. Doors have self-closing devices. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.3.3, C402.3.4 [FR8]1 Vertical fenestration U-Factor.U-_____U-_____Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Envelope Assemblies table for values. C402.3.3 [FR10]1 Vertical fenestration SHGC value.SHGC:_____SHGC:_____Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Envelope Assemblies table for values. C303.1.3 [FR12]2 Fenestration products rated in accordance with NFRC. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C303.1.3 [FR13]1 Fenestration products are certified as to performance labels or certificates provided. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.2.7 [FR14]2 U-factor of opaque doors associated with the building thermal envelope meets requirements. U-_____ Swinging Nonswinging U-_____ Swinging Nonswinging Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Envelope Assemblies table for values. Additional Comments/Assumptions: 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 238 ofPage 2012 IECC Plumbing Rough-In Inspection Complies?Comments/Assumptions C404.3 [PL5]3 Temperature controls installed on service water heating systems (110 ºF for dwelling units and lavatories in public restrooms and 90 ºF for other occupancies.) Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C404.4 [PL3]1 Automatic time switches installed to automatically switch off the recirculating hot-water system or heat trace. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable Additional Comments/Assumptions: 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 239 ofPage Section # & Req.ID Mechanical Rough-In Inspection Plans Verified Value Field Verified Value Complies?Comments/Assumptions C403.2.3 [ME55]2 HVAC equipment efficiency verified. Efficiency:_____Efficiency:_____Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Mechanical Systems list for values. C402.4.5. 1 [ME3]3 Stair and elevator shaft vents have motorized dampers that automatically close. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.4.5. 2 [ME58]3 Outdoor air and exhaust systems have motorized dampers that automatically shut when not in use and meet maximum leakage rates. Check gravity dampers where allowed. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.5. 1 [ME59]1 Demand control ventilation provided for spaces >500 ft2 and >25 people/1000 ft2 occupant density and served by systems with air side economizer, auto modulating outside air damper control, or design airflow >3,000 cfm. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2 [ME75]2 VAV fan >= 7.5 hp are driven by mechanical or electrical variable speed drive, or driven by vane- axial with variable speed blades, or operate with motor demand <=30% design kW at 50% design flow - calculations required Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Mechanical Systems list for values. C403.4.2 [ME75]2 VAV fan >= 7.5 hp are driven by mechanical or electrical variable speed drive, or driven by vane- axial with variable speed blades, or operate with motor demand <=30% design kW at 50% design flow - calculations required Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Mechanical Systems list for values. C403.4.2 [ME75]2 VAV fan >= 7.5 hp are driven by mechanical or electrical variable speed drive, or driven by vane- axial with variable speed blades, or operate with motor demand <=30% design kW at 50% design flow - calculations required Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Mechanical Systems list for values. C403.4.2 [ME75]2 VAV fan >= 7.5 hp are driven by mechanical or electrical variable speed drive, or driven by vane- axial with variable speed blades, or operate with motor demand <=30% design kW at 50% design flow - calculations required Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Mechanical Systems list for values. C403.4.2 [ME75]2 VAV fan >= 7.5 hp are driven by mechanical or electrical variable speed drive, or driven by vane- axial with variable speed blades, or operate with motor demand <=30% design kW at 50% design flow - calculations required Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Mechanical Systems list for values. 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2310 ofPage Section # & Req.ID Mechanical Rough-In Inspection Plans Verified Value Field Verified Value Complies?Comments/Assumptions C403.2.7 [ME60]2 HVAC ducts and plenums insulated. Where ducts or plenums are installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. R-_____R-_____Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME61]2 HVAC piping insulation thickness. Where piping is installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. _____ in._____ in.Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME61]2 HVAC piping insulation thickness. Where piping is installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. _____ in._____ in.Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME61]2 HVAC piping insulation thickness. Where piping is installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. _____ in._____ in.Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME61]2 HVAC piping insulation thickness. Where piping is installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. _____ in._____ in.Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME61]2 HVAC piping insulation thickness. Where piping is installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. _____ in._____ in.Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME61]2 HVAC piping insulation thickness. Where piping is installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. _____ in._____ in.Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME61]2 HVAC piping insulation thickness. Where piping is installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. _____ in._____ in.Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME61]2 HVAC piping insulation thickness. Where piping is installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. _____ in._____ in.Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME61]2 HVAC piping insulation thickness. Where piping is installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. _____ in._____ in.Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME61]2 HVAC piping insulation thickness. Where piping is installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. _____ in._____ in.Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME61]2 HVAC piping insulation thickness. Where piping is installed in or under a slab, verification may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. _____ in._____ in.Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2311 ofPage Section # & Req.ID Mechanical Rough-In Inspection Plans Verified Value Field Verified Value Complies?Comments/Assumptions C403.2.8. 1 [ME7]3 Piping Insulation exposed to weather is protected from damage (due to sun, moisture, wind, etc.). Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.8 [ME41]3 Thermally ineffective panel surfaces of sensible heating panels have insulation >= R-3.5. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.3.1. a [null]0 Total cooling capacity without economizers must be less than %varMaxKBtuPerH%. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.7 [ME10]2 Ducts and plenums sealed based on static pressure and location. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.7. 1.3 [ME11]3 Ductwork operating >3 in. water column requires air leakage testing. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.7. 1.3 [ME11]3 Ductwork operating >3 in. water column requires air leakage testing. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.7. 1.3 [ME11]3 Ductwork operating >3 in. water column requires air leakage testing. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.7. 1.3 [ME11]3 Ductwork operating >3 in. water column requires air leakage testing. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.7. 1.3 [ME11]3 Ductwork operating >3 in. water column requires air leakage testing. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.7. 1.3 [ME11]3 Ductwork operating >3 in. water column requires air leakage testing. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.3. 1 [ME50]2 Three-pipe hydronic systems using a common return for hot and chilled water are not used. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.3. 1 [ME50]2 Three-pipe hydronic systems using a common return for hot and chilled water are not used. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.3. 1 [ME50]2 Three-pipe hydronic systems using a common return for hot and chilled water are not used. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2312 ofPage Section # & Req.ID Mechanical Rough-In Inspection Plans Verified Value Field Verified Value Complies?Comments/Assumptions C403.4.3. 1 [ME50]2 Three-pipe hydronic systems using a common return for hot and chilled water are not used. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.3. 1 [ME50]2 Three-pipe hydronic systems using a common return for hot and chilled water are not used. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.3. 1 [ME50]2 Three-pipe hydronic systems using a common return for hot and chilled water are not used. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.3. 1 [ME50]2 Three-pipe hydronic systems using a common return for hot and chilled water are not used. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.3. 1 [ME50]2 Three-pipe hydronic systems using a common return for hot and chilled water are not used. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.2. 1 [ME53]3 Air outlets and zone terminal devices have means for air balancing. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.2. 2 [ME54]3 HVAC hydronic heating and cooling coils have means to balance and have pressure test connections. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.2. 2 [ME54]3 HVAC hydronic heating and cooling coils have means to balance and have pressure test connections. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.2. 2 [ME54]3 HVAC hydronic heating and cooling coils have means to balance and have pressure test connections. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.2. 2 [ME54]3 HVAC hydronic heating and cooling coils have means to balance and have pressure test connections. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.2. 2 [ME54]3 HVAC hydronic heating and cooling coils have means to balance and have pressure test connections. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.2. 2 [ME54]3 HVAC hydronic heating and cooling coils have means to balance and have pressure test connections. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.2. 2 [ME54]3 HVAC hydronic heating and cooling coils have means to balance and have pressure test connections. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2313 ofPage Section # & Req.ID Mechanical Rough-In Inspection Plans Verified Value Field Verified Value Complies?Comments/Assumptions C408.2.2. 2 [ME54]3 HVAC hydronic heating and cooling coils have means to balance and have pressure test connections. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.10 .1 [ME65]3 HVAC fan systems at design conditions do not exceed allowable fan system motor nameplate hp or fan system bhp. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Mechanical Systems list for values. C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2314 ofPage Section # & Req.ID Mechanical Rough-In Inspection Plans Verified Value Field Verified Value Complies?Comments/Assumptions C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2 [ME66]2 VAV fan motors >=7.5 hp to be driven by variable speed drive, have a vane-axial fan with variable pitch blades, or have controls to limit fan motor demand. VSD Vane axial fan Other VSD Vane axial fan Other Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2. 1 [ME67]2 VAV fans have static pressure sensors positioned so setpoint <=1/3 total design pressure. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2. 1 [ME67]2 VAV fans have static pressure sensors positioned so setpoint <=1/3 total design pressure. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2. 1 [ME67]2 VAV fans have static pressure sensors positioned so setpoint <=1/3 total design pressure. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2. 1 [ME67]2 VAV fans have static pressure sensors positioned so setpoint <=1/3 total design pressure. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2. 1 [ME67]2 VAV fans have static pressure sensors positioned so setpoint <=1/3 total design pressure. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2. 2 [ME24]2 Reset static pressure setpoint for DDC controlled VAV boxes reporting to central controller based on the zones requiring the most pressure. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2. 2 [ME24]2 Reset static pressure setpoint for DDC controlled VAV boxes reporting to central controller based on the zones requiring the most pressure. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2315 ofPage Section # & Req.ID Mechanical Rough-In Inspection Plans Verified Value Field Verified Value Complies?Comments/Assumptions C403.4.2. 2 [ME24]2 Reset static pressure setpoint for DDC controlled VAV boxes reporting to central controller based on the zones requiring the most pressure. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2. 2 [ME24]2 Reset static pressure setpoint for DDC controlled VAV boxes reporting to central controller based on the zones requiring the most pressure. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.2. 2 [ME24]2 Reset static pressure setpoint for DDC controlled VAV boxes reporting to central controller based on the zones requiring the most pressure. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.3. 4 [ME68]3 Hydronic systems greater than 300,000 Btu/h designed for variable fluid flow. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.3. 5 [ME26]3 Reduce flow in pumping systems >10 hp to multiple chillers or boilers when others are shut down. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.3. 5 [ME26]3 Reduce flow in pumping systems >10 hp to multiple chillers or boilers when others are shut down. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.3. 4 [ME69]3 Temperature reset by representative building loads in pumping systems for chiller and boiler systems >300,000 Btu/h. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.6 [ME57]1 Exhaust air energy recovery on systems meeting Table C403.2.6 Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.11 [ME71]2 Unenclosed spaces that are heated use only radiant heat. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.7 [ME35]1 Hot gas bypass limited to: <=240 kBtu/h – 50% >240 kBtu/h – 25% Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.7 [ME35]1 Hot gas bypass limited to: <=240 kBtu/h – 50% >240 kBtu/h – 25% Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.7 [ME35]1 Hot gas bypass limited to: <=240 kBtu/h – 50% >240 kBtu/h – 25% Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.4.7 [ME35]1 Hot gas bypass limited to: <=240 kBtu/h – 50% >240 kBtu/h – 25% Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2316 ofPage Additional Comments/Assumptions: 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2317 ofPage Section # & Req.ID Insulation Inspection Plans Verified Value Field Verified Value Complies?Comments/Assumptions C402.4.1. 1 [IN1]1 All sources of air leakage in the building thermal envelope are sealed, caulked, gasketed, weather stripped or wrapped with moisture vapor-permeable wrapping material to minimize air leakage. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.4.2. 1 [IN2]1 Roof R-value. For some ceiling systems, verification may need to occur during Framing Inspection. R-_____ Above deck Metal Attic R-_____ Above deck Metal Attic Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Envelope Assemblies table for values. C303.2 [IN3]1 Roof insulation installed per manufacturer’s instructions. Blown or poured loose-fill insulation is installed only where the roof slope is <=3 in 12. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C303.2 [IN7]1 Above-grade wall insulation installed per manufacturer’s instructions. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.2.5 [IN8]2 Floor insulation R-value.R-_____ Mass Steel Wood R-_____ Mass Steel Wood Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable See the Envelope Assemblies table for values. C303.2 [IN9]2 Floor insulation installed per manufacturer’s instructions. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C303.1 [IN10]2 Building envelope insulation is labeled with R-value or insulation certificate providing R-value and other relevant data. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C303.2.1 [IN14]2 Exterior insulation is protected from damage with a protective material. Verification for exposed foundation insulation may need to occur during Foundation Inspection. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.2.1 [IN17]3 Insulation intended to meet the roof insulation requirements cannot be installed on top of a suspended ceiling. Mark this requirement compliant if insulation is installed accordingly. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable Additional Comments/Assumptions: 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2318 ofPage 2012 IECC Final Inspection Complies?Comments/Assumptions C402.4.6 [FI37]1 Weatherseals installed on all loading dock cargo doors. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI47]3 Heating and cooling to each zone is controlled by a thermostat control. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI47]3 Heating and cooling to each zone is controlled by a thermostat control. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI47]3 Heating and cooling to each zone is controlled by a thermostat control. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI47]3 Heating and cooling to each zone is controlled by a thermostat control. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI47]3 Heating and cooling to each zone is controlled by a thermostat control. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI47]3 Heating and cooling to each zone is controlled by a thermostat control. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI47]3 Heating and cooling to each zone is controlled by a thermostat control. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI47]3 Heating and cooling to each zone is controlled by a thermostat control. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI47]3 Heating and cooling to each zone is controlled by a thermostat control. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2319 ofPage 2012 IECC Final Inspection Complies?Comments/Assumptions C403.2.4. 2 [FI47]3 Heating and cooling to each zone is controlled by a thermostat control. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI47]3 Heating and cooling to each zone is controlled by a thermostat control. Minimum one humidity control device per installed humidification/dehumidification system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI38]3 Thermostatic controls have a 5 °F deadband. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 2 [FI20]3 Temperature controls have setpoint overlap restrictions. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3 [FI39]3 Each zone equipped with setback controls using automatic time clock or programmable control system. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3 [FI40]3 Automatic Controls: Setback to 55°F (heat) and 85°F (cool); 7-day clock, 2- hour occupant override, 10-hour backup Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3.3 [FI41]3 Systems include optimum start controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3.3 [FI41]3 Systems include optimum start controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3.3 [FI41]3 Systems include optimum start controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3.3 [FI41]3 Systems include optimum start controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3.3 [FI41]3 Systems include optimum start controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3.3 [FI41]3 Systems include optimum start controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2320 ofPage 2012 IECC Final Inspection Complies?Comments/Assumptions C403.2.4. 3.3 [FI41]3 Systems include optimum start controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3.3 [FI41]3 Systems include optimum start controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3.3 [FI41]3 Systems include optimum start controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3.3 [FI41]3 Systems include optimum start controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C403.2.4. 3.3 [FI41]3 Systems include optimum start controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.5. 1 [FI7]3 Furnished HVAC as-built drawings submitted within 90 days of system acceptance. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C303.3,C4 08.2.5.3 [FI8]3 Furnished O&M manuals for HVAC systems within 90 days of system acceptance. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.5. 3 [FI43]1 An air and/or hydronic system balancing report is provided for HVAC systems. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.3. 2 [FI10]1 HVAC control systems have been tested to ensure proper operation, calibration and adjustment of controls. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C404.3 [FI11]3 Public lavatory faucet water temperature <=110°F. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C404.5 [FI25]2 All piping in circulating system insulated Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C404.6 [FI12]3 Controls are installed that limit the operation of a recirculation pump installed to maintain temperature of a storage tank. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C402.4.8 [FI26]3 Recessed luminaires in thermal envelope to limit infiltration and be IC rated and labeled. Seal between interior finish and luminaire housing. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2321 ofPage 2012 IECC Final Inspection Complies?Comments/Assumptions C403.2.2 [FI27]3 HVAC systems and equipment capacity does not exceed calculated loads. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.1 [FI28]1 Commissioning plan developed by registered design professional or approved agency. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.4 [FI29]1 Preliminary commissioning report completed and certified by registered design professional or approved agency. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.5. 4 [FI30]1 Final commissioning report due to building owner within 90 days of receipt of certificate of occupancy. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C408.2.3. 1 [FI31]1 HVAC equipment has been tested to ensure proper operation. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable C406 [FI34]1 Efficient HVAC performance, efficient lighting system, or on-site supply of renewable energy consistent with what is shown the approved plans. Complies Does Not Not Observable Not Applicable Additional Comments/Assumptions: 1 High Impact (Tier 1)2 Medium Impact (Tier 2)3 Low Impact (Tier 3) Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2322 ofPage Project Title: Data filename: Vail Golf and Nordic Clubhouse P:\Current Projects\15020.00 - Vail Golf Course & Nordic Center Clubhouse\Calculations\COMcheck\VAIL GOLF CLUBHOUSE.cck 07/13/15Report date: 2323 ofPage