HomeMy WebLinkAbout1989-04-18 Support Documentation Town Council Regular SessionVAIL TOWN COUNCIL
REGULAR MEETING
TUESDAY, APRIL 18, 1989
7:30 p.m.
AGENDA
1. Ten Year Anniversary Award to Joanne Mattio
2. Joint Discussion with Avon Town Council regarding the Television Translator
Issue
3. Fritzlen and Pierce appeal of the Planning and Environmental Commission
decision to deny a side setback variance request
CITIZEN PARTICIPATION
4. Adjournment
VAIL TOWN COUNCIL
REGULAR MEETING
TUESDAY, APRIL 18, 1989
7:30 p.m.
EXPANDED AGENDA
7:30 1. Ten Year Anniversary Award to Joanne Mattio
7:35 2. Joint Discussion with Avon Town Council regarding the
Television Translator Issue
9:00 3. Fritzlen and Pierce appeal of the Planning and Environmental
Mike Mollica Commission decision to deny a side setback variance request
Action Requested of Council: Approve/deny the applicants'
request. Applicants: William Pierce/Lynn Fritzlen
Background Rationale: The variance request was for a 4 foot
encroachment into the required 15 foot side yard setback.
This variance, if approved, would have allowed for the
construction of stair tower on the east side of the existing
structure. The purpose of the stair was to provide access
to a secondary, rental unit which has been proposed over the
garage area. The PEC, at their March 27, 1989 public
hearing, unanimously denied the applicants' request. The
vote was 7-0. Staff recommendation was also for denial.
Staff Recommendation: Uphold the PEC decision for denial of
the request.
9:25 CITIZEN PARTICIPATION
9:40 4. Adjournment
•A
~p .
TO: 'Planning and Environmental Commission
FROMe Community Development Department
DATE: March 27, 1989
SUBJECT: A request for a side setback variance to the Primary/
Secondary Residential zone district in order to
construct an addition to a residence on Lot 2, Block 5,
Intermountain Subdivision.
• Applicants: William Pierce and Lynn Fritzlen
I. DESCRIPTION OF VARIANCE REQUESTED
The applicants are owners of Lot 2, Block 5 of the Vail
Intermountain Subdivision, which is situated immediately east
of the Flussheim Townhouses and west of the Interlochen
Condominiums. A single family dwelling of 2,534 square feet
is located on the lot.
The applicants are requesting a variance from the side
setback requirement to allow for the construction of a stair
tower on the east side of the existing structure. The
purpose of the stair is to provide access to a secondary,
rental unit which is proposed over the garage area. The
variance request is for a 4 foot encroachment into the
required 15 foot side yard setback.
II. CHRONOLOGY
A. A variance request was approved by the PEC on January
23, 1989, to allow this property to be considered for
rezoning by the Town Council. The approved variance was
for a 6,620 square foot shortage in the minimum lot size
of the Primary/Secondary Residential zone district.
B. The Town Council approved a rezoning request, from RC
to P/S on March 7, 1989. This rezoning has allowed for
the addition of a secondary, rental unit on the lot.
III. CRITERIA AND FINDINGS
Upon review of Criteria and Findings, Section 18.62.060 of
the municipal code, the Department of Community Development
recommends denial of the requested variance based upon the
following factorse
A.
exist
vicin
other
+.,, „
Consideration of Factorse
The addition of a stair tower in the proposed location
should not create any problems to existing or potential
uses or structures in the vicinity. The property most
likely to be affected would be the Interlochen
Condominiums to the east, on which a parking lot and a
distance of 100 feet exists between the applicants'
structure and the nearest Interlochen residential
building.
B.
The degree to which relief from the
interpretation and enforcement of a
is necessary to achieve compatibilit
treatment among
objectives of th
privilege.
sites in the vicinit
is title without qra
strict and literal
specified regulation
and uniformity of
y or to attain the
nt of special
Staff has been unable to determine a physical hardship
regarding this variance request and feels that approval
of the request would constitute a grant of special
privilege. We also feel that the applicant has not
given full consideration to other design solutions for
access into the secondary unit which would not require
a variance.
C. The effect of the
distribution of po
facilities, public
safety.
equested variance on light and air,
ulation trans ortation and traffic
facilities and utilities, and public
Staff finds that the requested variance will have no
significant effect upon any of the above considerations.
Such other factors and criteria as the commission deems
applicable to the roposed variance.
IV. FINDINGS
The Planning and Environmental Commission shall make the
following findings before granting a variance:
That the granting of the variance will not constitute a grant
of special privilege, inconsistent with the limitations on
other properties classified in the same district.
That the granting of the variance will not be detrimental to
the public health, safety or welfare, or materially injurious
to properties or improvements in the vicinity.
~~
That the variance is warranted for one or more of the
following reasons:
s
i
The strict or literal interpretation or enforcement of
the specified regulation would result in practical
difficulty or unnecessary physical hardship inconsistent
with the objectives of this title.
There are exceptions or extraordinary circumstances or
conditions applicable to the same site of the variance
that do not apply generally to other properties in the
same zone.
The strict interpretation or enforcement of the
specified regulation would deprive the applicant of
privileges enjoyed by the owners of other properties in
the same district.
V. STAFF RECOPiP2ENDATION
Staff recommendation is for denial of the requested 4 foot
encroachment into the side setback. Without being able to
identify a physical hardship, staff cannot support the
applicants' request.
~~
~EC'C APR 1 1 1989
FREDERICK S. OTTO
JAY K. PETERSON
WILLIAM J. POST
W ENDELL B. PO RTER FIELD,JR.
April 10, 1989
Larry Eskwith
Town Attorney
Town of Vail
75 S. Frontage
Vail, CO 81657
OTTO, PETERSON ~c POST
ATTOAIVEYS AT LAW
POST OFFICE BOX 3149
VAIL, COLOEADO 81688-319
VAIL NATIONAL BANK BUILDING
(303) 476-0092
FAX LINE
(303) 479-Oa67
Road West
RE: Ron Byrne/Garage Encroachment
Dear Larry:
Pursuant to discussions with my client I am writing this letter
to request that the Town Council, if they so desire, take the
time to make a site visit regarding the above entitled matter. I
would hope after reviewing the site that it would be easier for
them to make a reasonable decision in solving this problem.
I would offer one of three possible solutions in our order of
preference.
1. The payment to the Town of Vail in the amount of $20,000.00
for approximately 48 square feet of encroachment. This
would certainly amount to a severe penalty to my client and
would certainly send a message to the community that these
encroachments would not be looked upon favorably.
2. The second alternative is to exchange on a square foot by
square foot basis by moving the southern wall of the garage
to the north by approximately 3 feet parallel to the
existing wall. We will then swap land with the Town from
the south westerly portion of the garage which would be
under our ownership for the south easterly portion of the
garage which is owned by the Town of Vail. This would allow
us to keep the basic form and size of the garage and would
not entail the Town selling property to a private
individual.
3. The third alternative would be for us to remove our
encroachment from the Town property which would leave a
garage of minimal size with a difficult access problem.
This last alternative is certainly not the best solution for
the Town being that the architectural design is not as good
as what is there today, nor is the garage as usable as under
either alternative 1 or 2 above.
Larry Eskwith
Town Attorney
Town of Vail
April 10, 1989
Page 2
I would hope that the Town Council take a realistic attitude
toward this problem given the fact that a mistake was made by my
client, however, at no time did he realize the encroachment until
after the garage was substantially constructed. The survey which
he relied upon was in the Town of Vail files and did show that
the future garage would be on his property. It is unfortunate
when these problems occur, however, the Town in the past has seen
fit to work with various individuals to solve these
encroachments. I would hope that we will be granted the same
consideration in resolving our problem to everyone's benefit.
May I please hear from you at your convenience.
Sincerely,
Ja,' Peterson
~C : n
AGE2~DA
REG~LAIt ~IEETYAIG
~1s~Y3L 1~IETROPOLITAId RECREATYOI~ ®YS~'RYCT°
BOARD OF' DIRECTORS
6~EDMESDA~Co APRIL, 12 0 1989 0 3 m 00 PM °° V~YI, TOWld COIINCYl,
to Call to order ° 3000 PM 1 min
20 Approval of Minutese March 22, 1989' 1 min
(see attached)
3o Financial Report ° Thompson ~ 7 min :
~a Ford Park Tennis ° Bill Pierce & Frank Payne 15 min
5o Sc~imming Pool Task Force Report ° Prit~ ~ Morten 20 min
6o Summer Golf Video Package ° Mike Fox 5 min
7o Symphony of Sports Report - Folz 5 min
8o TOV Employee. recreation passes - Barwick 10 min
Golfo Tennis and ice skating
9o Dodson Report 15 min
A) Eagle Vail cooperation agreement (see Lacroix letter)
B) Vail Recreation Plan - Winston Proposal
C) Pre Season and VGA Golf Fees ° approval
D) VMRD employee recreation passes (golf, tennis, ice)
l0a Dobson Sub Committee Report - Tom Salasky 10 min
llo Approval of PO°s 5 min
12o Adjournments
Attachmentso
Minutes 3/22/89
Lacroix letter
Jim Collins letter - TV District - FYI
Ve~~ &k~UI~ 'IGd~T DI~~Q°
PARCH 22, 1989
o ~ Wilson, Per Lapin, George Itamot, Tim Gdrt'An
o l~at DOdS011, Kattly Payne, ~ Salasky
2~~ ~O o ~ m~ti~ was called to order at 3 0 08 ~a
OF o Lapin made a motion to approve the Pgarda 8® 1989
minutes, secor~ by Wilson, passed unaniu~slyo
o Streve Zhcatq~san joins the meeting (see hand out) o
Inc joins the m~tir~ o
VIA D%~~2YC~o
Qad~i~ Tonal item) Roger LacxoiX arm Lauren ~eren join the meetir~ o fihey
were asked to join our meeting ~r Merv Lapin who had
previous met with the Eagle Vail Board arm cliscv~~~ed the
possibilities of joining the two recreation districtso
fiche two entities discusses funding a study by Winston ar~d
associates which would cost $3,0000 fihe study would
research coanbinir~ the districts o fihey also dis~assed
the possibilities of cxanuininq golf operation for 1989
summer oration e
Lapin stated he wants one district (one political entity)
fron- Vail to Edwardso Feels the Vail residents consist
only of retirees aril millionaires and would get }matter
representation on local issues if the dawn valley
residents oaald votes He feels it does not make sense to
have several districts run duplicate programse There is
an economic savings to ~ realizede
Garton stated if passes are good at courses it may
create too much local play at Vailo
Eagle Vail District arm V1~2D agreed to meet ar'd discuss
various ways they can work together for the bettervent of
their respective constituentso
Lapin made a motion to approve $1,500 for the Winst-.on &
Associates study to research the advantages and
disadvantages of consolidation of VN~2D and Eagle Vail
District -total fee not to e~oeed $3,000, secor~ by
P9olloy, passed unanimaaslyo
Roger Iacroix and Molloy,
meet frc¢n 8 to 9 AM at the
on Mardi 30, 1989.
Roger Iacroix asked ~D what they feel will be gained
from the ~--lady fra~n Winston. .lapin said th'e study will
outline the'. advantages and disadvantages of: each district
if a coa~alidation occurs -fees, tax base, etc. Gartoai
stated ea~nanies o~- borth sides could be realized from a
Lacroix is concerned if they offer items to people this
year and then find it necessary to removed these offers
next year it could be very difficult for the people. He
is cortcexxaed about implementing any progratYtis prior to the
shady being oc~leted.
F~ PARK ~S: Bill Pierre, Architect, joins the meeting 3:50 PM.
Dodson stated the building has been thirough the
prel iminaxy 1~2B process a~ revisions -have been made to
the building per that meeting...Zl~ey then met with xi~
and Wilson wY~ had further comments and suggested
revisions to the building. Zllose revisions are being
presented to the full board to see if they share Wilsoal's
and Knox's c3~anges. 'Ihe building is apptely
$350,000. Lg2B suggestions were-sink the east ccxart to
existing court level -this will inflate the cost
by $20, 000; mwe the bike path -more rocen arrnuxi the
building; increase the size of the entrance and signage
at the parking lot; terrace east side and eliminate the
berm - econcenic move.... - _
Wilson arxi Molloy want to seriously research keeping the
west berm. Bill Pierce reviewed the layout of the
building, parking, bike path and new cxurt locatioai with
the board,.
Dodson reviewed the ideas of Knxix and Wilson -rotate the
building (windows to exhibition courts), place offices oar
gro~u~d le~~e~ and eliminate dormer. lapin does not like
the building anxi wants to use all the space on the seootxi
floor.
Dodson asked how much does the board want to spenxi on the
project? Z~ae original budget was $200,000 and the
atn'~nt e~-timates are up to $350,000. Wilson is opposed
to building office space - he feels Bill Wright and Kathy
Payne do not need separate office spaces. Kathy Payne
stated she definitely need office space to ootuzt the
moaiey, pr~~are the arxi ~ schedules -all
this requires a QtJZET space. . -
Pierce will peat the offices oaa: ground flooro
Petex Patten asked the boa~i to thinDc long terra range, 15
to 20 years, on this buildia~o wink about possible
additioa~ o Stated it is best tc maximize the ~atdoor
space< Tennis .players ocene to be outdoars ®do Wort
aig+e slot of ir~3oor space,
Dodsoa~" sun~narized what he heard the boar saying to
Piexne v keep chest 'berm, add height if a~eoessarir to block
the wind; east beau stiauld be terraced, the exhibit
courts should be 'capable of vie~red fmn inside the
house, remove dormers, rotate the building 90 degrees
(sun will beocatae problem) , place the two offices aaz the
lower level aaxi oo~abine them into 1 offioeo
Dalson said the oonstxuctiorr bgxiget will make a lot of
the decisions for the ado I~pin wants the building to
be a first class facility arm suitable for long term
tennis puaposes e 'Iizinks a deck and caru~py should be
addeda It w+~ald be foolish financially to let a $350,000
budget dictate the boat~3s decisioa~so
Pierce will redesign the building in 1 week ar~i run it bar
the board o Any board ~ iauterested in this meetia~
should ocme to a 7 AM meeti~ next Friday, March 31, 1989
to reviews Bill°s plansa
PaDIb Dodson stag they interviewed the rea~irxier of the
applicants arm nave -now.. short -1ist~ecl - tl~eaa to two0
P7orter/Breivier and Barl~,er, Rink~°, Seacate Pritz will
speak to the two finalists arm the swia~nirig pool task
force will select the winner,
OF SP(~o Ceil Folz joins the ritieetir~ 5<00 ~o She has arrarx~ed to
have all the lunches ar~1 dinners donated, Vehicles for
transportation to and from Denver will be rented for $20
eaChe The budget 1's estimated to be between $29,000 to
$30, 000 which is $5, 000 belo~t original estimateso 'IY~e
ticket sales are slowo ZYie Y~edia push will begin next
weeke She reviewed the clinicians to date aril noted they
have changed as warioias people arse added and drq~i fr~n
the listo T~pin asked how mur~a revenue will be made if
all tickets are soldo $13,750 if all tickets are sold
said the TOV donate $16, 500 o Oeil is working to get ~Ii)t~e
Shannonof Vail Associates to purchase all the retnainig~g
unsold tickets for full ticket price and give them tQ his
en~loyees, Y-ie has given verbal oommitmerrt, but she is
waitir~ for this in writitago ~Pu- asks when the press
talk on this event they stress ABC will ~ filmir~ this
everrto Iapin wants to kr~a if -the Town Council can get
any of their moray back? Ceil said yes if the costs aa~e
kept dawn, all the ticxets sell arxi there is i.noome aver
exper,dit~,~s
RCN PfIILT~S : JOINT TCfV / VMRD MEETIl~GS. Phillips stated that last
week at cau~cil meeting they were discx~ssir~g the arexaa
expansiari plan. A oau~cil/district ~aittee should be
foamed and work tcxaards nutual cooperation. Steinberg
= and Eric Affeldt would like to continue being the
r~present,atives from the Town Qot~cil for the quarterly
. meetings.. Garton and Nbllay .will be the VM12D
rePresetrtatives.
ICS ARE3~1 Phillips stated the best way to
look at the arena issues i . e o ooaYVention center and new
ice surfare is to ocene up with a broadly represented task
force to ooaxhx.-t studies on these mayor issues.
Lapin stated it is his goal to get the arena operating in
a business like manner and if there is still no profit
they will need to look furt~ier into more non ice events.
Phillips stated the process to look at ice arena issues
should be similar to the prowess used on the S~
pool task force. Khooc agreed this process is necessary.
Phillips wants VMRD to establish this process and run the
task force.
REAL F~~TE ~2ANSFER TAX: Garton wants Dod~soa't to develop
a list of all the items suitable for the real estate
transfer tax use and present it to VMRD. 'II~e list should
be divided into required, essential, desirable or any
other suitable heading.
MEN & W~1~3d' S t~LF
ASSOC FEE SCI~JIE: Deferred to golf sub cce~unittee.
DOD6Cfl~I (OaNT' D) : Dodson introduced Tcan Salasky, Dobson Arena Manager. He
stated ID~ian Jones has been offered and has aooept-.ed the
position of Business Manager for the District.
VNIIZD MEEI~dG ~Il~+g'.S: Lapin made a moti~ to hold two meetings per month
throughait the busy season; second Wednesday of every
month at the Vail lbwn Council Q~ambers and fourth Monday
of every month at the Vail Golf Club. Zlzis sd~edule will
be effective April 1 thatx~ October 31, 1989, seooixi by
Molloy, passed unanimaasly.
Molloy leaves the meeting 5x45 PNg
APPRQVAL OF PO'S: Knox questioned the trash bill at Ben's shop arxi why
VMRD is paying for the USGA for Satterstrc¢n. Dodson will
~ these. Lapin made a motion to approve the PC1,
secarxi by Knoac, passed ursanimously.
~ ®1~gC'%°
° l It~~ o
%apin asked Docls~ to call Jim Cbllires aced ask if
cart stop the formation of the ~ Districto 6~e area .
A~etrogolitan District m does V~2D have the riot ~
pra~ride this sexvioeo Dodson stated ~+e are not a Nlet~
Districto Dodson sherd also call Jergy Davis and Bill
James for their irip~at ~ on tni.s subject,
Dodson handed out the Winston Associates (see
attached) , his iteza should ~ put on the next ageaeda
for disc~assiono
Action to adjourn 6e10 ~
Gail Alloy, Secretary
town of ~aill%
292 west meadow drive
vall, Colorado 81657
(3®3)476-2440
April 6, 1989
Roger Lacroix
Eagle Vail Metro Rec Dist
Box 662
Vail, CO 81658
Dear Roger:
VMRD
VAIL METROPOLITAN
RECREATION ®ISTRICT
(303)479-2279 -
recreetlon` department
Just some brief notes on what was discusses on March 30, 19.89
concerning cooperation between our respective districts. The
preliminary thoughts were as follows:
GOLF
A pass holder refers to a person who has purchased a pass at
either of our golf courses.
PUNCH CARD:
-Pass holder privilege: Would be eligible to purchase one punch
pass, good for six 18 hole rounds of golf.
-restricted on weekends and holidays from June 1 through September
20, 1989 .
-1 punch pass per pass holder (subject to change after review).
-Cost - $75 per card.
-non transferable, non refundable, good for pass holders only.
-A pass holder would be eligible to pay the green fee rate of the
resident, established by each course. Vail - $40 for 18 holes.
Eagle-Vail- $32 for 18 holesa Good 7 clays per weeks beginning of
season to the end of the seasono
IDENTIFICATION CARD
-Non pass holders Each golf course would extend the privilege of
their resident ID golf card to t~}e other districts
-Cost of the card $l0o ID cards must be purchased at the
respective golf course< Proof of eligibility (residency)
reclta i red o
-Cost $~0 for 18 holes at Vail, $32 for 18 holes at Eagle Vailo
That would be good 7 days per week beginning of season to end of
seasono
-No restrictions
-No replacement if the card is losto Must purchase a new cards
-No exchange of card - Card must be shown with picture drivers
license at time of payments
TENNIS
Resident tennis passes of VMRD and Eagle Vail will be honored at
all facilities in both districtse Residents of each district will
need to purchase a tennis pass in their districtse
SbdIMMING POOL
Eagle Vail - no decisions at this times Interested in exchanging
pool usage for ice arena usages
IcE ARENA a VMRD
No decisions at this timed Interested in exchanging ice arena
privileges for pool privilegeso
MISCELLANEOUS
Decisions were based on the followings All financial
transaction/remuneration for services stay with the facility
giving the services All responsibility for proof of residency
stay with the respective districts and applicants Discounted
green fee rates are not given away at the heavily used timesa
restricted to times least usedo There is a true benefit for the
residents of these two districts without impacting the other
district's facilities. A review process period is scheduled so
the boards have the opportunity to rectify any undesirable
situation.
Roger, I hope this accurately states the summation of our meeting.
Please let me know ASAP if you agree.
Sincerely,
Patrick .'Dodson
Recreation Director
PJD/la
c.c ~. V m RD boa rah /~t e r16 e ~~5
Ste J e S«-{~e~s'{roM
`~_,.~. ~ Cie
G~r~
~A ~ b
~es:de~t d b.. an
~olc 1~ss ~,o~dec,
~ 5 ,~~° ssb1~5P~5 ~~9 aot be repiacecl, One
G 4 r~
P°f s~sor~P°
~~ ms's
r~4$s IS r e 1
u n ~ I TU C 7 C//~ W @ E i~ Q ~ ~ e4 ~p~ 1C~Q
F ~ ~5 ~fOrh
° ~RiC~ 1 l
~b ~'4ct5 re g ~G~tS ` ~~y.
~u',rer-~ Sato- 5~~ oP'~'n~r~c~ ~ I'.3p
~~
-P~"
r
O IC ~ I ANr _ - - - - .
P<1RCHA57NQf p ~ tel. ~~E1T~ ON INFORMATIQOy IAl
S PASS {yfiHOUT qEq~ .
~ O ~< -1 Toro earA Y ^a*dnrtif
Gk- ~ va1~ ~~ ~D4 a^e.o~,.,u,w.we enE ~Ot e, pum~,~y
reeenniorq oroy
~oeeyeer~a~~~awaufM~ f~ ~Ir1pr ~~
m ate ~ oro rr. artace m an reaem;~ ~WA~1 PrpDer ~o
~~ J
a ~ ~
~~" °° e0 ~~ora0k to lee oM 13 ~ wa °p xnea J
"' 1 ~ ~ - ~ or goo. ilea les trop. ~ q,;a {n,,,re p '
DESIGN REVIEW BOARD
APRIL 5, 1989
3>00 P.M.
SITE VISITS
1:00 P.M.
6 1. Litchfield Residence (Final)
Lot 8, Block 2, Vail Village 1st Filing
TABLED until next meeting, April 19th at the
request of applicant.
7 2. Jacobson Residence, Deck Enclosure (Final)
Lot 8, Block 2, Vail Village 6th
Motion-Herrington Second-Osterfoss
Consent, VOTE 4-0
1 3. Roost Lodge, Color Change (Final)
Lots 10,11 & 12, Buffehr Creek
Motion-Herrington Second-McCluskie VOTE 4-0
Approve as submited, sandstone color on adequatly
color. Windows and doors to be green.
3 4. Vail Gateway Temporary Development Sign (Final)
12 Vail Road
Consent
4 5. Ski Museum Entry (Final}
Vail Village Inn
5 6.
2 7.
8 8.
Motion-McCluskie Second-Osterfoss VOTE 4-0
Approve as discussed with landscaping, steps,
railing color, gravel and plants in window well.
Bossow Residence (Final)
Lot 20, Block 7, Vail Village 1st
Motion-Herrington Second-McCluskie VOTE 4-0
To approve as submitted with condition to work
with staff on landscaping.
Atwell Residence
Lot 4, Block 1, Lionsridge #4
(Final)
Motion-Osterfoss Second-Herrington VOTE 4-0
To approve as submitted, provision applicant work
with staff on landscaping.
Vigor 2 Duplex
Lot 13, Block 5, Bighorn 5th
(Final)
Motion-C-sterfoss Second-Herrington VOTE 4-0
Approve as presented and discussed above.
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Peggy Osterfoss
Jamie McCluskie
Ned Gwathmey
Pat Herrington
STAFF APPROVALS:
MEMBERS ABSENT'
Roy Sante
NONE
18 City & State, Aprif I0, 19N1
thics® ~I®vv cl® ®u measure u ?
1. Are the ethical standards o[
public officials today higher
than, lower than or about the
same as they were 10 years ago?
^ Higher
^ Lower
^ About the same
2. Do you believe the public
generally perceives state and
local officials as being honest?
^ Yes
^ No
3. Are we experiencing an ero-
sion of ethical standards among
public officials?
^ Yes
^ No
4. Does publicity about ethical
controversies at the federal level
(for example, the John Tower
nomination) color the public's
perception of state and local of-
ficials' ethical standards?
^ Yes
^ No
5. Do you believe that most o[
your peers in government are
ethical?
^ Yes
^ No
6. How do your ethics compare
with your peers'?
^ Much higher
^ Higher
^ About the same
^ Lower
7. Should state and local gov-
ernments implement ethics leg-
islation?
^ Yes
^ No
8. Should such legislation apply
to appointed as well as to
elected officials?
^ Yes
^ No
9. Does your government unit
operate under an ethics law?
^ Yes
^ No
10. If you answered "no," has
an ethics law been proposed?
^ Yes
^ No
11. If you answered "yes," what
general areas does the law
cover? (Check all those that
aPP1YJ
® re government officials
6 aexperiencing an ethical
crisis? Are the media creat-
ing an unfair perception
that public officials are dis-
honest? What do you think
is "right" and "wrong" be-
havior for public officials?
City & State needs your
help in assessing the ethi-
cal standards prevailing in
state and local government.
Share your views by fill-
ing out this questionnaire,
and please feel free to pass
photocopies along to col-
leagues; also, any addi-
tional comments would be
welcome.
Later this spring, City &
State will publish a major
report on ethics in govern-
ment that will include the
results of this survey.
Please fill out the ques-
tionnaire, tear it out and
mail it to:
-- -_ . _ w
City & State ,.l ~,
._
n ~'
.
~•
Ethics In Government -- I i~ ~ :
~ ,,'1 ,! i , ~: ', ~ i~ F
'f ~~°"''
; ~~
I
Survey
740 N. Rush St. 1r~ ~I
I I I! V
I#s!~
: i I
i
~ i
..~~ ~ ~
i
i I ; jI ~ n
Chicago, Ill. 60611 _
- I- -'" - - _,
-,
~ -?'-'
--~:T=---~~ r =~ ~-
_ Countyguverruncnl
_ City guvcrnnu•nt
5pL'elal disn'ict
Other (please specify)
Elected official
_ Appointed official
Jub title
_ Non•government employee
Jub title
It you would agree to be con-
tacted by a repm•ter [or addi-
tional comments, please fill out
the following:
Name:
Phony.
I WISH T0:
^ Change my address
(affix label below)
^ Ask a question
about my subscription
(enclose question
and affix label)
^ Subscribe: t year ... $15'
(Airmail and foreign delivery
extra. Please write or call
1-800-992-9970.)
_ Campaign contributions
_ Statement of earnings and
sources of earnings
_ Employment outside govern-
ment
Stock holdings and other
outside business interests
_ Accepting gifts
_ Accepting honorariums
_ Other (explain briefly)
12. Do you believe ethics laws
covering public officials are en-
forceable?
^ Yes
^ No
13. Do you think your govern-
ment's ethics law is being en-
forced?
^ Yes
^ No
14. Have you ever violated the
ethics law?
^ Yes
^ No
15. Do you believe public offi-
cials should have to disclose all
their income and assets, includ-
ing details about sources?
groups or to other private
groups?
^ Yes
^ No
17. Do you think such honorari-
ums should be banned?
^ Yes
^ No,
18. Should full-time, paid public
officials be barsed from accept-
ing income from any outside
source?
^ Yes
^ No
19. Should a public official
allow a businessperson to pick
up the tab for an expensive
meal?
^ Yes
^ No
20. In your role as a public of-
ficial, have you ever accepted:
_ A gift of significant value
^ Yes
^ No
_ A trip
^ Yes
^ Na
21. A developer seeking rezon-
ing of a piece o[ land invites the
planning commissioners and
their spouses for a free weekend
al a luxury resort he owns. He
wants to make a presentation to
the commissioners, in a relaxed
setting, about the project he
plans and its advantages to their
community. Is it ethical [or the
commissioners to accept the in-
vitation?
^ Yes
^ No
22. Please briefly explain your
answer.
23. Should public officials be
expected to adhere to a higher
ethical standard than are lead-
ers in the private sector?
^ Yes
^ No
24. Why? Explain briefly.
25. Are public officials being
held to an unrealistic ethical
standard?
^ Yes
^ No
:~ * ~ * * :~
^ Yes
^ No
16. Do you accept money for de-
livering speeches to business
To help us tabulate the re-
sults of this survey, please
answer the following:
Arc you a:
_ Government olTiclal
_ State government
Nme
uue
pwlrnmenUCOmpanynome
aolress
6ry/sut4:ip
1 )
pnone
Payment en[IOSlO ^ Bill m!
^ CNrpe ~ Visa ~ MutcrCar!
Account rq.
siVnature
NNAIL T0:
~1~ ~ ~
Circulation Department
965 E. Jefferson Avenue
Detroit, MI 48207
~moor~-t
~ ~
a o
Q Attach Q
8 label here
for
8 addresschanges 0
and
Inquiries.
8 D
9 D
a a
B
®mo~
'SJO for non~governmenl subscribers.
71 to Vail T1-aQ - APn1 7, ] 989
° ~l~ese~
® ~~
i~®ny a1~~e °
People for the Ethical
Treatment of Animals, an or-
ganization based in Washing-
ton D.C., have called a meeting
for 10 a.m. on Monday, April
10, in the Vail town hall.
The group is protesting any
plans for animal research in
Vail that might accompany a
move by Dr. Richard Stead-
man, the famed orthopedic
surgeon who now operates out
of Lake Tahoe.
Although officials with Vail
Valley Medical Center have
acknowledged they are trying
to get Dr. Steadman to move
his practice to the hospital, they
have not announced any
agreement.
Also, while it has been widely
rumored that Steadman would
establish an animal-research
lab somewhere in the region if
he moved here, nothing defi-
nite has been announced.
Steadman has not returned
several phone calls made by.
The Vail Trail. `"'"'"":. ` - ,
.::Don Welch, a member of the ~ _
board of directors for the°:hos-
ptal, said he believes-no board
members would condone a
"torture chamber" for animals
as part of Steadman's work.
Welch went on to say that he
supports a committee to review
research techniques, to ensure
that no animals are caused to
suffer unnecessarily. ~~
-The Washington-based
group is seeking assurances
from Vail. Town Council mem-
bers that they will not allow
any animal experimentation as
.part of Steadman s.pVractsce ,
~4~ ~ .-
Tire VaQ ?}ai! - AAriI ~. 1989
~"~ the ~®u ~ ` t~
~et® ~e ~i ®arz
To the editor,
People for the E t h i c a l
Treatment of animals has
learned of a possible situation
in Vail that demands your im-
mediate.attention.
We have received informa-
tion that Dr. J. Richard Stead-
man, of South Lake Tahoe, is
relocating to Vail, and may be
accompanied by Dr. W.G.
Rodkey, of Letterman Army
Institute of Research. Dr. Rod-
key has conducted extensive
animal experimentation, sev-
ering the nerves and ligaments
of dogs, monkeys and rabbits,
in studies he himself concedes
"are not comparable to clinical
ir{juries" (although they ,pur-
port to study ski and orthope-
dic ir;juries).
The town manager has de-
nied that there are present
plans to allow doctors Stead-
man. and Rodkey to experi-
ment on animals in Vail. How-
ever, the possibility of this issue
coming before the council has
not been ruled out, and no
assurance has been given that .
such a request will be denied.
We believe the Vail Town
Council needs to know that the
caring and compassionate citi-
zens of Vail do not, -under any
circumstances, at any time,
want animal experimentation
to occur in Vail! _ _ -"
Please call the Vail Town
Council today at 479-2100 and
voice your concern. Tell the
council members and town
manager that, while you realize
there are no definite plans at
present, if and when this i s
brought before the .Town
Council, animal suffering and
misery will be rejected.
A press conference will be
held at 10 a.m. on Monday,
April 10, in the Vail town hall.
Opponents and proponents of
the research facility are invited.
Patrice Green
Researcher
People for the Ethical
Treatment of Animals
Washington D.C.
Servang Eagie County ~ _ ~ April 8,y989
Tuesday through Sunday `"° ~ „~, Volume IX, Number 83 .-
~~ _ ~ _
A~t~~~~~~ ~lle~~ animal ~°~search headed fog V~~1
By John Calhoun
Daily Staff Writer
A Washington, D.C.-based animal rights
group has alleged that a medical researcher,
who has reportedly used live animals for cx-
pcrimcnts, might be coming to Vail to scl up
shop.
Rcprescnt<~livcs from the group, Pcoplc
For the Ethical Treatment of Animals
(PETA), arc scheduled to hold a press con-.
fcrcncc at ]0 a.m. Monday at the Town of
Vail Municipal Building to officially an-
nounce their opposition to the "proposed
animal research facility" at the Vail Valley
Medical Center.
Hospital Administrator Ray McMahan
refused to confirm or deny the allegation of
a proposed animal research facility, saying
the physicians in the hospital do studies
which he, as the administrator, is not aware
of. "I'm not in a position to speak for any of
our physicians," McMahan said.
However, Town of Vail officials said that
they have not received a proposal for an
animal research ccntcr in Vail, which would
be required. And even if they did, they
would likely oppose it.
"I think the town's position is pretty
clear," said Town Manager Ron Phillips.
"The Town of Vail dots not have any plans
to allow experiments to be conducted on live
animals in Vail."
The allegations by the animal rights group
stemmed from the announcement Friday shat
~aanaa a-e.~~a~°~ a
From Q~~ge ll
animal expcrimcnt~uion," said
Thomas, one of several activists
who will be speaking in Vail nn
Monday. "Our 250,000 members
arc outraged by plans to harm
healthy animals for human sports
medicine, and we will urge them to
find other places to ski if this
facility is built. Dogs don't ski and
don't deserve to have their limbs
broken and be killed to study in-
juries arising from exclusively
voluntary human amusement."
Blondic Vucich, president of the
Eagle Valley Humane Society, ap-
plauded the effort of the
Washington, D.C., group. Shc said,
"The Town Council needs to know
that the caring and compassionate
citizens of Vail do not, under any
circumstances, want animal ex-
periments to occur here."
Dr. Richard Steadman, a noted orthopedic
surgeon who attends to members of the U.S.
Ski Team and other world class athletes, has
signed a contract to join the VVIVIC staff on
Aug. 1, .1990. According to McMahan,
Steadman signed the contract "within the
last seven days."
Steadman will occupy a section of the
hospital's proposed $8.3 million expansion,
and wilt reportedly bring a staff of
physicians wish him to Vail. According to
Gary Feucht, assistant Vail Valley Medical
Ccntcr administrator, one of those that
Steadman is negotiating with is Dr. W. G.
Rodkey, a researcher and physician at Let-
terman Army Institute of Research in Sar.
Francisco.
When the Council approved the
V V MC's request for the 3 I ,209
syuarc. foot expansion last month, it
made it clear that if an animal
research ccntcr was proposed in
Vail that it would have to get ap-
proval from the Council. And al-
though the Council did not vote on
the research ccntcr issue spccift-
cally, most members indicated that
they would oppose such a facility.
The hospital's proposed expan-
sion still ncctis the approval of the
Colorado Highway Department for
their proposed South . Fronwgc
Road access into the hospiul, and
the required frontage road im-
provcmcnt plan. From there, the
proposed building design would be
reviewed by the. Vail Design
Review Board, and then finally go
back to the town for the ncc;essary
building pcrrnits.
Although Rodkey was not available for
comment on Friday, a Research Institute
spokesperson said that "animals are used in
some of the Institute's research." She
refused to elaborate or say that Rodkey is
specifically involved in the animal research.
Victoria Thomas, of the animal rights
group in Washington D.C., said she has in-
formation that ties Rodkey to animal ex-
perimentation such as "severing [he nerves
of dogs, cats, mpnkeys and rabbits." She
said further that her organization contacted
Rodkcy's wife in California and Rodkey's
wife indicated that the couple was planning
to come to Vail to live.
"Dr. Rodkey has a very long history of
Please see Anima! research page 10
Saying that additional patient
care rooms arc needed as well as
additional parking, VVMC officials
arc seeking to complete the
second floor on the north side oC
the building and construct a full
third Door on top of the existing
west wing. The proposal also in-
cludes a 185-space, two and one
half Icvel parking structure on the
northeast side of the hospital and an
access road from the parking struc-
ture to the South Frontage Road.
Further, the Colorado Highway
Department and hospital are rcpor-
tedly close to an agreement on the
necessary modifications 10 the '
South Frontage Road.
"1'1-il/ 1~ENVER YOISI' Sunday, April 9, 1989
G~~u~aa0~i~egh$s r®t~s~
~cB~ec~aa9 era Va~~
VAIL - A belief that a Vail
hospital may use animals in ski
injury research will bring animal
rights activists out in force on
Monday.
Supporters of People for the
Ethical Treatment of Animals,
which claims 250,000 national
members, will announce Monday
it opposes a planned expansion of
the Vail Valley Medical Center
because they believe an animal
research facility is planned, said
Blondie Vucich, president of the
Eagle Valley Humane Society.
"There is not going to be any live
animal research clinic -period,"
said the hospital's chief operating
officer, Doris Allen, said Satur-
day.
.Officials also denied that plans
for the $8.3 million, 33,000 square-
foot addition to the hospital in-
clude an animal research center.
~~ ~
® ® ~ ® Saturday, April 8, 9989
: °rl der : ~ ~ '
s a l labs s
By Knight-Ridder News Servi
' .WASHINGTON - In a violent,
;Mambo-style remake of the story
of Noah's Ark, animal-rights guer-
rillas heavily damaged two Arizo-
na labs this week, left scrawled
threats to the researchers and saw
ed 1,200 mice, 42 rats, 12 rabbits
and two guinea pigs.
~: While the growing American ani-
mal-rights movement hailed the at-
tack earlier this week at the Uni-
•versity of Arizona in Tucson as the
70th direct "action" since 1977, at
least one member of the U.S. Sen-
ate has had enough.
"I contend that it is the animal
terrorists that dust be stopped be-
fore they cause anymore harm to
the public and the animals they
purport to protect," said Sen. Ho•
well Ileflm, .ll-Ala.; who introduced
a bill Friday to strengthen federal
laws to protect labs.
Heflin wants to make it a federal
crime to attack federally funded
laboratories, to illegally or falsely
obtain or use research data from
them or to "release, steal orother-
wise intentionally cause the loss of
any animal."
The proposal; sets up .ways for e
:labs tb gain restitution and sue vio;;
lators. , ~: ~ ~ ;
People for the Ethical Treat•
ment of Animals, or PETA, a„
Washington-based group that dis-
seminates information from under-
ground animal•rlghts groups, but
that disavows any illegal action it-
self, immediately condemned He-
fun's :bill as a duplication of state
' `SHE DEIVVEIt ~OST /G~Q~fO®i~~l~
.laws and beside the point.
"(Animal researchers) are a
segment outside society and this
further insulates them,' said.,~In-
grid Newkirk, the national direct6r
of PETA.
The public would be "most gro-:
tesquely appalled" if they knew
what goes on in animal labs, New-
kirk said. A more serious problem
is the research community's refus-
al toadopt new,.humaneguidelines,
approved by Congress in 1985; she
said. •
"They've blocked them at every
touch and turn," Newkirk said, ad-
dingthat average citizens would be
jailed for doing~the same things to
animals that researchers do in ex-
periments.
The Arizona arson, which caused
an estimated $150,000 in damage,
was the 70th attack by, animal- .
rights groups, according to infor•
mation provided by Newkirk. The
underground Animal Liberation
Front claimed credit for the,arson
earlier this week and most of the
other incidents,
The "actions" ranged from rela•
tively minor spray-paintings of
signs at labs and releases of small
numbers of mice, to the destruc~
tion ot• a $3.5 million animal diag
nostic lab at the University of Cali!
forma-Davis in April 1987 and
death threats against researchers.
"Many death tiu'eats and other
harassment of researchers are no4
reported by the press in order ~o
protect scientists and their fami- ,
lies ... "Heflin said.
~iAf ~ r
Conmcloum of coetm mod ecology,
Coloredena elected to mend the
Wlnter Getnem out Into the cold
by JERRY q/WSPoEW®4Upp
®A/hen Coloradans cast their fudlui.
nn Election Day to cut o1T stair
spending (or the 1976 Winter Olympicv,
(ew restdcnts were affected more am-
spicuously than a '_9-year-old G.cek im-
migrant named Fva gelus lsiaekmtns.
The vme mcatn that the Ciamcs would
now be held elsewhere-dat all-a torn
of events that Tsiagkouns faded to an_
tiapate last March. That was when he
bough) an old rnlfee shop nn Ihnvcr's
shabby East Colfax Avenue, grandly re-
namedthe place the Olympic Restaurant
and made ready for what he assumed
would be "a lot of free publicny be-
tween now and 1976."
Tsiagkouns accepted the election re-
sults bravely enough. Standing outside
his restauram he declared, "I feel bad
that there will be no Olympics here, but
what can I do?" He glanced at a splen-
did new sign over the door, one bearing
both the restauram's name and a pic-
ture of a lighted torch. Then he smiled
~6
--
®~~~~`
m¢IOOa TN¢ VOT¢, rctlaU tllCUr Tsi]g~(IUns
had just ih< right name for his new place.
0
Np~'. ~C~ l~>7.~
oirmvres ....,,,..,,
If you'tl like to keep
the leehng of the
great outdoors when
you're stuck indoors.
reach for Tlm benlne
after soave or cologru
Timberline's ruggetl.
exndarahng scent is
Ilke a Dreelh Of
Iresh, outdoor an.
Timberline after
shave, cologne.
soap, tleotlorants
antl gift sets trom
52.50. Also in
plastic for travel.
P,oEuQt of MEM cOTDr~y tnc,.NOnnrela.'IOrarwr
a
(~amnuncc opened w hen n :ants hnnhcd
id(am unpu rtes shout the xnnce ul pn,-
Uh mryc ra mp:ugn hinds. "'1 rc;dly Judl
fcC wha'IC II 111:11ICr~~~ lital~il'd I)()()(
( h.urman \4, H. (iondwn, who ale, i.
presidcm of Dcnvcr-h:ucd John.-M:m-
sillc Corp II pri,hahh JNlnl m. ncr:
h. a resounahng $17,J411 ^, i5g 906.:m
clcrlora tr wurru•J above ry,lcnn:d c ,.I.
and envronntcnlnl impart of the (lances
wppruvcJ :m amcndmcm lu the Coloruh,
am.unnum harnng Ihc use of (usher
.Lne fund.. In Ucnvcr valet. sl.o a•n-
aclcd a comp;uunn mc:uurc pwlutg a
vnul:u Gccrc un cur funds.
The Jcfcal of Ihc Olympics was man-
egcd by an army of Juorbell ringers call-
ing nsclf ('itiecns for Colorado s Fu-
l ore, w hrchspan 523,600 m i t s l l mom hs
of cvlstcncc-most of it collcctcd in rnn-
tnhuuons ul 55 or b10. The CCF had a
total media budget of 82.100, which it
used fur radio spots in rural C'oloradp;
its one big fund-raking project, a con-
cert by (olk singer Judy Collins, Lnr
51.000. The C(.F's honks, slashed in a
crate m the old house n used (or head-
quarters, wefe open to the public.
Simply put, the only thing directly af-
fected by the vote was a proposed 54.2
million m state funds 15800,000 had al-
ready been appropnated 1, since the rest
o(the 135 million of Olympic costs was
supposed to come from the Federal Gov-
ernment, Denver's treasury, TV revenues
and ticket sales. Still, bout sides had de-
fined the stakes as nothing less than the
fate of the Olympics, an interpretation
reinforced by the (act that the U.S. Sen-
ate, in passing a 515.5 million appro-
priation for the Games last September,
had made the measure contingent nn
Colorado's coming up with its share.
"The voters made their position clear,"
Goodwin said the morning after the elec-
tion in the DOOC offices, which com-
manded a view, smocking one now, of
the Rockies in the distance. "They don't
want the Olympics."
And now, seeking a new site for the
'76 Winter Games, the International
Olympic Committee could have more
trouble than Meyer Lansky. The San
Franrr:rrn C/rronir/r editorialized weeks
ago against California geeing any bright
ideas about proposing ahernative sites
in that state, and the French government
is not pushing Grenoble, the'68 site. An-
other former host, Innsbruck, did ex-
press imeresl, as did Vancouver, but the
IOC- indicated that it might be four
4fi
nwmin Ixtwc .I au' n rhu.cn. Willi
Ihc Wlillt'r UI)mpus already under lire
fie amtmcirla hvn, n Is nut utconccn~.
^blc Ihw Ihc IO( would sclrc this dcutac
In cinrcl Iha• G.uncs :dloccthcr.
Vur arc the IB7h Summer 1)1}mpics
unnuutc Innn wndar In,uhlcs. A ga,w-
mg am rOlvntplc nu,vcntcnt m hluntrc-
:d one Ih:u wnu1J lather sce Ihc env'.
u caxuc .pent un .urwl nettls la now
luukmp w Dcnvcr for ideas on how to
prucccJ. l'hc (olor:ulo cunp:ugn may
n(N exactly lit ihclr needs, lur m Dcn-
verthe opposauon centered on ecununtlc
plus cnvlronntcnial issues. l he rnult
hraugM u,gcdtcr under the :mn-Ulvnt-
plc banner young aclrvats, conscrv:u unt-
Isw, bloc-collar wprkcrs anJ liscal con-
<crvauves. I( the CCF prpvtJcd the lo-
mmotinn, the man at the comrols waz
Dick 1-umm, a lawyer who, at 37, last
week also won hu (ounh term as a stale
rcprescma t ivc
Lamm, an ,ntcnsc, intcllcculally resl-
Icss man, was tilting wnh the states big
money iniereus. "The people behind Ihc
Olympics arc the some ones who a;md
to profit-the airlines, hotels, hanks and
ski resorts.'' he said. Warning that Utym-
pics have always Deen seeded with "eco-
nomicland mines," he qucsuoned wheth-
er the DOOC could tea listically hope
to keep costs from soaring far higher.
The Olympic foes further argued that
the Games, al whatever cost, wore an
unwelcome extension of the "sell-C'ol-
oradu" campaign that Governor Love
has used to attract tourism and indus-
try during his three terms in olTice. In
&tct, this may hnvc been the strongest
slat in the bed on which the Denver
Olympics were laid to rest. Many Co-
loradans believe that Love's efforts hnvc
been, if anything, ton wccessful. Fvi-
dence thst the state may have been over-
sold is there in the Los Angeles-style
sprawl that now stretches from Dcnvcr
westward into Ihc foothills of the Rock-
ies. With problems of smog and water
shortages worsening, posters have gone
up urging outslJers m "Ski Kassa:'
and bumper stickers have Floweret read-
Ing IN)N~r ('AI.IfIIR NII'A If: f'(tl ltR SIN t.
"We're stanmg a+ re:dirc Ihal growth
isn't necessarily gout," said i-mom.
"We've got to stop this knee-jerk hoosa
erism and mindless promohunahsm."
All this was m stark mmrasl w Ihc
goodwill that prevailed back in May 1970
when a band of Denver boosters remrneJ
triumphantly from Amsterdam, having
r~,.n,.„ter
or_rmvres ...
t'in.nr.nded lh~ ~I.(~,nni~ha lha'l ll
.ergieen..ul.i1lLiem+unwhm the haa-
liill+ r l'+I nl Irrw 11 1l till .I i~r ~irnl.Iln ~n
~~~Ila .lighlla Ic.. ru n'ticd than Ihc'~Nin.
I„„I ^hnudc II ~I,, red i ~\unlcl~
J.nn IL:II Ihc Ulvmpi. ~,\n1di. aann+
,.~ndJ Ix• +Ln1cJ in 1 art cl ccn hin 1
h.Inpd>. ihr nuncl had txeu d1+rn,+cJ
.1 ilh (cw prnplc „h1, a.lualll liacd Ihcr c.
I he „pl„t+I n.~n di:11 +1...1 deaelnik•d
in Facrgrccn w.. .unxlnnc~ M+ICnea 1.
m,unt:nnmc Ih:1l h1.IIhLm .nngx'In u1+
..null gun dawn utnnccm ahddlcu m
iherr +duudva nt+. .\ more In+ldtahlcunt-
ccrn wa+ Ihc• 17(1(1( "+ fadurc In Icl Ihc
If )( m nn Ihc +ccrcl Thal f vcr green 1+
in a mdd region where ah:utcc+ui +nuw
al Ihc Ilmc 1+I Ihc Gamc+ would F+c tine
in :S. '(he vic+ haJ Fxcn ahu+cn, nl'
cuuru. m Ihc micrcV nl keeping Ihc
(lames an Ihc (root +IJc u(ihc raugc
:Ind Ihu+ ca+dv wnhm a pnnnucd 45-
mmutc dove
Simtlar Ihmkmg mpucnccd Ihc Iuc:1-
nnn of Ihc prtrpuud dol. nhdl unu+c.
Thi+was Muunl Snik lau;a craggy, wnul-
whlppcd peak wnh wanly snow cnvcnng,
a dclicicncy 1)cnvcr\ leaden hul M' hav-
ing an annl avhnl+h +now nn bald +ry n+
ui Ihc rycuuc whmlllcd In Ihc IU(
Pcrhapc Ihc ulrhru+hmg plnv wa+ a
pc'rftt'I ponucr lu Ihc enure hlunder: m
I lieu ca gcnte++lo hlur+l r)cnvcr.thecnnt-
rtnllCCnlen had cfcaric +rdd the wrong
udc of Ihc Ft ucklc+ u. Ihc IO('. I)cnvcr,
col of the (inu ulcnlal I)nulc. 1+ nut il-
+cl(aski arcs: the oha uni+(11~ntplc-cal-
Ihcr skung n ntan~ Imlc. hr the wc+l. II
i+gdl punting Ihul mrnc knawlcdgcahlc
prine+l+ were nnl rat+cd c:uher Ih;ut Ihcv
wa(r)n lop u( Ihc+c and other Imvcp-
rc+cntannn+. n ;d+u Ixrmnc clcu Ihnt
Ihc Ucnvcr commnlcc~+Sl4 nulhun pncc
lag w:n ulicrly unrcalnnr f luuuch Ihc
a~cd n( nhlu+canun came hm nn r,n of
light. Asked ghoul Ihc I)emcl adclcga~
lum\ pcrkrrm:utu' m 4m+a'nla nl. l ~,I.
u1:Ido LIa'UlCnanl l.n~cnurr Inhn \dn.
dcrhnof +;ud' .. I hca r c Ivc++cd Inr
Inns. w Ihca 6cd .1 hn r
1 hulcr gn w ,Ineak M Ihc
(tly ntpic Icadcnhgt went I„ \;glLn1., I,n
I ha' ~7~ (lame+whcrx' V.nu1 M. \I~hl d+
,i+aucJ uliia la l+ III,II ~ .,nil I' ..I Ihc
ix~ul+k' hunk Il,~me „I~n~~~a Ihc rtl.m
pn+ fn argue nulerw nc. Ihc new la
IurntcJ ((i .ein ihrca• Jclc eelc..~I Ii+
from Its SCquenlial Cam System That antiquates
Ute conventional noisy cam near and swuvlmq
pIaIC IO ds Syrlfh rnnnllS Power Umi Ihc RSR
MCDonaltl 81016 tlCSignetl Io match nr
excned thn, perinrrnancC of any
aUlOmaiic Turntable CUrrCmly
avaaablC® SOmC OIhCr
highlights Include a VanablC
~ Pitch Control®A t 2"
dynamically balanced
turntable plalierQ
A viscous-
damped
cue and
0 r~~ pause
• ~) control wdh
exclusive
Irichon Cue
Clinch to keep
A Ihn lone arm cuCd
!p4 Over the exact
groove®Anautomahc
tone arm ICCk 10
elimmale accidental
' ~;~ damage tO the SlylUS or
a~ Mme, record®AConcemnc
Introducing the ~ ~ ( Gimbal Arm Mount and
.:~ leatherweighl push-button
®SR McDonald 810 operatign Icatunnq the widest
'selection of gperatlnq modes0
Vour RSR McDonald dealer wdi be
Transcription Series happy to audition Ihc 81010r youp
The pace for this unbelievable perlormer~
Automatic Turntable. 514950®FromRSRlThe a o
world. largest manulaclurer®®®
of automatic turntablesA
BSR (USA) Ltd
____ _ elat,yeu_N v. to91~ RAe00NAlD
OLIYPICS ~~ ....
~~„n I,~ Id D.i n, ,+hcn' Ihc+ Ini rrd Ihcir
.~.~+ ~nl,• .~ nxclmF n. Irll the IUt ,d
..1 a ,.,t r; .1111 bl )I, Inhlt +L'11111OCnl ill
t `I„i,l, i,~ Itrnu sole Mnne. rhea ea.dv
.,,I lr. ia',I - ~nnlwa'., .,,mc _'~,IMIII
im,tc Ih,ut iln' uumher nccdal to pw
the I IhnthL+,~n Lnl wrek'. hallul,
I ,llcl. ,+hdr the +unicr .purl would
t+.uched wnh emwing am:vcmwl. the
I h'mrl p.un•I ul.lJr a Lnl. Jcyxra lc cl~
I„II h, .,oa a+cr~lhmg M tcJ iNnhw mg
um I,.unr. .~ .Jledulc rcluruun h~
.cptrd M Ihr IU(. I ua hoMlcddmg
a,l. hua led ngM ow, nrcr the futile uh-
icaltat. of Ih:u +run'. uucrn:won:d led
rrn tan. i hen Nordic cvcnK were shell-
ed I tom F acrgrcen tit Slcamhn:u Spnng.,
e I Sfi~mdc dove through the muuntams.
:~Ipme cvcnK wound up IIN) mdcs aw:rv
near Fail. Unly loge. haxkev ;utd skat-
ing stuycd m Ucnvcr I'hc ccaltcrcd new
sacs made txncr tcchmcul and ccolugu;d
unse, but lnsfead o(Ihe centralvnl cnn-
rcpt promtud m Amsterdam they of-
fered astrange new Olympic mode and
a sharp break with hlslorv. In addition
m cx pence. there was the prospect of
three Ulymptc Villages, plus :ur and awn
lifts (or competitors to opening and dos-
ing recs.
In (heir clTons w undo the damage
caused by past sms, Ulympic supponers
seemed clearly desperate: McNichols
was accused of election code violations
when Ineruture calling the Olympics "a
force for peam, hmtherhond and intcr-
national goodwill'- was distributed wnh
the pay envelopes of the city's H,O(IO em-
ployees, and d the mayor could have
had his way, he dearly would have sub-
mined the emire maser to Emily Post
for arbitration.
"It's like inviting somebody to din-
ncr,•' McNichols said. "You just cant
Icar up the invitation."
Another ilbadvised campaign move
was the DOOC's eBon to discredit n.
foes by circulating a Drm•rr Peer stixv
that darkly deuribed CCF's orgamtcrs
as "a smell bw anful band of tcnacuna
young political activists who have lihere~
into Colorado over the past two years."
The story omiued the fact that nnc of
the key CC'F leaders mentioned, 24-yrtr-
nld Meg Lundstrom, was horn ul (lllu-
rado. "And our people didn't litter
here," she addeJ. "They rmnr here. "'Elie
DOOC leaflet also did nm mention the
fact that, nn the other vde, C hairman
Goodwin himself became a Coloradan
only when Johns-Manville moved ns
50
think area
r a hanf~
t ~~ ~ Clro~. c mlo.ro61. and m
~ r '' ,hen .00 at.ong from rood ro <oe.c
Cal: ih. n . Ramada Inn /o. free
~ .. enr Remedo Inn.
Remede Inn e...„r.. olgc.r
~r "~ PO. Bo. 390,~Vhorn:., •nrene BS001
~IIELC®IME ~®IIAE
ocrpsvres ,.,,,,..,,,.,r
hr;ulgnancly Ir,nn Nc\, YrnA la.l vcv
In II\ Imal clfurl to wlvc the 1 )I. nqucv,
iilr I)U1)(" vluhhurnl\ vnlaA to n. ctt
n,dlum cuvl eV imale. :urJ areucd I hal the
(,a nuv, I:u lium hcum cm rtunmcnl:Jla
h:omlid. \unJJ pn nlucc \:du:rhlc I:uul-
u+c Phumur4 lin (ldrnaJu Ihly \v:rv a
Innm Ihal 0111 )< blca-I'reuJcnl Inc
~1ucr. a S+usv-h,nn cncinccl. w.v vnll
m:rkmc av I;uc :n I Iccoan I . when he
and Lamm nlcl lul a dchalc I ~ ~ I hr 1 rl\ nr-
picv. Hnun ur 1{t ronducElc'.'~~ I m n chan-
ivlrv clavvn+um ;u Ik•nvcr (nnunumw
l nllcec.
\ucr, an cmhaulcd 6enrc ^nud the
Hunvcn hurncrv ;md clcmcm chain. +.av
rluqucm m hchall' of boon. "~1 he 1)Irm-
I+ICV wdl hone Urecl her vla lc :mJ Icdcral
fnvlnnuncntal plannmc m ("ulnradn lur
Ihr lire Ilmc." he prunuvcJ. "'~fhcv~ll hr:
the c:ualvsl lur IanJ uvc."
I{ul nett dav, when the vino wcrc
arunleJ, n wav all hnunJog~lc. The ann-
Ulymplc :uncnJmcm vwcpl vlrlually
every pan of ('nlnradu evicepl the +kr
enunlry annurJ Vad and Sleamh, ral
tinnnee - and n love m each of Ihuve cum-
numnlcs by only a handful of voles. In-
\ufar a+ the nnrcv were munev and envl-
rnnmcnl, the rrnlCnnlc w:l\ rcmlm\cCnl trf
puhbc rclcctnm nl snot her hlc pngcti~l,
the SSI~. Hw the eumpelenee ul the
I)OOC Icadcrshlp alvu wav m yucslum.
and the messy tle for n cnvs-nJJen Ulvm-
plc mavemenl seemed elect r. the esccl-
Icnce and fair play nnnincly c. peeled m
Olympic cnmpcuuun arc nu Icvv nccn-
sary mthe hack nwmv where the Games
arc actually or~amceJ.
Thu wav the firs) umc Ihal an al-
ready annruveJ vanuc had ever nnneJ
Juwn an (Avmpicv. Ycl n wav nol a
vote agannl the Olymplcv pr:r vc, nor
a vu1C agamM upon. Hul II w;la e
vole agalnvl <pnrunH faaliucv Thal scut
la rpaycn nnlhum of Julian and work
:ILJ mrl l'r\CIIIIaI lllnac r\allnll aiIIInJ{:1
in the area concerned.
A+ fur ulhcr Icssunv. L:unm wggolcJ
a couple w'hde cclchr;Umg :u dIC (~(~I '~
I-.Icclion NiFhl panv, '-N'c have shown
Thal we Junl need cucuvo m (ulurldu,
we nttd suluuom lu prnhlcmv." AI Ihclr
wake clvcwhcrc m Ucn\'cr, pm-Olympic
troops were lindme cuminn dl a wcll-
utwkcJ bar. ~hhc (Yl made du wnh m-
cxpensrve Caldnrma wine and areal
quanuucs of Ulymnra. a F+ccr popular
m the Wcsl. Lamm. m hIV vv lvJum. mar
have found Ihal bran) urlnprupn:uc.
Ile was Jnnkinc HuJwcl+rr. owo
5 ~ ~~ Jam'- B+
g~ ~®~ "'kph .
,`~ °"
v®,~ ®e~tr°a ~MIf P-~~~~°~®~~~
made t
~Y~~;®~d16Y~~ta~FM~P ~waes~NKP°We ,
see s L s
~ d le ea °~
~~®~9~~~~`~ ee se~ec~(onlcso he ous?e~eoOP~~e\s~ h
~®~s the R`mo P ad~e~saun9 sFM m ptn9iaM s1a~tO t~~;n91n bO
atloudn~ muhtp serfs t~a yt,he ~11un'dand ~p 19x 9` es Y°u n'°le
11 veMandhha~9'vssma~WhodemMa9na~° ~g~~y07i
on1Y qua PM. F°( th ~
FM a%
"Gat ~ -gyp caeerera~ said I~: Moog ~a~reiIl.
..Ynll'rf vl.,r\." I v.u,l "I r,~ l I. n,l
Idr vunlr 4un1 ,.1 phmncr., rln
nm•
h+L,„I wnh Ju,va• I,n a.,lwra .
hf v nd
I +. i,l.
'tio I\Ihl. canon rarn•vlin,lfl
-. ..~' he a+rla~nr,l II'.
arn,mrrBIIC :end it L~Av+ rr„I, r
tic, Ilp, .,. .,4f n,.,, .
Ir. ~Idf h\ rof r.'„plc ,. L.. ~~~ it \
Iha rLun,nn p1n., n,l., c~n...nr\
Frown ur .,. Ihr\., r rrnl\
w I l h v,
"In.I ., .n,l .I,.., .I'
"I ,h,n'I An„w
he v.u,l "I In. ?I n.m.l., ..u •.,':
h.I. ,, t \ .~~ gn.n.uurr I, ,. ...
Irvv lh.ur Cllr Kilh rli,I:,•n~•
Ilavh I nu k,. Ih.,n j l •n
`fm .,,hl It cfi 16..c I'..., r~l
v.ui U„ 1 Ieer,n4ppu~
Itl1~fV'11~LJ-Yr
~~~ ~'.
Thr smell camera for prown~upf
•'~
- ~-
~~ h.tt All(: ntt•:uts.' It ntr:uu you _ut to
h.n'c rltildren in the house. Ancl you
clan t h.n'r children in the house :my
nun'r."
lie >i~h.. h:ur_in~ up. "\tat'be tct,•rr
duin~ ,unu•thiu~ lur her kids. tukin!~
llicm out of Iltat rnt'irunnTCnt. but tch;tt
c,m 1 tlo hn' her' Tun c:ut see bury
nmcli time I have. Her house h:is rats.
ru:u•he,.:nxl peelin~~ point. The rclut•a-
tion people have been canting ;wound
for sewn-and-u-half uumihs ht talk
.shunt getting her a new platy. but thec
ucycr (inci her a home."
Cur:ut looks nutntent;u'ih' depressed.
.:\ number of ns t;et together and h;n'e
:~ beer utter work :uul talk about thim~s
I like Ihi.," ht• tells me. "The t'oun~ ones
get impatient because they tc;mt to save
jhc tcorhi toduri. I ask them tt'hat they
iutrnd ht tlo hnuurrntt'. They don't un-
drrstantl that. ~f the purpose of tt•el(art•
is to help people !het but•k into sorieh•.
nbt'iousk tyr•re f;tiliug. \\'elfure is • a
self-petprtuatiug bastard. \\•e make su-
ci:d ye~rtubles of unr t•lieuts. I har't'
I~ +een fifth-gencr;ttiun welfare f:unities
~ tchere it was asocial status thing to
have your otyn case number and to ~~ct
yutL;tternth!F1Flr` rl'ecklowntown C;hi-
~ t;tgu, I visit Dayitl L. Daniel, Cook
~ Cnunh`s public aid director, a soft-
spoken blut•k man tyho has tyorked in
tcelf;u'e siure 1938. llauiel seems
~ stunned by the sh:unbles around him.
Couditiouz there never hooky-don', hr
~I explains: yet at Ieast the ratio of t•asr-
tyurkers ;uxl clerks to welfare ret•ipieuts
permitted some sort of service. But in
tht• past two ur there vc:us, tyith the
lti~h..rgtc of nuernploxmttmt-tfte~itu='
scion suddeuh• tvorseuttl. Each of those
yew's saty a all to 33 per cent int•rcasc
in the number of rases. But the state
:utd federal ~uycruutents, tahith pay
cascu'urkt•ts• sal:u'ies, lied uu iutcrt•st
iu increasiu~~ manpower. Then tcert•
uwre iuterestt•d in economy.
..It's very discoura~iug." sacs ll:uticl.
..For uearh' four years tce't•e tcritten
utrwos. held t•unfcrcnccs. and cuuunun-
icated yin "1'\' :uxl the press. untl tt•e
still t:ut't t•uuciutc ;utybudt' tt'c aced
more help. \1'r just cau•t do our jab. If
it weren't so terrible, it tyuuld bt• funny.
\\'e t•;ut't It:uttlle et•it•tions, deaths, and
fires-;aid the people tyho nerd solar-
thing lodaq. whrit•e run out of fuutl.
\1'c look Iikc,Fnuls to our clicuts and to
tht• business people tye• cleat tyith."
Sileutk. he slides across the table a
list of {ate u:uncs of dc:id persons typo
are still gettiu!~ relief c'hec'ks. "Bv the
sheerest ac•citlcut.° he says. "tt•c uncot•-
ered these cases this tyce•k because of
.a new reuuimment that our c•licnts get
D. cards so .their stolen c'hec'ks can't
cashed by thieves. Somebody was
~uilh' of plain fraud. :utd rye tveren t
able to discover it before now.••
Back at the En;letytxtd office the
next day 1 w;tit for )nnmv Jefferson.
the young t»:m tyho needed the 514.GO
entergenrt' chet•k for bus f:u•e so he
cuuhl get to his uew jab. \\%hen he m'-
riccs. Corm greets him in the tyaiting
room :uul presses a sealed envelope in
his hand. "1'm afraid it's doing to take
a week for Springfield to issue you the
chick. \Ieantt•hile this will help."
After Jefferson leat'es. f ask Cor:ut
what was in the envelope. "All I could
get for him tt;ts hyo bus tokens, so I
trot iu hyo dollars of my own moues.
It teas c•ilher that or let him tcalk to
u'ork.'•
Bumpy Course
for the
Denver
OIyI11pICS
lil• \IIL1'ON \'IOHST
\CASHINCTO\. D.C.-As ;utt doo•u-
hill racer knotys. it's not the fit:at hard
bump un the t•uurse that thrusts you.
Its tchen they t•ume two, three, ur four
in a ruts. bur Denver. Colorado, a t•ih•
tn'iug kt remain cret•t through the plau-
ning~t;rl,+c:c n€-Eler-1S)r(i \1'intr.r Olyrnpu .
C;mx•s that it is st•hcdulctl to bust. the
humps are tomiuK h;u'd un cac•h other.
And the trickiest strett•hes lie ahead:
o -Phis sunnner :ut ;utti-Establish-
nteut tayta~cr-ec•olugist group called
Citireus lur Coloratlo•s FuUtrr cullct•t-
cd. tt'ith remarkable rase', ~ i,(100 sig-
uatures-half again :u nutt•h :u the
minimum needed to put on the ballot
in Not•embcr a rcquircnx•ut that the
state gocernmt•nt prucitle nu outer' sub'
sitlirs fur the Den 'er tyinter Oh'mpit•s.
o Ilacing suc•t•c•cdetl ou this front.
(:itizens for Colorado's Future began
cirt•ulatiug petitions to ~~iye the voters
u chant•e to pass a simil:u' restrit•tiun un
speudiug by the llt•nyrr cite' gut•crn-
uu•nt. "1•huu~~h only S,:il)(1 signatures
a•erc needed. aLnost lll,ll(Nl w'rrc t•ol-
Ict•tctl, :uul that questiuu. tau. is uu the
b:dlot.
o Hcrc in \\'asbington'both the Scn•
ate and the house tyerr remarkably
.l/iltun 1'iursl i.e rr .tr/ndic•ufrd t•olumni.d
lur flu' \\'axhim~ton Star-Nctcs unit rtn
rtcirl.rkirr. •
slow in respondinG to Culortdu's cull
for federal subsidvt despite the tradition
of federal help for this kind of under-
taking. lunalh•, under pressure from
Colorado Sen. Cordon Allott, the Sen-
ate approved a 515-million subsidy. The
1[ouse btterior Committee, hutyeycr,
bottled up the legislation, :utd the com-
mittee is unlikely to tike at•tion before
the November referendum.
a The llepattmcut of Iluusinti; ;u~cl
Urban llet•elopmeut bus pledged only
a fraction of the 531.3 million Colorado
has requested for housing. The state
t•uutends that the fat•ilities it trill huihl
to utcommodate the games ;md its lt,u'-
tit•ipauts t•;ut later be tr;utsfurmccl int~~
luny- sort rnedinnrincome housing.
o -[hr Enyirunnu•ntul 1'rotrctiuu
Ageuct', tyhit•h is requirrtl by late to
assess the ent'irunmental impart of Ird-
cralh' finautcd pruGratns. has ju+t ;ui-
uuunt•ed that the Olympics shunltl hr
ret•vt•1ed to such previous sites as Srpcttc
\-alley, California, ur Lake Plac•itl, \ctc
Tnrk, and asked Congress (u cunsiclrr
these sites ht•kn'r upprot•inf; ul frclrr.tl
funding fur the ]97(i winter ~~ames.
o Finalh', the people of Dcnyrr-
like others around the wurtd-tcrrr di+•
t•etniblt• affected he the events :d the
summer Oh'mpit•s in \fuuit•h. \ul uuly
did the tnw'dcr of clct'cu lsraclis qua
a pall Dyer the Olt'mpit• spirit, but the
const:urt quarrels user judging ;uul sc~r-
ing rtised serious questions about Oh m•
pit' spurtsm:utship. Citirens fur Culunt•
do's Future has said that it does nut
tt•;urt ht n'in its referendum h;tttlcs nn
the issue of \hutit•h, but its campaign
t•learly acquired acct' muutenUtm front
the tragedy there.
The llenyer Oh•mpic Committer
(DOC) sees the bumps down the
nwwthtin. ahead-:utd insists it tt ill
master them. Butte iu \\'ashin!~ttm and
in llenyrr. hutcet'rr, must objrt•ticr oh-
scn•ers remain skeptit:d about the cunt-
mittee•s abilih' ht t•omplete the cwu'+c.
aud with rca.+uu.
Thr tyhule uotinu uF the Culrn'.uln
winter Olympics ryas ske•tchilt t•uu-
ceit•ed :acct, to this day' i. ht•ing rtr•
t•uted more he impntyisatiun th:ut ht
muter plan. Thr booklet of rctuuchrd
color pit•tures that :u•cump:utictl the
original hid fur the !~atnes suitl that lhr
alpine cccuts would be ht•hl un \luuut
Suikhw, :u: undcyclupcd slope ^hunt .u.
hour ur su fronr• the city, tyltilr the
\urdic contpetiton tyuuld r:u•r sent++
the couutn'sidr iu the llt•nycr +uhurh+,
tlcspite the l per rent pruhahilih• of
natural wary-a critical f•tc•tur not nx•n-
tinned in the prnpotal. Siucr thin, hoty-
cyt•r, ~luunt Sniktaa has hct•n scrapped
in favor of Vail-Bcaeer Gci•k, a hcn-
hour trip by car, while the Xurdie
events have brrn transferred ht Ste.un-
SR/0CT0"DER ^t ~ _
,,,u ~lu'u,~., lean' hours ;nc,,y un the
rthcr f.,re of the Rockies. \lean+chile.
n„ suitable pl:u+ h;u ever been devised _~
f,,r a bobsled run, :uul, after serious - '\\- .\ ~ ~r
thou~_ht +v,,s ~ivcn ro placinG the cum-
f~etition-hrlievc it ur not-at 'Lake
I'L+ricl, the event a as scrapped.
[_+enthin; about Dcnyers pitch, in O ® c
!.ict. >mackeci of cxagGeration and liyeh j3FyG~~P
~,m.t~inatiun-and the bid surely would Q ~,r
not have been accepted had not the
Intrrn.ctiun:,l Olympics Committee de-
. i+lcd that the l'nited States should Get
1,rcference in its ' bicentennial year.
Then. too. Denver +cas the onh• Amer- -
ir,u+ site that seriously solicited the
honor. The Denser Ob mpic Committee
h.,d _ood reason to +eant the games. Its \
i membership is composed of re~resenta-
tires of the industries that stand to gain
most b+ the extriyag;mza-the airlines,
the hotels and restnurm+ts, the telephone
company. the real-estate dealers, the
Rocky \tonntain ski resorts. l'nofficialh~,
the llOC~s closest ties are with the ~j
Colorado Associ;,tion of Commerce and Y
indush~y. +yhich represents :m amalgam
' uF the state's ++~ealthiest business inter- meeting it. And, if Coloradans wind up
c.ts. paying off the debts, it should be re-
Roth Coy. folm Loye and Mayor \~'il- membered that their state's population
liam \tc\ichok of Denser, +vhere more is only about one-tenth that of Califor-
than half the state's hyo million people nia. Sen. Fred Hams, the chief con-
. lice. had for some years been caught up gressional foe of the Olympics subsidy,
in the momentum of their myn "Sell raised two very relevant questions at
Colrn-ado" program, a kind of modern the legislative hearings: "\Vho pays?
!ihoosterism that attempts to attract pop- \t'ho profits?" The answers seem to be already is dangeroush• out of control.
ulation and investment, whether the that the profits will go to a h:urdful of While the legislature spends money to
re,ion needs them or not. Rv the time businessmen, while the mnents +yi11 ''Sell Colorado," popuLction so;,rs •uul
`the t+co men c:une to recognize the dis- be made 1>y the bulk of C:olorado's cit_ hrnd continues to be eaten up. fn c•un-
aciyantages and the unpopularity of the izens. - trast to the French Alps, where steep
Ohmpics. they +yere overcommitted. As liut even more fuss these days is be- slopes and the danger of acalanc•hes
a result, they went right on truing to per- ing raised by the issue of the damage limit construction and require that build-
ar,cde eyen•day Coloradans that the the games are likely to do to the yate'+ ings be carefully grouped into prepl:ur
Olympics +vere good for them. environment. Denver, despite the vision ned communities, the Colorado liockies
Rut :u-e they? The precedents are of clean air and unspoiled greenen• that are a land speculator's paradise. The
hardly promising. Fr;mce spent 5240 its name seems to evoke, has in fact high tree line protects the mouutuin-
million fur the winter Olympics at Gre- been in environmental trouble for some sides. The gentle slopes make wide val-
noble in 1968. Japan ran up an inered- time. A city that once beckoned east- legs. A builder can construct a house or
ihle bill of 51.3-billion for_the_winter ward for new inhabitants, Denver now :u+ inn almost anywhere, without paying
names of Sapporo last January. A4uch suffers tFie ;monies oFodercrowding com= attention to such trivia as slides or sew-
nf this outlay, of course, was repaid in mon to older American urban areas. en. The only disadvantage is that thr
recenuc, bul no Olympic games in his- \toreoyer, because Dem•er has both a land, because it is so' accessible, is ex-
tm~+• ever came close to prying their unique topography (located at the foot pensive-but that's a handicap onh• to
o++~n ++ay. \\'hile no final loss was ac- of the Rockies, the city experiences fre- the poor. The rich, for their part, c;li,
cnrateh ~ established for Americ'a's last quent thermal inversions) and the high- ignore the price onh• at ecen•one else's
cxt~ericnce ++•ith the +vintcr games-in est per-capita auto registration in the expense. For if the DUC and the Ohm-
19B(I at Sgna+y Valley-('aliforniu tax- nation, it ranks first among Americ;ur pies "sell" Colorado to more outsiders,
p;ners ++rre shu•k +vith a fi13-million cities in the carbon-monoxide content the ecological chaos will be compuund-
defic•it. And. althonGh skiers continue to of its atmosphere. The problem is ag- ed and solutions to the state's problems
day S9 a clay for the use of the lifts there, Gravatcd by Denver's altitude and i. +vill be even more elusive than they arc
C;diforni:u+s still pay an annual subsidy ertic•ularh~ acute for athletes. Normal- ~ro~~'
to kce Sc now Valley from bankne tcv. P'
P 1 P Iv the air i at its worst during the Rich:vd Lamm, assistant minoritc
At the moment the projected expense winter +vcather-and it would surely leader of the Colorado 1 fuuse of Rcprc-
of the Colorado Games, which the become worse yet with thousands of scntatiyes ;uul a legislator who h:cs
DOC first estimated at S14 million, cars and buses zooming from one ath- grown increasinGly critical of the
has rc•nc•hed almost S 100 million, and Ietic• event to another. DOC, said: "[ joi~+ed a unanimous
even if the figure were to go no hiGher,~ 1'et the real problem, Dyer the long Colorado legislature in 1967 in yotinG
++•hic•h seems unlikely, the income from urn, could be the devastation the games to invite the Olympic Gam's to be held
al sources would not come near to would brine to a state whose growth in Colorado. But the Colorado public
r
U~ ~IIYI~
and le~l,l;ltlll'l' IGl\'t' Illil l'I llllldl'lll'C In \\'hell It \\';l1 ,U111 111 ;( Ill,ln Irl lln » Ii~l•.
j the Deu\'Pr Ohn)1)ic (:unnnittt•c. l~cor\ The IlrscPndants \rc Ilnrcha,Ill it lulu \1 '.u,
' titnc I ,uk n Iluc,tinu nLnut ocolnq\- a~u. (hu bonze Irt, (loon anll \vuulll»,
tht• OI\'n)I)ic people tell nu'.'1)nu l \cl~r-
1'1•, 1Cl' ,lrl' QIIIII~ tU takl' 1',11'1. 111 Ihal.~
F~®wer qua that »'crc uln'nc(1 be h:unl, :n1(I I)1•t•It I
Illrnllgll \\'1111 ('Yl`, 111;1( ,l'r\'Ill .111/1 ,.I\\
'
lint :1 ;taco th;lt Ila, nlcor token (lu\cll ashim_hnl-ILI nun III tLI
(:oOr~P \\
i ,IS nn u'll ;u .1 ,inl,lo Lillhn;ull to in)-
l'11\'l' (Ill' l'II\'I1'1111I111•III 1, III II 111111 III
'
~
se-Tour
H (iut pnlchasel \\'.u au ul(iIl r III t'n•
1)11(1'1 ll'SC (.(11111(\. \'Ulllntl'l'I:T-,11 111 11 ll.l, .
,
p ou »i(Ic-bo:n'(1 flnlns ,uul ,i\ Ini1iII;11 fin .
rnn ;ul Olcnlpic, Ihal lhI oi'ululisls
I \conhl like.' ~
(.Ilrlflll,I\~. It ?1'1`1)1, :Ill,),IrPIIt t1ClI Ihl'
Caper plaols.
1'111. .I \cl'(`k LPfnrl' Ill(' 111111' 111\ \\llt'
h 11('1'1 I:II II II GtI OI~\,1)Ili(', ('llry)1))il ti't'-cll., 't•Ill•t t•lt':Il lt•11 .1, III'\I.1
:111(1 hl'I. h11115t•~t
' 111 h':ISI
11 11 Ill' ~1 if 11 , Ill( l,l 111111 I/'Ilt 1:11 I
"
' 1
IlOfl11'1 •. l:\Y`I'\~ k11U\\'ll ,1)1 •(. ~. III IfI1,I
, .
nu'mLor,-»rnlhl nut ho I_rircuu,l\ (1 is- II
lit Gl';\P, ti\II
l »;1; rnnlc(l. Onl on tll'.• la\cn, ton
Ippuinllll it Iirlnnul,uu'c, lincotl tho 1'I\L•: I'l.Al\ti. \.1.-'1111` la(Iils ul Liroll Ili1h-slhnolcr cir(loll In(lII„I\ IIII
c':Incrllalillll ul IhI »irltrr 1;unc; ,1111- the 1'lu»'IV' (:hlh 1':uul h, Inc hon,o la,t nor liltlo tracGn'. cntling :uu1 rllnnln'y
"
-
1rlhlr. (Irlainl\.:1\or\ Itr~unlall, tLo \cook. "ILI\ hmnlLt msc,. Ions. „Ira_
1 LI II.lilnl, Ili
1
I:~III h41aI III 1r.1,<.
ILo I lu\cl•r('Inh pl~uroll ILnni,ll 1L1.
rI[rntl\ rllirlll clluirnl:ul nl lLo IU('. unl I
liiunls, ;uul llric(I :u'lichokcs sprP;u
nrccr Iunccalo/l Ili, /Ii,I;n11 I~Ir ILI \c;n to look liko cuurnu,u, Llossoms. ~I'Loc Lnnn•. alLliul In ;Intl ,nLh'aolil r, IIal1
thI »iufcr OI\olpic.+ h:nc /•n,hrll. II c:uric(I in pnh :ultl hn\\'Is :uul a Li/ ILI Ilnral /li,l)!.n~ cull arr,nrv•nu•n~.
»;IS uol jn,t thl'ir comnu•rliali,nl 1Lal hnckl•t Iu h;u r_ Iron) ILI cr;uu` ill thI \II Ihi, \cll,l In1 nnlil :Ihunt .ul Illlnl
Lolhorlll biol. thonlh suroh tLc Uonccr kilchcn liroplacc. IIIIurI :LI Ilnr »:n IIuI In L11ili: l\\.'
1:onc, \cunltl L(' a, Iolnnx•rt i.il ^, tLc It »':IS ull Inc ILc IIi,Nn'ica) Sn(•iI•I\ 1I~IIo<'k un a LI•anlil nllc Iluulllr„ ti,llnl
1;uno., Ilacr ever 1>oon. ISrnndutl' ^hu ;uul hlo»rr (:IuL hnn,r lunr. This sort
h Il,lc. "fLl ll ton Lon,~•Llrplr IIII. IL.'
:uul unr Li1L ,1 II ,,,!
1!u\cIr \cunl, a Iloll
Iunlc„III 111 ;1 nu,t:dlia lur tLo nhl 11,1\, it
ul Inu(I-raisiul uporaliun is ct•n
k
~
" .
\ knulkl,l on ILI• Lack pali:l IIIIIr
Il
»~on ILI 1;uncs »erc ;mall :Intl IIII l
ti a~
three »•PP
out hl•ro in lhi• stick,. n
Iunlpltiton li\III nI\t III ono :uudhcr \lillbruok, just suulh 111 us, halt a t11Sn' (nrh"I urunnll Ili, ;nnl. rlacLil,e II.,
"
in a ,nr,lo OI\mpil \'illal~r. LI tLu,c to hcnolil tLc Uutlln•ss School. OI \\ 11.:!
p.Ia Ili, 1•Ihu»'-\ca, a ,nakl.
'
"
Il:n,, \\ hicll nl;n hI lnno lur(•\'/~
i\ tLI Iunrso. nlalcllin~ ro a~uiust \[illhrullk I
In• :nLIJ.
,Lunlli ! (1u » ith hint:'
'~
\
II111111:11'\ 111 Ill(' l'\pl'1'll'l ll'1' ~l'Illl lttl'I\' \\'f ll 1111 hl' IIAI' til'1lll IIII^ \(1111' t\'1111':11 fllllll<1 Ililn fill (Ill` Ill11111.
Irlaloll the ,pint of iulcrualional ;unit. I~Irnccr ('Inh I;Id\ into lhl~ rin!1 a~lain,t Ilurrur uunlholl nlo. Iri11111111 \ i,iun,
"
i V J)l'll\l'r ILI• 1):u'lic1ilr.lnl; \cunhl Juo I~rucicr. \lillbruul. llus mansions iu II:I Dori,(, tnl info 1Lo I):II ':
r,:nlo:
:Ik1' , II1:1 c1 ' :111(1 1'111 l(ll'I'rl shlllf `I' 111> III
11
pl'I111:1111\ IIII( l'\'(`II 1l't 111 1.1111\\' 11111' ;111- \\'1111'11 II\'l` 11:11111', atl:ll'lll'(1 tll 11 l':It 1
'
~ nlhl•r. Ilun,inl »ol
hl hr ,prrall all uclr
l nP,. \ Inc of [Ic(lo Park
\nu'ric;nl Iurlu •1•.
1rcl! 1Lcn1: lhI tuuri,tx pnniL annl!•
1
,
I III(' (.I 11111'111111 Illll'k Il',. :11111 till' 1`\'1.111, 1
I1l'1 };1111111' I'I':lllkllll I ). Il(lo\('\'t'It ; "I('1I- 111'l';Ik 1111116';. Ill,( ltl l(1' I:I \\';IIII,. (1111
1••
' \\'1 111111 (:1 ~(' 111;1('!' \\'It 1111111 ;111\' 1'('1,111111 Ill illlll' I'll\':111s1s ;Il 111 Ill:( ll'f:l C't(11's (11 1
(Ill(! (.1't rill (11 It ! Illtll I hl` I)I'~1111.
ii 1)'(`111 1111 1\'1(11 1111' ,11:11.1'
I
Il
(` !
'
•Il
~ tll Ill ll' :Illnllll'1'. tiI)1'l't ;11111', :11111 I):1 rt ll'I- '•I 1';11 \\'t';IIt II I'l',Il1P[I 111 thl' \Illlhrnllk .
.
l
:i
(
\l
l
11•;1\'1111 .1 sl\' 11'111 11;11111111 III 1111' ;III'.
', p;lllls allkl' \\'l ll 1111 ,111 •II(I 1111111'; III 1:11',
111' 111 ('11:1I'I1'1'1'(1 ;I 11'('1':111. 17111111at1• 1111'11' :lrl':1.
Il ha(1 1':111 It'll 11:1111 1111 tI1P (la\' 111 till' \Il 111 11`11(, Iall`I' III, Ills 11111`1' l'; 11111' tll 111 I\ 1'
~ 1:11111•, \\'1111111 Ill It Ll`
o \I1111)1'1111k 111111'. :II III (Ill' I'l'111t'Illl)I':111 ('l' 111111 11111111'. •
.
1,;111• hl,t ,print nu•mhc•n of thl' 1)PII- nl 111't's cLc\cinl np \cct la»ns ^n:l Onr clnL amt sulil•1\' hostc,sl, :u-
'
err OIcnlllic .Cunuoilloo n1lt \\ iIL ILI Lurtlcs of unllrrollas (Irippint~on polishcll ccorc rnonl
rico(I. "tionlcunc neat he in
"
10(: ill I.:nn:uuu', S\ciV.crl:uul, t11 lLa\cinl-room flours »;1; still fresh »Lell tho IlisGn'ilal tiucilt\
al rccr\ miuntc.
1)1'(',1.111 :1 tl1'1111'1',1 1'1'1)111'1 1111 1111' \\'11111.1' :l llltitlll'll':11 tilll'IPI\' 1:1(1\' l':IIIPd In ;I,k IIII\' l`Illpll:l\I%cll. '()lhPl'l1'Itie.
"
lanlos. 1)O(: spoke,nunl said tL.l1 IIII it I \cuul(I upon ul~' home lu the pnhlic I
\\oll. suu\'ruir hnnlors, \an kun\\.
nu•otinl \cas ^ I~r;uul sncccss :uul (hat fora (Llc. lilll I cunsontctl, of cuurs('. :;roclcll the hustrsscs. ,unu• ul \\Lu,l'
'
! the inlcrnaliunal ho(Ic hall only prai;c ..It's :ul honor." I told nl\ \ciFe. "It's tho ccn Illinl
fuccs \cor(` \;I,~ucl\' (amili:u. L
for 1)IVCCr•s achicvcnx•nl, (u Ih~tc. Lc,.c ;y1t•~ ul unr social calccr. \4't'r(• up is Incoly, thc\' slid.
e minutes to t»n \chcn I
n
fl
It
partial uhscr\'Pn I(•fi \citL the inlpres- tlu•rc \cith Marv f.askcr:ulll peopk• like s
e
\r
siun That the IOC \cus
in f;u•t
rather that \c Lu (lu ihinls lur Ph:u'ih•, sec, tlis(•uvcrc(I that I »'as stu cin ~. I Loa l•1
.
,
roscr\t•(1 ^buul \chat it h:ul hr:u•d. limn- Loup upon ns as tlio poor man's~CartPr 1;It Ihcn ur »:lit Ilnlil sis, \chen the tour
dut~c sai(I, us he bud un a prcvium ant( .~tnuuul;l-•• onded. It \conl(1 ho impossible to (lu
ut•t•asiun, th;ll he »;IS disUu'hcd b\ iu- ,."I'hcv broke np," nn \vifP said. Iin1 :o tllninl the tunr.:IS uuP ul tLP \lill-
'
rrcasinl in<licutiuns ul lultrrinl cum- u;lturull\' she \cas plcasetl, e` 11;1,1
brook people hall foml(I out. \\
nuulilc support fur thc~auncs. \\'hat he •\ couple ul' da\s later, the Flu»•cr seen him \ceacin!); thrumlh the tonrisls.
sct•uu•(I to ho saving »•;IS that from here ('luh la(lics :uricPil lu look our house a liccr»•Inst in one h:uul, a slice Id I
un the IU(:'s endurscnunll-like the over. !?:u•h look resl>unsibilih' fur the hroa(I ;u111 a Leer in the other, hope- j
k•deral !{uvcrunu•nt's-prubuhly tlr- arran~~cuu•ul of a particul:u• room. -fhc lc.csl\ seokint; ;ul Plnpt\' corner. I \\:IS
ponds upon hu\c tht• pcuplr ul' (:uluradu I listorical Sucicty Ia(Iv stopped hc, too. not I;oinf; to be trappe(1 IikP that su ~
cute in lhP \uvemher rek•rendum, to discuss a brochure that \could hr I thrc\c lulether a salad an(l. st:uulinl ;
The Dorrt•rv Yu\I's must rec•cnt Dull h:ultlctl u(d in the tour homes. ConL•I III)-for \ce h:ul glut our kitchen table !
indicates that uppusitiuu lu the public »'t• tell Lcr about our Lunlrs past? This (Irn\•n ill the t•cllur to often nil the
I
fondiug of the 1:uuc•s coos about (\cu »':u our stronlr point. I~)r our c•olouial i; nx/nl-1 spooned on some ma\onnaisl.
'
So one. State uffit•ials, lhP I)t•II\'PI' Ohnr kuu»'n to 6:1\'r hrcn stuntlinl; in tSJI, here \cus my j
anll starte(1 eatink. \1
It Committee, and other likr-mindrd
' ----- _.- -- \cife' t'pstuirs, cumbiu~ her hair ur I
'" ps inxist that then »'ill echu•ate a Ucnc SuliUl. Nlc uulJulr u/ \1'hen the sonu•thin~.
'
sih• of Culuruduus dl the virtues of Cheeriu~ Stopped, lur.c jest cnrnplrto(1 oiC•es in the hull. The hurt-
H:uk! \
es l>v elec•tiun clay. Flit nu» nn ur(•uunt ul .\'ulrulr(ur Ill's ill-fnh•(1 c.cscs I;rceted the voices. [ \volled du\cn j
'
s unlikely. C \ .\!r•.rican rl•ntnrl., my salad and yanked upt•n
tht• last ul
• L; }972 1-
JANUARY 29,1972
sniffing Worcester as alien territory, they stayed away,
too. Only McCarthy came, and only McCarthy agreed
to abide by the decision of the caucus. The balloting
showed that an early announcement and a year's or-
ganizing paid off for George McGovern. On the first
ballot he received 51 percent; McCarthy, in second
place, and Chisholm split the rest. By the third ballot,
McGovern had surpassed the ti0 percent needed for
endorsement, and McCarthy and Chisholm had
swapped places.
But the caucus gave a clue to how the ex-senator
will answer the query, "'Where have you been since
19ot3?" McCarthy ran through the litany: "When three
of the other candidates stood on the platform in 1968
after the speech about the politics of joy, with their
arms raised to the convention, 1 was in Grant Park.
When an amendment was offered to require presiden-
tial approval before National Guardsmen could use
live ammunition against American citizens, it got only
two votes in the Senate. Mine and one other. When a
black peace candidate challenged Henry Jackson in the
Democratic primary in 1970, I was the only senator
who campaigned in Washington against Jackson. And
when Frank Rizzo -who now favors a municipal elec-
tric chair for Philadelphia -was running for mayor,
I campaigned .. ,fur his Republican opponent. You
a,k where I was; 1 ask you, where were the others?"
The McCarthy campaign headquarters will close in
Massachusetts, though his name may stay on the bal-~
by ~~>l~n ICI, ~rr~~o ~>zo
In Mav of IQ70 three members of the Denver Organiz-
ing Cummit„~eee 1DOC) along with Colorado Governor
)uhn Luve, Denver Mayor Bill McNichols and Walter
M. Schirra, )r. traveled to Amsterdam with 14 others
to make a presentation to the International Olympic
Committee IIOC- advoi sting Denver as the site fur the
t97o Winter Olympics.
Up to that time, the orRanizinK effort was financed
by $500.000 in state and city funds, $200,000 in pri-
SAM W'. BRIT\cV. jR., u~a5 an organizer of the Vietnam
~19bvptorium Committee.
~~ ~ ~,~
15
lot for the April 25 presidential primary. McCarthy
left other doors ajar, however. "Having finally rejected
the premise, 'my country right or wrong,' " he said of
the other hopefuls, "They cling to the less tenable
notion, 'my party right or wrong.' "Thereby making
it clear that McCarthy does not.
Fourth Warty
A favorite piece of literature in the McCarthy head-
quarters is a Field poll taken in California last fall pair-
ing McCarthy and Lindsay as fourth-party candidates
against Nixon, three different Democrats (Muskie,
Kennedy, Humphrey) and Wallace in four-way races.
It showed Kennedy winning in arty combination but
McCarthy polling between 18 and 23 percent, depend-
ing on the Democratic nominee, and spoiling the
chances of both Muskie and Humphrey. For instance,
one pairing showed Nixon with 38, Humphrey with
25, McCarthy with 23 and Wallace with 7. Without
McCarthy, Muskie trailed Nixon 40 to 42; however,
with McCarthy in it was Nixon 37, Muskie 30, Mc-
Carthy 20 and Wallace 7. Lindsay, as a fourth-party
candidate, ran a few points behind McCarthy but
with the same effect. The poll reminds one of the sin-
gle promise McCarthy is making on the campuses this
year, namely: young people will have a choice in 1972.
The Field poll gives his threat to run as a fourth-
arty candidate a sense of reality.
~'he '76 VVinte>l• ®lympics
Snow Joy
In Colorado
- er
representatives had made trips at public expense ro
Mexico Cin•. Spain, Yugpslavia and Swi-zerland,
among other places, IonR before the Amsterdam IOC
vale donations, and $300,000 in donated kuuds and
services. The money was spent fur promotional activ-
ities determined by the 12 appointed members of the
DOC, which includ~ an airlines executive, two bank-
ers, a telephone Eompanv executive. a maKazine pub-
lisher, a former under secretary of the Navv, a univ-
ersity administrator, two attorneys and other busi-
ness executives.
Tu promote Denver these men and other Denv
a
lb THE NEW REPUBLIC
meetin.;. The committee had been able to prepare an
impressive report fur the IOC.
Richard O Reilly, reporter for the Rocku Mountain
\.~u~-, ti.rute in a siv-part series on the Olympics pub-
lished A[•ril -i-a. 1x71:
6v C\1av 170 (the DOC) had compressed its bid
into a fancy two-volume color picture book edi-
tion complete with slipcase and a half-hour
color movie for presentation to the IOC at Am-
sterdam.
The bid book was and is a magnificent piece
of salesmanship. From the heavy coat of snow
airbrushed by an artist onto a photo of Mt.
Sniktau. to cover potentially embarrassing
bare spots, to the statement that construction
of an Olympic speed skating rink "will begin in
1U70. the books contain a series of misrepre-
sentations.
Denver promised 100,000 beds for tourists
x~hen only about 35,000 will be available,
Norman C. Brown, DOC public affairs manager,
admitted.
.-1nd it promised a 45-minute drive from the
Olympic village to Mt. Sniktau, but didn't men-
tion that was possible by shutting off all traf-
fic on [-70 and running six lanes of buses up
the mountains, Brown acknowledged ... .
Denver promised to stage Nordic ski events
requiring snow-covered countryside in a rapidly
growing mountain residential area with a 4 per
cent chance of having enough natural snow.
And Denver promised to hold Alpine ski
races on a mouniaia-_tivhicl~probahly ~o.u_Idn't be
developed except for the Olympics.
By this impressive if dishonest salesmanship, Den-
ver beat Sion, Switzerland, by a 39-30 vote of the IOC
as the chosen location for the 1976 Winter Olympics.
Major Denver newspapers were elated and congratu-
latory. For the first time site locations were published
in full. Small stories, however, usually buried in the
back pages, and some letters to the editor began to re-
veal that not everyone considered it Colorado"s finest
day.
The Metro Denver Fair Housing Association charged
that when low-cost housing for Denver residents was
badly needed, money was instead being allocated for
housing press people during the Olympics. They
vowed to mount an anti-Olympics campaign unless
immediate steps ,were taken toward more low-cost
housing.
[n November 1970 the Ad Hoc Committee of Citi-
zens Interested in an Equitable Olympics (CIEO), a
group of Denverites concerned about minority repre-
sentation in Denver Olympic Committee planning,
filed a protest a petitions with the city council. Six
nority represe~tives were thereupon appointed to
the 25-member DOC board of directors, none of whom
were acceptable to CIEO. No minority members were
appointed to the nine-man executive council.
A letter to the editor of the Denver Post was the only
printed notice that the Colorado State Grange, with
8000 members, voted in September 1969 against hold-
ing the games anywhere on the front range.
Residents of Evergreen, the proposed site for the
Nordic events, responded angrily to DOC plans. Ever-
green is an unincorporated community of about 12,000
residents with Denver Mountain Parks in its midst.
Seven hundred Evergreen residents attended a meet-
ing with DOC officials at which they voiced their con-
cern about the ability of Evergreen to handle Olympic-
sized crowds and to emerge from the events without
permanent environmental damage. Two Evergreen at-
torneys discovered, among other things, that the bi-
athlon trail proposed to the IOC went through Ever-
gteen's high school and an elementary school: that
one hill would be leveled and another hill"s top cut off
for lifts and stands, and that proposed sanitary facili-
ties would infect local wells. The prospect of a 7000-
car parking lot in Evergreen did not thrill residents.
A poll of 26b people showed 71 percent against hold-
ing the games there, 27 percent in favor.
Besides, the residents pointed out, Evergreen is in an
area of the mountains known locally as the "banana
belt," and its ~~nces of having natural snow in late
February, the date~f the games, were less than one in
25. Artificial snow machines, which might be unac-
ceptable to the IOC, could cost as much as ~~ 5 mil-
lion. The res dents formed an organization. Protect
our Muuntai Environment (POME1, to fight the
.Olympics. O January 1, 1971, its board of directors
voted unanim usly to ask the state legislature to re-
fuse funding to the DOC until another site was found.
DOC officials said in January 1971 that they would
try to find another site. Three mentioned were Buffalo
Creek in Jefferson County, Indian Creek in Douglas
County, and Steamboat Springs. Residents in all three
locations began organizing against the Olympics, and
tjJhe DOC has said no more on the subject.
1l n the months following the Olympic bid, the slip-
s~od methods of DOC planning and management be-
came evident, and the secrecy of their closed meetings
rebounded on them, as shown by the following examples:
oThe principal owner of Loveland Ski Corporation,
Bob Murri, first heard on his car radio that Loveland
Basin was the site for some of the Alpine events.
When the DOC announced that Alpine events would
be held on Forest Service land, the Forest Service peo-
ple there had never been approached on the matter.
Furthermore, a study released by the University of
Colorado revealed that the Sniktau site 'will generate
the least amount of income and revenue of all sites
studied, both during and after the Olympic attendance
period. They said it was wholly unsuitable for after-
JANUARY 29,1972
use because of the space limitations in the base area
and the absence of beginner and low intermediate
slopes. The DOC eventually started looking for an-
other Alpine site.
The DOC announced the Denver Coliseum would be
used for top figure-skating and hockey events. As of
April 5, 1971, almost a year after the Olympic bid had
been Riven to Denver, no one from the DOC had talked
to Bob Faes, the Coliseum manager, about it.
The DOC went to Maurice Mitchell, chancellor of
the University of Denver, in 1969 and asked him,
"Do you mind if we say that the Olympic Village could
be at the University of Denver%'" He agreed, but was
not contacted again until ten months after the bid had
been received. Students at the university have, of
course, never been consulted about their coming evic-
tion, which occurs in the middle of a quarter.
~In an international bulletin published in 1969, the
DOC promised an international arts festival, claiming
"The Denver-centered Festival figures to be one of the
most historic tributes ever made to the many cultures
of the world." A year-long festival in 1976 had been
proposed by the Colorado Council on the Arts and
Humanities (CCAH) in 1967, but the plans depended
on adequate state funding, which has not materialized.
(CCAH was given $27,157 of a requested $150,000
from the legislature in 1970.) The DOC never dis-
cussed with CCAH what could take place in actuality,
and never offered them Funding. At this point, the
DOC has decided to bypass CCAH completely and run
its own festival.
The DOC has produced no firm figures on costs;
specifically, what percentage Colorado and Denver
taxpayers will have to foot.
They did tell the International Olympic Committee
that the games could be produced in Denver for $14
million because "we already have 80 percent of the
facilities.'" Lt. Gov. John Vanderhoof later admitted,
"They (DOC) were pressed for time so they lied a bit."
On February 4, 1971, nine months after they had re-
ceived the Olympic bid, the DOC told the Joint Budget
Committee of the state legislature that the Olympics
would cost $25 million -almost doubling the estimate
in a nine-month period. Of this amount, they said,
state and city taxpayers might have to provide $10-
15 million -unless the federal government provides
funding (which spreads the number of taxpayers help-
ing to sell Colorado).
This is the revised estimate after less than a year's
time, and if other Olympics are any indication, a strong
possibility exists that the estimates will be revised up-
ward again and again.
[n spite of the fact that Colorado taxpayers may be
footing up to three-fifths of the bill, they will not even
be allowed to watch the events on their television sets
at home, as the rest of the US will and as Grenoble citi-
zens did during the 1968 Olympics. The DOC plans to
ban live broadcasts in the state, except by closed cir-
17
cult piped into theaters where viewers will have to pay.
Willy Schaeffler, member of the DOC board of di-
rectors, says, "[ feel personally if Denver and Colorado
spend $50 million on the Olympics even without a re-
turn, it's the best advertising for Denver and Colorado
t~h{a't's ever been done."
llhe only return the state will get is increased tax
revenues, which is not expected to cover the costs. In
fact, no government has ever made money on the
Olympics, and even the DOC admits it is unlikely
Colorado and Denver will. The Squaw Valley Winter
Olympics in 1960 has, to date. cost the taxpav~s more
than 13 times the original estimate, a total bf $13.5
million. The area has never become self-supporting,
and when recently put up for sale by the state, only
one bid was received - $25,000. H. D. Thoreau, chief
organizer of the Olympics there, has said that if the
California legislature had known the full cost from the
beginning, "the games would not have been held in
California.'"
The Grenoble Winter Olympics in 1968 cost $250
million, of which $50 million was paid by taxpayers.
The city is still heavily in debt for it, and local prop-
erty taxes have risen by an incredible 125 percent.
These figures, of course, do not reflect such hidden
costs such as highways and streets, policing, water and
sewage extensions, solid waste disposal, military equip-
ment and personnel on loan, use of public lands, gov-
~cernmental agencies and services, uncontrolled growth
costs to communities, and, of course, such items as
loan of Public Service Company helicopters for visit-
ing dignitaries. (This latter cost is presumably ade-
quately covered by a recently granted rate increase.)
Concerned over these financial facts and possible
environmental effects of the Olympics, two legislators,
Bob Jackson (D, Pueblo} ana Richard Lamm (D. Den-
ver), introduced a bill in the Colorado House in Feb-
ruary 1971 to prohibit any more state money from
being spent on the games. The bill never made it out
of committee.
On February 2, 1971, 11 Democratic legislators.
eight of them from Denver, released a statement de-
manding that promoters of the Olympics furnish de-
tailed inft~ilrtation on the costs and environmental ef-
fects of they' games. A resolution was passed unani-
mously in both houses calling for a legislative study
of the state's role in the Olympics. On March 2a, 1971,
the committee recommended that (1_) future state
spending be limited to $600.000 to make the total
state appropria~tions. $1.1 million; and (2) the state
should review ~1v` spending and site selection. On
May 27,1971, the legislature gave final approval to'a
bill creating the Colorado Olympics Commission
which would approve all DOC contracts funded by the
state sand coordinate Olympic events with other state
centgnnial celebrations.
The important watchdog functions of this ~commit•
18
tee. however, were negated by Governor Love's 11 ap-
pointees, five of whom are men who have been heavily
involved in either the effort to gain the Olympics or
the planning effort since that time. What the DOC
wants, the DOC will get. While the money amounts
sound relatively small in the context of billions FoT
weapons systems, they are critical to a small state such
as Colorado. For instance, the cost of the bobsled and
IuKe course is Four times the annual state budgets for
air and water pollution control; the cost of the speed
skating facilities is seven times the budget for handi-
capped children: and the ski jump will cost 75 times
the amount spent on the control of venereal disease
last year. °
Several of the Olympics events will leave permanent
.cars. The bobsled run, for instance, is a mile-long,
refrigerated concrete snake which, as there are only
100 competitors in the world, has very limited after-
use.
More important, however, environmentalists are
strongly concerned that the ""Sell Colorado" concept
will attract people and industry to a part of the state,
the front range, that is already facing serious environ-
mental problems from overcrowding, such as smog and
traffic congestion. Denver now has the sixth worst
smog in the nation, because of a high percentage of
automobile ownership and atmospheric conditions.
The Denver Sierra CI_ub on March 31, 1971 offi-
cially voted to oppose, for ecological reasons; Den=
ver s hosting of the Olympics. The Colorado Open
Space Council, a coordinating council of 36 environ-
mental groups with a total membership of 100,000,
has said that no more state money should be spent for
the games ""until more pressing statewide environmen-
tal needs have been funded."' It urged that the plan-
ning commission appointed to review DOC decisions
"should be structured and have sufficient authority
so as to assure that environmental protection will be of
first importance'" and recommended that all commit-
tees, commissions and boards involved in planning
and staging the games open their meetings and their
records to the public.
Faith in the Denver Olympic Committee has not
been bolstered by its record. Its members have talked
up the long-term benefits of the Olympics to Denver
citizens, yet the facts of the case show that their prom-
ises are often unrealistic and sometimes simply un-
founded:
Press housing for 3500 people will be needed during
the Olympics, which the DOC talks of turnint; into
low-income housing afterwards. Howev_r, the land
under consideration is thought by city planners to be
too isolated for low=income housing, although suit-
able.foi hotel development. [n addition, successful de-
velopment depends on cleaning out the railroad tracks
,, which is highly unlikely before the Olympics
-~f lack of time and money.
~" ansit system has been said to be possible
THE NEW REPUBLIC
because of the Olympics, and sketches have been
drawn in city planning offices for a system using
buses, monorails, mini-trains, magna-buses and cars.
Yet the Olympics have very specialized transportation
needs, basically moving large groups of people to cer-
tain places at certain times. These needs are obviously
not those of a metropolitan population, and therefore
any system designed for the Olympics will have very
limited use for Denver citizens afterwards. The only
exception is buses, which Denver already has.
It would have been more difficult for such a poten-
tial disaster to develop had it not been For three factors.
First, the planning has been done secretly. The press
and public are barred from all meetings of the DOC;
official publications generally consist of one office
copy, not to be removed or duplicated; contradictory
figures and opinions are issued, leading to misrepre-
sentations.
Second, Colorado's most prominent citizens are al-
most all on one side of the issue. Both US senators,
all Colorado congressmen, the governor and his 1970
opponent, the mayor of Denver and his 1971 oppo-
nent, the state's leading businessmen (particularly
those with real estate interests), the two large news-
papers in the state and a majority of both houses of
the legislature favor the Olympics. On the other side
have been blacks, Chicanos, environmentalists, many
students, a growing number of low-income taxpayers,
a small number of state legislators and residents of
the areas near the proposed sites.
That the Winter Olympics is a sport for the rich
paid for by the poor in order to promote real estate
and tourism is not an easy truth to conveyc~Fiowever,
a citizen's group has recently been trying
Citizens meetings through the spring and summer of
1971 led to the publication of a third-page ad in the
Denver Post environmental section on January 2,
1972. Choosing the name "Citizens for Colorado"s
Future," the citizens then mailed 7000 people in the
state a petition addressed to the [OC which stated sim-
ply, "We, the undersigned, respectfully request that
the 1976 Winter Olympics not be held in Colorado.
We will oppose any attempt to spend taxpayers' mon-
ey in support of the Games."' The cover letter with
the petition was signed by John Zapien, head of the
Legal Aid Society in a predominantly Chicano neigh-
borhood; Representative Paul Hamil~on, a black state
representative; and Ruth Weiner, a leading environ-
mentalist. State Representatives Lamm and Jackson
joined in announcing the petition drive. The citizens'
committee also plans to send a delegation to Sapporo,
Japan to present their petitions to the Iriternational
Olympics Committee.
A large number of people were simply waiting for
an opportunity to express themselves. Volunteers,
calls, letters and requests For speakers poured into
the office.
The issue is rare in that its environmental and eco-
JANUARY 29, 1972
nomic aspects complement each other, and environ-
mentalists have joined, and are in fact being educated
by, working people. The committee's greatest failure
has been in its efforts to establish ties with organized
labor leadership, which has been inclined to share the
"growth is good"" philosophy of DOC organizers.
Meanwhile, two important events have occured.
First, Avery Brundage, president of the IOC, has ad-
vocated elimination of the Nordic and Alpine events
due to "professionalism,'" a cut which would leave
the major expenses of the Olympics intact (bobsled
runs, housing speed skating facilities, etc.) while
eliminating the major source of television revenue and
19
spectator interest. Brundage has also stated strong
opposition to dispersal of site events from the central
city. Since the nearest of the five Alpine sites the DOC
is presently considering is 75 miles away (lt~i hours driv-
ing time), this could spell real trouble for the DOC
when it meets the IOC in Sapporo.
Second, the Revolutionary Bicentennial Commission
announced on December 10 that the 1976 Winter
Olympics are to be an official part of the nationwide
bicentennial celebration, thus establishing th at
least in Colorado, taxpayers will celebrate the evo-
lution by sponsoring promotions for the business
community.
1
e~~C ~
by ~>l.>~~~>r~~ ~e ~U~d~~ly
Last week Alexander M. Biikel discussed the need to
limit the President s ability to make war, and he re-
market that the Senate is very likely to pass a War-
Puwers hill designed to do that. The bill, which re-
:rntly was approved 13-U by the Foreign Relations
Committee. n•:ugnizes a presidential right h, repel
attack. end to h,restall the imminent threat of attack,
but it rcyuires that the President obtain permission
from Congress in order to iontinue hostilities longer
than JO Javs. The pnni ipal author of the War-Powers
bill, ticnatur Ja;ah K. Javrts, says that legislation of
this kind might have prevented the incremental in-
volvement that led to full-.isle war in Indoxhina. The
Nixon administrahun opposes the bill and, apparently.
any attempt to limit its ability to make war. Its repre-
~entativcs complain that the proposed restriitiuns
would narr.iw the ~x,wer given the President by the
C „nstttuhun ;\ bash question, therefore, is whether
the President due. have a constitutional right to make•
war and? if •u. under what rircumstan;es.
Uuring 10 of the last 2 z years. Amencan Presidents
have been x+'aKing undeclared wars. In the case of the
Kucean ~Var President Harry } Truman s decision
appeared to he the product of emergency -the quick
(%. ~~ tsrx n,, author u/ Tonkin Gulf. iontnbuted
sis of the Pentaevn Papers to The New Republic
2 8s 1,1.
response to aggresswn. As we shall see later. it ,cas
more than that. In the iase of the Indochina ~\'ar
a gradual es; alahun was uh<;ured by of f ii ial se: rc•.'y. ,
and then facilitated >uddenly by the Tonkin Gulf
resolution. That resolution has'hcen repealed fur more
than a year, but the game war :untinues, hanging
legally in mid-air. supported by an extrapulatiun of
the Cunstitutiun known as the President . u,herent
power to commit armed forre~ to ;unfhrt. But even
hefore the Tonkin resolution came under heavy fire.
the State Department was busy refurbishing the execu-
tive branch s claim to en independent. iunstitutiunal
right to make wrr. Ina memorandum of P1ar:h• S
1900, that claim w•as :fated tun;iseh• by Leonard C
Meeker. legal adviser to the State Dr•partmcnt
"Under the Cunstituhun. the President. in addih.m
to beinK Chief Exe;utive, is Commander in Chief of
the Armv and Nav~•. He holds the pnme respun>ibility
fat the rundu;t of United States foreign relations.
These duties :arrv •erv hn,ad lq,wers 'tniludtnK the
power w deploy A rnian for: e+ ahruad and curi,mit
them to mditan• operations when the President deems
.uch action necessary to maintain' the secunty and
defense of the United Stea•s
Tu prove ht. point, the Ie~;al adviser appealed to
precedents bark h, the eanc~st dws of the Repubhr:
'Since the Constitution was adopted there have been
at least 1:5 instances m which the President has or-
- .: Richard Lamm, one of the 1
- ""the fight against the Colors
,', - pits, argues his case at a Den
:: Club luncheon. Behind him, w
'. - ~ ~ a chance to rebut, is Henry Ki
:; _ a;:~.s.. .
- of. the Denver Olympic Co
.:: ~:.7t~:. .
:~'. ~- - .
,, the Olympic movement; buffeted mlready theg.year
® by murder and discontent at Munich,'fatxs yet en-
-, other blow to its spirit nextweek when Colorado Voters .
:. ~3?~- ~~= go. to the polls. At stake will be the future.of the 1976
_ .
~ Winter Games, awarded to Deaver over two years_ago.
~~1~~:. _
~ If a public referendum.passes--and its chances are rat.
® ~ ~-50=-it will cut off all future state funds for the .
-- :;.; ..Olympics and automatically sever federal financing.
_ ~ - -^ _ ' Denver officials admit they would then have no choice
`'
c
' `w
but to return their Games to the International Ol
ympic
• ; _ , : '. '; Committee £or reassignment to some other country. .
1i1~ "It would be.the worst international disgrace in
American history," claims Don Magarxcll, a former
member of the Denver Olympic Organizing Committee.
Mayor William McNichols argues that "the people of
Colorado would have to live with this shame the rest
__ _ of their lives." But the year-long debate has forced Co-
loradans to think hard about the future of their state's
environment. The Winter Olympics were lured by what
is good in Colorado: some of the world's best skim
g,
®~ magnificent scenery, abundant elbow room. But many
I~ peo
le now
h
p
see t
em as a symbolic villain bringing more
of what they think is bad: more people, more cars, more'
growth. As the bumper stickers say, "Don't Califor-
nicate Colorado."
TTSe International Olympic Committee awarded the
Games to Denver is May 1970, after a slick, smooth
®.. selling job that was fouled with misrepresentations.
. ? Denver officials claimed they could stage the Games
_ - for only $14 million, since "80oJo' of the facilities were.
^; ~ ' already built.. The estimate now stands at $35 million
'
;.
-="_~t.~,{ and holding-until after the election.Anexpensivetwo-
• - - volume "Bid Book" vowed that all sites would fulfill
Olympic requirements by being within a hour's drive
of Denver. A submitted picture of the proposed down-
; hill ski course at Mt. Sniktau had snow airbrushed over
-
the bald spots:
Returning home with the prize, Colorado officials
were given a hero's welcome. Denver's Chamber of
Commerce president purred, "We're recognized as a
major city." But statewide euphoria soon began crum-
blinginto anger, mistrust and embarrassment.
' Residents of Evergreen, a suburb in the Denver foot-
. hills, learned that the Nordic events (jumping, cross-
= country skiing and biathlon) were scheduled for their
area. They also learned that eight-foot-wide ski tours-
;. es were mapped through their schools and backyards, t
Angrily, citizens pointed out that their town lay on the 1
enders of eastern slope of the Rockies where snow seldom falls
o Olym-. in February. Chastened Olympic offici
l
fi
l
a
s
na
ly locat-
erLions ed the: Nordic events in Steamboat Springs-a tough
aitingfor
156-mile drive from Denver.
mbrough .
Meanwhile, Alpine skiing had to be moved from Mt.
mmittee. e
Sniktau when studies revealed that the mountain's low- e
er terrain was so treacherous it would be worthless as
'
• .
apost-Olympic ski resort. Private interests are now de- t
'.:;•.
_~ veloping all the Alpine courses at Avon, near Vail 1
_
,
j which is a hundred miles from Denver. h
The anti-Olympic forces, calling themselves Citizens
". for Colorado's Future (CCF), opened up headquarters L
in an old wooden house in Denver in March and easily a
_ gathered 77,392 signatures to force the fate ofthe Olym- e
pits onto the ballot. They claim that the Olympic costs
have been greatly understated and the benefits over- i
stated. The only ones to profit, says State Represen- s
e
tative Dick Lamm, a founder of CCF, will be "airline r
th
executives, hotel executives and land promoters." in ci
- - ~, fact, ofthe 140-odd people involved in the various Den- d
v
th
...:; :..i'..: - x .. ~ :.: "~-Cis='~ "~ -'s~{`'~t~e° ^,-~ z,
ytnp,c cotnmrttass b9 ara-Pa'a~e~Oe€`b~rd'e%1
' .CltalrmCll Of corporations, 8nd~.aY~'ldtae4Qsiett~ `~'
sires. "Just about everybody wlio profile fi~e~ ~, ~ -
is on there; ' said one Bouldecpo(jr,;~~, ~.~,~~~,
Even though the oppoeition~re top-1l~Yy'y~-~;~
business and financial Elite of Co1otadovnd~F--':
staffed, uaderfinanced CCF cottld: knoel<.::ffieaa:o~;_';
• `People are tired of having the Chamber of Cotiomerce.,":'?".
run this state," Lamm contends,. "'Ibey itre fed up ~iieh;:~ `".:
the 'Sell Colorado' campaign: People are' starting to': -.:'.~
realize that `big' and `good' are. not neces.9art7y the : ~~'
same thing." _ .. ...: .: .:~c,"`.:':;::-..
Olympic officials argue that costs forithe~~Denver
Games will Gave a ceiling of $35 million-with only $5 .
million to come out of state funds, approximately $16
million from the federal government, and the remain-
der from television and admission revenues, plus the ...
sale of commemorative coins and souvenirs..::'Amer::
icans are the biggest junk-buyers in the world," says •-
Henry Kimbrough, one of the chief Olympic spokes- ' _
men. If, for unforeseen reasons, more money is need- _
ed, Kimbrough maintains that "it won't come from .
Colorado taxpayers.. We'll cut -corners sad make do ' "
with what we have-or go to private business," He
adds, "Killing the Olympics is not going to eliminate ` '
the problem of growth. We must use the Olympics as a '
.tool to focus is on,these problems." -
Even if the Olympics survive next week's vote, the ~ _!
CCF has saved the Denver Olympic Committee from a
good deal of future embarrassment and mt7lions of dot-. _
tars in needless facilities. Denver's price tag may, in fact, _ '
come in below $50 million, in part because of the deci- _'
Sion not to build a $I.5 million four-man bobsled run,
"The Olympics are obviously a growth promoter," .
says Lamm. "Who ever heard of Sapporo before this
year's Olympics in Japan?" His group believes that the
last thing Colorado needs is more promotion and more
growth. "Why spend millions to sell a state which has
already been thoughtlessly oversold?" asks Lamm.
"I don't think the Olympics will generate the kind .
of growth problem Lamm fears," argues Kimbrough.
Colorado already has 7.5 million tourists a year, and
only 600,000 to 900,000 total attendance is projected . .
for the Olympics. The Olympic committee expects to
sell ?5°Jo of its tickets to Colorado citizens. As for the
eventual costs, the fact that Denver has only to build a
speed-skating arena (budgeted at $6.8 million), a lugs
course in the Denver foothills ($3 million estimate) and
he Nordic sites ($2.2 million) should prevent any gal-
oping overruns. - - - -
. ,, ~
®ut the most de resin as ~
® p g pest of the Denver Olym- j
pits may not be money at all. They have become '
he spread-eagled games. Alpine skiing, the glamour
vent, will be two hours by car from Denver. All Nordic
vents, including the popular and exciting ski jumping,
will be four and one half driving hours and two moue-
ainpasses away in Steamboat Springs. Even ifbuses are
aid on, Denver residents, to say nothing of tourists, can
ardly be cheered by that sort of midwmferlogistics: '.":`''"~
Meanwhile, the rhetoric runs strong. Governor John j
ove talks about "the power of the Olympic ideal as .
vehicle of world peace" and how "Colorado can ben-
fit mightily as she helps advance the brotherhood of
man." But no[ all the phrases are hollow. There really
a question of "pride and honor" out here where west-
npride and the honor ofa handshake still mean some-
ing. Never in all the history of tl'~e Olympics has a i.
ty bid and won the right to stage the Games-and `
en chanorrl ~r~ ~,~~„t r. €
MINUTES
SPECIAL MEETING
EAGLE VALLEY 7V TRANSLATOR COMMITTEE
APRIL 10, 1989
12:30 P.M.
REUBEN"S RESTAURANT - EAGLE
PRESENT:
Mike Metcalf
Mike Robinson
Mike Caccioppo
Jeff Heermans
Norm Wood
Lynn Weas
Bill James
John Dunn - Attorney
Mike Cheroutes - Special Attorney
Stan Bernstein - Finance
Larry Brooks - Town of Avon
The meeting was called to order by Mike Metcalf, Vice Chariman.
The Committee reviewed the language amending the Service Plan as adopted at the
previous meeting. The implications of the amendment were discussed by legal
council and it was decided to proceed with the amendment as adopted.
A motion was made by Mike Caccioppo to "Amend the Service Plan to include the
provision that the Board of Directors will solicit bids from private contractors
for the operation and maintenance of the television translator system.
The motion was seconded by Jeff Heermans.
Following discussion the motion was approved.
Mike Robinson moved to adjourn. Mike Cacioppo seconded and the meeting was
adjourned at 1:45 PM
EAGLE VALLEY TV TRANSLATOR COMMITTEE
MEETING
APRIL 6, 1989
MINUTES
PRESENT:
arm Wood Bill James
ike Metcalf Mike Robinson
ike Cacioppo Jeff Heerman
evin Whelan
The meeting was called to order by Mike Metcalf9 Vice Chairman.
The Committee discussed various options for proceeding with the formation of
the District.
Michael Cacioppo made a motion to amend the Service Plan as follows:
If no adequate signal is received by any taxpayer in the district during the
first three years of the districts existence, then such taxpayer may apply for
and receive a full refund of any taxes paid and for exclusion from the district.
The determination of adequacy of the signal shall be exclusively made by the
district's engineer.
Any application for refund and exclusion must be submitted during a six month
period beginning three years and one day after the formation of the district.
Failure to apply during that period of time shall forever prohibit an automatic
granting of a tax refund and exclusion from the district. Payment of any refund
shall be made by the district within ninety days of determination by the district
board that the signal is inadequate.
The board shall be obligated to provide public notice within the district of the
six month refund and exclusion application period. Failure of the board to
provide timely notice shall cause the six month application period to be extended
to a time six months after the last publication notice. Public notice shall
consist of three publications in a legal newspaper of general circulation within
the district.
Kevin Whelan seconded.
Following discussion the amendment was approved.
The meeting was then adjourned.
®e~~
MwuDRy /lo•:l [}x(9'69 - - ® ~~
.. ~ Illlrt ht s~
.~ ~~ F~ ~ ~ .~~ g
action
Cable choice
grand' or
atraaeous'
~IJCtI IJ tv The USA is gble~savvy and
become a subscnbers want changes and
want them now!
major player'; ers ~~ USA~ODArs ca-
CnIBC debuts b1e Tv hot line over the week-
today, 3 ~ end to spout off, o9er opinions
and even ladle some praise.
"Cable in this city is outra-
- genus;' says Donna S!Iverth-
orn of Baltimore. "They charge $20 a month and out of 30
channels we only have four or five.ot good quality."
On the flip side is Joyce McDaniel of Magnolia, Ark.: "Ca-
ble TV is by tar the grandest invention of modem civili7a-
don. It has brought more entertainment, it has brought
more selective choices for intelligent viewers."
One of those choices, CNBC, begins operation today. Thir-
teen million subscribers on 90 systems will receive NBC's
news and information service -just one more outlet for
cable TV's growing original programming.
At the same time, however, cable discontent seems to be
on the rise. This week, Sen. Howard Metzenbaum, D-0hio,
continues hearings begun last week on monopolies and the
gble industry. Many hot line callers directed comments at
just that topic, expressing fntstration about cable services
beine limited to a sinpJe provider in each community.
Thou -tn o ne nvites more grousing than
praise, the intensity of responses clearly demonstrates ca-
ble's unique place in the nation's living rooms. Passionate
Please see COVER STORY next page
House Speaker Jim Wright's
hold on [he Democratic Party's
top job will be tested today
when the House ethics commit-
tee releases its initial report on
his financial dealings.
Details of the 10-month
probe -and the fine print of
outside counsel Richard Phe-
lan's 458-page report -may
prove more damaging than the
actual charges against Wright
But the 8fryearold Texan al-
ready has begun his effort to
turn the indictment-like report
into anacquittal - a process
-that could take several weeps.
Wright wrote leaders of the
ethics committee Sanday re-
questing anopportunity to ap•
pear as early as this afternoon.
I am most anxious to have
the matter resolved without
further delay; he wrote. It !s
"in the best interest of the
House, as well as the nation."
Key to Wright's hopes: The
panel must find "clear and con-
vincing' evidence of violations
in the next phase of its inquiry.
Today's IIndings -backed by
a majority of panel Democrats.
The New York Tunes reports
- indicate oNy "t~eason to be-
lieve" there was misconduct
„The committee is very con-
scious of the distinction be-
tween the two standards," says
Rep. Alan Mollohan, D-WVa.,
a panel member. Phelan's t'e-
port, he says, is "onesided."
Once Wright makes his case.
the panel decides whether the
charges stand and what penal-
ty - tram a critical letter to
expulsion - to recommend.
Floor action follows.
The main charges against
Wright' He and wife Betty ac-
cepted guts from a Fort Worth
developer with an interest in
legislation; Wright sold a book.
Resections of a Public Man. in
bulk to sidestep outside income
limits. Weekend reactions:
p "We have to be terribly
careful that we don't let accu-
sation bring about its own taint
of gullt," says House Majority
Leader Thomas Foley, who
would likely succeed Wright
® "I think he will survive as
spealter into the foreseeable
future:' says Senate Majority
Leader George Mitchell
Housing and Urban Devel-
opment Secretary Jack Kemp
said Sunday he'll give public
housing directors new tools to
speed evictions of tenants con-
victed of dais-related CTlIrle3.
Kemp said he would notiry
directors this week of their
new authority to kick out ten-
ants who sell or use drugs.
He also wants to speed evic-
tion hearings and court appear-
ances, cutting the usual 10-
month processing time by half.
But Norman Siegel. New
York director of the American
Civil Liberties Union, warned
govetrunent officials "cannot
and should not shortcut the
Constitution" to fight drugs.
He said existing nu~sattce
laws are suffident to evict
dealers and attacked Kemp for
wanting "to look good on the 6
o'clock news."
HUD also may nearly dou-
ble the 350 million available
for antidrug security in the na-
tion'shousing projects. home to
1.3. million families. -" "
In February, Kemp queried
the nation's 3,200 public hour
ins authorities about their
methods for battling drugs.
Efforts to fight back:
®Chicago's Operation Clean
Sweep has cut project crime by
32 percent Tenant IDs, resi-
dentpatrols and treatment pro-
grams have helped.
®New York housing police
have made 30 sweeps of public
projects since 1988, resulting in
3,536 drug arrests.
~ Lakeland, Fla., officials
use cameras to tape drug sales.
® New Haven, Conn., build-
ings Gave new vandal-proof
lighting, intercoms and alarm
fns.
® Many projects have start-
ed "Just Say No" clubs. Among
them: Danville, Ill.; Salem,
Ore.; and Scotts Bluff, Neb.
~~. ~~~ .,
~~
ing between the two nations. y
As a lieutenant colonel, Ei-
senhower worked in the White
House under his father, he
went into the reserves, retiring
as a brigadier general, served
as ambassador to Belgium,
then struck out on his own.
'The hell with it I'm going to do
something my old man
couldn't get into."'
One major review of his lat•
est work doesn't even mention
his father. "God, it feels great!"
Eisenhower says.
- PaW Clancy
buy the deicing theory are involved.
She's been in touch with Theresa
Griffin, widow of pilot Capt. John
Griffin, who has worked separately
since the crash to clear his name.
"For someone to have as their 5-
nal epitaph negligence, when they
were never a negligent person, is un-
Griffin says her husband used to
discuss news of accidents with their
two children, now in college. "He al-
wayssaid if they can't find the cause,
they'll blame the pilot because a
dead pilot can't talk"
- Lorl Sharn
COVER STORY
Top-a~ated on calble: `3 Stooges'
Continued from lA
and vehement. the calls also reveal a
surprisingly high level of under-
standingconcerning the pay TV busi-
ness and its future.
Key areas of caller comments:
- Cost Basic cable rates have
zoomed 31 percent since 1986.
- Customer service. Installation
and servicing was second to costs on
the complaint Ilst
"We lose channels now for one or
two days a week and they don't rep-
resent that in the rates," says Gerald
Schmaltz of Bluffton. Ind.
I'm very dissatisfied with the ser-
vice," says Judy David Kochenauer
of Alexandria, Va. "The technicians
oNy come out between 8 am and 5
p.m., and you can't get a set time
which means you have to take a day
ot[ from work Sometimes you have
to take oII two or three days before
you get the problem fixed."
- Progamming. Cable now has
more channels and more original
programming than ever. But quit
tiles about the quality of that pro-
gemming was frequent, especially
regarding repeating of programs.
Says M.J. Fitzgibbon of Youngs-
town Ohio: "I've had it a month and
I've seen programs so many times
it's sickening I bought it for the Dis-
covery Channel" -primarily life
science documentaries - "but I've
seen the same buffaloes and birds so
many times I'm sick of them"
Few would argue that cable is sup-
plying more original and better pro-
gramming. Yet cable's highest-rated
non-movie programming as of Octo-
tier 1988 was The Three Stooges, The
Andy Griffith Show and The Brady
Bunch. All are reruns airing on su-
perstation TBS.
As for movies -whether basic or
= -viewers have a severe case of
yew.
:ink they repeat the movies too
.;n;' says Tony Tober of North
::~dgeville, Ohio. "Every time you
want to setlle down to see a movie,
it's the same one they've played over
and over again."
Callers frequently linked their an-
happiness to the deregulation of the
cable industry in 1984.
- In 1980, when cable was still reg-
ulated, basic rates were $7.85.
- In 1987, as 98 percent of the
USA's TV households subscribed, ba-
sic cable bills averaged $13.27.
- In 1989, able moved into 55
percent of TV homes, and the month-
ly basic bill will rise to $16.52.
Cable defenders say deregulation
has actually led to cable improve
meats. Decker Sandstrom of the Na-
tional Cable Television Association
says since deregulation, '"fhe num-
ber of cable networks has increased
by 40 percent, spending on new pro-
grammitrg by cable systems has
jumped from $300 billion to $800 ail-
lion ayear."
Across the board, major cable net-
work executives are spending more
than ever on their programs,
- USA Network spent $62 million
in 1987, $86 million in 1988 and plans
to spend $113 million this year.
- Ted Turner's six-monthold ba-
sic Able channel TNT estimates it
will quintuple it's programrrling bud-
get to $50 million this year. TNT
president Gerald Hogan says he
doesn't want to see repeats dominat-
ing TNT as they do now. "Our goal is
to become a major player, a [oe-io-
tce competitor with the networks,"
says Hogan
Improving service is also an issue
cable leaders are addressing.
"What you are seeing is renewed
attention by the operators to custom-
er service;' says Sandstrom. "It's
been a problem created largely in
part by rapid growth since the early
1980s. Customer demand simply out-
stripped our systems."
Among improvements: New leis
phone systems, extended hours,
opening "cable" stores in shopping
malls and customer service training
programs.
"The service is still a little behind
the progamrrling," admits Bob Clas-
sen, president of Comcast Cable
Communiptions, the nation's sev-
enth-largest Able operator. "The
product is getting better and the cus-
tomer has to be assured if we sched-
ule aninstallation we get there, if
they call the office they can get
~~ ..
Giessen says for the last three
years the percentage of his cable
subscribers ordering disconnects has
continued to decrease.
"The cable industry must be regu-
lated:' says Joyce MacDonald of
Westbury, N.Y., where her Cablevi-
sion system has been in the midst of
controversy over not airing some
New York sports progiammitrg.
' I'm paying $50 a month to watch
TV and I don't have half the chan-
neLsthat other people have for $20 or
$25. It's a monopoly. If you are not
going to have competition then you
have to have regulatidn."
Telephone companies have been
hoping to increase competition by
entering the.txble marketplace, but
so far haven't been allowed. Some
callers think they should be.
"The cable industry has tended t0
take advantage of their monopolistic
position and I would certainly hope
the telephone company is allowed to
provide some much-needed comps
tition." says Jce Laposa, who works
for the City of St Louis (Mo.) Cable
Division. "It will certainly give Ute
cable operators an incentive to im-
prove customer service, operations
and keep the rates more reason-
able."
Still, the cable industry says restor•
ing regulation would be a mistake.
And few believe it will happen.
"I don't see any widespread inter-
est to re-regulation; ' says the NCTA's
Sandstrom. "Deregulation has only i
been in effect for two years and 'I
while there are some problems there
are some great advantages. There's
more channel capacity, there's dou-
ble the investrnent in new programs
and that's clearly benefited the con-
sumer." ,
Tom Malloy of Arlington, Va,
agrees. "Put it this way, I like to eat a
lot, and I like to watch sports a lot
But I would rather give up my refrtg-
erator than my able TV."
Nutri/Systems Sulpports
Nati®nal Weight Loss Month.
THE PROBLEM: 68 million
adult Americans are overweight;
34 million of those are obese."
THE SOLUTION: According
to the Council on Scientific Affairs
of the American Medical Associa-
tion, the solution has three simple
elements: 1. A nutndonallv-balanced
diet; 2. Behavior modification;
3. Exercise.
Nuttri/Systetri:
ComprehP ive Weight
lLoossss tt+ogrztm
One program that features all
the elements recommended by the
AMA isthe Nutri/System' Weight
Loss Program. It includes:
• Nutrition and Behavior
Counseling to provide
support, and to help understand
weight control problems.
• Delicious, low-calorie meals
that are nutritionally balanced, low
in fat, and portion-controlled.
- -~•~
N•A•T•I.O•N•A•L
WEIG~T~O-- SS
- V
• Light Exercise for people not
used to exercising regularly.
• Weight Maintenance to keep
pounds off and begin a healthy
new life confident of pemranent
weight control.
"War on Obesity"
Nutri/System supports the
designation of April as National
Weight Loss Month, to raise pub-
licawareness and concern about the
Number One National Health
Threat-Obesity. Here's what
you can do:
1. See your family physician to
make sure you are not one of
•d„.u.n.aw,,u,.,,a... nn.. d.,,. aa,rr rv...,d~,. ~ N~ e. ,wa ~. w,.n.. ~.~..~. ~,.,d min, Sao
•'Nw.W LuaNm d IbIA ue,ua.ivi~r n LJ..,~ nvrt m...,n vW.+iu.l'• Sv..El..e,yi~.
the 68 million overweight
Americans.
2. If you are overweight, seek
help through a comprehensive
program for weight loss and
weight control.
3. Enlist others in the "War
on Obeaity:' Join the thou-
sands of Americans who will
observe Natonal Weight Loss
Month during April.
4. Call for a national health
policy on obesity. Write or
call your Congressman today
to join the "War on Obesity."
Let's lick this National Health
Threat.
A message in the
public interest from the
1,100 Nutri/System'
Weight Loss Centers
throughout North America.
We Succeed
Where Diets Fail You.=
T'6e continuing "oisl
eariv - findings :!lists
cussed move to abolish
than "Aviation: Safety F
replace itwith•a bore
gate all translwrtation
The legislstion is pe
ECONO
LARGi
1~~~~
~^~1•(•
^^~~^
^=:
^^
r:`
E
>!
k
]!
f
E
Econor
been s.
Especia
that to
exquisi
Rent th
Chrysle
just $3~
with a
advent
or $36.'
24hou
ticipati~
Or, rern
of its tit
Plymot
with a
at part
restrict
New Y
25¢ a i
These
taX, Or
FORYOURI
charges apF
and Newari
~~~~^
^~^
^~^
^
^
~~wmake~rs clairrt
By the 6-ssocia4ed Press
WASHINGTON -Cable television
executives faced a buzz saw Wednesday
from congressional, broadcast and con-
sumer critics who said cable companies
are reaping billions of dollars in profits
at public expense.
Sen. Howard Metzenbaum, D-Ohio,
led the attack at a congressional hearing,
sa in cable rates have risen an avers e
0 2 ercen nation since Con ess
ifte vi ua y a regu ations on ca e
operators in 1984. _
"The government reports that the
price consumers pay for cable service in-
creased at a greater rate than any other
commodity or service in the entire
United States," said Metzenbaum, chair-
man of the Senate Judiciary subcom-
mittee on antitrust, monopolies and
business rights.
Metzenbaum said what little authority
the Federal Communications Commis-
sion has to regulate cable is a joke, and
h ant duced two bills that would allow
cif P*n*n° *~to regulate P
rates, rewire that cable programmers
make their rograms avaTbT to com-
peting technologies suc as satellites and
wire ess ca e, an pro i it a ca a com-
pan~om controlling more than 25 per-
cent of the cable. subscribers in the
country.
Edward Fritts, president of the Na-
tional Association of Broadcasters, said
the cable companies now dominate the
local TV marketplace.
"In 1984 when Congress passed the
Cable Act, cable characterized itself as a
struggling, infant industry," Fritts said.
"That act, which in essence removed
all regulatory oversight, has become the
communications equivalent of anabolic
steroids. To~v. cable television o__ppe~~ra-
tors en'oy an•unre ulated monoo oIy.
mazm~y, 032 of more than 8 000
cable systems ave any rec c~_pe
S®® C~1~~E, netts pag®
Viable
Frmrn.®-~
tion," Fritts said. .
Fritts. said cable TV now is a
$14 .billion industry that is avail-
able to: nearly 80 ::milIion U:S.
homes: He ~ said 'the five largest
cable companies account for
more than 40.percent, o~"subscrib-,
ers. Gene Kimmelman,: executive
dii~ector:~of the Consumer Feder-
ation of America;' testified, that
competition' iri "the .cable market-
place could -drive dowri prices by~ ~
as-much as 50. percent, with a
savings.to consumers' of $6 bil-
lion. ~ . , ,:.
Cable executives.ilenied the
monopoly-allegations .and said.
the .American public has bene-
fited.tremendously from the ,in-.
troduction .of cable TV since' the
early 1970s. _ - -
Gerald Levin, vice chairman of
Time Inc., which .owns Home
Box Office and Cinemax, denied
the monopoly label and said cable
is providing more. and better pro-
gramming_ by owning both the
program suppliers and.-cable sys-
terns. - • .
I;evin also said cities.~reap biI-
lions of dollars in franchise fees
from cable operators, and munic-
ipalities are free to give those
franrhises to other companies if f
they don't like their cable service. .
REC°~ APR `1 8 X89
DOUBLETREE
at Vail
250 S. Frontage Road West
P.O. Box 1928
Vail, Colorado 81657
(303) 476-7810 April 14, 1989
Vail Town Council
75 South Frontage Road
Vail, CO 81657
Dear Council Members:
I wish to express my strong support for the proposed television
translator system for Eagle County.
As the manager of a business entity in Vail that requires television
service, I would prefer to have an alternative to the cable
service monopoly that currently exists.
Additionally, I represent many employees who would benefit from
a choice that could positively impact their cost of living in
our community.
I urge you to support the television translator system and ask
for your favorable consideration.
Since y yours,
J' Thalman -
General Manager
JT/ml
551 Broadway
Eagle,Colorado 81631
(303) 328-7311
OFFICE OF THE COUNTY NlP,YdAGER
Fcr Immediate Release
By: James R. Fritze
April 14, 1989
AP
The Board of County Commissioners has scheduled a public
hearing on May 8, 1989, from 9:30 to 11:30 a.m, to allow interested
persons to discuss the removal of the County Seat from Eagle. The
meeting will take place in the Commissioners' Meeting Room in the
Courthouse Building, 551 Broadway, in Eagle.
The hearing has been requested by interested citizens from the
eastern part of the County.
Board of County Commissioners Assessor Clerk and Recorder
P.O. Box 850 P.O. Box 449 P.O. Box 537
Eagle, Colorado 81631 Eagle, Colorado 81631 Eagle, Colorado 81631
Sheriff
P.O. Box 359
Eagle, Coloeado 81631
Treasurer
P.O. Box 479
Eagle, Colorado S1b31
551 Broadway
Eagle,Colorado 81631
(303) 328-7311
Office of the County Manager
For Immediate Release
Ey: James R. Fritze Q~
April 12, 1989
Glenn Ehlert has been appointed as the acting Director of
Information Services for Eagle County. Mr. Ehlert has been with
Eagle County since November 1984, when he was hired as an Appraiser
by the County Assessor. In January of 1987, Mr. Ehlert was
promoted to a Programmer/Analyst with the Data Processing
Department. A search for a permanent Director has begun. He will
replace Sara Fitzgerald who recently resigned.
Sidney N. "Sid" Fox has been appointed as the acting Director
of Community Development for Eagle County. Mr. Fox has been with
Eagle County since January of 1981, when he was hired as an
Environmental Health Officer. He has served in that capacity since
that time. A search for a permanent Director has begun. He will
replace Susan Vaughn who recently resigned.
Board of County Commissioners Assessor Clerk and Recorder
P.O. Box 850 P.O. Box 449 P.O. Box 537
Eagle, Colorado 81631 Eagle, Colorado 81631 Eagle, Colorado 81631
Sheriff
P.O. Box 359
Eagle, Colorado 81631
Treasurer
P.O. Box 479
Eagle, Colorado 81631
f~EC~ APR .14 X89.
~y ®~~®RA~fI ~~ lE~
Rocky AAountain Pdews Staff Writer
The town of Vail is fighting the Lodge at
Vail's proposal to buy 385 acres of private
land within the Eagles Nest Wilderness Area
and trade the parcel for 2.1 acres of U.S.
Forest Service land next to the Vista Bahn
ski lift.
The small parcel also is adjacent to The.
Lodge at Vail, which originally made the .
proposal in 1983 to build a 100-room addi-
tion, said Jim Bailey, the attorney represent-
ing the lodge.
The town's opposition to the proposal is
based on the undervaluation of the land adja-
cent to the resort, the precedent the land
swap would set for more development and
substantial citizen pressuee, said town attor-
ney Larey Fskwith.
"The greater issue here is, do we let them
start here and where does it end," said Frsk-
with. About 2,000 of Vail's 4,800 year-round
eesidetits have signed petitions against the
swap, he said.
Vail -the shops, restaurants, homes and
condominiums -was built on privately
owned land. The Forest Service owns all the
surrounding land, including the mountain ski
VAIL ~ s t'mey llake, at 1377o,uoo, said n;leanoe 5. , .~ 2.1- acre tract put the value at close to $4
Gran y idatio 2 'Towns, director of lands for the regional' .million. last year, a 3,400-square=feat con-~
LAND ~~ i ''' rings ®envBt' '`, office. ~ ~ dominium near the Vista Bahn lift sold for
The Forest Service approved ,the . es $2.6 million,.he said.
SWAP ~ `change at thestate and aegional levels, both ~_ -' "This is the best parcel of land left in Vail
rN1'1 ~ appealed by the town. for development. Xou walk out the door and
~~illdl
Roc~cr MouNrAtea Ntswa
slopes.
The Forest Service appraised the 2.1 acres
at $980,000, and the 385 acres, located near
"Our No. 1 acquisition priority is wilder- ~ Proac a ores rvtce a u a t to
Hess in-holdings," Towns said. "The 2 acres al land for an expansion, the agency identi-
of land has no Forest Sea~vice character. We ' fied the 385-acre private parcel in ,the
., wilderness area.
'~ If the exchange is approved after Vail's ; • you're at the Vista Bahn," he said:
third appeal, scheduled for April 25 in the ,~ -~ Bob Lawton, Hands forester in the ~Ihite
Washington, ®.C., office, the Lodge at Vail liiver National Forest, 'said other. land _ex-,
would buy the 385 acres from.the owner and changes have occurred involving tracts adja-.
give it to the Forest Service for inclusion in ,cent to a ski area.
the wilderness area. ~ ~' He said when the Lodge at Vail first ap-
hed t6 F t Se bo t dd't' n-
do wilderness, we don t do urban land man-
agement."
The Lodge at Vail would receive the 2.1-
acre tract and pay the LT.S. • Treasury
$145,000 to cover part of the difference in .
the land values.
"The appraisal was completed following
Justice ®epartment stapdaeds. We were not
part of that process;' Bailey said. "What
attracted us to this is using the land ex-
change process to do some wilderness es-
pansion.»
Faskwit6 said a private appraisal of the
"We know there are some folks that are
opposed because they fear development of~
.. that 2 acres," Towns said. "On behalf of the
public, we fear development of the 385 acres
of land surrounded by wilderness."
' Bailey said the town's planning and zoning
process should determine whether The
Lodge at Vail develops the parcel, not ap-
peals to the exchange.
"Anything that is done on that land will
have to be done with the town's blessing,"
Bailey said.
~.c~~~ ~~/~ /'~~~./, Jam, ,.'u ~l'1(e~~)~a,~~~.~cc
~ + YVW'W 1 lY Y'tVW~/YYI, 9 ~'Y'~"~WVJ
~l• ~~•~9
~~
Discussion Points - Heritage Franchise Agreement
1. The Town may be entitled to regulate cable TV rates
because of the absence of effective competition to cable services.
- compelling a determination that no effective
competition exists may be time-consuming and expensive
if Heritage contests this point
2. Consider whether Heritage should be allowed to
directly or indirectly assign the franchise without the prior
consent of the Town.
3. A ten-year franchise may give the Town a better
opportunity to ensure that the system is state-of-the-art.
4. Consider whether it would be appropriate to compel
an upgrade of the system to a 450 MHZ system with the capacity of
69 channels by some mutually agreed upon future date; as an
incentive, perhaps the term of the franchise could be extended
from ten to fifteen years upon completion of the upgrade.
5. Consider whether customers should be entitled to a
refund or abatement of cable service fees in the event of
significant signal outage.
6. Should Heritage pay interest on converter deposits?
7. Should Heritage refund to a subscriber the costs
incurred by the subscriber in contributing toward the cost of a
line extension to the subscriber's residence at such time as the
minimum density requirements of the franchise have been met?
a~,
~~~
d
8. Even though technical standards are preempted by
the FCC, consider the possibility of negotiating a provision
requiring compliance with stricter standards now or, at a minimum,
at such time as such standards are no longer preempted by the FCC.
-2-
:~
,:.
lawmakers claim
~y the Associa4ed Grass
WASHINGTON -Cable television
executives faced a buzz saw Wednesday
from congressional, broadcast and con-
sumer critics who said cable companies
are reaping billions of dollars in profits
at public expense.
Sen. Howard Metzenbaum, D-Ohio,
led the attack at a congressional hearing,
satin cable rates have risen an average
~r~2 ercen~ nation since Con ess
fte vi u y a regu ations on .ca e
operators in 1984., _ , : - ' .
"The government reports that the
price consumers pay for cable service in-
creased at a. greater rate than any other
commodity or service in the entire
United States," said Metzenbaum, chair-
man of the Senate Judiciary subcom-
mittee on antitrust, monopolies and
business rights.
Metzenbaum said what little authority
the Federal Communications Commis-
sion has to regulate cable is a joke, and
h int duced two bills that would allow
city gOvP*^^~^* ;moo regulate P
rates, require that cable proggrammers
ma a t~ir rograma avai a6Te to com-
pe ing technologies suc as satellites and
wire ess ca e, an pro i it a ca a com-
pany~'rom controlling more than 25 per-
cent of the cable subscribers in the
country.
Edward Fritts, president of the Na-
tional Association of Broadcasters, said
the cable companies now dominate the
local TV marketplace.
"In 1984 when Congress passed the
Cable Act, cable characterized itself as a
struggling, infant industry," Fritts said.
"That act, which in essence removed
all'~iegulatory oversight, has become the
communications equivalent of anabolic
steroids. TgS~v. cable television oppe___r___a-
tors en'oy an ~unre fated mono oTy.
`mazmg y, on y 3 of more than 8,000
cable systems eve any rec c_ o~ ne`
. S®® CA~~E, nattg pa~®
abbe
tion," Fritts said.
Fritts said cable TV now is a
$14'Fiillion induatry.that is avail-
able~to,'nearly 80;;million iJ:S.
homes: He• said: the five largest
cable' companies account for
more than-40,percent, o~ subscrib-.
ers:.Gene Kimmelman,: executive
director; of the Consumer Feder-~
ation of :America;' testified. that
competition:. iri,~the. cable market-
place could ~ drive down prices by
as=much as 50_ percent, with a
savings.to consumers` of $6 bil-
lion. ~ , . ,a.
Cable executives denied' the
monopoly allegations and said..
thg'.American .public has bene-
fited:tremendously from tfie _in-_
troduction :of cable TV`since the
early, 1970x. :~~.'
Gerald. Levin; vice:~chairman of
Tune Inc., which .owns Home
Box Office 'and Cinemax, denied
the monopoly label and said cable
is providing more. and-better pro-
gramming. by owning both the
program suppliers.and.~cable sys-
tems. .. -
Levin also said~~cities reap biI-
lions of dollars in franchise fees
from cable operators, and munic-
ipalities are free to give those
franchises to other companies if
they don't like their cable service.
MwuDA1 no.:l t~,ryK9
.... ®
Wrt i~t k
seo
~
ac#ion
Cable choices
~outrageous9
~VC1I i~ tv The USA is cablesavvy and
beCOme a subscnbers want changes and
want them now!
major player" , e~ ~~ USA TODAY's ca-
CNBC debuts ble TV hot line over the week-
end to spout oH, offer opinions
today, 3~ and even ladle some praise.
"Cable in this city is outs-
- - genus," says Donna Silverth-
orn of Baltimore. "They charge $20 a month and out of 30
channels we only have four or 5ve.of good quality."
On the flip side is Joyce McDaniel of Magnolia, Ark: "Ca-
ble TV is by far the grandest invention of modern civiliza-
tion It has brought more entertainment, it has brought
more selective choices for intelligent viewers."
One of those choices, CNBC, begins operation today. Thir-
teen million subscribers on 40 systems will receive NBC's
news and information service -just one more outlet for
cable TV's growing original programming
At the same time, however, cable discontent seems to be
on the rise. This week. Sen. Howard Metzenbaum, D-0hio,
continues hearings begun last week on monopolies and the
cable industry. Many hot line callers directed comments at
just that topic, expressing frustration about cable services
haino limited to a sinele provider in each community.
Thou -in o Sne tnvites more gro,ising th.ut
praise, the intensity of responses clearly demonstrates ca-
ble's unique place in the nation's living rooms. Passionate
Please see COVER STORY next page D
House Speaker Jim Wright's
hold on the Democratic Patty's
top job will be tested today
when the House ethics commit-
tee releases its initial report on
his financial dealings.
Details of the 10-month
probe -and the fine print of
outside counsel Richard Phe-
lan's 456-page report -may
prove more damaging than the
actual charges against Wright
But the 66•yearold Texan al-
ready has begun his effort to
turn the lndictmeRL-like report
into anacquittal - a process
that could take several weeks.
Wright wrote leaders of the
ethics committee Sunday re-
questing anopportunity to ap-
pear as early as this afternoon
I am most anxious to have
the matter resolved without
further delay," he wrote. It is
"in the best interest of the
House, as weu as the nation"
Key to Wright's hopes: The
panel must find "clear and con-
vincing" evidence of violations
in the next phase of its inquiry.
Today's findings -backed by
a majority of panel Democrats.
The New York Times reports
- indicate oNy "reason to be-
lieve" there was misconduct
"The committee is very con-
scious of the distlnctlon be-
tween the two standards," says
Rep. Alan Mollohan. D-W.Va,
a panel member. Phelan's re-
port, he says, is "onesided."
Once Wright makes his case.
the panel decides whether the
charges stand and what penal-
ty - from a critical letter to
expulsion - to rernmmend.
Floor action follows.
The main charges a~inst
Wright: He and wife Betty ac-
cepted gifts from a Fort Worth
developer with an interest in
legislation; Wright sold a book.
Reflections of a Public Man. in
bulk to sidestep outside income
limits. Weekend reactions:
p "We have to be terribly
careful that we don't let accu-
sation bring about its own taint
of guilt.' says House Majority
Leader Thomas Foley, who
would likely succeed Wright
p' I think he will survive as
speaker into the foreseeable
tutors." says Senate Majority
Leader George Mitchell
Housing and Urban Devel-
opment Secretary Jack Kemp
said Sunday he'll give Public
housing directors new tools to
speed evictions of tenants con-
victed of dnig-related crimes.
Kemp said he would notify
directors this week of their
new authority to kick out ten-
ants who sell or use dtvgs.
He also wants to speed evic-
tionhearings and court appear-
ances, cutting the usual 10-
month processing time by halt.
But Norman Siegel, New
York director of the American
Civil Liberties Union warned
government officials "cannot
and should not shortcut the
Constitution" to fight drugs.
He said existing nuisance
laws are sufficient to evict
dealers and attadted Kemp for
wanting "to look good on the 6
o'clock news."
HUD also may nearly dou-
ble the S50 million available
for antidrug security in the na-
tion'shousing projects, home to
1.3.ttrillion families. ""
In February, Kemp queried
the nation's 3,200 public hous-
ing authorities about their
methods for battling dnigs.
Efforts to fight back:
®Chicago's Operation Clean
Sweep has cut project crime by
32 percent Tenant IDs, resi-
dent patrols and treatment pro-
grams have helped.
®New York housing police
have made 30 sweeps of public
projects since 1986, resulting in
3,536 drug arrests.
® Lakeland, Fla., officials
use cameras to tape drug sales.
® New Haven, Conn., build-
irigs have new vandal-proof
lighting, intercoms and alarm
ms.
® Many projects have start-
ed "Just Say No" dubs. Among
them: Danville, Ill.; Salem,
Ore.; and Scotts Bluff, Neb.
~~ (~~ ~/ ~ /~~: -- ~ r ,e .r T p.E'f, TED ?N l~G~ i/
i'
frig between the two nations.
As a lieutenant colonel, Ei- The hell with it I'm going to do
something my old man buy the de-rcing theory are involved.
She's been m touch with There Griffin says her husband used to
di The contlntring •<.ors)
senhower worked in the White
House under his father, he
couldn't get into."'
One major review of his lot- sa
Griffin, widow of pilot Capt. John
Grf1Bn
who has worked se
aratel scuss news of accidents witlr their
two children, now in college. "He al-
id if th
'
5 early .findings auejs <<
cussed move to abolish
th
A
went into the reserves, retiring
est work doesn't even mention ,
p
y
since the crash to Geaz his name. ways sa
ey can
t
nd the cause,
they'll blame the pilot because a an
viation::Safery F
•replace it with a boars
as a brigadier general, served
as ambassador to Belgium, his father. "God, it feels great!"
Eisenhower says. "For someone to have as their fi-
nal epitaph negligence
when they dead pilot can't talk" gate all transportation
Th
l
l
i
then struck out on his own.
- i?aW Clancy ,
were never a negligent person, is un-
- Lorl Shorn egis
e
pt
on is pe
COVER STORV
Top-rated o~ cable: `3 ~tooge~'
Continued from IA
and vehement, the calls also reveal a
surprisingly high level of under-
standingconcerning the pay TV busi-
ness and its future.
Key areas of caller comments:
- Cost Basic cable rates have
zoomed 31 percent since 1986.
- Customer service. Installation
and servicing was second to casts on
the complaint list
"We lase channels now for one or
two days a week and they don't rep-
resent that in the rates," says Gerald
Schmaltz of Bluffton. Ind.
'I'm very dissatisfied with the ser-
vice," says Judy David KoChenauer
of Alexandria, Va. "The technicians
only come out between 8 a.m. and 5
p.m., and you can't get a set time
which means you have to take a day
oft from work Sometimes you have
to take off two or three days before
you get the problem fixed."
- Pro®amming. Cable now has
more channels and more original
proganuning than ever. But quib-
bles about the quality of that pro-
gramming was frequent, especially
regarding repeating of programs.
Says MJ. Fil7gibbon of Youngs-
town Ohio: "I've had it a month and
I've seen programs so many times
it's sickening. I bought it for the Dis-
covery Channel" -primarily life-
science documentaries - "but I've
seen the same buffaloes and birds so
many times I'm sick of them."
Few woWd argue that Able is sup-
plying more original and better pro-
gramming. Yet cable's highest-rated
non-movie programming as of Octo-
bar 1988 was The Three Stooges, The
Andy Griffith Show and The Brady
Bunch. All are reruns airing on su-
perstatlon TBS.
AS for movies -whether basic or
~= -viewers have a severe case of
:ew.
:ink they repeat the movies too
.;n," says Tony Tober of North
::rdgeville, Ohio. "Every time you
want to settle down to see a movie,
it's the same one they've played over
and over again."
Callers frequently linked their un-
happiness to the deregulatlon of the
cable industry in 1984.
- In 1980, when cable was still rel;
Wated, basic rates were $7.85.
- In 1987, as 98 peroent of the
USA's TV households subscribed, ba-
sic able bills averaged $13.27.
- In 1989, cable moved into 55
percent o1 TV homes, and the month-
ly basic bill will tine to $16.52.
Cable defenders say deregulation
has actually led to cable improve-
ments. Decker Sandstrom of the Na-
tional Cable Television Assotdation
says since deregulation, "The num-
ber of cable networks has increased
by 90 percent, spending on new pro-
gramming by cable systems has
jumped from $300 billion to $800 tril-
lion a yeaz."
Across the board, major cable net-
work executives are spending more
than ever on their programs.
- USA Network spent $62 mlllion
in 1987, $86 million in 1988 and plans
to spend $113 million this year.
- Ted Turner's six-month-0Id ba-
sic cable channel TNT estimates it
will quintuple it's programming bud-
get to $50 million this yeaz. TNT
president Gerald Hogan says he
doesn't want to see repeats dominat-
ing TNT as they do now. "Our goal is
to become a major player, a toe-to-
tce competitor with the networks"
says Hogan.
Improving service is also an issue
able leaders are addressing.
"What you are seeing is renewed
attentlon by the operators to custom-
er service;' says Sandstrom. "It's
been a problem created largely in
part by rapid growth since the early
19805. Customer demand simply out-
stripped our systems."
Among improvements: New tele-
phone systems, extended hours,
opening "able" stores in shopping
malls and customer service training
Prol;~•
The service is still a tittle behind
the programming," admits Bob Chts-
sen, president of Comcast Cable
Communicatloas, the nation's sev-
entlr-largest Able operator. "The
product is getting better and the cus-
tomer has to be esstired if we sched-
ule an installation we get there, tl
they call the office they can get
~~„
Clasen says }or the last three
years the percentage of his cable
subscribers ordering disconnects has
continued to decrease.
"The cable industry must be regu-
lated; ' says Joyce MacDonald of
Westbury, N.Y., where her Cablevl-
sion system has been in the midst of
controversy over not airing some
New York sports programmlrrg
I'm paying $50 a month to watch
TV and I don't have half the chan-
nels chat other people have for $20 or
$25. It's a monopoly. If you are not
going to have competitlon.tlren you
have to have regWatlcfn."
Telephone companies have been
hoping to increase competitlon by
entering the cable mazketplace, but
so taz haven't been allowed. Some
callers think they should be.
"The cable industry has tended t0
take advantage of their monopolistic
position and I would certainly hope
the telephone company is allowed to
provide some much-needed compe-
tition," says Jce Laposa, who works
for the City of SL Louis (Mo.) Cable
Division. "It will certainly give the
cable operators an incentive to im-
prove customer service, operations
and keep the rates more reason-
able."
Still, the able industry says restor-
ing regulation would be a mistake.
And few believe it will happen.
"I don't see any widespread inter-
est in re-regulatlon; 'says the NCTA's
Sandstrom "Deregulation has only
been in etteCt for two years and
while there aze some problems there
are some great advantages There's
more channel capacity, there's dou-
ble the investrnent in new programs
and that's cleazly benefited the con-
sumer." ,
Tom Malloy of Arlington, Va.,
agrees. "Put It this way, I like to eat a
lot, and I like to watch sports a lot
But I would rather give up my refrig-
erator than my cable TV."
~~~~~
^~^^^
^~~~^
^:
^^
f . ", ``
=_,~;:
Y
d
F
Econor
been st
Especi~
that to
exquisi
Rentth
Chrysle
just $3~
with a
advanc
or $36.'
24hou
ticipatii
Or, rent
of its tit
Plymot
with a
at part
restrict
New Y
25¢ a 1
These
tdX, Of
l~iitri/~ysten~a Supports
Nati®nal t7Veight Loss Moth.
THE PROBLEM: 68 million
adult Americans are overweight'";
34 million of those are obese.**
THE SOLUTION: According
to the Council on Scienrific Affairs
of the American Medical Associa-
tion, the solution has three simple
elements: 1. A nutritionally-balanced
diet; 2. Behavior modification;
3. Exercise.
Nutri/Systetri:
Comprehensive Weight
Loss ttagtam
One program that features all
the elements recommended by the
AMA is the Nutri/System' Weight
Loss Program. It includes:
• Nutrition and Behavior
Counseling to provide
support, and to help understand
weight control problems.
• Delicious, low-calorie meals
that are nutritionally balanced, low
in fat, and pomon-controL'ed.
N•A•T•I.O•N•A•L
WEIGHIT~LOSS
~~
the 66 million overweight
Americans.
2. If you are overweight, seek
help through a comprehensive
program for weight loss and
weight control.
3. Enlist others in the "Waz
on Obesity:' Join the thou-
sands of Americans who will
observe National Weight Loss
Month during April.
4. Call for a national health
policy on obesity. Write or
call your Congressman today
to join the "War on Obesity."
Let's lick this National Health
Threat.
A message in the
public intereBt from the
1,100 Nutri/System'
Weight Loss Centers
throughout North America.
We Succeed
Where Diets Fail You.-
• Light Exercise for people not
used to exercising regularly.
• Weight Maintenance to keep
pounds off and begin a healthy
new life confident of permanent
weight control.
"Waz on Obesity"
Nutri/System supports the
designation of April as National
Weight Loss Month, to raise pub-
licawareness and concern about the
Number One National Health
Threat-Obesity. Here's what
you can do:
1. See your family physirian to
make sure you are not one of
•M oW6n duM n....s. m Y..K d.v aeu.tit, boa, .adx. triwd N d. 1959 ALaa,fLy~ ~. bunai.e i..vv~. ++.dn.~e W,r„ l,,:o
"NannJ Lumm a I,nld ~k+..e Marv a 1J~.,. mor. xwe n +dwW 1 "' .,,tn.
FORYOURI
charges apF
and Newarl
EDONO
LARGI
^~~~~^
^^^
^~^
^
^