Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout03. 2019 Bravo! Vail Event RecapEvent Recap: Bravo! Vail Cultural, Recreational & Community Category December 4, 2019 Bravo! Vail: June 20 –August 4, 2019 Caitlin Murray Executive Director Phone: 970.827.4318 CMurray@bravovail.org 2 Overall Event Highlights & Successes 3 •List the top 4-6 successes you want to share with the CSE (consider this a snapshot for your recap). •North American debut of Chamber Orchestra Vienna –Berlin •Premiere opera production: Puccini’s Tosca •Two nights –July 11 and July 13 •Pavilion sold out both evenings •Doubled video views on social media (444,000 views) •Net Promoter Score: 85 4 Questions from CSE 5 •The CSE will ask questions about your event and recap •Leave this blank –it’s a placeholder Estimated Attendance Results 6 •Was this the attendance you expected? •Continue to see attendance increase year over year •Attendance was on trend with past several years •How would you impact attendance next year? •Bravo! Vail’s debut of Chamber Orchestra of Europe will continue to bring international exposure to festival •A 3-year audience acquisition program will kick-off in 2020 to attract new audiences Visitor Type 7 •Was this the visitor type split you expected? •Visitor type was a diverse mix of local, regional, national, and international •Split was expected and on trend with past years •What steps would you take to optimize visitor mix for future events? •Continue to bring international artists and ensembles to drive cultural tourism •Draw a more diverse audience through varied programmatic offerings •Continue to offer affordable ticket prices and free events •Education & Engagement Programs strategic plan to increase awareness Overnight Visitor Profile: Overnight Visitors & Seasonal Residents Only Only 8 •What measures did you take to encourage attendees to book lodging in the Town of Vail? •Links on the Bravo! Vail website to all lodging partners under the “Plan Your Visit” tab to encourage overnight stays. •Opportunities for Bravo! Vail hotel partners to send offers to patrons through Insider’s Club emails. •Featured hotel partners in e-blasts to over 19,000 people. •Hotel advertisements in program bookNumber inPartyAverage Lodging Expenditures $131 per person (up $10 from 2018) ($396 per party –up $22 from 2018)Nights in AreaLodging Location Overall Visitor Profile 9 •Who was your anticipated target demographic? •Bravo! Vail seeks to reach a healthy mix of patrons including diverse income levels, ages, and geographic locations. •Bravo! Vail strives to bring in new audiences through innovative programming, targeting families and younger audiences. •Did you reach your target demographic? Why or why not? •Bravo! Vail reached its target demographics in 2019. Bravo! has built brand loyalty over the years through strategic marketing and development initiatives while continuing to focus on attracting new audiences. •Brought new audiences with Tosca and reimagined After Dark Series •What would you change to attract that audience next year? •New audience acquisition program will provide guidance in concert experience, social components, and music educationHousehold IncomeAgeGenderState Estimate Spending Results 10 •Estimated average spending per person: •Dining: $98 •Shopping: $214 •Lodging: 131 •Other Activities: $318 •Total average spending per person: $771 Town of Vail spending Bravo! Vail generated: $13.7 million NPS (Net Promoter Score) 11 •Do you think the NPS scores reflect the attendee event experience? •Bravo! Vail provides artistic experiences at the highest level. The organization makes customer satisfaction a priority by openly asking for feedback in post concert emails and concert surveys, as well as by acting on and responding to customer comments and feedback emails. These procedures improve the patron experience and lead to a high NPS. •What steps would you take to improve the NPS scores for your event next year? •Continue to present innovative artistic projects •Participate in GRFA venue improvements to improve customer experience •“Voice of Community” -Expand repertoire and adjust programming to meet the needs and desires of audiences while fulfilling mission Event Strengths & Weaknesses 12 •How did the event exceed expectations? •5 new corporate sponsors secured in 2019 •Successful North American debut of Chamber Orchestra Vienna –Berlin and the Bravo! Vail debut of world- renowned violinist Anne-Sophie Mutter despite inopportune weather on all three nights •8 sold out orchestra concerts •Bravo! Vail’s first ever opera production with two performances of Puccini’s Tosca •What are areas for event improvement? •Further diversify audiences through new programming and marketing initiatives •Explore the potential to have additional signage in village during the festival •Improve the customer experience through new communication opportunities such as website and text messages to keep audiences informed •Venue improvements such as audio, windscreens, roof, etc. •How did this year’s event compare to previous years? •Sold out 8 of 19 orchestral concerts (42%) vs 6 of the 20 in 2018 (30%) •77 vs 60 (2018) events in Town of Vail Vail Brand Compatibility 13 •How did the event support the Vail Brand? •Unique Experiences: Bravo! Vail provides once in a lifetime experiences each and every time through a variety of programs. Over the summer, the Festival hosted 77 events in Vail attracting a diverse audience through accessible programming. •International festival: Bravo! Vail welcomes internationally renowned musicians from around the world to Vail each summer. Some of this summer's international soloists included: Yefim Bronfman (piano), Seong-Jin Cho (piano), James Ehnes (violin), Augustin Hadelich (violin), Paul Huang (violin),Anne-Sophie Mutter (violin),Hanzhi Wang (accordion), and Knut Weber (cello). •Cultural leader:Bravo! Vail enriches the cultural life of Vail by creating meaningful connections between artists and patrons thus increasing the Town of Vail’s prominence as a summer destination for cultural tourism. •Economic Growth: Bravo! Vail contributes to the economic growth and vibrancy of the Town of Vail by bringing a high volume of visitors each summer. These visitors represent a highly sought- after demographic and bring revenue to the Town of Vail in the form of shopping, dining, lodging, and recreation. The Premier International Mountain Resort Community Community Contribution 14 •How did the event impact Vail’s sense of community? o Bravo! Vail strives to make music and the arts accessible to the entire community through its Education and Engagement Programs. In 2019,the Festival offered more than 25 free events throughout Vail including free community concerts, Little Listeners @ the Library, and the new Inside the Music series featuring a Master Class and informative talks. o Bravo! Vail has been a fixture in the community for 32 years, presenting 20 orchestral concerts at the Gerald R. Ford Amphitheater and seven chamber concerts at Donovan Pavilion in 2019. o Bravo! Vail maintains affordably priced lawn tickets and a season pass (ranging from $6/concert for students to $17/concert for adults) targeted to locals.​ o Bravo! Vail partnerships with numerous local businesses including Vail Resorts, hotels, restaurants and retailers, as well as with other local nonprofit organizations including Vail Valley Foundation and Vail Health. o A new partnership with Vail Symposium offered five unique opportunities to enrich the Tosca experience. Topline Marketing Efforts 15 •Include overview of top 3 successful marketing tactics or executions •New partnership with arts and entertainment PR firm that garnered Bravo! Vail a wide classical music reach through coverage in all major classical music magazines (The Strad, Opera Now, Gramophone, BBC Music Magazine) and showcased a billboard in Times Square of Anne-Marie McDermott that was picked up by 140 outlets with a potential reach of 49 million. •Expanded marketing efforts to the front range with four brand awareness billboards located in highly traveled stretches of I-70, I-25, and Broadway, providing over half a million impressions (520,128). •Audience Cultivation Efforts -Social media channels saw significant growth by posting engaging and timely videos of performances and patron experiences: •427,000 users reached (compared to 204,000 in 2018) •Video plays in 3 second, 10 second, and 100% views doubled compared to 2018 totaling 444,000 video plays •Increased Facebook follower rate by 3.75% and engagement rate by 2.45% compared to 2018 16 Potential for Growth & Sponsorships/Media Exposure 17 •How do you see the event evolving or growing next year? -In 2020, the Festival will host the Colorado debut of Chamber Orchestra of Europe, offer a new Immersion Series, and rebrand its education and engagement programs. -Bravo! Vail will continue to seek new corporate sponsors and media partners as the Festival expands and diversifies its programming, audiences, and brand awareness. •What sponsors do you plan to target next year? (Including existing and potential sponsors) -Bravo! Vail continues to look at developing new partnerships with local, Front Range, and national businesses such as Northern Trust, UBS, real estate businesses, and more. -Bravo! Vail is committed to developing a deeper engagement with current partners such as First Bank, Holy Cross Energy, LIV Sotheby’s, and Fidelity. •How will you leverage media exposure and extend the marketing reach next year? -Chamber Orchestra of Europe with internationally renowned pianist Yuja Wang, the new Immersion Series and the Symphonic Commissioning Project are expected to garner national arts media attention. Sustainability Efforts 18 •What measures were taken at your event/program to support the environmentally-friendly goals of the Town of Vail? -Bravo! Vail provides electronic distribution of brochures, program books, event invitations, and other communications when possible.​ -Bravo! Vail ensures it recycles appropriately at all of its hosted events.​ -Bravo! Vail promotes the use of the Town’s bus system for transportation and for patrons to bring their own reusable water bottle to the amphitheater. •What waste reduction methods were used during your event/program? -In Spring of 2019, Bravo! Vail began composting at its office and has seen a significant reduction in trash. Additionally, the office recycles, uses energy efficient appliances, light bulbs, and many recycled fixtures. -Festival program books left behind at concerts are gathered, saved, and redistributed at future performances. •How could you improve on sustainability efforts for next year’s event? -Bravo! Vail’s “Green Team” will continue to educate employees on recycling, composting and other green initiatives. -For 2020, Bravo! Vail is evaluating how to make communications more green and/or electronic. -Bravo! Vail will work with amphitheater management on recycling and composting efforts. Event Budget 19 Item $ Total Event Budget:$8,302,113 CSE Funds:$288,661 Cash Sponsorship (not CSE):$5,325,126 In-kind Sponsorship:$1,900,000 Marketing Budget:$672,495 Profit & Loss:Bravo! Vail’s FY2019 ended Sept. 30. A full audit will be available in late December. Bravo! Vail projects a surplus for FY2019. How did you use the CSE funds? (marketing, operations, staff, venue, etc.) Support residencies of Chamber Orchestra Vienna –Berlin ($78,275), The Philadelphia Orchestra ($90,193), and New York Philharmonic ($90,193) and New Works Project ($30,000). Additional Information/Appendix 20 •Provide detailed budget in the Appendix -* Event producer to attach detailed budget for recap •Provide final marketing plan in the Appendix •Provide full version of the Survey Dashboard PDF in Appendix •Provide any additional information or marketing materials you think the CSE would benefit from Bravo! Vail Music Festival 2019 Income Statement & Budget 8/31/2019 2019 Budget 2019 Proj 2018 PYTD 2018 Actuals Over/Under 2019 Proj Fiscal Year 2019 Fiscal Year 2018 Revenue 01-40301 Ticket Sales $2,082,851 $1,838,723 $2,082,705 $2,015,825 $2,056,794 $25,911 01-40302 Soiree Ticket Sales $56,500 $60,000 $56,500 $61,250 $61,250 ($4,750) 01-40303 Gala Auction & Ticket Sales $178,746 $193,870 $193,870 $280,320 $311,540 ($117,670) 01-40304 Education Income $200,596 $155,416 $200,596 $159,365 $168,015 $32,581 01-40305 Festival Contributions/Gifts $3,260,641 $3,343,739 $3,260,641 $3,950,861 $4,808,980 ($1,548,339) 01-40308 Edu - Tuition $1,880 $9,300 $1,880 $2,775 $2,775 ($895) 01-40309 Program Advertising $160,105 $155,500 $160,105 $146,813 $153,156 $6,949 01-40310 Guild Dues and Merch Sales $29,410 $30,000 $30,230 $29,451 $30,711 ($481) 01-40311 Interest Income/Stock gains $9,143 $1,000 $9,000 $2,248 $3,081 $5,919 01-40315 Endowment Contribution $0 $200,000 $200,000 $0 $0 $200,000 01-40331 Released from Restriction $2,152,550 $2,314,565 $2,152,550 $882,896 $596,133 $1,556,418 $8,132,422 $8,302,113 $8,348,077 $7,531,803 $8,192,434 $155,643 TOTAL REVENUE Expenses $3,895,294 $4,024,225 $4,024,225 $3,540,676 $3,583,052 $441,173 Artistic $961,638 $998,917 $980,571 $803,300 $867,376 $113,195 Concert Operations $288,572 $405,881 $418,324 $240,323 $263,075 $155,249 Education $609,255 $747,467 $672,495 $636,996 $661,303 $11,192 Marketing $546,150 $729,152 $607,670 $524,681 $549,833 $57,837 Development $446,795 $437,115 $466,789 $464,808 $578,429 ($111,640)Administration $838,093 $959,356 $921,264 $874,793 $1,155,078 ($233,814)Salaries/Taxes $7,585,797 $8,302,113 $8,091,338 $7,085,577 $7,658,147 $433,191 TOTAL EXPENSES 01-70001 Transfer account $0 $0 $0 $114,954 $0 $0 In Kind 01-40332 In Kind contributions $391,384 $1,900,000 $1,900,000 $225,724 $1,637,255 $262,745 01-50460 In Kind Expense $391,384 $1,900,000 $1,900,000 $225,724 $1,637,255 $262,745 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 $0 Total In Kind $546,625 $0 $256,739 $331,272 $534,287 ($277,548)NET SURPLUS/(DEFICIT) Page 1CONFIDENTIAL Bravo! Vail Music Festival 2019 Income Statement & Budget Page 2CONFIDENTIAL 2019 Bravo! Vail Music Festival Season Marketing Plan Background Bravo! Vail is the only festival in North America to host four of the world’s finest orchestras in a single season. The 2019 season features residencies by the Dallas Symphony Orchestra, The Philadelphia Orchestra, and the New York Philharmonic, plus the North American debut of Chamber Orchestra Vienna-Berlin, each featured in programs of the great classics, plus spectacular pops. In addition, world- renowned chamber music artists perform a diverse and eclectic chamber music series. 2019 also marks Bravo! Vail’s debut opera production: Tosca, which will be presented twice in July as part of The Philadelphia Orchestra’s residency. Brand Tenets 1. World-Class music 2. Spectacular setting 3. Highly social, friendly, and welcoming atmosphere Goals & Objectives 1. Maximize attendance and revenue. Achieve ticket sales goal. 2. Support fundraising and education / community goals; think holistically about organizational goals in marketing efforts. 3. Raise profile of Bravo! Vail among key target markets (ie: tourists, drive market, orchestra home towns). 4. Raise profile of Bravo! Vail in the classical music and opera world on a national and international level (ie: classicaly music enthusiasts, opera enthusiasts, artists, media, etc.) 5. Build attendance with current audiences and build new audiences for festival. Build out of KPIs to outline specific, detailed performance measurements Target Audiences - - Strategies 1. Develop marketing plans along two dimensions: audience and program a. Increase ticket sales and engagement with current audience with a thoughtful, engaging direct-response campaign, personalizing messages and offers by segment. b. Develop program-specific marketing plans for events with special audience targets, unique value propositions, special concerts: i. Chamber Orchestra Vienna-Berlin (separate marking plan) ii. Tosca (separate marketing plan) iii. Jaap Van Zweden’s inaugural season as NYP Music Director iv. Pops programs: Jurassic Park (6/30), Unforgettable: Nat & Natalie Cole (7/1), Legendary Movie Music (7/14), Legendary Movie Music (7/14) v. Deneve conducts: Magic of Music (7/6) vi. Classically Uncorked vii. Free Family viii. Bravo! Vail After Dark 2. Work with fundraising team to continue to build and implement on a cohesive, coordinated, segmented communications strategy. Consider data append. 3. Identify and invest in first-time buyers. 4. Aggressively capture and market to leads at every opportunity. 5. Engage current and prospective audiences through compelling story-telling using video, photography, blog posts, social media, and other tactics. 6. Focus on in-market tourists with concierge incentive program, high-profile presence and awareness-building activities in the Valley. 7. Continue national and international awareness-building tactics, focusing especially on press and content marketing tactics. 8. Continue targeted acquisition tactics, focusing on: a. Geography -- Locals, select drive markets (Denver, Colorado Springs, Boulder, Glenwood Springs, Grand Junction), NY metro, Dallas metro b. Affinity -- Arts & culture interest/participation; particularly classical music and opera Campaigns 1. Donor Ticket Sales (begins mid-December, 2018) 2. Season Launch & Create Your Own Package campaign (begins Feb 12, 2019) 3. Single Tickets (begins March 19, 2019) 4. Promotions / Event-Specific Marketing (begins beginning of June, 2019) Tactics 1. Direct Response a. Direct Mail (brochures and postcards for each campaign; during season) b. Email (Bravo Beat newsletter plus promotional emails) 2. Advertising a. Digital Advertising i. Banner Advertising 1. Behavioral Retargeting 2. Targeted Acquisition ii. Pre-roll video - Youtube iii. Google Ad Words iv. Facebook and Instagram Promotions b. Print Advertising i. Local Magazines 1. Vail Lifestyle: Summer & Winter 2. Eat: Winter 3. Vail Valley Magazine: Summer ii. Local Newspapers 1. Vail Daily, Summit Daily, Glenwood Post, Aspen Times iii. Colorado Magazines / Newspapers 1. 5280: May/June (consider July) 2. Denver Life: May 3. Denver Post: June & July iv. National Magazines 1. Symphony Magazine: listing 2. Gramophone: listing 3. BBC Magazine: listing 4. League of American Orchestras: listing 5. Chamber Music America: listing c. TV & Radio Advertising i. Targeted Comcast cable buy in select micro-markets (statewide) ii. Colorado Public Radio underwriting in local and key drive markets iii. Local radio: TBD 3. Content Marketing a. Video – Filmmakers in Residence b. Colorado Public Radio Broadcasts c. Social: Facebook & Facebook Live, Twitter, Youtube, Instagram d. Blog 4. Press a. Targeted and individualized press outreach and journalist invites to major U.S. and internationally-based media for coverage of the 2019 season (e.g. New York Times, Wall Street Journal, CNN, The Economist, Washington Post, etc.) b. Target feature pitching and achieve new levels/channels of press interest in 2019 through focus on: i. First-ever opera production – Tosca (July 11 & 13, 2019) ii. Annual Commission (Glass, Edgar Meyer) iii. Chamber Orchestra Vienna – Berlin and Soloist Anne Sophie Mutter iv. Anne-Marie McDermott Profile Pieces c. Brand-building targeted press and journalist invites for classical music media (e.g. BBC Music Magazine, Strings Magazine, NPR Classical, Musical America, WQXR, etc) d. Coordinate interviews, create press releases, proactive online PR outreach, strategy and tactical implementation e. Seek out national listings with outlets like The New York Times, Wall St Journal, BBC Music, and more. 5. OOH & Hospitality Marketing a. Banners – Vail roundabouts, covered bridge b. Bus ads – exterior (Eagle County) and interior (Vail) c. Poster & Postcard distribution – season & program-specific d. Hotel & Tourist Info Center distribution – season brochures, postcards, digital frames and weekly concierge flyers (hotels only) e. Program Book distribution – high traffic locations, doctor’s offices, lobbies, partner businesses, etc. Marketing and Public Relations Findings 2019 Audience and Orchestra Surveys Contents 22019 Marketing Findings Introduction 3 Attendance History and Overall Reactions 5 Children 11 Respondent Profile 14 Appendix 20 2019 Marketing Findings Introduction Overview 3 Overview This report summarizes the key findings from the 2019 Bravo! Vail audience surveys with regard to marketing and public relations implications. A separate report is provided that summarizes the economic impacts that the 2019 Bravo! Vail season had on the various local economies. 42019 Marketing Findings 2019 Marketing Findings Attendance History and Overall Reactions Overall Ratings •Prior Knowledge •Past Attendance • Sources of Awareness •Supporting Bravo! Vail 5 Overall Ratings Satisfaction ratings of Bravo! Vail remain high 62019 Marketing Findings Overall, audience members are very satisfied with Bravo! Vail, are very likely to return, and are very likely to recommend Bravo! Vail to others. How would you rate your overall satisfaction of the Festival? n=821 How would you rate the likelihood of returning to the Festival, either this season or in future seasons? n=818 How likely are you to recommend Bravo! Vail to family, friends, and/or co-workers? n=819 0 = lowest rating, 10 = highest rating 16% 10% 11% 19% 11% 11% 63% 78% 76% 0%25%50%75%100% Overall Satisfaction Likelihood of Returning Likelihood of Recommending Exhibit 1: Satisfaction, Likelihood of Returning, and Likelihood of Recommending 0-6 7-8 9 10 Mean 9.3 9.5 9.5 Prior Knowledge Most attendees have heard of Bravo! Vail before this visit to the Vail Valley 72019 Marketing Findings Roughly one in ten attendees had not heard of Bravo! Vail previously, but a majority had heard of the organization. Did you know of Bravo! Vail before this visit to the Vail Valley? n=759 91% 9% Exhibit 2: Prior Knowledge of Bravo! Vail Yes No Past Attendance A vast majority (81%) of attendees have attended a prior season 82019 Marketing Findings Approximately one in five attendees (19%) had never been before. A similar portion (24%) have been coming to Bravo! Vail for more than 10 seasons. Including this season, how many Bravo! Vail seasons have you attended? n=823 19% 30% 16% 11% 24% Exhibit 3: Past Attendance 1 season 2-4 seasons 5-7 seasons 8-10 seasons 11+ seasons Sources of Awareness The web site is a key source of awareness 92019 Marketing Findings First-time attendees were most likely to have heard of Bravo! Vail through the Bravo! Vail website (30%), and 21% said they learned of Bravo! via web search. In addition, friends and family were also a common source of awareness (27%). Among repeat attendees, Bravo! Vail communications are all common sources of awareness, though friends and family remain a key source of awareness among this group. How did you learn of Bravo! Vail concerts? n=154 (first-time attendees); n=656 (repeat attendees) 41% 36% 26% 25% 13% 8% 8% 6% 5% 3% 3% 3% 2% 0% 12% 8% 30% 2% 27% 8% 4% 21% 8% 8% 2% 2% 3% 1% 0% 17% 49% 38% 32% 25% 15% 9% 5% 6% 4% 3% 3% 3% 3% 0% 11% Email from Bravo! Vail Bravo! Vail website Mail from Bravo! Vail From a friend or family member Vail Daily News Article Vail Daily Print Advertisement Web search Social media (ex: Facebook, Twitter) Radio Hotel staff/concierge Ticket brochure in local activity racks Poster Vail Daily Online Advertisement TV8 Vail & Beaver Creek Other Exhibit 4: Sources of Awareness Total First-Time Attendees Repeat Attendees Supporting Bravo! Vail Patrons are most likely to support the New York Philharmonic and the Philadelphia Orchestra 102019 Marketing Findings Aside from general operating support, most respondents prefer to support one of the visiting orchestras. >The New York Philharmonic is the most desirable followed by the Philadelphia Orchestra. In addition, 29% said they would support general operations. If you were to support Bravo! Vail –financially or otherwise – what would you choose to support? n=738 45% 39% 29% 26% 22% 21% 21% 21% 15% 8% 4% New York Philharmonic The Philadelphia Orchestra General operating support Dallas Symphony Orchestra An International Chamber Orchestra Music Education Pops Opera Chamber Music New Music/Composer Commissions Other Exhibit 5: Supporting Bravo! Vail 2019 Marketing Findings Children Children in Attendance • Free Performances and Educational Programs 11 Children in Attendance Approximately one in six audience members attend with a child 122019 Marketing Findings Those with children are most likely to attend with a child age 7-12 (50%), or age 13-17 (49%). Children ages 0-6 were somewhat less common (30%). Did any children attend Bravo with you? If so, what are their ages? n=816 (total); n=134 (with children) 30% 50% 49% 0-6 years 7-12 years 13-17 years Exhibit 6b: Child Ages 16% 84% Exhibit 6a: Children in Attendance Yes No Free Performances and Educational Programs Approximately one-third of attendees with children say their children also attend Free Performances and Educational Programs 132019 Marketing Findings 31% of those with children said their children attend such programs. Did they attend any of the Free Performances and/or education programs? n=141 31% 69% Exhibit 7: Child Attendance at Free Performances and Educational Programs Yes No 2019 Marketing Findings Respondent Profile Age and Gender •Primary Residence • Property Ownership •Household Income and Net Worth 14 What is your age? n=795 What is your gender? n=786 Age and Gender 152019 Marketing Findings Half of audience members are age 65 or older 28% of respondents were under age 55, and 17% were age 75 or older. Respondents tended to skew female (63%). 9% 8% 11% 21% 33% 17% 18-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65-74 75+ Exhibit 8a: Respondent Age 63% 37% Exhibit 8b: Respondent Gender Female Male Primary Residence One-third of audience members are not from Colorado 162019 Marketing Findings The most common primary residences for attendees (aside from Colorado) were Texas and Florida (7% each). Where is your primary residence? n=744 State Pct CO 64% TX 7% FL 7% CA 2% AZ 2% IL 2% NM 2% KS 1% PA 1% VA 1% Others 12% 2019 Marketing Findings Eagle County Property Ownership and Location 17Do you currently own property in Eagle County? n=796 Where do you currently own property? n=341 Around two in five audience members own property in Eagle County 43% of audience members owned property in Eagle County. Vail is by far the most common location for property (34%) followed by Edwards (19%). 43% 57% Exhibit 10a: Own Property in Eagle County Yes No 34% 19% 10% 8% 8% 6% 6% 6% 3% 1% Vail Edwards Eagle Eagle Vail Avon Beaver Creek Cordillera Arrowhead Gypsum Bachelors Gulch Exhibit 10b: Where Property Is Owned Visitor Category 182019 Marketing Findings Over half of audience members are visitors to the area Around two in five respondents (43%) were homeowners in Eagle County, but 28% were visitors from Colorado, and 29% were visitors from outside Colorado. 43% 28% 29% Exhibit 10c: Visitor Category Home owner In-state visitor Out-of-state visitor Household Income and Net Worth 192019 Marketing FindingsWhat is your Household Annual Income before taxes? n=516 What is your Household Net Worth? n=454 Roughly half of audience members have household incomes of $150k or higher The median net worth for attendees was roughly $1.5M. 3% 4% 10% 15% 22% 16% 22% 9% Under 30K 30K up to 50K 50K up to 75K 75K up to 100K 100K up to 150K 150K up to 200K 200K up to 500K 500K or more Exhibit 11a: Household Income 14% 16% 27% 20% 16% 4% 2% Less than 250K 250K-500K 500K-1.5M 1.5M-3M 3M-10M 10M-25M 25M+ Exhibit 11b: Household Net Worth 2019 Marketing Findings Appendix Data Collection Overview •About Corona Insights 20 Data Collection Overview Research Mode and Sampling >Online surveys were distributed to audience members who attended a paid Bravo! Vail performance in the 2019 season. All surveys were collected between August 5 and September 3, 2019. Sample Size >A total of 933 surveys were collected from audience members. >A total of 96 surveys were collected from orchestra members. >Sample sizes vary for individual questions due to some respondents leaving questions blank. 212019 Marketing Findings About Corona Insights 222019 Marketing Findings Our founder named the company Corona because the word means “light.” It’s the knowledge that surrounds and illuminates an issue;exactly what we provide.Our firm’s mission is to provide accurate and unbiased information and counsel to decision makers.We provide market research,evaluation,and strategic consulting for organizations both small and large. Learn more at www.CoronaInsights.com 1580 Lincoln Street Suite 510 Denver, CO 80203 Phone: 303.894.8246 Direct Economic Impact Report 2019 Audience and Orchestra Surveys Contents 22019 Economic Impact Introduction 3 Direct Spending 6 Tax Revenue and Direct Economic Impact 14 Appendix 19 2019 Economic Impact Introduction Overview •Background and High-Level Results 3 Overview This report summarizes the economic impacts that the 2019 Bravo! Vail season had on the various local economies. A separate report is provided that summarizes the key findings from the 2019 Bravo! Vail audience surveys with regard to marketing and public relations implications. 42019 Economic Impact Background and High-Level Results Bravo! Vail retained Corona Insights to estimate the direct economic impact created by the 2019 Bravo! Vail Festival on Eagle County. Bravo! Vail, a six-week annual festival, is a leading cultural attraction in Colorado and Eagle County and draws guests from around the world. Bravo! Vail provides substantial direct benefit to the local community through audience and orchestra member spending and generates tax revenue for the town, county, and state. In 2019, a total of 56,282 guests paid to attend Bravo! Vail in addition to thousands of other attendees at free events. Overall, 590 musicians, chorus members and staff traveled to Eagle County. On average, musicians were accompanied by 2.1 guests. The direct impact model of the 2019 season estimates a total direct impact (including tax revenue) on Eagle County of approximately $24.6 million and approximately $14.3 million in the Town of Vail. This report documents the economic impact methodology and summarizes the direct economic benefits to Eagle County and other jurisdictions resulting from Bravo! Vail. 52019 Economic Impact 2019 Economic Impact Direct Spending Food and Beverage •Lodging and Hotel Expenses • Bravo! Vail Direct Expenses •Shopping •Activities 6 Direct Spending in Eagle County The total direct spending associated with Bravo! Vail for Eagle County was roughly $23.5 million in 2019. These figures are examined in detail in the following slides. 72019 Economic Impact Note: Bravo! Vail direct expenses include costs associated with running the festival including hosting events, food, venue leases, permits, parking, and board meetings. Associated tax revenues are not included in these figures. Expenditure Food and beverage $9,080,420 $358,070 $9,438,490 Lodging and hotel expenses $7,171,296 $774,848 $7,946,143 Bravo! Vail direct expenses -$228,852 $228,852 Parking $68,390 -$68,390 Shopping $3,533,003 $110,655 $3,643,658 Activities $1,996,412 $140,691 $2,137,104 Total Direct Spending $21,849,521 $1,613,116 $23,462,637 Total Direct Spending Audience Spending Orchestra Spending Direct Spending in the Town of Vail The total direct spending associated with Bravo! Vail in the town of Vail specifically was approximately $13.7 million in 2019. These figures are examined in detail in the following slides. 82019 Economic Impact Note: Bravo! Vail direct expenses include costs associated with running the festival including hosting events, food, venue leases, permits, parking, and board meetings. Associated tax revenues are not included in these figures. Expenditure Food and beverage $5,073,411 $249,986 $5,323,397 Lodging and hotel expenses $4,635,359 $774,848 $5,410,207 Bravo! Vail direct expenses -$228,852 $228,852 Parking $44,206 -$44,206 Shopping $1,456,811 $69,265 $1,526,076 Activities $1,063,967 $140,691 $1,204,658 Total Direct Spending $12,273,753 $1,463,641 $13,737,394 Total Direct Spending Orchestra Spending Audience Spending Food and Beverage The 2019 Audience Survey asked Bravo! Vail guests how much their party would spend on dining out, groceries, and liquor store expenditures for one day. On average, audience members spent roughly (per person, per day): >$56 on dining out >$22 on groceries >$20 on alcoholic beverages For guests that indicated that Bravo! Vail was a primary reason for their trip, Corona included all of their dining and grocery expenditures for the average trip length.1 For those audience members who indicated that Bravo! Vail was not a primary reason for their trip to Eagle County, Corona included the expenditures for one evening of dining out if they said that they dined out on the evening they attended Bravo! Vail (67% of these attendees). Bravo! Vail audience members spent roughly $9.1 million on food and beverages in Eagle County and approximately $5.1 million on food and beverage just in the Town of Vail. The 2019 Orchestra Survey asked orchestra members how much their party would spend on dining out, groceries, and liquor expenditures during the duration of their stay in Eagle County. Orchestra members and their parties spent roughly $358,000 dining out, on groceries, and on liquor while in Eagle County, $250,000 of which was spent in the Town of Vail, specifically. Corona also included concessions expenditures from Bravo! Vail concerts throughout the summer. During the season, audience members spent approximately $357,000 on concessions.2 92019 Economic Impact 1 Average trip length was calculated from survey respondents who indicated that they were not residents of Eagle County and did not stay for more than 14 nights. The average total nights spent in Eagle County was 3.7 nights. 2 Exact concessions figures were not available for 2019, so Corona used the average, per-person spending from 2017 to arrive at this estimate. Corona deducted 3 percent for standard credit card fees, bringing the total direct concessions impact on Vail Valley to approximately $347,000. Lodging and Hotel Expenses Audience members were asked how much their party would spend per night on lodging. Corona only included lodging expenditures for audience members who indicated that Bravo! Vail was a primary reason for their trip to Eagle County. Corona calculated lodging expenditures for guests based on the average trip length (3.7 nights). Bravo! Vail guests spent approximately $7.2 million on lodging in Eagle County, over half of which ($4.6 million) was spent in the Town of Vail. Bravo! Vail provided Corona with the total lodging expenditures for orchestra members. Orchestra members spent about $642,000 on lodging, all of which was in the Town of Vail. This does not include the value of in-kind contributions from local lodging partners. Orchestra members were asked how much their party would spend on hotel expenses other than lodging (e.g., room service and private functions) during the duration of their trip. Orchestra members reported spending about $133,000 in hotel expenses, all of which was in the Town of Vail. Bravo did not collect data on hotel expenses other than lodging for audience members. 102019 Economic Impact Bravo! Vail Direct Expenses and Parking Bravo! Vail Direct Expenses >Bravo! Vail provided Corona with their total direct expenses in the Town of Vail. These expenses included costs for events, food, venue leases, permits, parking, and board meetings. >These direct expenses totaled approximately $229,000. Parking >Audience members were asked how much their party spent per night on parking. Corona only included parking expenses for those who were not full-time residents. >Total parking expenditures were approximately, $68,000, $44,000 of which were in the Town of Vail. 112019 Economic Impact Shopping The 2019 Audience Survey asked guests how much their party planned to spend on shopping while in Eagle County. Corona included shopping expenditures only for those guests that indicated that attending Bravo! Vail was a primary reason for their trip. Audience members spent approximately $3.5 million shopping in Eagle County during the duration of their stay, $1.5 million of which was spent shopping in the Town of Vail. Orchestra members spent about $111,000 shopping in Eagle County, $69,000 of which was spent shopping in the Town of Vail during their stay. 122019 Economic Impact Activities The audience and orchestra member surveys asked respondents how much they spent on activities (e.g., spa visits, bike rentals, rafting, tours) during their stay in Eagle County. Corona only included activities expenditures for audience members who indicated that Bravo! Vail was a primary reason for their visit. Audience members spent roughly $2.0 million on activities in Eagle County, $1.1 million of which was spent in the Town of Vail. Orchestra members spent roughly $141,000 on activities in Eagle County during the duration of their stay, all of which was allocated to the Town of Vail. 132019 Economic Impact 2019 Economic Impact Tax Revenue Generated and Direct Economic Impact Impacts on Eagle County and the Town of Vail 14 Tax Revenue Generated Direct spending associated with Bravo! Vail generated substantial tax revenue for Eagle County and for the Town of Vail. The above table is a breakdown of tax revenue collected in Eagle County and the Town of Vail. In total, Corona estimates that spending associated with Bravo! Vail generated approximately $1.1 million in tax revenue for the county and municipalities, $551,000 of which was tax revenue for the Town of Vail. 152019 Economic Impact To estimate tax revenues for the Town of Vail, Corona used a rate of 4 percent for food and beverage (excluding groceries), shopping, and activities and a tax rate of 5.4 percent for lodging. For other municipalities, Corona applied appropriate tax rates on food and beverage (excluding groceries), lodging, shopping, and activities. To estimate tax revenues for Eagle County, Corona applied a 1.5 percent tax rate on food and beverage (excluding groceries), lodging, shopping, and activities. Expenditure Food and beverage $398,106 $186,301 Lodging and hotel expenses $450,881 $255,634 Shopping $169,933 $61,043 Activities $102,177 $48,186 Total Tax Revenue $1,121,097 $551,164 Town of Vail All Eagle County Governments Direct Economic Impact The table above shows that the total direct economic impact (direct spending plus tax revenue) generated by Bravo! Vail in 2019 was approximately $24.6 million, $14.3 million of which was in the Town of Vail. 162019 Economic Impact Expenditure Food and beverage $9,836,596 $5,509,698 Lodging and hotel expenses $8,397,024 $5,665,840 Bravo! Vail direct expenses $228,852 $228,852 Parking $68,390 $44,206 Shopping $3,813,591 $1,587,119 Activities $2,239,280 $1,252,844 Total Direct Impact $24,583,734 $14,288,559 Eagle County Town of Vail Total Direct Impact on Eagle County 172019 Economic Impact Bravo! Vail Attendees: 56,282 Orchestra members: 590 Food & Beverage $9,438,490 Note: The total Bravo attendance figure used in the impact model includes all paying attendees. Lodging & Hotel Expenses $7,946,143 Bravo! Vail Expenses $228,852 Parking $68,390 Shopping $3,643,658 Activities $2,137,104 Direct Spending Tax Revenue Total Impact $23,462,637 $1,121,097 $24,583,734 This flow chart presents the total direct economic impact generated by Bravo! Vail on Eagle County. Combined, audience, orchestra members, and Bravo! Vail spent roughly $23.5 million in Eagle County and generated approximately $1.1 million in tax revenue, creating a total direct impact of roughly $24.6 million in Eagle County. Total Direct Impact on the Town of Vail 182019 Economic Impact Bravo! Vail Attendees: 56,282 Orchestra members: 590 Food & Beverage $5,323,397 Note: The total Bravo attendance figure used in the impact model includes all paying attendees. Lodging & Hotel Expenses $5,410,207 Bravo! Vail Expenses $228,852 Parking $44,206 Shopping $1,526,076 Activities $1,204,658 Direct Spending Tax Revenue Total Impact $13,737,394 $551,164 $14,288,559 This flow chart presents the total direct economic impact generated by Bravo! Vail on the Town of Vail. Combined, audience, orchestra members, and Bravo! Vail spent roughly $13.7 million in Vail and generated approximately $551,000 in tax revenue, creating a total direct impact of roughly $14.3 million in the Town of Vail. 2019 Economic Impact Appendix Data Collection Overview •Analysis Methodology• About Corona Insights 19 Data Collection Overview Research Mode and Sampling >Online surveys were distributed to audience members who attended a paid Bravo! Vail performance in the 2019 season. All surveys were collected between August 5 and September 3, 2019 Sample Size >A total of 933 surveys were collected from audience members. >A total of 96 surveys were collected from orchestra members. >Sample sizes vary for individual questions due to some respondents leaving questions blank. 202019 Economic Impact Analysis Methodology (1 of 2) The analysis methodology for 2019 was replicated from the 2018 survey. The following is a general overview of the methodology used in 2019. Bravo! Vail’s direct economic impact on Eagle County is generated by direct local spending by audience members, orchestra members and their guests, and the associated tax revenue. These estimates do not include indirect and induced impact from this economic activity. The most critical factors influencing the economic benefit are the number of attendees; their length of stay; and their food and beverage, lodging, parking, shopping and activities expenditures. Bravo! Vail gathered spending data from audience and orchestra members through intercept and online surveys that were collected throughout the Festival. Corona reviewed and provided recommendations for the audience and orchestra member surveys prior to Bravo! Vail using them to collect data. 212019 Economic Impact Analysis Methodology (2 of 2) Audience survey respondents identified expenditures on food and beverage, lodging, parking, shopping, activities, and spa treatments. Respondents also identified where —e.g, the Town of Vail, Avon, Minturn, Beaver Creek —in Eagle County they spent money. Orchestra members identified expenditures on food and beverage, hotel expenses (other than lodging), spa treatments, shopping, and activities and indicated where they spent money. Hotel lodging expenditures for orchestra members were provided by Bravo! Vail. In addition to dollars directly spent by Bravo! Vail on orchestra lodging, participating hotels made significant in-kind contributions that are not included in the impact model. Corona aggregated personal responses from the intercept and online surveys and relied on total concert attendance and orchestra data provided by Bravo! Vail. This analysis distinguishes between Festival attendees that live in the Valley and those that traveled from outside the region, and between visitors to Eagle County who listed Bravo! Vail as a primary reason for their visit and those who did not. Corona created an economic impact model that identifies spending in Eagle County and in individual communities within Eagle County by audience and orchestra members. The model is a conservative estimate of the impacts of Bravo! Vail because it only counts the dollars spent by attendees whose primary purpose for coming to Vail was to see Bravo! Vail. In addition, only those attendees spending in a category are included in the model. In addition, we report only direct impacts, not the indirect or multiplied impacts that come from spending dollars in a community. 222019 Economic Impact About Corona Insights 232019 Economic Impact Our founder named the company Corona because the word means “light.” It’s the knowledge that surrounds and illuminates an issue;exactly what we provide.Our firm’s mission is to provide accurate and unbiased information and counsel to decision makers.We provide market research,evaluation,and strategic consulting for organizations both small and large. Learn more at www.CoronaInsights.com 1580 Lincoln Street Suite 510 Denver, CO 80203 Phone: 303.894.8246