HomeMy WebLinkAbout01. VLMDAC July Meeting PresentationVLMDAC BOARD MEETING
JULY 20, 2023
Agenda
I. MONTHLY FINANCIAL REPORT (5 minutes), Alex Jakubiec, Town of Vail
II. MINUTES APPROVAL
●Action Requested of Board
III. INFORMATION & DISCUSSION UPDATES
●2024 Campaign Concepts (60 minutes), 970 Design + Lumenati
●Vail’s Stewardship Roadmap (15 minutes), Mia Vlaar, Town of Vail
●2024 Operating Plan & Budget (5 minutes), Mia Vlaar, Town of Vail
●2024 Goals and Priorities (20 minutes), Board and Partner Group
●Organic Traffic and July Lodging Campaign Report (10 minutes), Miles Partnership
●Public Relations Update (15 minutes), Kirstin Yantis, MYPR
●Group Sales Update (10 minutes), Kim Brussow, VVP
●Other Business
●Adjournment
●Brand Platform Working Session, Resonance and VLMDAC Board
FINANCE UPDATE
MINUTES APPROVAL
Minutes Approval
Action requested of board to approve the June 15 minutes.
2024 CAMPAIGN CONCEPTS
2024 Campaign Concepts
Concepts to be presented at time of meeting.
VAIL’S STEWARDSHIP ROADMAP
*See packet materials for full roadmap
*See packet materials for full roadmap
Strategies related to VLMD
*See packet materials for full roadmap
*See packet materials for full roadmap
Strategies related to VLMD
Strategies related to VLMD
*See packet materials for full roadmap
2024 OPERATING PLAN & BUDGET
Objectives
Align on Goals and Priorities
Approve budget scenarios
VLMD Operating Plan / Milestones
2024 Planning Timeline
●7/11 Second Partner 2024 Planning Session
●7/18 Town Council meeting, first look at 2024 TOV budget – flat to 2023
●7/20 VLMDAC Meeting: 2024 Budget discussion – secure board direction on priorities
●8/17 VLMDAC Meeting: Present Draft Operating Plan for Town Council on 9/19
●9/7 VLMDAC Special Meeting Operating Plan FINAL: Virtual
●9/19 Town Council Meeting: Present and adopt 2024 Operating Plan
●9/21 VLMDAC Meeting
●10/19 VLMDAC Meeting
●11/7 Town Council Election
●11/16 VLMDAC Meeting
●12/5 Town Council Meeting: Present final budget
●12/5 or 12/19 VLMDAC board seat interviews at Town Council
●Jan. 2024: New Town Council sworn in
Amended 2023 Budget Reference
Marketing Amended 2023: $5,446,780
Annual Operating Budget: $5.2M
Use of Reserves: $175k
Transfer to General Fund: $1.4M
2024 Budget Scenarios
Scenario A: $5.4M
4% Annual operating increase
Annual Operating Budget: $5.4M
Use of Reserves:$0
Transfer to General Fund: $0
Scenario B: up to $6.6M
4% annual operating increase + use of reserves:
Annual Operating Budget: $5.4M
*Use of Reserves: $1.2M
Transfer to General Fund: $0
*not to exceed, while retaining 25% fund balance
One-time spend only
Current Amended 2023: $5.4M
Annual Operating Budget: $5.2M
Use of Reserves: $175k
Transfer to General Fund: $1.4M
GOALS AND PRIORITIES ‘23 vs ‘24
2023 Goals & Priorities
Drive responsible revenue growth in Vail by focusing on quality of guest, length of stay and guest
spend, while effectively communicating community values. Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)
include lodging occupancy and average daily rate and lodging and sales tax revenues with a focus
on mid week and lower demand time periods.
Business Goal
Maximize longer
stays and higher
spend, gain greater
understanding of
customer through
research.
Optimize
Visitation
Use data to
understand our
guest to enhance
engagement &
loyalty.
Grow Database +
Build
Relationship
Protecting and
sustaining our
natural environment
and attractions
while elevating the
guest and resident
experience.
Destination
Stewardship
Position Vail as the
Premier
International
Mountain Resort
Community and
work with
community partners
to define, support
and deliver on the
brand.
Brand
Positioning
Goals and Priorities Update
Goal:
-Year-round / Winter inclusion
Priority:
-Destination Stewardship with direction from Vail’s Stewardship
Roadmap
NOTE: Updates based on Brand Development may occur Dec 2023 - Jan. 2024
2024 Goals & Priorities Update
Drive responsible year-round revenue growth in Vail by focusing on quality of guest, length of stay
and guest spend, while effectively communicating community values. Key Performance Indicators
(KPIs) include lodging occupancy and average daily rate and lodging and sales tax revenues with a
focus on mid week and lower demand time periods.
Business Goal
Maximize longer
stays and higher
spend, gain greater
understanding of
customer through
research.
Optimize
Visitation
Use data to
understand our
guest to enhance
engagement &
loyalty.
Grow Database +
Build
Relationship
Safeguard Vail's
visionary spirit,
sustainable
appeal, and
community values
to attract
conscious
travelers and
protect the natural
environment.
Destination
Stewardship
Position Vail as the
Premier
International
Mountain Resort
Community and
work with
community partners
to define, support
and deliver on the
brand.
Brand
Positioning
NOTE: Updates based on Brand Platform
may occur Dec 2023 - Jan. 2024
ORGANIC TRAFFIC REPORT
Organic Traffic
Highlights
June organic activity rose significantly from May and was well above
year ago
●Note: Pineapple activity began mid-June 2022
Users
22.8k
+26% YOY
+101% MOM
Sessions
29.1k
+26% YOY
+105% MOM
Time on Page
2:18
+8% / :10 YOY
-5% / -:07 MOM
Bounce Rate
53%
-5% YOY
-1% MOM
Organic Traffic
●With the summer season upon us and new blogs and
optimizations in full swing, we saw a +97% increase in organic
traffic from May to June
○Site has yet to have a ‘normal’ year to show what is to be expected
Organic Traffic
●Organic traffic for the period June 19 - July 11 was basically flat
○Higher through much of June and for the 4th itself
○Slightly down since the 4th; in line with actual travel patterns
Organic Traffic
Possible Reasons Why
●Demand continues to be down nationally
Organic Traffic
Highlights
●Attracting higher quality traffic to the site
○Book Direct clicks are up via organic search +11%
○Average time on page has remained stable
Time on Page
2:06
-:01s YOY
Sessions
35.7k
-3.8% YOY
Book Direct Clicks
381
+11% YOY
Organic Traffic
Other Highlights
●Website is maintaining its positioning with Google
○In top 50 terms where we saw decreases in traffic, we’re in position 1
or 2 for majority of terms
○Page 1 keywords - all time high in June
●Blogs are pulling their weight by leading the way in driving 24% of
organic traffic followed by:
○Things to Do: 22%
○July 4th page: 15%
○Homepage: 3%
Organic Traffic
Keep in Mind…
●Site changes confuse Google
○As site improvements are made and structure evolves, traffic
will be in flux
■Structure changes/address swaps
○Combined with post-pandemic and inflation, actions are erratic
Organic Traffic
Recommended Next Steps
●Continue blog development and optimization
●Discuss upcoming improvements with 970 to prep for changes
●Put additional resources beyond SEO on non-blog pages
●Redirect 404s
○Miles create redirect map from 404 list and bad backlinks;
970 execute
●Consider creating one article/month that is not as branded/Vail
focused to pull additional organic traffic into the site
Blog Development
●Blogs have been created and optimized for content
○New blogs in late May-June
■Play, Stay & Slay in LGBTQ+ Friendly, Vail
■Best Things to Do in Vail in July
■Best Vail Hotels with Pools for Cooling Off in Summer
■Adventure like a GoPro Mountain Games Athlete in Vail
■9 Cool Hotel Bars in Vail to Enliven Your Vacation
■4 Ways to Experience Colorado’s Farm-to-Table Flavors in Vail
■Vail Summer Mini-Itineraries
■Best Photo Spots in Vail for Every Season
Keyword Performance
Strong performance with flat or
positive movement on majority of
keywords
●‘Hotels’ and ‘golf’ KWs grew
significantly with new blog support
●Uncertain what happened to ‘history’
- will keep an eye
●Need 2022 list of terms to
reference/sync still
JULY PROMO CAMPAIGN
July 2023 Campaign:
Drive Market Lodging Specials
●Starting July 1, we began to run ads in key drive
markets (Colorado, New Mexico and Utah)
promoting the up to 20% off lodging message
●Supported in Digital Display, Paid Search and
Paid Social
○Complemented by 50% non-lodging messaging
in same markets and 100% in fly markets
July 2023 Campaign:
Drive Market Lodging Specials
●Preliminary data is for media performance only
○Still early as campaigns take some time to gain momentum, but
provides initial look
●Destimetrics data available early August
●Adara data available early-mid August
July 2023 Campaign:
Drive Market Lodging Specials
●Through July 12, we have spent $6.2k for 886k impressions
Media Investment Impressions
Digital Display Ads $1,136 189k
Paid Search (SEM)$3,372 53k
Paid Social $1,663 644k
TOTAL $6,171 886k
July 2023 Campaign:
Digital Display
●Digital display has produced 177 clicks and 3 conversions so far
○Performing above CTR benchmark and strong conversion rate
○Top performing ads are mobile versions of Empty Nesters and Families
at .11% and .13% respectively
○Note: General campaign is performing better with an average CTR of .20%
Impressions Clicks CTR Book Direct
Clicks
Conversion
Rate
189,309 177 .09%3 1.7%
*.08 CTR
benchmark
7/1-7/11/23
July 2023 Campaign:
Paid Search (SEM)
●Paid Search has produced over 9k clicks and 126 conversions to-date!
○Implementing Google Performance Max (P-Max) tactic
■Very strong CTR and conversion
■Performing well with CPC of $0.22
■Static promo campaign is generating the majority of lodging clicks
■With initial analysis, we switched the P-max effort, which is doing very
well overall, to promote the general campaign and shifted the
remaining lodging promo budget to the static campaign which was
generating better conversions
Impressions Clicks CTR Book Direct
Clicks
Conversion
Rate
52,705 9,066 17.2%126 1.4%
*4.32% CTR benchmark
7/1-7/11/23
July 2023 Campaign:
Paid Social
●Paid Social has produced over 1.7k landing page views and 22
conversions
○Low CTR, but quality clicks, as conversion rate is good
Impressions Landing Page
Views
CTR Book Direct
Clicks
Conversion
Rate
643,642 1,704 .51%*22 1.29%
7/1-7/11/23
*.9% CTR benchmark
PUBLIC RELATIONS UPDATE
Public Relations + Paid Storytelling Update
We’ve Been Busy!! Last quarter we….
●Set up partnership and attended the Mexico media mission in Mexico
City
●Media outreach
○Pitching - securing stories
○Media visits - press trip + individual
●Influencer strategy - selects, contracts, travel, itineraries, hosting
●Blogger strategy - selects, contracts, travel, itineraries, hosting
●Monthly Destination Stewardship Program column Vail Daily
●Content development
○Michelin release
○Summer/fall events
○Media kit docs
PR Measurement
MEASURING PUBLIC RELATIONS
●Continue Current Efforts - comp set comparison, reach, number of clips,
message tracking, etc.
●Two Additional Measurements
○Secure at least two dozen stories that include DiscoverVail.com
○Secure at least two dozen stories or visits from media who
represent target media outlets.
PR Measurement
Q2 Comp Set Media Coverage
Vail Breckenridge Aspen
PR Measurement
Key Messages Total Reach
PR Measurement
New KPIs!
●Secure at least two dozen stories that include DiscoverVail.com
○Vail.com continues to be the prominent site that media reference.
●Secure at least two dozen stories or visits from media who represent
target media outlets.
○Placements in 18 target market publications (37 stories)
○Media visits from journalists representing 16 target market outlets
○Bonus Measurement! At least 17 target market publications
represented during NYC media mission.
Media Hosting
8 Domestic + International Visits in June
Paid Storytelling - Influencer Program
@jj.trailwalker
●Utah-based
●High authenticity score
●Followers: 200K
●Engagement Rate: 2.7% (1.4% higher
than similar influencers)
Paid Storytelling - Influencer Program
@through.the.llyns
●Arizona-based
●High authenticity score
●Followers: 155K
●Engagement Rate: 2.4% (average
similar influencers)
Paid Storytelling - Influencer Program
@theloverspassport
●California-based
●High authenticity score
●Followers: 390K
●Engagement Rate: 2% (1% higher
similar influencers)
Paid Storytelling - Blog Program
●Local Adventurer
○Domain authority - 57
○350K UVM
●The World Pursuit
○Domain authority - 50
○290K UVM
●The Travel Bite
○Domain authority - 54
○50K UVM
What’s Next?
●More hosting!
○15 media, blogger + influencer visits in July + August
●More pitching!
○Late summer/fall visits
○Support August/September Michelin announcement
○Fall media tipsheet
●More travel!
○Attend Travel Classics in Vancouver
GROUP SALES UPDATE
Groups in the Pipeline
YOY Leads up 43% from 2019 Pre-Covid
Pipeline Remains Strong - up 68% from 2019 Pre-Covid
Influx of Larger Group Programs
•US Healthcare - February 2024 - 2,610 RNs
•LoanDepot - March 2024 - 930 RNs
•Events by Miri - April 2027 - 2,200 RNs
•BMO Capital - March 2025 - 1,055 RNs
•IEEE - March 2025 - 2,867 RNs
•CO Judicial - September 2025 - 1,170 RNs
•Interski - April 2027 - 5,250 RNs - Vail Won the Opportunity to Bid
•Carecraft - February 2028 - 1,500 RNs
Groups on the Books
Group Bookings Remain Strong
YOY up 33% from 2022 in RN’s
YOY up 47% from 2022 in Room Revenue
Key Groups on the Books
•Yamaha - July 2023 - 955 RNs - $311,435 Revenue
•MT2030 - October 2023 - 325 RNs - $59,325 Revenue
•SMOS - December 2023 - 1,148 RNs - $235,692 Revenue
•National Ski Patrol - March 2024 - 1,641 RNs - $326,559 Revenue
•Encova - June 2024 - 1,039 RNs - $333,655 Revenue
•Mill Creek - June 2024 - 1,160 RNs - $349,100
Cvent - Groups Booked
Group Travel Trends
•Remote work wipes out 1-day events - booking destination
programs that are longer in duration
•Short lead times and conversation will continue in 2023
•Increase in event spending results in intense focus on cost savings
•Business travelers taking steps to reduce carbon footprint
•Millenials are the decision makers - tech savvy/social media
•Meetings with “purposeful” experiences, within a destination that
reinforces that purpose
•More strategic use of event data - analyzing ROI impact
•DEI & Health/Wellness still top of mind
TOV UPDATES
Thank you!
Upcoming Meetings:
VLMDAC Monthly Meeting, August 17, 2023, Grand View Room
BRAND PLATFORM WORKING SESSION
APPENDIX
Blog Performance
Six of the top 10 blogs have been newly written or recently optimized
●Users are spending time with the articles and staying on the site
Blog Performance
Highlights
#1
#1
“July in Vail”
“LGTBQ Vail”
DEI gap
#2
Blog Performance
Highlights
#2
“Vail Photo Spots”“Vail Hotel Bars”
“Vail hotel pools”
#3
#6
Blog Optimization
●Additional optimizations on existing blogs during June
■Only in Vail
■Yoga Offerings
■Scenic Gondola Rides
■Ditch Your Car
■Vail Golf Club
■Gold Medal Waters
■Easy Strolling
■What’s Open Vail