HomeMy WebLinkAbout01. VLMDAC October Meeting PresentationVLMDAC BOARD MEETING
OCTOBER 19, 2023
Agenda
I. MONTHLY FINANCIAL REPORT (5 minutes), Alex Jakubiec, Town of Vail
II. MINUTES APPROVAL
●Action Requested of Board
III. INFORMATION & DISCUSSION UPDATES
●Incremental & Events Media Plan (20 minutes), Miles Partnership
●Website Monthly Metrics (15 minutes), Miles Partnership
●Consent Management Platforms (10 minutes), Miles Partnership
●2024 Campaign (60 minutes), 970 Design / Lumenati
●2023 Budget Shifts (20 minutes), Liz Gladitsch
●Town of Vail Updates (5 minutes), Town of Vail
●Other Business
●Adjournment
FINANCE UPDATE
MINUTES APPROVAL
Minutes Approval
Action requested of board to approve the September 21 minutes.
EARLY WINTER MEDIA PLAN
Agenda
1.Lodging Campaign Insights
2.Media Brief
3.Tactical Overview + Strategy
4.Partner Details
5.Budget Overview
6.Next Steps
LODGING CAMPAIGN INSIGHTS
2022/23 Lodging Campaign Insights
●SEM is a bookings workhorse, bringing in efficient and qualified
traffic
●Display placements create important halo of awareness, but we
want to continue to find ways to hone in on key audiences
●Social media outlets provide an efficient driver of traffic
●Colorado.com inventory provides opportunity to efficiently reach an
audience already predisposed to Colorado
●Messaging should provide the ‘why to come’ - eg., event, activity -
not just lodging incentive
CAMPAIGN BRIEF
Objectives:
●Promote Vail lodging deals with the lead message of events
●Drive traffic to DiscoverVail.com/lodgingoffers
●Impact bookings for November 10th - December 17th
Timing:
●October 30th - December 10th, 2023
Budget:
●Available Budget: $118,000
○Early Winter recommendation: $75,900
○Remaining: $42,100
Audience:
●Travel Intenders
●High Net Worth Empty Nesters
●High Net Worth Families
Media Brief
STRATEGY + TACTICAL OVERVIEW
Overall Media Strategy
●Consolidate vendors and streamline dollars to create cost
efficiencies and collect accurate first-party data by merging
campaign efforts to establish a more holistic media plan
●Tap into media partners with key search and booking data to
capture users as they are actively planning their travels
○Opportunity to competitively conquest users who are
searching/booking for other mountain destinations
Geographic Targeting
IN-STATE
Colorado
DRIVE/FLY
Dallas
Kansas City
New Mexico (Statewide)
Phoenix
Shift in market emphasis to focus on non-competitor drive/fly markets to
maximize impact
Campaign Tactics
Paid Social
Digital
FB/IG CAROUSEL +
STATIC ADS
DISPLAY
SEM
GOOGLE TEXT ADS
FB/IG VIDEO + POLL
ADS
Partner Overview
PARTNER TACTIC CAMPAIGN OPTIMIZATION KPI
Adara Display Prospecting
Primary: Engagement Rate
Secondary: Click-Through Rate
Landing Page Visits
Site Engagement
Book Direct ClicksColorado.com Display Prospecting
Google Paid Search Primary: Engagement Rate
Secondary: Click-Through Rate
Book Direct Clicks
Facebook/Instagram Paid Social Reach
Book Direct Clicks
BUDGET OVERVIEW AND FLOWCHART
Campaign Flowchart
INCREMENTAL & EARLY SEASON MEDIA PLAN
2023 Q4 Media Recommendations
1.Incremental Media Plan
○Planning Parameters
○Tactical Overview + Strategy
○Partner Details
○Flowchart
2.Events Media Plan
○Planning Parameters
○Tactical Overview + Strategy
○Flowchart
INCREMENTAL MEDIA PLAN
Timing:
●November 6 - December 31, 2023
Budget:
●$48,934
Audience:
●Travel Intenders
●High Net Worth Empty Nesters
●High Net Worth Families
●Competitive Conquesting
Planning Parameters
Overall Media Strategy
●Continue awareness efforts through the end of the year via an
extension of the Early Winter media campaign and select
tactics
●Tap into media partners with key search and booking data to
capture users as they are actively planning their travels
○Opportunity to competitively conquest users who are
searching/booking for other mountain destinations
Geographic Targeting
IN-STATE
Colorado
DRIVE/FLY
Dallas
Kansas City
New Mexico (Statewide)
Phoenix
Targeting will mirror Early Winter in order to maintain a presence in those markets
Campaign Tactics
Paid Social
Digital
FB/IG CAROUSEL +
STATIC ADS
Navigator
SEM*
GOOGLE TEXT ADS
FB/IG VIDEO + POLL
ADS TIKTOK
*Covered by Always On campaign budgeted for Early Winter
Partner Overview
PARTNER TACTIC CAMPAIGN OPTIMIZATION KPI
Ink-Global Navigator (Display)
Primary: Engagement Rate
Secondary: Click-Through Rate
Landing Page Visits
Site Engagement
Book Direct Clicks
Google Paid Search Book Direct Clicks
Facebook/Instagram Paid Social Reach
Book Direct Clicks
TikTok Paid Social Reach
Competitive
Conquesting
Navigator Display
●Target Vail campaigns to travelers either actively searching for
Colorado flights OR competing destinations via United Airlines booking
data
●Audiences include users searching for flights into Eagle + DEN as well
as competitive destinations
○Ex. Snowmass Village, Aspen, Avon, Breck
●Ads are served to users across Facebook/Instagram and TikTok using
United’s audience data
●Total impressions: 1,250,000
Campaign Flowchart
Creative Execution
EVENTS MEDIA PLAN
Objectives
●Support early Winter events - Revely and Vail Holidays - locally and in
the front range
●Drive visitation to Vail for early season events
●Drive traffic to DiscoverVail.com/events
Timing:
●November 10 - December 31, 2023
Markets
●Vail
●Front Range
Audience:
●Vail locals
●Front Range residents
Budget:
●$15,000
Planning Parameters
RADIO
Campaign Tactics
Paid Social
Digital
FB/IG CAROUSEL +
STATIC ADS
DISPLAY
FB/IG VIDEO + POLL
ADS
Traditional
EBLASTS SPONSORED
CONTENT
Partner Overview
PARTNER TACTIC CAMPAIGN OPTIMIZATION KPI
KZYR-FM (97.7 FM)
Radio n/a Reach
KKVM-FM (104.7 FM)
5280
Display
Primary: Engagement Rate
Secondary: Click-Through Rate
Landing Page Visits
Site Engagement
Book Direct ClicksSponsored Content
Eblasts Primary: Open Rate
Secondary: Click-Through Rate
Landing Page Visits
Site Engagement
Book Direct Clicks
Facebook/Instagram Paid Social Primary: Engagement Rate
Secondary: Click-Through Rate
Reach
Book Direct Clicks
Campaign Flowchart
MONTHLY WEBSITE METRICS
Why Organic?
●Largest source of traffic
●Most valuable source of traffic
●Most engaged source of traffic
●Endorsement and measurement of our content quality
Organic Performance
●Nearly 33% of users found our
website via organic search
●43% of all conversions were from
organic, generating nearly 10,000
partner/lodging clicks
Source: Google Analytics 4
September ‘23 compared to September ‘22
●Avg 1m 10s per session, 76% of
sessions are engaged
●Higher quality content drives longer
time on site for an engaged visitor
Organic Performance
●50% growth in clicks YoU, up to
25,933
●66% growth in impressions YoU,
up to 1.6M
●Ranked Keywords up 130%
Source: Google Analytics 4
September ‘23 compared to September ‘22
●Of the top 10 trafficked Blog posts
in September, 7 were optimized
within the last 9 months
Search Performance
●Over 48% of users found our
website if we broaden to general
search
●81% of all conversions were from
search, generating nearly 17,328
partner/lodging clicks
●Avg 1m 20s per session, 76% of
sessions are engaged
Source: Google Analytics 4
September ‘23 compared to September ‘22
CONSENT MANAGEMENT PLATFORMS
Data Privacy
●Due to new privacy regulations, data privacy is becoming an essential part
of revenue and customer success.
●When do data privacy practices impact your team?
○Under laws like the GDPR (EU), CPRA (CA), and CDPA (VA) collecting
data without the proper data privacy practices in place can put your
company at risk.
●Your business is subject to different data privacy laws based on where
your lead is coming from.
○Tracking visitors by region will help you prepare for compliance early.
Consent Management
●50+ countries (and growing) have visitor consent laws, but each country has
its own nuances about what constitutes consent.
●Osano automatically displays and enforces the correct consent requirement
based on the geolocation of each website visitor.
Data Protection and Privacy Legislation Worldwide
There is currently no federal law, but States are passing their own rules.
What Does it Entail?
●We have integration for WordPress
○Documented install procedure for WordPress sites (plugin + code)
●Installing this enables us to gather the scripts, cookies, iframes that are
currently loading.
○We will first do this in listen mode to not affect the site.
●Then, we go into Osano to configure and group together the scripts.
○Categorize scripts into Analytics, Essential, Marketing, Personalization,
other.
●Afterwards, reconfigure the tags in Google Tag Manager to adhere to user
preferences.
Why Osano and Why Now?
●Osano offers a variety of benefits over OneTrust/CookieBot. Here are a
handful that drove our decision to partner with Osano over other solutions.
○DSAR Management
○Vendor Management
○Policy Change Detection
●Beyond legal requirements, there will be a significant impact to marketing
insights without a CMP implementation.
○Google will soon no longer allow advertisers to collect consent
directly from users.
○Using a CMP allows us to maintain access to aggregated data like user
clicks on ad, demographic info, and interest data – and even in some
instances where a user denied consent since the data isn’t tied to an
individual user.
○Without an CMP integration, we will not have access to any of that data or
insights once fully rolled out by Google.
Consent Management Budget
●Shift $7,500 from Branding & Production (6300.55.22) to Website
(6300.55.21)
●Branding & Production costs were lower than expected in CY2023
●Shift is requested to cover the following costs associated with Osano
implementation and setup
○$450 partial license for Q4 2023
○Setup, audit, classification of tags (one time)
○Activate Google Consent Mode (one time)
○Ongoing maintenance
2024 CAMPAIGN
2024 Campaign Update
Update to be presented in person at the meeting
2023 BUDGET SHIFTS
2023 Budget Shifts
The following items are shift requests that we will bring to Town Council on
November 6 in addition to 2024 budget approval.
Requesting approval and discussion from VLMDAC
Budget Shifts
Account Name 2023 Shift
Request
Shift Reasoning
Advertising Agent
Fees
25,760 Agency fees more accurately represent work.
Shift from Branding and Production
Email Marketing 3,480 Savings
Photo/Video 187,200 Miscode moving from website
Website (157,680)Miscode moving to photo/video + Osano
Branding/
Production
(23,040)Shift to Advertising Agency Fees
Social (28,760)Savings
TOTAL Net 0
TOV UPDATES
Thank you!
Upcoming Meetings:
VLMDAC Monthly Meeting, November 16, 2023, Grand View Room