HomeMy WebLinkAboutVAIL DAS SCHONE FILING 2 BLOCK H LOT 12 LEGAL••fiLE COpy
Department of Community Development
75 South Frontage Road
Vail.Colorado 81657
970-479-2138
FAX 970-479-2452
www.ci.vail.co .us
Ma y 17,2001
JohnMartin ,AlA
P .O.Box621
Vail ,CO 81658
Re:Ment/ik Residence -Lot 12,BlockH ,VailDas Schone #2/2437 GarmlschDrive
Dear John:
On Monday,May 14,2001 ,thePlanningand Environmental Commission votedto approve the variance
requestforsnowstorageinthe right-of-way at2437GarmischDrive.Thevariance request for parking in
the right-of-way wasdeniedduetothe availability of architectural alternatives,which would allowaU of
therequired parking tobelocatedwithinpropertyboundaries .
On Wednesday,May16,2001 ,theDesignReviewBoardvoted unanimously to approve thefinal
proposal fortheMentlikresidence .Therewerefourconditionsofapproval :
I .That the garage shownonth e southelevationbefacedwithstoneuptothedeckrails;
2 .That the driveway entrancebereduced to 24feetattheedge of GarmischDrive:
3 .That a revocable right-of-way permitberequiredforthelandscaping ,driveway ,concretepan,and
snow storage tobelocatedintheTownright-of-way;and
4 .That stamped engineering drawings berequiredforretainingwallsbetween4and6feettall.
These conditions mustbeaddressedprior to applyingforabuildingpermit.Ifyouhaveany questions or
concerns,pleasedonot hesitate to contact meat479-2148or ak jerulfrfi)eLyail .co.us.
Sincerely,
Ann Kjerulf
Planner II1GIS Specialist
Town of Vail
o RECYCLEDPAPER
•
TOWN
Project Name:Mentlik Res idence
Project Description:
•
Design Review Board
ACTION FORM
Department of Community Development
75 South Frontage Road,Vail,Colorado 81657
tel:970.479.2139 fax:970.479.2452
web :www.ci.vail.co.us
DRB Number:DRB010047
Newsingle-family residence
Participants:
OWNER WILLIAM L.MENTUK
600SouthAvenueWest
Westfield,NJ
07090
License:
APPLICANT JOHN G.MARTIN AlA
PO Box621
Vail,CO
81658
License:
Project Address:2437 GARMISH DRVAIL
03/15/2001 Phone:908-518-6305
03/15/2001 Phone:477-2476
Location:
Legal Description:Lot:12Block:HSubdivision:VAIL DAS SCHONE FIL2
Parcel Number:210311413008
Comments:
BOARD/STAFF ACTION
Motion By:BillPierce
SecondBy:Charlie Acevedo
Vote:4-0
Conditions:
Action:APPROVED
Date of Approval:05/17/2001
Cond:CON0004728
Thatthegarageshownonthesouthelevationbefacedwithstoneuptothedeck
rails
Cond:CON0004729
Thatthedrivewayentrancebe reduced to24feetattheedgeof Garmisch Drive
Cond:CON0004730
Thata revocable right -of-way permitberequiredforthe landscaping,driveway,
concretepan,andsnowstoragetobelocatedintheTownright-of-way
Cond :CON0004731
Thatstampedengineeringdrawings be requiredforretainingwallsbetween4and6
feettall
Cond:0
(PLAN):DRB approvaldoesnotconstitute apermitforbuilding.Please consultwith
TownofVailBuilding personnel priortoconstructionactivities.
Planner:AnnKjerulf DRBFeePaid:$200.00
~.
•DESIGNREVIEW BOARD AGEND!'
Wednesday,May 16,2001
3:00 P.M.
PUBLICMEETINGRESULTS
PUBLIC WELCOME
PROJECT ORIENTATION I LUNCH-Community Development Department 12:00 pm
MEMBERS PRESENT
Clark Brittain
BillPierce
HansWoldrich
CharlesS.Acevedo
MEMBERS ABSENT
AndyBlumetti
SITEVISITS
1.DauphinaisResidence-1936W .GoreCreekDrive
2 .SunVail Condos -655N.FrontageRoad
3.Summers LodgeCondos-123WillowPlace
4.All Seasons Condos -434GoreCreekDrive
5 .GoldenPeak-458VailValleyDrive
2:00 pm
Driver:Allison
PUBLICHEARING-TOWNCOUNCILCHAMBERS 3 :00 pm
1.EdelweissCondos-Finalreviewofproposedroofingmater ial.Brent
103 Willow Place ,Edelweiss Condomin iums/Lot 4 ,Block6 ,VailVillage1st Filing .
Applicant:Edelwe iss CondoAssociation ,representedbyNedbo Construction
MOTION :Bill Pierce SECOND:Charlie AcevedoVOTE:4-0
TABLED UNTIL JUNE 6 ,2001
2 .Summers LodgeCondos-Final reviewofproposedroofingmaterial.Bill
123Wi llow Place/Lot5,Block6,VailV illage 1st Filing.
Applicant:SummersLodgeCondoAssoc.,representedbyRickHalterman
MOT ION:Bill PierceSECOND :HansWoldrichVOTE:4-0
TABLED UNTIL JUNE 6,2001
3.SunVailCondos-Finalreviewofproposedrepaintwithcolorchange.Bill
655N.FrontageRd.lLot9 ,Block2,VailPotatoPatch
Applicant:SunVa il Homeowner'sAssociation,representedbyKentKrohlow
MOTION:BillPierce SECOND :Charlie Acevedo VOTE:3-0(Woldrich recused)
CONSENT APPROVEDWITHONECONDITION:
1.Approvedinaccordancewiththesubmittedpaintchipsamples ,notthepaintsample
appliedtothebuilding .
1
••'-.,
4,All Seasons Condos -Final review ofproposedroofingmateria ls andrepaint.
434Gore Creek Drive/Lot B ,Block3 ,VailVillage51h Filing.
Applicant:All Seasons Condominium Association
MOTION:BillPierceSECOND :Hans Woldrich VOTE:4-0
APPROVED WITHONE CONDITION
Bill
1.Approved in accordance withthe submitted tarandgravelroofandbrown metal
fascia sample .Theredtrimcoloris approved in accordance withthe submitted paint
chip sample.
5 .MenUik residence -Final review ofnew single-family residence
2437 Garmisch Drive/Lot 12 ,BlockH,Vaildas Schone Filing2
Appl icant:WilliamL.Mentlik,represented byJohnG .Martin
MOTION:BillPierceSECOND :Charlie Acevedo VOTE :4-0
APPROVED WITH4 CONDITIONS:
Ann
1 .That thegarageshownonthesouth elevation befacedwith stone uptothedeck
rails;
2 .That the driveway entrance bereducedto24feetattheedgeofGarm isch Drive;
3 .That a revocable right-of-way permitberequiredforthe landscaping,driveway,
concrete pan,and snow storagetobelocated inthe Town right-of-way;and
4 ,That stamped engineering draw ings berequiredforretaining walls between 4and6
feettall.
6.Lazier residence -Final review ofa new single family residence andEHU .
1290 Westhaven Circle /Lot26,GlenLyon Subdivision .
Applicant:Buddy &KeraLazier ,represented by William Reslock
MOTION:BillPierceSECOND :Charlie Acevedo VOTE :4-0
CONSENT APPROVED WITH 2 CONDITIONS:
1.No outside comer materialchangesareallowed.
Bill
2 .Add10aspentrees,6to8feetinheight ,inthearea between thehouseand driveway.
7 .Petrus residence -Final review ofnewsinglefamily residence withEHU .Bill
84 Beaver Dam Road/Lot 28 ,Block7 ,VailVillage 1s1 Filing.
Applicant:Petrus Management,represented by JMP Arch itects
MOTION:BillPierceSECOND :Hans Woldrich VOTE :3-0 (Acevedo recused)
CONSENT APPROVED WITH3 CONDITIONS:
1.Resolve retainingwall height issueswithstaff;
2 .Meet all Public Works Department requirements;
3.In lieuof low level plantings,provide 10sprucetrees,8to12feet inheight,inthefront
ofthesitewiththe intent ofscreeningtheviewof vehicles parkinginthedriveway.
2
8.
9 .
10.
GoldenPeak-cleptual reviewofproposedaddition e
458E.VailValleyDrivefTractF,Block3,VailVillage5th Filing
Applicant:VailResortsDevelopmentCompany,representedbyPatrickHim
CONCEPTUAL -NOVOTE
Daupinaisresidence-Conceptualreviewofnew single-family &TypeIEHU.
1936WestGoreCreekDrive/Lot1,StraussSubdivision.
Applicant:PatDauph inais
CONCEPTUAL -NOVOTE
Red Sandstone Athletic Field -Finalreviewofproposed athletic field .
610N.FrontageRd.WestlA portionof Tract C,VailPotatoPatch .
Applicant:TownofVail ,representedbyGreggBarrie
MOTION :BillPierceSECOND :CharlieAcevedoVOTE :4-0
APPROVED
Ann
Allison
Allison
11.VailValleyMedicalCenter-FinalreviewofproposedPhaseIadditions .George
181 West Meadow Drive/LotsE &F,VailVillage2nd Filing.
Applicant:VailValleyMedicalCenter,representedbyBraun Associates
MOTION:BillPierceSECOND :CharlieAcevedoVOTE :3-0 (Woldrich gone)
TABLED UNTILJUNE6,2001
Staff Approvals
VailGloLodge-Replacefiberglassswimmingpoolwith smaller fiberglasspool.Ann
701W .LionsheadCircle/Lot1,Block2 ,VailLionsheadFiling3.
Applicant:Maximum Comfort PoolandSpa
Fleischer residence-Changestoapproveddeckdesign .Bill
1765WestGoreCreekDrive ,EastUnit/Lot7VailVillageWest2nd
.
Applicant:Chad Fleischer
Manartres idence -Frontentrychange ,newdeckrailings,newgaragedoor.Ann
2945MannsRanchRd /Lot4-B ,Block1,VailVillage13th Filing.
Applicant:FrankC .Manart
Tyler residence -Additionofbaywindow.Allison
433GoreCreekDr.I Lot7VailTrailsEast.
Applicant:Tim &NancyTyler
Hormel residence -Additionofpatioarea,2hottubs,additional landscaping .Allison
1527VailValleyDr./Lot10,Block3,VailValley1st Filing.
Applicant:Geo .A.Hormel &CO
LaBottega-Additionofoperablewindows .Allison
100E Meadow Dr./VailVillagePlazaCondominiums.
Applicant:Jamm LTD .
Vail Chamber of Commerce -Temporary directionalsignageforVillageandLionshead .Russ
241E.Meadow Dr/VailVillageandLionshead.
Applicant:TownofVail
3
BrandessBuilding-Installatio!f air conditioning unit.
2077N.FrontageRd.!Lot39 ,BufferCreekSubdivision.
Applicant:DentalCenterofVail,PC
Wh ite residence-Additionofsp lit railfence.
1833LionsridgeLoop !Lot4 ,Block3,Lion's RidgeSubdivision .
App licant:Kenneth L.&KathrynWhite
Billingsley residence-Addressmonument.
1170PtarmiganRd.!Lot3 ,Block7 ,VailVillageFiling7.
Applicant:LucyC.Billingsley
Timber FallsCondos-Installation ofbaywindowonunit#404.
4496 E.MeadowDr.!Timber FallsCondominiums
Applicant:CarolynBrown
Dikeouresidence -Change i ndormer.
352BeaverDamRd.!Lot5 ,Block3,VailVillageFiling3 .
Applicant:Gwathmey,Pratt ,Schultz ,Architects
•Allison
Allison
Allison
Ann
Allison
The applications andinformationabouttheproposalsareavailableforpublicinspectionduring
regularofficehoursintheprojectplanner'soffice,locatedattheTownofVailCommunity
Development Department ,75SouthFrontageRoad .Pleasecall479-2138for i nformation.
Signlanguageinterpretationavailableuponrequestwith24hournotification.Pleasecall479-
2356 ,TelephonefortheHearingImpaired,forinformation .
4
••
Planning and Environmental Commission
ACTION FORM
Department of Community Development
75 South Frontage Road,Vail,Colorado 81657
tel:970 .479 .2139 fax:970.479.2452
web:www .ci.vail.co.u5
Project Name:Mentlik Variance Request
Project Description:
PEC Number:PEC010032
Request for variance fromTitle14toallowforsnowstorageintheright-of-way.
Participants:
OWNER WILLIAM L.MENTLIK
600 South Avenue West
Westfield,NJ
07090
License:
APPLICANT JOHN G.MARTIN AlA
PO Box 621
Vail,CO
81658
License:
Project Address:2437 GARMISH DRVAIL
04/17/2001 Phone:908-518-6305
04/17/2001 Phone:477-2476
Location:
LegalDescription:Lot:12Block:HSubdivision:VAIL DAS SCHONE FIL2
Parcel Number:210311413008
Comments:
BOARD/STAFFACTION
MotionBy:John Schofield
SecondBy:Doug cahill
Vote:6-0
Conditions:
Cond:CON0004732
Thatadequate screening be provided.
Planner:AnnKjerulf
Action:APPROVED
DateofApproval:05/17/2001
PECFeePaid:$250.00
••
Planning and Environmental Commission
ACTION FORM
Department of Community Development
75 South Frontage Road,Vail,Colorado 81657
tel:970.479.2139 fax:970.479.2452
web:www.ci .vail.co .us
Project Name:Mentlik Variance Request
Project Description:
PEC Number:PEC010038
Request forvariancefromTitle14toallowforparking intheright-of-way.
Participants:
APPLICANT JOHN G.MARTIN AIA04/17/2001 Phone:477-2476
PO Box 621
Vail,CO
81658
License:
OWNER MACLEAN,JOHN &CAROL FAMILY05/17/2001 Phone:
11 MAIN ST
CLEBURNETX
76031
Project Address:2437 GARMISH DR VAIL Location:
Legal Description:Lot:12Block:HSubdivision:VAIL DAS SCHONE FIL2
Parcel Number:210311413008
Comments:
BOARD/STAFF ACTION
Motion By:John SChofield
SecondBy:Doug Cahill
Vote:6-0
Conditions:
Planner:AnnKjerulf
Action:DENIED
Date of Approval:
PECFeePaid:$0.00
PLANNINGAND ENVIRONMENTAL COMMISSION
Monday,May14,2001
PROJECTORIENTATION 1-Community Development Dept.PUBLIC WELCOME
,,•
PUBLICMEETINGRESULTS
•
11:30am
MEMBERSPRESENT
DianeGolden
JohnSchofield
DougCahill
GalenAasland
DickCleveland
Site Visits:
MEMBERSABSENT
BrianDoyon
12:45pm
1.VailPlazaHotelWest-13VailRoad
2.VailValleyMedicalCenter-181WestMeadowDrive
3.StraussSubdivision-1916 &1936WestGoreCreekDrive
4.Mentlikresidence-2437GarmischDrive
5.VailRacquetClub-4695VailRacquetClubDrive
Driver:George
NOTE:IfthePEChearingextendsuntil6:00p.m.,theboardmaybreakfor dinner from6:00 -6:30
p.m.
Public Hearing -Town Council Chambers 2:00pm
1.ArequestforavariancefromSection12-6D-10oftheTownCode ,to allow forareductionin
thelandscapingandsitedevelopmentrequirements,locatedat383BeaverDamRoad/Lot3,
Block3,VailVillage3'd Filing.
Applicant:A2ZHoldings,LLC
Planner:BillGibson
MOTION:JohnSchofieldSECOND:DickClevelandVOTE :6-0
APPROVED
2 .Arequestforafinalreviewofaproposedspecialdevelopmentdistrict,toallowforthe
constructionofanewconferencefacility/hotel;andafinalreviewofaconditionalusepermit,
toallowforTypeIIIemployeehousingunitsandfractionalfeeclubun its,locatedat13Vail
Road/LotsA ,B,C,Block2,VailVillageFiling2.
Applicant:
Planner :
DoramarHotels,representedbytheDaymerCorporation
BrentWilson
1 ~TOW~
SPECIAL DEVELOPMENT DISTRICTREQUEST
MOTION :JohnSchofieldSECOND:ChasBemhardtVOTE:5-1 (Clevelandopposed)
••,
RECOMMENDATION OF APPROVAL WITHCONDITIONS:
1.Thatthe developer submitsthefollowingplanstothe Department of Community
Developmentforreviewandapprovalasapartofthebuildingpermit application for
thehotel:
a.AnErosionControlandSedimentationPlan;
b.AConstructionStagingandPhasingPlan;
c .A Stormwater ManagementPlan;
d.ASiteDewateringPlan;
e.ATrafficControlPlan;
f.ASpraddleCreekroutingandcontainmentplan;and
g .Anenvironmentalauditincludingsoilsandstream conditions (duringexcavation).
2.Thatthedeveloperprovidesdeed-restrictedhousingthatcomplieswiththeTownof
VailEmployeeHousingrequirements(Chapter12-13)foraminimumof28
employees,andthatsaiddeed-restrictedhousingbemadeavailableforoccupancy,
andthatthedeedrestrictionsarerecordedwiththeEagleCountyClerk &Recorder,
priortorequestingaTemporaryCertificateofOccupancyfortheVailPlazaHotel
West.
3.ThatthedevelopersubmitsafinaldetailedlandscapeplantotheCommunity
DevelopmentDepartmentforDesignReviewBoardreviewandapprovalpriorto
makinganapplicationforabuildingpermit.Thisplanwillinvolvetheremovalofthe
obsoletedeliverybayasphaltfortheChateauVailontheNineVailRoadproperty.
4 .Thatthedevelopersubmitsacompletesetof civil engineer drawingsforalloff-site
improvements,includingtheimprovementstotheSouthFrontageRoadandWest
MeadowDriveforreviewandTownapprovalpriorto application forabuilding .permit.
5.ThatthedevelopersubmitsacompletesetofplanstotheColoradoDepartmentof
Transportationforreview andapprovalofarevised access permit,priorto
applicationforabuildingpermit.
6.ThatthedevelopermeetswiththeTown staff toprepareamemorandumof
understandingoutliningtheresponsibilitiesand requirements oftherequiredoff-site
improvements,priortofirstreadingofanordinanceapprovingthespecial
development district.Thisincludesstreetscaping improvements alongSouth
FrontageRoadandWestMeadowDriveinaccordancewiththeTownofVail
Streetscape MasterPlan,asamended .
7.ThatthedeveloperrecordsaneasementforSpraddleCreek .Theeasementshallbe
preparedbythedeveloperandsubmittedforreviewandapprovaloftheTown
Attomey.TheeasementshallberecordedwiththeEagleCountyClerk &Recorder's
OfficepriortotheissuanceofaTemporaryCertificateofOccupancy.
8.Thatthedevelopersubmitsafinalexteriorbuildingmaterialslist,atypicalwall
sectionandcompletecolorrenderingsforreviewandapprovaloftheDesignReview
Board,priortomakinganapplicationforabuildingpermit.
9 .ThatthedevelopersubmitsacomprehensivesignprogramproposalfortheVail
PlazaHotelWestforreviewandapprovaloftheDesignReviewBoard,priortothe
issuanceofaTemporaryCertificateofOccupancy.
2
••
10.Thatthedevelopersubmitsarooftopmechanicalequipment planforreview and
approvaloftheDesignReviewBoardpriortotheissuanceofabuildingpermit.All
rooftopmechanicalequipmentshallbeincorporatedintotheoveralldesignofthe
hotelandenclosedandscreenedfrompublic view.
11.Thatthedeveloperpostsabondtoprovidefinanc ial securityforthe150%ofthetotal
costoftherequiredoff-sitepublicimprovements.Thebondshallbeinplacewiththe
Townpriortothe issuanceofabuildingpermit.
12.Thatthedevelopereitherreceivesapprovalfromtheneighboringowner's
associationstoallowforconstructionact ivities onneighboringpropertiesorsubmits
aconstruct ion stagingandlimits ofdisturbance planthat indicatesallofthese
activitieswilloccurontheapplicant'sproperty .
13.Thatthedeveloperprovidesaccess(viaapermanent ,legallybinding easement
agreement)fortheNineVailRoadAssociationandgueststoenterthe subject
propertyfromVailRoadandexitacrossthesubjectpropertyfromthelocationofNine
VailRoad's surfaceparkingareatoSouthFrontageRoad.Thisis necessary to
facilitatetheapplicant'sproposedtrafficcirculationplan.
14.ThattheapplicantsubmitscivildrawingstodeterminecompliancewithallTownof
VailengineeringrequirementspriortofinalDesignReviewBoardapproval.
15.PursuanttoSection 12-7A-14,TownofVailCode ,theapplicantshallpayroad
impactfeesinanamountthatisdirectlyproportionatetotheanticipatednewroad
impactsgeneratedbythisdevelopment($5000perpeakhourtripend).A specific
amountforroadimpactfeeswillbedeclared(andadoptedviaa memorandum of
understanding),basedupontheanticipatednewroadimpactsoutlinedinthe
applicant'strafficstudy .Thisdollaramountwillbeputinescrowonceabuilding
permitisissued .Anyactual improvements constructed tothefrontageroadwillbe
cred ited againstthetotal.Theescroweddollarswillbeheldforaperiodof10years
fromtimeofpermitissuance.Ifandwhenanysortoffundingmechan ism isputin
place(suchasaspecialdistrictwhichthis development participatesin)anydollars
generatedfromthedevelopmentwillbeoffsetbytheamountowed.Ifthereisan
excessitwillberefunded.Anyshortfallwillbemadeupbytheescroweddollars.
16.Thattheapplicantcomplieswithallfire department stagingandaccess requirements
pursuanttoTitle14(DevelopmentStandards),VailTownCode .Thiswillbe
demonstratedonasetofrevisedplansfortownreviewandapproval prior tobuilding
permitsubmittal.
17.ThattherequiredTypeIII deed-restricted employeehousingunitsshallnotbeeligible
forresaleandthattheunitsbeownedandoperatedbythehotelandthatsaid
ownership transfer w ith thedeedtothehotel property.
1B.Thatthe developer coordinatestherelocation oftheexistingelectric transformers on
thepropertywithlocalutilityproviders.Therevisedlocationofthe transformers will
bepartofthefinallandscapeplantobesubm itted forreviewandapprovalbythe
DesignReviewBoard.
19.Priortofirstreadingofanordinanceadopting aspecialdevelopmentdistrictforthe
property,thedevelopershallresolvetheguestexitdrivealignment tothe satisfaction
ofthetownengineer.
20.Withintheparametersoftheapprovedbuildingenvelope ,anadditionalcommon
employeestorageareamustbeprovided .
3
••
VOTE:5-2 (Schofield &
Clevelandopposed)
21 .Anadditionalsix inchesofheight(perstorey)maybeaddedalongtheSouth
FrontageRoadw ing withinLevels4andabove.
CONDITIONAL USEPERMIT-FRACTIONAL FEE CLUB UNITS
MOTION :JohnSchofieldSECOND :ChasBernhardtVOTE:6-0
APPROVEDWITHONECONDITION:
1.Theapprovalofthisconditionalusepermitisnotvalidunlessanord inance
approvingtheassociatedspecial development districtrequestisapprovedon
secondreading .
CONDITIONAL USEPERMIT-EMPLOYEE HOUSINGUNITS
MOTION :JohnSchofieldSECOND :Chas Bemhardt VOTE:6-0
APPROVEDWITHONECONDITION:
1.Thattheapplicantrecordsapplicabledeedrestrictionsforallemployee
housingunitswiththeEagleCountyClerk &Recorderpriortothe issuance of
aTemporary Certificate ofOccupancyfortheVailPlazaHotel West.
3 .Arequestforafinal review ofaconditionalusepermit ,toallowforthe construction ofPhase
IofDonovanPark improvements,generallylocatedsoutheastofthe intersectionof
MatterhomCircleandtheSouthFrontageRoad.
Applicant:TownofVail
Planner:GeorgeRuther
MOTION :ChasBemhardtSECOND :DougCahill
APPROVEDWITHONECONDITION:
1.Thattheheightofthepavilionshallnotexceed38.5feet.
4 .ArequestforavariancefromTitle14(DevelopmentStandards),VailTownCode ,toallow
forsnowstorageandparkingwith in thepublicright-of-way ,locatedat2437Garm isch Drive I
Lot12,BlockH,VaildasSchone2nd Filing.
Applicant:
Planner:
WilliamH.Mentlik,representedbyJohnMartin,AlA
AnnKjerulf
VARIANCE-SNOWSTORAGEINTHERIGHT-OF-WAY:
MOTION:JohnSchofield SECOND:DougCahill
APPROVEDWITHONECONDITION :
1.Thatadequatescreeningbeprovided.
VARIANCE-PARKINGINTHERIGHT-OF-WAY:
MOTION:JohnSchofield SECOND:DougCahill
VOTE :6-0
VOTE:6-0
DENIED-DUETOTHE AVAILABILITY OF ARCHITECTURAL ALTERNATIVES WHICH
WOULD SOLVETHEPARKINGPROBLEM
4
••\5.Arequestforaminor subdiv ision andavariancefromSection12-6D-5oftheTownCodeto
allowfortheresubdivisionofLot1,StraussSubdivision,aresubdivisionofLots46 &47,
VailVillageWestFilingNo.2,re-creatingLots46 &47,locatedat1916 &1936WestGore
CreekDrive.
Applicant:
Planner:
PatDauphina is,represent ing RichardStrauss
AllisonOchs
TABLED UNTILJUNE11,2001
6 .Arequestforaconditionaluse penmit ,toallowforanaddition totheVailValleyMedical
Center,locatedat181WestMeadowDrive/LotsE &F,VailVillage2 nd Filing.
Applicant:VailValleyMedicalCenter,representedbyBraun Associates
Planner :GeorgeRuther
MOTION:JohnSchofieldSECOND:ChasBernhardtVOTE :6-0
APPROVEDWITHTHREECONDITIONS:
1.Thattheapplicantsubmitsafinallandscapeplanand exterior lightingplantothe
CommunityDevelopmentDepartmentforthereview andapprovaloftheDesignReview
Boardpriortotherequestforabuildingpermit.
2 .ThattheapplicantreturnstothePlanning &Environmental Commission withan
applicationforanamendedconditionalusepermitaddress ing theproposeduseofthe
firstfloorspacepr ior requestingabuilding penmit foratenantfinishofthatspace .
3.Thatthe penmit expires5/31/03andtheapplicantmustreturnpriorto5/31/03toprovide
additionalparking.
7.Arequestforaworksessiontodiscuss anewspecialdevelopmentdistrict,to allow forthe
redevelopment oftheVail Racguet Club ,locatedat4695VailRacquetClub DrivelVail Racquet
ClubCondominiums,Bighorn5 h Addition.
Applicant:
Planner:
RacquetClubOwnersAssociation ,representedbyFritzlenPierce Architects.
BrentWilson
WORK SESSION-NOVOTE
8.Arequestforaworksessiontodiscussamendingcertainresidentialzonedistrictsinthe
TownofVailtoallowhomedaycarefacilitiessubjecttotheissuanceofaconditionaluse
permitandahomeoccupation penmit.
Applicant:
Planner :
TownofVail
GeorgeRuther
WORK SESSION-NOVOTE
9 .ArequestforthereviewofaproposedtextamendmenttoChapter11,DesignReview ,of
theZoningRegulationstoallowforproceduralchangestotheperfonmancebondprocessas
prescribedintheVailTownCode.
Applicant:
Planner:
TownofVail
GeorgeRuther
TABLED UNTILJUNE11,2001
5
Arequestforaconditionalusepermit,toallowfortheconstructionofa soccer field,located
at610N.FrontageRd.Westl AportionofTractC,VailPotatoPatch .Afullmetes &bounds
legaldescriptionisavailableattheDepartmentofCommunity Development.
10.
Applicant:
Planner:
•
TownofVail
AllisonOchs
•,
TABLED TOJUNE11,2001
11.ArequestforavariancefromSection 12-60.6 (Setbacks),VailTownCode,toallowforthe
constructionofagaragewithintherequiredfrontsetback,locatedat1956GoreCreekDrive
/Lot45,VailVillageWestFiling#2 .
Applicant:
Planner:
DavidIrwin
AnnKjerulf
TABLED TOJUNE11,2001
12.ArequestforavariancefromSection12-7H-10oftheVailTownCode,toallowforaproposed
additionintherearsetback,locatedat660WestLionsheadPlace/Lot1,VailLionshead 1st
Filing.
Applicant:
Planner:
WITHDRAWN
LionsSquareCondoAssociation
BillGibson
13.ApprovalofApril23,2001minutes
14.InformationUpdate
Theapplicationsandinformationabouttheproposalsareavailableforpublicinspectionduring
regularofficehoursintheprojectplanner'sofficelocatedattheTownofVail Community
DevelopmentDepartment ,75SouthFrontageRoad.Pleasecall479-2138for information .
Signlanguage interpretation availableuponrequestwith24hour notification .Pleasecall479-2356 ,
TelephonefortheHearingImpaired,forinformation.
Community DevelopmentDepartment
6
TO:
•
MEMORANDUM
Planningand Environmental Commission
FROM :
DATE:
SUBJECT:
Community Development Department
May 14 ,2001
A request foravariancefromTitle14 (Development Standards),Vail
TownCode,toallowforsnowstorageandparkingw ithin thepubl ic right -
of-way,locatedat2437 Garmisch Drive I Lot12,BlockH,Vaildas Schone
2nd Filing.
Applicant:
Planner:
WilliamH.Mentlik,represented byJohnMartin ,AlA
Ann Kjerulf
I.DESCRIPTION OFTHE REQUEST
The applicant is requesting avariancefromthe Development Standards to allow for snow
storageandparkingwithinthepublic right-of-way in association withaproposalto construct
anewsinglefamilyresidenceat2437 Garmisch Drive .
At12,750s.f.,thesubjectpropertyisnon-conformingwithrespecttolotsize.Thislimitsthe
development potentialofthelottoonefreemarketdwellingunit.Furthennore,the average
slopeofthelotisgreaterthan30%thusreducingtheallowablesite coverage to 15%oflot
s ize.Insituationswheresteepslopesexistandsitecoverageisreducedto15%,somerelief
fromthe strict appl ication ofthezoningregulat ions is achieved by allowing garages tobe
constructed inthefront setback.However,thereisnorelieffromthe Development
Standards thatrequireprivateparkingspacestobe accommodated within property
boundaries .Similarly,the Development Standardsrequire snow storage tobe
accommodated withinproperty boundaries andtobe contiguous with driveway area .
Theproposed residence requires2.5parkingspaces according to Section 12-10-10,
Schedule S,oftheZoningT itle.Accord ing to Section 12-10-11,where fractional
requirements result from application of the schedule,thefraction shall be raised tothe next
whole number.Thus ,theparking requirement forthe proposed residence becomes 3
spaces.Twoofthesespacesare proposed with in agarage .Theth ird space,9'x19 ',is
proposedinfrontofthegaragebutwitha14foot encroachment intothepublic right-of-way .
The14foot encroachment intothe right-of-way isroughly proportional toand just lessthan
the15foot encroachment ofthegarageintothefrontsetback.
Thereis150s .f,of driveway area within theproperty boundaries and450s .f.of driveway
areaintheright-of-way.Becausethedrivewaywillnotbeheated,30%ofthedrivewayarea
or180s.f,isrequiredforsnowstorage .Theapplicantisrequest ing that180sJ.ofright-of-
way ,aroughlysquarearea adjacent tothe driveway and encroaching intotheright -of-way
approximately 14feet,beallowedforsnowstorage .
Attached tothe staff memo isa letter fromthe applicant's representative that outlines the
technical issuesinvolvedwiththesitingofthegarageinthefrontsetback.
1
•
II.STAFF RECOMMENDATION
•
TheCommunityDevelopmentDepartmentrecommends approval oftherequestedvariances
subjecttothecriteriaoutlinedinSectionVofthismemorandumandthefollowingfindings:
1.Thatthegrantingofthevariancesdoesnotconstituteagrantofspecialprivilege
inconsistentwiththelimitationsonotherpropertiesinthe Primary/Secondary
ResidentialZoneDistrict.
2 .Thatthegrantingofthevariancewillnotbedetrimentaltothepublichealth,safety
orwelfare,ormateriallyinjurioustopropertiesorimprovementsinthevicinity.
3.ThatthestrictliteralinterpretationorenforcementoftheDevelopment Standards
resultsinapracticaldifficultyorunnecessaryphysicalhardshipinconsistentwiththe
developmentobjectivesoftheTownCodeorthePrimary/SecondaryResidential
ZoneDistrict.
4.Thatthestrictinterpretationorenforcementofthespecifiedregulationwoulddeprive
theapplicantofprivilegesenjoyedbytheownersofotherpropertiesinthesame
district.
III.REVIEWINGBOARDROLES
A.ThePlanningandEnvironmentalCommissionisresponsibleforevaluating:
1.Therelationshipoftherequestedvariancetootherexistingorpotentialuses
andstructuresinthevicinity.
2.Thedegreetowhich relieffromthestrictorliteral interpretation and
enforcementofaspecifiedregulationisnecessarytoachieve compatibility
anduniformityoftreatmentamongsitesinthevicinity,ortoattainthe
objectivesofthisTitlewithoutgrantofspecialprivilege.
3.Theeffectoftherequestedvarianceonlightandair,distribution of
population,transportationandtrafficfacilities,publicfacilitiesandutilities,and
publicsafety.
4.SuchotherfactorsandcriteriaastheCommissiondeemsapplicabletothe
proposedvariance.
B.The ORB hasNOreviewauthorityonavariance,butmustreviewanyaccompanying
ORBapplication.TheORBisresponsibleforevaluating :
1.Architecturalcompatibilitywithotherstructures,thelandand surroundings
2.Fittingbuildingsintolandscape
3.Configurationofbuildingandgradingofasitewhichrespectsthetopography
4.Removal/Preservationoftreesandnativevegetation
5.Adequateprovisionforsnowstorageon-site
6 .Acceptabilityofbuildingmaterialsandcolors
2
••
7.Acceptabilityofroofelements ,eaves,overhangs ,andotherbuildingforms
8.Provisionoflandscapeanddrainage
9.Provisionoffencing,walls ,andaccessorystructures
10.Circulationandaccesstoasiteincludingparking ,andsite distances
11.Locationanddesign ofsatellitedishes
12.Provis ion ofoutdoorlighting
IV.ZONINGSTATISTICS
Staff hasreviewedtheproposalaccordingtothePrimary/SecondaryZoneDistrictandthe
surveysubmitted.Theanalysisprovidesthefollowing :
LotSize:
Zoning:
Hazards:
Standard
GRFA :
Garage
Setbacks:
Front:
Sides:
Rear:
12,750s.f ./0.2927 acres
Primary/SecondaryResidential
none
Allowed
3,613s.f .(inc/.425s.f .credit)
600s.f .
20 ft.(GRFA)/O ft.(garage)
15ft.(north)
15ft.(south)
15ft.
Proposed
2,978s.f .
510s.f .
20ft.(GRFA)/5ft.(garage)
16ft.
15ft.
53ft.
Site Coverage :1,913s.f.(15%*)1,913s.f .(15%)
*Site coverage is limited to 15%onlots with slopes greater than 30%.
V.CRITERIAANDFINDINGS
A.ConsiderationofFactorsRegarding theVariances:
1.The relationship ofthe requested variance to other existing or potential
uses and structures inthe vicinity.
Parkingintheright-of-way :
Theproposedparkingintheright-of-wayencroachesupto14ft.intothe
right-of-way .Thesnowstorageareawouldalsoencroachupto14 ft.and
occupyanareaof180s.f.ofright-of-way.Becausethereisbetween25 ft .
and28ft.ofright-of-waymeasuredbetweenthepropertylineandedgeof
Garm isch Drive,staffbelievesthattheproposedparkingandsnowstorage
intheright-of-waywouldhavenoeffectonusesorstructuresinthevicinity .
2.The degree to which relief from the strict and literal interpretation and
enforcement of a specified regulation is necessary to achieve
compatibility and uniformity of treatment among sites in the vicinity or
to attain the objectives of this title without a grant of special privilege.
Theapplicantisproposingtoprovideenclosedparkingspaceswithina
3
••
garagethatwouldlegallyencroach15feetintothefrontsetback.Duetothe
steepnessofthelot,thegaragecannotbepushedfurtherbackintothesite
withoutnecessitatingtheconstructionofretainingwallsinexcessof6feet.
AccordingtotheDevelopmentStandards,retainingwallsinthefrontsetback
maynotexceed6feetinheight.Itispossibleforthegaragetobedesigned
insuchawaytoaccommodatethreeparking spaces-by stackingtwoofthe
spacesandeliminatingsomeoftheproposedGRFAwithinthelowerlevelof
theresidence.However,staffwouldnotrequirethis typeofadjustmentwith
typical residentialdevelopment.Itwouldfurtherlimittheapplicant'sabilityto
utilizeavailableGRFAwhentheproposedresidenceismorethan600s.f.
sma ller than itcouldbeaccordingtotheallowableGRFAforthislot.
Furthermore ,duetothe15%sitecoveragelimitationandinabilitytoadd
GRFAwithinthefrontsetback,theapplicant'sabilitytoaddGRFAtothissite
inthefutureishighlyunlikely.
3.The effect of the requested variance on light andair,distribution of
population,transportation and traffic facilities,public facilities and
utilities,and public safety.
Notably,theproposalforsnowstoragedoesnotinterferewitha large
drainageswalethatexistswithinthe right-of-way.Staffdoesnotbelievethat
thevarianceswillhaveanegativeeffectonthefactorslistedabove .
B.ThePlanningandEnvironmentalCommissionshallmakethefollowingfindings
beforegrantingavariance:
1.Thatthegrantingofthevariancewillnotconstituteagrantofspecialprivilege
inconsistentwiththelimitationsonotherpropertiesclassifiedinthesame
district.
2 .Thatthegrantingofthevariancewillnotbedetrimental tothepublichealth,
safetyorwelfare,ormateriallyinjurioustopropertiesorimprovementsinthe
vicinity .
3.Thatthevarianceiswarrantedforoneormoreofthefollowingreasons:
a.Thestrictliteralinterpretationorenforcementofthespecified
regulationwouldresultinpracticaldifficultyorunnecessaryphysical
hardshipinconsistentwiththeobjectivesofthistitle.
b.Thereareexceptionsorextraordinary circumstances orconditions
applicabletothesamesiteofthevariancethatdonotapplygenerally
tootherpropertiesinthesamezone.
c .Thestrictinterpretationorenforcementofthespecifiedregulation
woulddeprivetheapplicantofprivilegesenjoyedbytheownersof
otherpropertiesinthesamedistrict.
4
•
VICINITY MAP
Planning and Environmental Corrrrission
May 14,2001
sti~kclProPEirty:.••..••....•..........
Lot 12,BlOCk H,.·..
Vail DasSChone RUng 2
1
2556
N
-=====-==~;...;...,;;,====~~~~~-=====""'===--===--==Ma,;""..p~_1IITOWN.L Ftocil.Ired by the Corrrronity 1Jevfiopment Department,May 7,2001
•John Gt Martin·Architect
C REATIVE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN
MAIIJIi>l,
P.O.IJOX 621
VAil.cot.cRA DI..--:1'16M
A ,
2586 DAVOSTRAIL
VAn .COb ..'2AOO Ptlb5'1
1970)40 77-24 10
(970)4 '17 -223 1
jmarti n@di ve.Dd .
...".joLogmarbn.com
Memo
10:Ann Kjerulf,PlannerI,
TownofVail,Departmentof Community Development
7S S.FrontageRd.
Vail,Colorado,81657
From:JohnG.Martin,AlA
(970)477-2476
Cc:William L.Mentlik
doLDLK&M
(908)654-7866fax
DaIIIII:04/1712001
He:TownofVailPlanning and Environmental Commission VarianceRequest
MentlikResidence,Lot12,Block H,VailDasSchone #212437 Garmish Dr.
No.:2 attached sheets
Mr.W illiam Mentlikrespectfullyrequestsavariance for two unresolvedzoningissuesonthe MentHk
Residenceasstatedon the staffreviewmemodatedMarch30,2001 ,signedbyAnn Kjerulf.
1.Requiredparkingspaces(3)mustbe accommodated withinlotboundariesandare9'x18'
insideagarageand9'x19'outside.
2.Snowstoragemustbe accommodated withinlotboundariesperTOVstandards.Please
reviseplansaccordingly(10%area of heateddriveor 30%areaunheated drive).
Therealdesignhardship onthissiteisthefactthattheproperty lineis approximately 26feetfromthe
edge of pavementonGarmish Driveandatthepropertylinethegradeshavealreadyrisen
approximately10feetandcontinuetodimbanother10feettothe20footfrontsetbackline.Inother
words,at the pointthat we canplaceour first Livable Area perimeterwall,we are already '20 deepfeet
intheground.The MentJik Residence,which conforms toallotherzoning requirements forSingle-
FamilyResidencesonsteeplots,will haveaproblem conforming tothethird parking requirementand
snow-storagerequirement due to the severesteepness ofthe lotand the allowablegaragelocation
withinthefrontsetback.
Tobemore specific,wehavedesignedthegaragetobewithin S'.{)"of theFrontPropertyLinesoasto
conformtothe 6'.{)"retainingwall requirements .Pushing thegaragebackawayfromtheFront
PropertyLineshalfincreaseretainingwaifsbeyond the allowable height We show 27feetlength of
driveway fromthe FrontPropertyLineto the edge of existing road atGarmishDrive.TIlis ismorethan
adequatelengthtoprovideathirdandfourthautomobileparkingspaceinfrontofthegarage.It just so
happenstobeonTown of VailRightofWay.Also,we havemorethanenoughsnowstorageareato
theimmediatesouth of theentirelength of driveway,butagain itis alfwithin Town of VailRight of Way.
Weallknow from common sensethatautomobileparkingand snow storagearegoingtooccurinthis
•Page1
••
area anyway.Whynotwaivetheserequirements ,orallowtheserequirements tooccuruponTown or
VailRight or Way,sothatthis finehouse,which the ORB hasalreadyperceived to be agoodaddition
tothe neighborhood,can be builtasdesigned.
1.Therelationship ofthe requested variance tootherexisting orpotentialusesand struelures in
thevicinity:
Weshall be par1<ing carsona27'length or privatedrivewayandsnowstorageshalloccuron
thegradualslopingfrontyardoftheresidencejustasallotherneighborson Garmish Drivedo.
2.Thedegreetowhichrelieffromthestrictor hteral interpretationand enforcement ofaspecified
regulationisnecessarytoachievecompatibility and uniformity of treatment amongsitesinthe
vicinityortoattainthe objectives ofthis titlewithoutgrant or specialprivilege:
Inordertoachieve compatibility with similarsite walls,driveways,andsnowstorageareason
Garmish Drive,we need 1000k degreeofrelieffromthestrict interpretation or the specified
regulations onthethird par1<ing requirement andthesnow storage requirement .
3.The effect or thevarianceonlightandair,distribution or population ,transportation,traffic
facilities,utilitiesandpublicsafety:
Thereshall be no effect onany or thelisteditems.
4.Howtherequest complies with Vail's Comprehensive Plan:
Therequestfor par1<ing andsnowstorageintheTownRight or Way onthis residential dead-
endroadhasno detrimental effecttoVail's Comprehensive Plan.
•Page 2
10 15 ID
1-36'01'06'
R-125.00'
l -7&'58'
1-40.64 '
Cl..£N-n.29 '
BRU-N 34-50'27"E
AHAo•
D4Tt:~..01 "__Illr:
JOHN G,lI.lRTIN.ARCHITECT Mr.WIlliam L MentIIk
P.D...Itt w.IL ~....,.
=-r.:l~~Lot 12,IlIock Ii.Vd Diu ecta.I'a'cI 2-...-...,_IlL.""'CloIIlr.-_
,!>Y!>T£M!;TO BE 'DE!>I6N-aIlI.D"
;TO BE .a.PPRO\IED BY'"cwe:t..
R!'F'ENCIES ElEn'EEN 010!>EH ST'&TEM
•BY 0l'N:R.
IolS<L TNIT ......,APf'RO',/ED BY ClH'ER.
:APPFlOVED BY ~
AAfA ·__!>F.
Jt>.SOFFFIT RECESSED CAN --LJI
~DIRECT IONAl.LI5HT .
HOlE,AU.ARVoS OF Ie<~TO I'EUM F'ROP6<_TlOI<
U5II'S ~llRlP-l..1lE 5Y5TE11 TO Ell:~AHl>
5(.BMlTTED TO M<"HrfGT BY I..J'W5GN'E ~TOR.
AU.DI5Tl.R!lED N1EA5 ~1lEGEM:REVB5ETM"'"SEEIllIO&.
EFlO5IOH eotm<DL 5HAU.Ell:"'''''<TAItE>BY IVG&ll9IT OF HA'(e.o.JL5_Jll'PLICAel£
",-
LANDOCAFE LEGEND
5Yl'1lOl.-5lZE GlWlTTT'l'
65 •
~•
6F •
CA 2
QA 10
CW 6
CJ 6
56 6
0052~RD 6
OG b
F'F 6
GC NlEA ·__5F .
/
/
/
/
•
/
//
"I"F
o
~
"""~-ot
A __tor:
JOHN G.MARTlH,ARCHITECT Mr.W1BJam L Mentlik
,.0....U.....~.tW Lot 1t._H,V..0........Fa1g I=-=~:=.....T._--__Dr..-.e..-_
..
~'.IJIj~J
.J B,
Ji ~~
ci II..:III~
!
"'I~i
~:'r"Id~g
~~~h
I
I•
I
I
I
I
I
6 ....•..
r -----------------,
....'II -,
.-
..
GUEST
BEDROOM
"'.1'X 12'·2'
'-.J
'--r------
..
I'III
jf;:jI:•-,,-___0-.
•
~L~LEVEL FLOOR PLAN ~M2 ~\4 ecALE.V8'·I'-ID'-."'CJJ
,,
",I,,,,
.,~-.......
GCWIII5l---iil3i:---
IIfTID.MeA
&'-5'.l'&'~',,'
"I ",,,
,,'I'...,,,
,I '
,..I ",,
!_i,f ,:1.--··~~i
,>~t
~~:I~~:,,
--------------------------~MASreR :
BEDROOM :
11'-2".x 16'..q"I
-1':
//1 ',:
/I ":/I \.:
~I ~
I II ,I
11 I I I
III
•
•
•
1r-----i
r-I I
I :
I :
I
I
I
IL J
L _
L
I1 ---'
:I
I I_J
:I
I I
I I
1.1.
..
:!Ie '.Aii II:E J.J I,
Jj!li
ci II
~d
!.,I1=-~I
9 ill!1~din....
~~~J!
..
.-:'.Ii IJ~~!Ii !ic~JI~sI
!
~;!Ul
uaul
§1.1-~~h
----,
l
I
I
l-
I
I
I
,J
II I
L 1.-1.-
I
I
I
IL J
L _
r-----
I h-------------L-I
I
I•
•
@ fIlOOF PLAN
A&SCALE.1/4'.I'-/t)'
•
@ ~~:,~~T )EL.EVATION
,
i
.~
•
---
.I -
i
---.J_
I
I
I
2-__
1
I
I
I I
cL l-------l I
cL _~
------------------------------------
,e
I
-----+=::::::::=~~===
I I I '..I
~_.--}--r ---l~------------"--~
II
I I
II I
•:d ,b
I I
I I
~----------~
----
•
•
I
I
I
I I
I ~
I
I
I
I
r-------:L ~
/I
/".I__""""t J
••John G.Martin·Architect
CREATIVEA RCHITECTU RAl D ESIGN
•~liIEE!IT'
P.O.BOX 62 1 2 t:86DAVQsTRAIL
vxn,COLCRADO BlOSS.VAll.COLORADO Blb57
1970)4 77 -2<70
(970)47'1.2237
jrn,utin@ctive.ncl
www.job ngm a:r lin .com
Memo
To:AnnKjerulf ,Planner I,
Town of Vail ,Department of Community Development
75S.Frontage Rd.
Vail ,Colorado,81657
From:JohnG .Martin ,AlA
(970)477-2476
Cc:William L.Mentlik
doLDLK&M
(908)654-7866 fax
Date;04/1712001
Re:TownofVail Planning and Environmental Commission Variance Request
Mentlik Residence ,Lot12,BlockH,VailDas Schone #2 /2437 GarmishDr.
List of namesand addresses of all property owners adjacent tosubject property.
RomaChmielewski
2445 Garmisch Dr.
Vail,Co .81657
(Lot11)
TJ.Conner
POBox548
Vail,Co .81658
(Lot13A,2447 Garmisch Dr.)
Gary DePaolo
2427 Garmisch Dr.
Vail,Co.81657
(Lot13B)
Aspen Chalets
Ron Jones -Apartment Manager
17VailRd .
Vail ,Co .81657
(2428 Garmisch Dr.)
VailSkyHigh Condominiums
VailSkyHigh Condo Assoc.
POBox3527
Vail,Co .81658
(2448 Garmisch Dr.)
•Page1
-Is ITEMMAYAFFECTYOUR PROPE~
PUBLICNOTICE
NOTICEISHEREBYGIVENthatthePlanningand Environmental Commission oftheTownof
Vailw ill holdapublichearingin accordance withSection12-3-6oftheMunicipalCodeofthe
TownofVailonMay14,2001 ,at2 :00 P.M.intheTownofVailMun icipal Building .In
consideration of:
A request foraconditiona l useperm it,toallowforanadditiontotheVa il ValleyMedical Center,
located at181 West Meadow Drive/Lots E &F,VailVillage2nd Filing .
Applican t:
Planner:
VailValleyMedicalCenter ,representedbyBraun Associates
GeorgeRuther
WilliamH.Mentlik ,representedbyJohnMartin ,AlA
AnnKjerulf
plicant:
Planner:
A request foravariancefromTitle14 (Development Standards),VailTownCode ,toallowfor
snowstorageandparkingwithinthepublicright-of-way,locatedat2437 Garmisch Drive/Lot
BlockH,VaildasSchone2 nd Filing .
Arequestforaworksessiontodiscussamendingcertain residential zone districts intheTown
ofVailtoallowhomedaycare facilities subjecttotheissuanceofaconditionaluse permit anda
home occupation permit.
Applicant:
Planner:
TownofVail
George Ruther
ArequestforavariancefromSection12-6D-6(Setbacks),VailTownCode,toallowforthe
construction ofagaragewithintherequiredfrontsetback ,locatedat1956GoreCreek Drive!
Lot45 ,VailVillageWestFiling #2 .
Applicant:
Planner:
DavidIrwin
AnnKjerulf
A request fora worksession to discuss anewspecial development district,toallowforthe
redeve lopment oftheVa il RacquetClub ,locatedat4695VailRacquetClub DrivelVail Racquet Club
Condominiums ,Bighom s"Addition ..
Applicant:
Planner:
RacquetClubOwners Association ,representedbyFritzlenPierce Architects.
BrentWilson
Arequestforafinalreviewofaproposedspecial development district,toallowforthe
construction ofanew conference facility/hotel;andafinal review ofaconditionalusepermit,to
allowforTypeIIIemployeehousingunitsandfractionalfeeclubunits ,locatedat13VailRoad!
LotsA ,B,C,Block2,VailVillageFiling2 .
Applicant:
Planner:
DoramarHotels,represented bytheDaymer Corporation
BrentWilson
Arequestforaconditionalusepermit,toallowforthe construction ofa soccer field,located
610N.FrontageRd.West/Aportionof Tract C,VailPotatoPatch .Afullmetes &boundslegal
description isavailableatthe Department ofCommunity Development.
Applicant:
Planner:
TownofVail
AllisonOchs
1
~.
u V
o C--t-'-\J _l\-'~\\
••...
A requestforafinal reviewofacondi tional usepermit,toallowforthe construction ofPhaseIof
DonovanPark improvements,generallylocatedsoutheastofthe intersectionof Matterhorn
C ircle andtheSouthFrontageRoad.
Applicant:
Planner:
TownofVail
GeorgeRuther
Arequestforthe reviewofaproposedtext amendment to Chapter 11,DesignReview ,ofthe
ZoningRegulationstoallowforprocedura l changestothe performance bondprocessas
prescribed intheVailTownCode .
Applicant:
Planner:
Town ofVail
GeorgeRuther
A requestforavariancefromSection 12-60-10 oftheTownCode ,toallowforareductioninthe
landscaping andsite development requi rements,locatedat383BeaverDamRoad/Lot3 ,Block
3 ,VailVillage3'dFiling .
Applicant:
Planner:
A2ZHoldings,LLC
BillGibson
Areq uest fora minor subd ivision andavariancefromSection 12-60-5 oftheTownCodeto
allowfortheresubd ivision of Lot1,StraussSubdivision ,aresubdivisionofLots46 &47 ,Vail
VillageWestFiling No.2 ,re-creat ing Lots46 &47 ,locatedat1916 &1936WestGore Creek
Drive.
Appl icant:
Planner:
PatDauph inais ,representingRichardStrauss
Allison Oc hs
The applications andinform ation abouttheproposalsareavailableforpublic inspection during regular
office hoursintheprojectplanner's office ,locatedattheTownofVailCommunity Development
Depa rtment,75SouthFrontageRoad .Thepublic is invitedtoattendprojectorientat ion andthesite
v isits thatprecedethepublichearingintheTownof VailCommunityDevelopment Department.
Pleasecall4 79-2138forinformat ion .
Sign language interpretation availableuponrequestwith24-hour notification .Pleasecall479-
2356 ,Telephone fortheHearingImpaired,for information.
Community Development Department
Published Apri l 27 ,2001intheVail T rail.
2
I
I
I
I
I
TOWN
...."r>.~..,."
r."'...
,·1
NO .232
Application for Review by the
PlanninCi and Environmental Commission
Deca'tmeIlt r:A QlrnrnunIr ~
75 SC1JttI fftllltage RaI.Vall.ClIIcIr1Dl 81657
b!I:97Il.419..2.139 1\IX:97U.Q!il.2452
WII!b:_.d.vail.co.us
P.2 141 01
c.._lltlfannatian:
ihlS aPl)liCalian is tor any proj8tt reqI.iring apprtMll from tt1e.Planning and Enviltlnl'herlli!ll CDmmission.Please reer
to the :iiUtmitml reQUin;!n'Ii!lICS to:"tt2 ~~that Is ~...",.,An appIcaIbl fOr IIIanring am
ElWilDillStal CGlnrnisSiDn ~cannot b!!IICXlt$G!d fJI'lljl all ~lntcAilldtbl is ''''::hcd by the CammunIt.Y
~~Tre pQjeCt tni!V also need 1:1)be ~~Dj tt1l!Town QlundI andIOJ"ltIe Design
~8oartL
,.".of AMAatiolt ....'-:
I!I VOlriana!
CI 5ig1 ViIrianCIl
LI Aszanlng
I:J Mi!Ijor~
CI MInar SIl~'
[J 5pB:Ia/DlMIopnB1t OI~
C MaiD"AlNndrner1t ttl an SODo~Arredl'_,tto an SOD
C 2Dning COde ....idrnl!lIt
$2SO
$200
$200
$1000 +$2Ojlaf;
$2SO
$1500
$1000
$200
$250
o COIldillaniil UM PlInTtit
o ~Hau*Ig LJnIV1\IrII'_o ~and 8n5iI1dastofl9jar&lJ!rior Nl!Ilaa....lIIliDin·rron in val VllllIge
CI MinOJ"Ederiar Ala dID.in vail YilIage
[J M$r eanor Abiill:illh in l..iI:lnshMd
c:J MInCIr ElcreriDr ~in I..iClnSIIeIdoliocqila!n I1IIIdil'Il:lIIoAmendrnenttD8De:Pl!lllP'11I!I1t PIlM1
Ie IlIPF III lite Ph....._1:~1'2...Bkldc H SlA:adivision:V,·7 k!fo *,4,cfe fjlqj Z
pb,.-a'Addleu.2'137 Gar~("9t:"PI".&t"r a,.SIr,,£7,
Plm:IlI No.c z,0 ~,I "f I ~00 ill (Con1ilCt Eagle Co.ASS""IO'"_910.328-.8640 for parcef no.)
Zo JftIp ftlMA'C'?,/$"eCO'4JQ'Y'"@,QQ~tl~(
Nalllll(s)of Owt_CII):Wt'I(i,.~i-.Me/lt-/,-It:5'9 40U;~H
Mdlno ....,n:(GOO S t::Ivrn ...4L..o'F-.we$[""15~""'Elet-o N .J_Q7l:'~O
_________~--;~~'1';7"--Pl!iOOf*qO'b -$7'i>-iP30 C
own.(s)SiQMlln(s);_....~ce;;.~~.q.L ~-_
Name of A.....13IIIt:-lOff,..{4:.HLIi!.T,,.,(-......It!"-
Mil ,tteu:fbQqc:WZ I k14fl Co.gfii2 $"'?I
_______________PIwifte.j'zr.:?1.{7 2 ~Z'£Zl4'
I
Far otIIa!Ute Onlr.
FeeP8id;Qleck:No.:,By'=",:~__-----_------AppIc3Ii:III DIlle:PEr;:Na.:_
PIl!nner:----------~NO.:_
••
Application for Review by the
Planninq and Environmental Commission
Department of Community Deve !opment
75 South Frontage Road ,Vail,Colorado 81657
tel:970.479.2139fax:970.479.2452
web:www.d .vail.co .us
General Information:
This application isforanyprojectrequiring approval fromthePlanning and Environmenta l Commission.Please refer
to the submitt:ll requirements for the particular approval that is requested.An application fer Planning and
Environmental Commission Review cannot be accepted untilall required information is received by the Community
Develo pment Department.Theprojectmayalso need to be reviewed by theTown Cou ncil and/orthe Desig n
Review Board .
Type of Application and Fee:
~Variance
o Sign vartance
o Rezoning
o Major Subdi vision
o Minor Subdivision
o Speci al Development District
o Major Amendment toan SDD
o Minor Amendment toan SDD
o ZOning Code Amendment
$250 0 Conditional Use Perm it
$200 0 Employee f-'.ousing Unit/Type:__
$200 0 Bed and Breakfast
$1000 +$20/lot 0 Major ExteriorAlteration inVail Village
$250 0Minor Exterior Alteration inVail Village
$1500 0 ~"ajcr Exterior Alteration in Lionshead
$1000 0 MinorExterior Alteration in Lionshea d
$200 0 Floodpla in modification
$250 0 Amendment to a Development Plan
$200
NoFee
$200
$500
$200
$500
$200
$200
$250
Description of the Request:r """"0 Z""'1/11
i ,Wt/','ve "J,r.J a .-4 ,-"of a
hJ 6S"'F1 E:'I.-Q ri ·)..0 7010
Cfo'O -51 0 -G3 o £
Z A[fo'-"7110.....-5'&('t"e aM..h ClUv/'q~"':J 2 1 'k"9 fb Of'c!l'lVt'¥7Z tvr""':'1 --;D..<"p.o·W.
Location of the Proposal:Lot:12-Block :H Subdivision :(1,;>.7 a.,7c~P.1C fj Zf4j Z
Physical Address:2'137 G c./''''I /'ic.l,pl"'.(q /f?r2.'Z/tR 7'Z,
Pc:rcel No.:ZI O~II '1/300 'b (Contact Eagle Co.Assessor at 970 ,328-8640 for parc el no.)
Zoning:f b'Ma"z /;ieco"'l J a <l'''7 fks;~e,n'Cr I
7 (7
Name(s)of Owner(s):W r /({C/<1/!L-.Me/7 HI 'k c/o L..0 £..,.0'H
Mailing Address:G oo 5 0l./T rt A:vr-:.wC:ST
__________________Phone:_..I.!o<'-""'_L.L--""-_~L..=._J__
Owner(s)Signature(s):_
Name of Applicant:-!ot/rJ G .HI./Z II,'(-AlA
Mailing Address:..!.!fb"'--"~=:::....ioG~2....1'___~.L.L."____''--'=::..:...--'-~~'-'=''____10ff 1:'0.1)(05"""<Q
________________Phone:"(70 tt Z?-2'fz<e
PLEASE SUBMIT THIS APPUCATIo.'\I,AU.SUBMmAL REQUIREMENTS
AND THE FEE TO THE DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT,
75 SOUTH FRONTAGE ROAD,VAIL,CO LORADO 81657.
For Office UseOnly:
Fee Paid:Check No.:By:_
Application Date:PEC No.:_
Planner :ProjectNo.:1
JO'0 15 20
EROSIOW GCJNT'ROL
~CT)FfItO€.
AnON OF ST.AKED
HA,'(MILS Fost SEDIt-err
GONTROL 5WOHt HATCl-EO
1*36"01 '06·
R·1 25 .00-
L=7 8.59 '
1=40.64'
CLEN=77.29'
BR(j=N3 4·5{)'27 "E
8 88
o•
0.5'TRLN(DlA.
""",""IO.OOS (TYP)
OArt:5-'1-01 APw-*_1llr:
JOHNG.MARTIN,ARCHITECT Mr.W1HIam L Mentllk
'.0....S21 'foI.CoIwOdo e1eM l.Dl 12,Block If,Val Du Bchan8 ~2::=;-:~::J :~:~;;;
In-tlr4ollthoLoom
_..~
__Dr••Val,CoIorodo..,
.~/
lG 5 T'5n:MS TO ee "DE5IG~ElUILO·.
tr5 TO BE APf'ROVl'D BT'OWNER.
GREF'ENG IES BE1l"'EEN Gt\05EN 5T'STE H
:D B Y OI"fER.
~L TANT AND Af'PROVEJ)BT'0I'f'lER.
3E Af'Pl<OVE'D BT'ortlER.
>w E-glalo!lo)
OPE AHA.Y FROM PER IMETER OF HC.:lUSE .
3E D tREGTED BY 0HiER.
NOTE I ALL J>.RE.ItoS OF l'£J'i L..ANO'5CAPlN6 TO ReCEIVE PROPER IRRI6ATlON
usll<6 ~DRIP-LINE SYSTEH TO BE O6I<>I£D AND
5U>H1TTED TO ARlA<ITEGT By lANDSC.APE WK!RAC.TOI'-.
ALL DISTl.I<BEO AREAS SHALL RECEIVE I<EVE6ETAnoo SEEDII<6.
EROSION WNTROL SHALL BE HAINTAINfD BY PL~OF HAl'8AJLS
I'+IERE APPLICA6l..E,
NS
65 I ~~5f'flI!GE ~'I>'TALL 4
RJ I ~~cf"~~~,b 'TALL 4
6P fi'l'l.EGONf PINE ~1>'TALL 4
CA I ~1<6 ~RAB APPLE ~'~AL.2
QA I ~~~."1'-'
3·~AL.10
Cill 1 ~~OI 06).3 GAL..b
C J I ~~'".JJNIPER ,,~,56AL.~
56 ,='~';S "AL .~
RD I =:~D 5 <>AL.b
OG ='1A~FOlII.H)S <>AL .b
Pf ~'I;';!\tO.'~~~5 (,AL.b
->fA
GC ~~~~""""'"WA~)AREA =__5.F .
,=~~RTM-l T
.~~~Pa6J
~~
5EED NA Tl.O'W.I">RAS6ESIHIL.DfLOto£RS AI<fA •__S.F.
alANTIN
SOFfFIT RECE55ED CAN
DIRECTIONAL L16HT
LANDSCAPE LEGEND
Sll'ElOl NAME SIZE
.'
//
'.
•
./,>'/~'///t I /"///.,r"~.,//j'i l ;:
...,....~I /.1 .//j I /...:~.ii I~.'f---_r /I 1 /1/","'..//
r "-/-:/!I i .'!-I i
,/1 )<,///.'./'....I
,/'/............//I !;<..........i ~//f /.'X /,._r 1 ~q,I ./',-'/'/.I /...'l.o.I
.:.if !:/"-.:
'////j /'/:......
V //'/I ///'
/,//;/;1;.II
////1/'
I ///I'_#h~
/./"'Z58>L6l#.~~
/./,//1:1 .
,./"'P--I--,HH'lY'lII
<c:
t H1 10 15 10 "
GJ
06
DATI;s-q-ol
,,__for:
JOHNG.WARTIN.ARCHITECT Mr.William L Ment6k
,.0...at 'Ultl.~.'15lI LDt"._H,VoI Du_~2r.=-~:~l ~~:rJ~--.----_....."......-....,.
..
ji IIr~I.J R,Ji !i
ci II
:id
!
81 IU
<;>
~1§fj l";1?;i oRRIf\
~~~J 5..,~~
CRAWL8PACE
5'-0'MAx.I£~
TO ..kJISTS ABOVE
2 CAR
GARAGE
20'-10-x 24 '-6"
5KJ SToAA6e
I .....,•
r -----------------i
I I •
I I
I I
I I
I I
I $....-.se L.f!'IB-I
I T.o.GOHG ,•eo!i4'-4"I
MEDIA ROOM
12'~'"14'~"
-,
:t<11Il
1---",+'-:---1•••
1~...J
IIII
•I I
,I I ,Lili~il
I:J .•
•
•
...
--~-.""""I--"._+--f1
8ITllIlG
MEA
el-5',t 0 ·....•
/I ',,I "
/I ,
,/I-,
/I ,
/I '","I "
I
I
..
~'.Jil jI~~!
l~~~~i iI
ilfl
:!i
BI J1:-
U I
~lsil l
9 ',""l';ciiiU,/,
;!
zl-6~h;l ,~.
Hl6H
I Hlt<O\?l'e
Ir ----,
I
I
I
_J
I
I
I
I
I I
1-1-
<,//,--
",f /'---L
\J/
BEDRooM.....'rc !I'f")(12 '~6'
,
$~~::-~L
GftN TO
6REAT ROOM
BElOt'I
L
-1 "I,I:--'---').'-n /
.'-1/
!
BEDROOM
f!I j II'-/')'x 12'-&'
I:1---------,
r ---
i rr=~~~~~~~~~~~~§~~~~~~
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
L I
L _
1r------t-
IIr -
I
I II
I II
•
•
@ Ut=I=e;,..LEvEL FlOOR PLAN
A4 SCALE,1/4'.I'-c:!)'
..
~'IIiI
1:&I.J I,
J~Iii~~II
i ~i
!
"'I~j
;1ia
~i sS I"ii g
z JJ§~ul
---I
I I
-l l-
l
I
I
f-
I
I
I
I -----J
L
-----,
I I
I I
~__J
I
I
I
ILJL __
r -----
I 1---r-------------'---1
I
I
•
•
•
.~
•
----.+=:===:~===
II I I
~_.--..l i---l~-------------_-.S
II
II
•:I I
I d------i ---------------1
I I
I I
c!-.-...s
•
----
..
I
I
IL __1
I
I
I I 11111L~----l I
cL _~
----
•
•
I
I
I
I I
I ~
I
I
I
I
I -------..L~
I
________________________l ~
•
1.PRE-APPLICATION CONFERENCE
Questions?calle Planning Staff at 479-2138
APPLICATION FOR A VARIANCE
SUBMITTAL REQUIREMENTS
/
Apre-applicationconferencewithaplanning staff memberis strongly encouraged.Noapplication
canbeaccepted unless itiscomplete.It is theapplicant'sresponsibility to makean appointment with
the staff to determine additionalsubmittalrequirements .
II.SUBMmAL REQUIREMENTS
)(FEE:$250.00.Thefee must bepaidatthetimeof submittal .
)!:f Stamped,addressedenvelopesandalistofthenamesandmailingaddressesofall property
ownersadjacent to thesubjectproperty,includingpropertiesbehindandacrossstreets.The
applicantis responsible forcorrectnamesandmailing addresses.Thisinformationisavailable
fromtheEagleCounty Assessor's office.
A written statement oftheprecisenatureofthevariancerequestedandthespecific
regulation involved.
A written statement addressing thefollowing:
A.Therelationshipoftherequestedvariance to other existingor potential usesand
structuresinthevicinity.
B.Thedegreetowhichrelieffromthestrictorliteral interpretation and enforcement
ofaspecifiedregulationisnecessarytoachieve compatibility and uniformity of
treatment amongsitesinthevicinityortoattaintheobjectivesofthistitle without
grant ofspecialprivilege.
C.The effect ofthevarianceonlightandair,distributionofpopulation,transportation,
trafficfacilities,utilities,andpublicsafety.
D.HowyourrequestcomplieswithVail'sComprehensivePlan.
ON flL-e rg Apreliminary title report,includingschedulesAandS,to verifyownershipandeasements.
CondominiumAssociationapproval (if applicable).
o Anyadditionalmaterialnecessaryforthereview of theapplicationasdeterminedby the
Administrator.
Four (4)copiesofthefollowing:
Atopographic and/or improvement surveyatascaleofatleast1"=20'stampedbya
Colorado licensed surveyorincludinglocationsofallexistingimprovements,includinggrades
andelevations.Otherelementswhichmustbeshownareparkingandloadingareas,ingress
andegress,landscapedareasand utility anddrainagefeatures.
DeP.:o I Wj.:t
~l'gJ5"":3
REeD A.PR 1 7 2001
Ptuo\OD32-
*
••Asiteplanatascale of at least1"=20'showingexistingandproposedbuild ings.
Building elevat ions andfloorplanssuffic ient toindicatethedimensions,generalappearance,
scaleanduseofallbuildingsandspacesexist ing andproposedon the site.
For interior modifications,an improvement surveyandsiteplanmaybewaivedby the
Admin istrator.
,
t
III.PLEASE NOTETHATONLY COMPLETE APPLICATIONS CAN BE ACCEPTED.ALL OFTHE REQUIRED
INFORMATION MUSTBE SUBMITTED IN ORDER FOR THIS APPLICATION TOBE DEEMED COMPLETE .
N.TIME REOUIREMENTS
A.The Planningand Environmental Commissionmeetson the 2ndand4thMondays of each
month.A complete application formandallaccompanying material (asdescribedabove)
must be acceptedbytheCommunityDevelopment Department bythe appropriate submittal
date,wh ichisa minimum of four (4)weekspriortothe date of the PEC public hearing.
Incomplete applications(as determined bytheplanning staff)willnotbe accepted.
B.All PEC approved var iances shalllapseif construction isnotcommencedw ithin oneyearof
the dateofapprovalanddiligentlypursuedtocompletion,or if the useforwhich the approval
is granted is not commencedwithinoneyear.
V.ADDmONAL REVIEW AND FEES
A.If th is applicationrequiresaseparatereviewbyanylocal,StateorFederalagency other than
the TownofVail,theapplicationfeeshall be increasedby$200.00.Examples of suchreview,
may include,butare not limitedto:Colorado Department ofHighwayAccessPermits,Army
Corps of Engineers 404,etc.
B.The applicant shallbe responsibleforpayinganypublishingfeeswhichareinexcess of 50%
of the application fee.If,attheapplicant'srequest,any matter is postponed for hearing,
causing the matter tobere-published,then,the entire fee for such re-publ ication shallbe
paidby t he applicant.
C.ApplicationsdeemedbytheCommunity Development Department tohavedesign,landuse
or other issueswh ich mayhaveasignificant impact onthe community may require review
byconsultants inadditiontoTownstaff.Shoulda determination be madeby the Town staff
that anoutsideconsultantisneeded,the Community Development Department mayhirethe
consultant.The Department shall estimate the amount of moneynecessarytopay the
consultant andthis amount shallbe forwarded totheTownbythe applicant at the time of
filing an application.Expensesincurredby the Towninexcess of the amount forwarded by
the applicant shall be paidto the Townbythe applicant within30days of notification by the
Town.Anyexcessfundswillbe returned to the applicant uponrev iew completion.
2
•John G.Martin·Architect
C REA TIVE ARCHITE CTURALD ESIG N
MAillI!Q,
P.o.R\.-'X 621
VAil ..COLORAIX'BlbM
•:3.l:KEEr1
2 586 DAVOE T RAil.
v ..\JI..('nl~DO 61&57
(970)4.77-2476
(9101 40 77-2237
jlll 41tiu@c ti Vt'one l
.........jol.ngmutin .c om
Memo
To:AnnKjeru lf,Planne r I,
Town of Vail ,Department ofCommunity Development
75S.Frontage Rd .
Va il,Colorado,81657
From:Joh n G .Martin ,AlA
(970)477-2476
Cc:William L.Mentlik
c/oLDLK&M
(908)654-7866 fax
DalBc 0411712001
Rei TownofVailPlanningandEnv ironmental Commission Variance Request
MentlikResidence,Lot12,BlockH,VailDas Schone #2/2437 Garm ish Dr.
No.:~attachedsheets
Mr.W illiam Ment lik respectfully requests avariancefortwo unresolved zon ingissuesontheMentlik
Res idence asstatedonthestaffrev iew memodatedMarch30 ,2001 ,signed byAnnKjerulf.
1.Required parking spaces (3)must be acco mmodated withinlot boundaries andare9'x18 '
insidea garage and9 'x19'outside.
2 .S now storagemustbe a=mmodated withi nlot boundaries per TOV standards.Please
reviseplans a=rdingly (1()Oil.areaof heated drive or30%area unheated d rive).
Therea l design hardship onthiss ite isthe fadthatthe property lineisapprox imately 26feet from the
edgeof pavement onGarmishDriveandatthe property line the grades have already ri sen
approximately 10feetandcontinue tocl imb another 10 feetto the 20footfron t setback line .Inothe r
words,atthepointthat we canplaceour first Livable Area perimeter wall ,we are already 20deepfeet
inthe ground.The Mentlik Res idence,whichconforms toallother z oningrequ irements for Single-
Family Residences onsteeplots ,willhaveaprob lem conforming totheth ird parking requirement and
snow-storagerequirement duetothe severe steepness of thelotandthe allowable garage location
withinthefrontsetback.
Tobemorespecific ,wehave designed the garage tobewithin5 '-0"of theFront Property Linesoasto
conformtothe6'-0 "retain ing wallrequirements.Push ing the garage back away fromtheFront
Property Lineshall increase reta ining wallsbeyondthe allowable he ight We show27feet length of
driveway fromtheFront Property Linetotheedge of exist ing roadatGarm ish Drive .Thisismoretha n
adequate lengthtoprovide athird andfourth automobile parking space infrontofthegarage .It justso
happens to be on TownofVa il R ight of Way.Also ,we havemorethan enough snowstorageareato
the immediatesouthoftheent ire lengthof d riveway,butagain it isallwith in Town of Va il Rightof Way.
We allknowfromcommonsensethat automobile parking andsnowstorageare going to occur inth is
•Page 1
••
area anyway.Why notwa ive these requirements,or allow theserequ irements to occur uponTownof
VailRight of Way,sothatthisfinehouse ,whichtheORBhas already perce ived tobeagoodaddit ion
to the ne ighbortlood,can be builtas designed.
1.The relationsh ip ofthe requested variance to other existingor potential usesand structures in
the vicinity:
We shall be parking carsona27'length of private driveway andsnowstorageshall occur on
the gradual sloping frontyardofthe residence just asall other neighbors onGarmishDrivedo.
2 .The degree towhichrel ief fromthestrictorliteral interpretationand enforcement of a specified
regulation is necessary toach ieve compatibility and uniformity of treatment amongsitesinthe
vicinityortoatta in the object ives of thistitle without grantofspecial privilege :
Inorderto achieve compatibility with similar sitewalls,driveways,andsnowstorageareason
GarmishDr ive,weneed100%degree of relief fromthestrict interpretation of the specified
regulations onthethird parking requ irement andthesnowstorage requirement.
3.Theeffectofthevarianceonlightandair ,distribution of population,transportation ,traffic
facilities,utilities and public safety:
Thereshall be noeffectonany of thelisteditems.
4 .Howthe request complies withVail's Comprehensive Plan :
Therequestfor parking andsnowstorageinthe Town Rightof Way onthisresidential dead-
endroadhasnodetrimentaleffecttoVail's Comprehensive Plan.
•Page2
0411712001
************************JIIt************************************tIIl*******.*.**************
TOWNOFVAl L,COLORADOCopy Reprinted on04-17-2001at16:32:14
Statement
****************************************~*******************************.*******************
Statemen t Number:
PaymentMethod :
R0 000 0061 0
Check
Amo unt:$250.00 04 /17/200104:32 PM
Init:AK
Notation:check #5183
Permi t No :
Pa rcel No :
Si te Add re ss :
Lo ca ti on:
PECOI0032Ty pe:
2 103 114 13008
24 37 GARMISH DR VAIL
PEC -Variance
Total Fees:$250 .00
This Paymen t:$2 5 0.0 0 TotalALL Pmts:$250.00
Balance:$0.00
********************************************************************************************
ACCOUNT ITEMLIST :
Acco un t Code
PV 001000 03112 500
Des c ription
P EC APPLICATION FEES
Current Pmts
250.00
04/1712001
************************JIIt*****************••**••••••••••••••*iIIl••••••••••••••••••••••••
TOWNOFVA IL.CO LORADOCopy Reprinted on04-17-2001 at16:32:20
Statement
•••••***.***.***.*********•••**••••*•••**.*********************.**•••••*••••*.**************
S tatement Number :
Payment Met ho d:
R000000 610 Amount :
Check
$2 50.00 04 /1 7 /200104:32 PM
Ini t :AK
No ta t ion :check #5 183
PEC-Va ri a nc ePermitNo:
Parcel No :
S ite Add ress :
Loc ati o n :
PEC010032 Ty pe :
2103 11 413 008
2 437 GARM ISH DR VAIL
Tot al F ees:$250 .00
Thi sPa ymen t :$250 .00 Total ALL Pmts :$250 .00
Ba la nc e:$0 .00
*******************************•••**•••**••••••••***••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••
ACCO UNT ITEM LIST:
Accou n tCod e
PV 00100003 112500
Descript io n
PECAPPLICA TIONFEES
Cu rre nt Pmts
25 0 .00
•
Department of Community Development
75 South Frontage Road
Vail,Colorado8165 7
970-479-2138
FAX 970-479-2452
www.ci.vail.co.us
April5,200I
JohnMartin,AlA
P.O.Box 621
Vail,CO81658
Re:MentfiA Residence -Lot 12,Block H,VailDas Schone #2/2437 Garmi'ichDrive
DearJohn:
TheproposalfortheMentlik residence received a conceptual review from theDesignReviewBoard
yesterday (April 4dl).Iwouldliketo summarize thetwomajor comments madebytheORB:
[J Reconsider the location ofthe retaining wallsonthe north sideofthe property .As proposed,theyare
veryclosetotheproperty line.Trytopullthewalls away fromthe property lineand eliminate some
if possible.
[J Examine thesidesofthegarage where cedarisproposed andlookforan alternative suchasusing
morestone.Also,lookfor alternatives totheproposed shedroofabovethe garage.
Currently,theproposalis scheduled fortinal review on April 18th
•Please submit revised plansbynoon
on Monday,April16th inorderto proceed to this meeting.Iam confident thatyoucanresolvethe
parkingissuewithintheexisting building footprint.Therearealsosome outstanding Public Works issues
thatmustbe resolved priortotinal approval.
IwillbeoutoftheofficeuntilApril 16th•Ifyouhaveany planning questions.pleasefeelfreetocontact
any memberoftheplanningstaffwhocanbe reached through Judy Rodriguez at 479-2128 .Youmay
alsocontactLeonard Sandoval regarding Public Works issues at 479-2198 .
Sincerely,
AnnKjerulf
PlannerI
Town of Vail
o JU'CYCLEDPA PF.R
C -~FommumtyDevelopmentPlanRoutmg orm
Routed To:TomKassmelor Leonard Sandoval,Public Works
Return To:AnnKjerulf,Planning
Date Routed:03/21/01
ReturnBy :03/28 /01
Project Name:Mentlik Residence
Project Address:2437 Garmisch Drive
Project Legal:Lot12,Block H,VailDas Schone #2
Project Description:New Single Family Residence
__Approved __Denied(citedetailedreasons)_x_Approved withconditions
•
1-'.J"''''r~\il''t\~"~,rt~~f;c~_'!j'.,."..~'JID ~ir;!~1f§l)f '~..,1!!':i5',~~"l1t ~;',
Ij ,"~."",,,'.C;Q~l~l §,"J."d'"''',1 .~'O~..,~:$~
Max width of driveway is 24'.(Flared endtoflaredend)adjust and revise .
Provide landscape plan.
Revocable right of way permit for parking space withintheright of way ,snow storage in R.O.W.,4'concrete
panand landscaping.
Need stamped approved drawing from license P.E .forall boulder retaining walls4-6ft.
Revocable right of way permit required.Concrete pan,landscaping,driveway,and concrete wall.At Building
permit stage.
Date received :
Reviewed by :Leonard Sandoval Date reviewed:5-9-01
•FILE COpy ·
D epartment ofCommunityDevelopment
75SouthFrontage Road
Vail,Colorado 8 1657
9 70-479-2138
FAX 9 70-479-2452
www.ci.vail.co .us
Mar ch30,2 001
JohnMart in,AlA
P.O.Box621
Vail,CO 8 1658
Re:Mentlik Residence -Lot 12,Block H,VailDas Schone #2/2437 GarmischDrive
Dear John:
Planning ,PublicWorks,andFireDepartment staff havereviewedtheproposalforthe Mentlik residence
tobelocatedat 2437Garmis ch Drive.Priortofinalapprovaltherearcanumber of issuesthatmust be
resol ved:
Public WorksIssues:
Site Pia"&Landscape Pia"
o Finishedgrad es may notexceed 2 :1..Please revise plansindicat ing gradesnotgreaterthan 2:I(note
northeastern and s outheasternportion s oflot).
o SnowstoragemustbeaccommodatedwithinlotboundariesperTOVstandards .Pleasereviseplans
accordingly (10 %area of heateddriveor30%areaof unheateddrive).
o Sh ow all (3)requiredparking spacesonthe siteplan.
o Showtheelevationgrade of thebottom of theditchontheeast and westsides of theculvert.There
mustbeatleast I 'ofcove r over theculvert.
oShowthelimits of disturbancefenceonboththesiteandlandscape plans.
oShowonthesiteplan,b est managementpract ices forerosion control(onthelotanintheTOVr.o.w.)
oOnthenortheastern portion ofthelotnearthepatio,betweentheconcretewalland boulder retaining
wall ,a 6'benchisrequired .Wallscannotexceed6'.Pleasereviseplansaccordingly .
oAlllandscapingmustoccurwithinlotboundariesandr.o.w.unlesstheowner of Lot13gives
approvalforplantingonLot13.Pleasereviseplansaccord ingly.
PlanningIssues :
Site Pia"
oRequiredparkingspaces(3)mustbeaccommodatedwithinlotboundariesandare9 'xI8'insidea
garageand9 'xI9 'outside .
o Community DevelopmentDept.mustreceiveacopy of anencroachmentagreementfortheretaining
wa llproposedwithinthe utility easementonthesouthside of thelotorthewallmustberemoved.
o RE CYCLEDI'APER
•
Fire Department Issues:
o The residence will have tobe sprinklered duetosite constraints.
•
Please notethatpriortothe issuance ofa building permit,the Community Development Department will
requirethe following information:
o P.E.-stamped drawings forwalls between 4'and6'in height and double-tier walls.
o A revocable right-of-way permitforthe concrete pan,portionof driveway,landscaping,andconcrete
wallintheTownofVail right-of-way
Youare scheduled fora conceptual review withthe DRB onApril-l".Afterthat meeting,Iwillprovide
youwiththeBoard members'comments sothat ~ou can make any further necessary revisions totheplans
andproceedtoa final DRB meeting onApril 18 '.Ifyouhaveany questions or concerns,pleasecontact
meat 479-2148 or email meatakjerulf@.ci.vai1.co .us.YoumayalsocontactLeonard Sandoval at479-
2198 regarding Public Works issues or Mike Vaughan at 479-2252 regarding Fire Department issues.
Sincerely,
dlU 'LL-~AnnK~e~J
PlannerI
TownofVail
••Community Development Plan Routing Form
RoutedTo :TomKassmelorLeonard Sandoval,Public Works
ReturnTo :AnnKjerulf,Planning
DateRouted:03/21/01
RetumBy:03/28 /01
Project Name:Mentlik Residence
Project Address:2437 Garmisch Drive
Project Legal:Lot12,BlockH,VailDasSchone#2
Project Description :NewSingleFamilyResidence
__Appro ved _x_Denied (citedetailedreasons)__Approvedwithconditions
North easts ide of lotnearGarmishDr.-disturbedgradingmustreturntoa2:Igrade.Adjust andrevise.
Retaining wallmayberequired .
Snowstoragemustbewithinlot boundaries perTown of Vailstandards.Adjust andrevise .Sitedistance
requirements willbeaffected.
Showallrequiredparkingspacesonsiteplan
Showelevationgrade of bottom of ditchlevelonbotheastandwestside of culvert .Theremustbealeast I'of
coverover culvert.
Showonsiteandlandscapeplans-limit of disturbancefence .
Showonsiteplan -Best Management Practices .ErosionControl.OnlotandinTown of VailRight of way.
Northeastside of lotnearpatioarea -Betweenconcretewallandboulderretainingwall,a6'benchisrequired .
Half thedistance of thetwowalls.Asshown ,willnotwork.Wallcannotexceed6'inheight.Adjustandrevise.
Provide stampedapproveddrawingforwallsbetween4 -6 ft inheight.Alsoprovidedrawingfordoubletier
walls.
Fire Department approval required .
Landscape plan-anytreesplantedmustbewithinlotboundariesunless owner oflot 13Agivesanapproval.
Adjustandrevise.
Revocable right of waypermitrequired.Concretepan ,landscaping,driveway,and concrete wall .
Datereceived:
Reviewed by :LeonardSandoval Datereviewed:3-27-01
•
APPLICATION FOR DESIGN REVIEW APPROVAL
G ENERAL INFORMATION
This appl ication is fo r anyproject requiringDesignReview approval.Any project requiring designreview must
rece ive Design Review approvalpriortosubmittingfor a buildingpermit.For specific information,seethe submittal
requirements for the particular approvalthat is requested.The application cannot be accepted until all the required
inform ation is submitted.Theproject may also needtobereviewedbytheTownCounc il and/or thePlanningand
Environmental Commission.Design Review Board approval expires one year after final approval unless a
huilding permit is issued and construction is started.
A.DES CRIPTION OFT HE REQ UEST:Vrc;.W evS ToJA efS (O~TCA-k 'it&r R-fPHU..I(.
Ytzr4f:.-liAef-.1 (<:iN PC?<uE 52e·..WIl..LdAM L MeNrtdl::.
Construction ofa new building .
Includesanyaddition where square footageis added toany r esidentialor
commercialbuilding.
Includes minorchangestobuildingsand site improvements.suchas,
reroofing,painting.willdo~additions.landscaping.fencesand retaining
walls,etc.
$20oMinorAlteration-
LOC ATION OF PROPOSAL:LOT :12.BLOCK:H fiLING :VA("b,H SC tUJ/Jf .#7-
P HYSICAL ADDRESS :Z I.{"5 7 (it A f?H ISH Dl2...
P ARCEL #:2 J ():5 ~Uc;-I ~·a:::aContact EagleCo.Assessors Office at 970-328 -8640 for pared #)
ZONING:fflHAf8!5w,vD,c..7?'t'.,
NAME OF OWNER(S):WfL..L.CAM t...Be AJ Tl.-IK cfc.,Lrz l..k,Jt H.
MAILING ADDRESS :tRot:><;()()Tk AI$&)VE W6~T
/,tJ~sTF!EkD &1.CQo'V2 PHONE:"to(3-5(e~(j,~o,..
OWNER(S)SIGNA TURE(S):-----.:SrY--==---?-:.---&-f-tl-"''''~:::..:·if"='''--------------.I U
NAME OF APPLICANT:-lD lof.,.{Gr f.1,M?rtr{•A:IA
MA ILING ADDRESS:'-I..'f6!£--I:g1':O~)<,----,~~z.-:::...I...(_
\lArk Co.<6l "s=!>I
TYPE Of REVIEW AND fEE;
j(}New Construction -$200
o Addition -$50
B.
C.
D.
E.
H.
-*F.
G.
DRB f eesar e tobe paidatthetime o f submittal.Later.when applying forabui lding permit,please identify
the acc urate va luation oftheproject.The Town of Vail willadjustthe f ee according totheproje ctv aluation.
P LE ASE S UBMIT THIS APPLlCATION ,ALL S UBMITTALR EQUIREMENTS Al'lD THE FEE TO THE
DEPART iVIEN T OF COiVlMUNITY DE VELOPMENT.75 SOUTH FRONTAGE ROAD,
V AIL,COLORADO 8165 7.
MAR.13.2001 12:29PM LE RNE R,DAVID,LITTE NB
Da /1~/20al 10:%2 FU 970 9237 JOHN G MARTIN •
NO .418P .l
III 02
AUTHORIZATION SIGNATURE FROM
OWNER FOR DESIGN REVIEW
APPLICATION:
~•
WlUIam L Menttik
JOI'lN G.....,RTIN,ARCIoIITECT
11'4 _ii,-..__8.UI
......,(lml')~?t
"",.(S7Q)D7_~.,..........--JoM""'_.........
J~PlnIJMI A'1 _fIIIr.
Mr.William L Mentlik
Lat 12,.-oM v.II ElU ...FlIng 2
:w.:p Or..va GJ_..,.
NEW CONSTRUCTION DESIGN REVIEW
••
GENERAL INFORMATION
The review process fornew construction normally requires two s eparate meetings of theDesign Re view
Board:a conceptual approval andafina l approval.App licants should p lan on presenting their deve lopment
proposal at a minimum of two meetings before obtaining final approval.
I..SUBMITTAL REOUIREMENTS
A preliminary title report.including Schedules Aand B.to verify ownerships and easements.
Photos of the existing siteand adjacent structures.where applicable.
C ondominium Association approval.if applicable.
o
Three (3)copies of the following:
To pographic survey,stamped byalicensed surveyor,ata scale of I"=20'or larger.on which th e
following information is provided :
Yd Ticsto existing benchmark.either USGS landmark or sewer invert.This infonnatioo must
be clearly stated onthe surveys othatallmea surements arc based onthe same
commencement point.
Qd Lotareaand if applicable,buildable area .
J2"Legal description andph ysical address .
~Scale witha graphic barsca le a nd north arrow .
~Property boundaries tothe nearest hundredth (.01)ofa foota ccuracy.Distances and
bearings anda basis of bearing mustbe shown.Show exi sting pins o r monuments found
and their relationshi p totheesta blished comer..
ca.Topographic conditions attwofoot contour intervals unless the parcel consists of6 acres o r
more.in which case.5'contour intervals maybe accepted.
Exist ing trees or groups of trees having trunks with diameters of 4"or more,as measured
froma point onefoot above grade.
Rock outcroppings and other significant natural features (large boulders.intcnnitteiit
streams.etc .)...
All existing improvements (ineluding foundation walls.roof overhangs,building overhangs.
etc .).
1fV~Hazard areas (avalanche,rockfall,etc .),centerline and edge of stream or creek,required
c reekor stream setback,IOO-yearfloodplain and slopes of 40 %or more,if ap p licable.
•
~Size and type of drainage culverts.swales.etc.
•••
o
IE Exact location of existing utility sources and proposed service linesfrom their source tothe
structure.Utilities to include:
Cable TV SewerGas
Telephone Water Electric
Showallutility meter locations.including any pedestals onsiteorinthe right-of-way
adjacent tothesite.
Indicate all easements identified onthe subdivision platand recorded against the property as
indicated inthetitlereport .List any easement restrictions.
Spot elevations attheedge of asphalt.along thestreet frontage of the property at twenty-five
foot intervals (25').anda minimum of onespot elevations on either side of thelot.
Site and Gmding Plan.ata scale of I"=20'orlarger.showing the following information:
rB Property and setback lines.
~Existing and proposed casements.
!lsi Existing and proposed grades.
IZI Existing and proposed layout of buildings and other structures including decks.patios.
fences andwalls.Indicate thefoundationwithadashedlineandthe roof edge withasolid
line.'.
All proposed roof ridgelineswith proposed elevations.Indicate existing and proposed
grades shown underneath all rooflines.Thiswillbeusedto calculate building height ,
Proposed driveways.including percentslopeandspot elevations atthe property line.garage
slabandas necessary along the centerline of the driveway to accurately reflect grade.
A4'wide concrete panattheedge of asphalt for driveways thatexitthe street inanuphill
direction .
Locations of all utilities including existing sources and proposed service linesfrom sources
tothe structures..'
Ui Proposed surface drainage onandoff-site .
aI Location of landscaped areas .
Location of all required parking.
Snow storage areas.
Retaining wallswith proposed elevations attopand bottom of walls.A detailed cross-
Proposed dumpster location anddetail of dumpster enclosure.'.
2
I ••
section and elevation drawings shallbe provided ontheplanor separate sheet.
g~Delineate areas tobe phased and appropriate timing.ifapplicable
"'¢"Landscape Plan,ata scale of I"=2<Y orlarger.showing the following information :
Landscape planmustbedrawn"atthe same scale asthesiteplan .
Location of existing trees,4"diameter or larger.Indicate treesto remain.tobe relocated
(including new location).andtobe removed.Large stands of treesmaybe showntas
bubble)if the strand isnotbeing affected bythe proposed improvements and grading.
Indicate all existing ground cover and shrubs.
Detailed legend.listingthetypeandsize (caliper for deciduous trees,heightfor conifers.
gallon sizefor shrubs andheightfor foundation shrubs)of allthe existing and proposed
plantmaterial including ground cover.
Delineate critical root zones for existing treesinclose proximity tosite grading and
construction .
Indicatethe location of all proposed plantings.
~.;,',4
The location andtype of existing and proposed watering systems tobe employed in Cl1l,1ng
forplant material following its installation .:.•:;
Existing and proposed contour lines .Retaining wallsshallbe included withthetopofwall
andthe bottom of wall elevations noted .
Architectural Floor Plans(1/8"=I'orlarger.1/4"is preferred).including the following:
~Floor plans of the proposed development drawnto scale andfully dimensioned,Floor plans
and building elevations mustbe drawn atthe same scale.
~"Clcarly indicate onthefloorplanstheinsideface of the exterior structural walls of the
building.
il!J Labelfloorplansto indicate the proposed floorareausc(i.c .bedroom.kitchen,etc.).
I2SI Oneset of floor plans mustbe "red-lined"indicating howthe gross residential floor area
(GRFA)was calculated.Sec section 18.04 .130 Floor Area.gross residential (GRFA)of the
Vail Municipal Code forthe definition of GRF A.
~Provide dimensions of all roof cavesand overhangs .
o Architectural Elevations (1/8"=I'orlarger.1/4"is preferred),including the following:
~All elevations of the proposed development drawn toscaleandfully dimensioned.The
elevation drawings must show both existing and finisbed grades.Floor plansand building
elevations must bedrawnatthe same scale.
3
••\
rJlp If building faces areproposedatanglesnotrepre sented wellonthenormalbuilding
ele vations.show thesefacesalso.
Elevations shal l show proposedfinished elevat ion offloorsandroofsonalllevels .
1ilJ All exterior material s andcolorsshallbespecifiedontheelevations.
~.Thefo llowing shallbeshowngraphicallyandfully dimensioned:fascia.trim .railings .
chimney caps.meterlocations.andwindowdetails .
Wi}Showall pro posed exteriorlig hting fixturesonthe building ..
Illustrat e alldecks.porches andbalconies .
~Indicatethe roof andbuildingdrainage system (i.e,guttersanddownspouts).
fJ(Indicate allrooftopmechanicalsystemsandallother roof structures.if applicable.
Il4 Illustra te proposed buildingheightelevationonrooflinesandridges .These elevations
s hould coordinate withthefinished floor elevation s andthedatumusedforthesurvey .
till E xterior color a ndmaterialsamples s hallbe submitted to staff and presented attheDesign
ReviewBoardmeeting .
Q($a £,jAcJ~g h t i n g Plan.indicating ty pe.locationandnumb er of fixtures.Include heightabove grade .lum ens
r~output.luminous a reaand attac h acutsheet of eachfixture ,
The A dministratoran d/or ORBmay require the submissionof additiona l plans.drawings.
spec ifications .samples andoth er materials(including a model)ifdeem ed necessary to determine
whether a project w illcompl y withDesignGuidelineso rif theintent oftheproposal isnotclearl y
indicat ed.
.~
II..IMPROVEMENTLOCA nON C ERTIFICATE lILC)
On cea buildin g permithasbeenissued,andconstructionisunderway .and before the Building
Department willscheduleaframinginspection.two copiesofan Improvement LocationCertific ate
survey(lL C)stampedby aregisteredprofessional engineermustbe submitted.Thefollowin g
information must be providedontheILC:
A.Basis of bearing andtictosection comer.
13.All property pinsfoundor set.
C .Build ing locationls)withticstoproperty comers (i.e.distan ces andangles ).
D.Building dimensions.including decksandbalcon ies.tothenearesttenthofafoot.
E.Building andgaragefloor elevations and allroo f ridgeand eaveline elevations .
F.Alldrainageandutilityservicelineas-builts,showing ty pe of material.sizeand exact
location.
H.All casements.
4
BUILDINGMATE RIALS:
•
'.
LIST OF rROPOSED MATERr~LS
T YPE OFMAT ERIAL:
•
COLOR:·
Roof
Siding
Other W all M aterials
Fascia
Soffits
Windows
WindowTrim
.Doors
MelfA!'?'<iffr'4l£-1'0 ~te
v'G(2.r:11<(,leG a pAF
/)(E2 fler,der IK'f 5'IOff.()<If "I(..~
5e/Hw A(,C/H ,.CLAD
...)l...,.,.,Ptc SiJ>..((..{-SQL.ID
,t gv-r(~fl,lvT "
J1p()r?E PAid rc.-Cl.?Si.l-{
#470
0 ·5 <'SeC-IO •f?...rr€,dWr
If {''''IT€'RrJ.Yi
5f4N!7AeQ T~
II /1 8 vrrGRtJU(
S )AtJP"#l2 ~
Door Trini
Handor Deck Rails
Flues
Flashings
Chimneys
Trash Enclosures
Greenhouses
Retaining Walls
Exterior Lightingt"
5M,,!I;A~la lJ AJr20w 7f;IH .."({B(/~C/T
2"~C13.P ?iC'-{(?A((...S .Mti'rA.L.f1f'5H(cwl£)II I'Fvr71i f:rJVr
/
5fe :5rr~fM JJ /~T(oN 5,
err C~L-6-[?~.Cf u,I
Other
*Pleasespecifythe manufacturer's color,numberandattachasmallcolorchip
**Allexterior lighting must meetthe Town's Lighting Ordinance18.54.059(1).Ifexteri6r lightingisproposed,
please indicatethenum ber offixtu res andlocations onaseparate I ightingplan .Identify each fi xture typeand provide
theheightabovegrade,lum ens output.luminous area,andattachacut sheet of the lighting fixtures .
2
~
~:Up'd~ted 6/97
•
PROPOSED LANDSCAPING
"":,J'E €-lA::-~.YP5c....-~f'l-At0
•
,PROPOSED TREES
AND SHR'UBS :
EX ISTING TREES TO
BE REMOVED:
Botanical Namc
,.'
COOJmolJ Namc Ouantity
GROUND COVER
SOD
SE ED
IRRIGATION
"Minimum 'requirements for landscaping:deciduous trees -2 inchcaliper
coniferous trees-6 feetinheight
shrubs -5 gallons
Square F ootage
T YP E OR M ETHOD OF
E ROSION CO NTROL
OTHER LANDSCAP E FE ATURES (retaining wail s,fenc es,swimming pools,ctc.)Please specify.Indicatetop and
bottom e leva tionso f retainingwa lls,'Maximum heightofwalls \v it h i ~thefront s etback is '"feet,Maximum heigh t of
walls e lsewhe r e a ll the p roperty iso fe et.
',';"
3
"'{i
,"
·...1
.Updated 6197
•()--,,
:('-1":;/:"'-'-1'1_-'
UTILlIY LOCATION VERIfICATION
I ~.?
This form is to verity service availab ility andlocationfornew construction and should beusedin conjunction
.with preparing yourutilityplanand scheduling installations .Thelocationand availability of utilities.whether
theybemaintrunklinesor proposed lines.mustbe approved andverifiedbythe following utilitiesforthe
accompanying site plan .
Authorized Signature
D~~
l:..C.J..A1 T lI<-r
949-5530
FloydSala zar "\'i\-i2-1A Ji./l Z
,11'l1'1ti ~S-~o
EagleRiverWater
~~~~~t;gon District *r:L;4/f
Fred Haslcc ~JI }tl)iltdk~t-.3 --f Z -(J
*Pleasebringasiteplan.floorplan .andele vations when obtaining Upper Eagle Valley Water &Sanitation
U.S .West Communications
1-800-922-1987
468 -6860 or 949-4530
(&,el)
Public Service Company
949 -5781 CI 70)u,,2,·I{OS=7
~)h i(f \]rq)11q,(o uq(~
HolyCrossElectric l slbciJ '1 Q)(v,Q,~~t.o
94lJ-5892 f~
TedHusky /John Boyd
'6~'i:>'C"f -'-{blO
signatures.Fireflow needs musthe a ddressed.
NOTES:
I .Iftheutility verification form has signatures fromeach of the utility companies.andno
comments arcmadedirectlyontheform,theTownwill presume thattherearcno problems and
the development canproceed.
2.Ifautility company has concerns withthe proposed construction.theutility representative shall
note directly ontheutility verification formthatthereisa problem whichneedstobe resolved.
Theissue should thenbedetailedinan attached lettertothe Town of Vail.However,please
keep inmindthatitisthe responsibility of theutility company andthe applicant to resolve
identified problems.
3 .These verifications donotrelievethe contractor of the responsibility toobta in aPublicWay
Permitfromthe Department of PublicWorksattheTown of Vail.Utility locationsmustbe
obtained before digging inanypublicright -of-way or casement within theTown ofVaiI.A
building permit isnotaPublicWay permit andmustbe obtained scnarately.
4 Updated 6/97
•
I.PRE-APPLICATION CONFERENCE
•
A pre-application conference with Town of Vail staff is required.No application canbe accepted unless the
mandatory pre -appl ication meeting hasbeen completed.It isthe applicant's responsibility to schedule this
meeting by calling 970-479 -2128.
II..TIME REOUiREMENTS
The Des ign Review Board meetsonthe l st and3rd Wednesdays of each month .A complete application
form and all accompanying material mustbe accepted bythe Community Development Department a .
minimum of three anda half(3 1/2)weeks prior tothedate of the ORB public hearing.
Ill.REVIEW CRITERIA
Your proposal willbe reviewed for compliance withthe Design Guidelines assetforthin Section 18.54 of the
Municipal Code.
IV .NOTE TO ALL APPLICANTS :
A.Ifap roperty is located ina mapped hazarda rea (i.c.snow avalanche,rockfall .floodplain,debris
flow.wetland,etc).ahaz..ard study must be submitted andthe owner must sign an affidavi t
recognizing the hazard report prior tot he issuance of a building permit.Applicants arc encouraged
to check withthe planning staff prior to submittal of aORB application to determine therelationship
of thc property toall mapped hazards.
B .BasicPlan Sheet Formal.Forall surveys,siteplans,landscape plans and other site improvements
plans.all of the following mustbe shown .
I .Plan sheet size must be24"x36".Forlarge projects.larger plan size maybe allowed.
2.Scale.The minimum scale is1"=20'.All plans must be atthe same scale.
3.Graphic bar scale.
4 .North arrow.
5.Tit le block,project name,project address andlegal description.
6.Ind ication ofplan prcparcr,address and phone number.
7 .Dates of original plan preparation andall revision dates.
8 .Vicinity mapor location map at a scale of 1"=1.000'or larger.
l).Sheet labels and numbers.
10 .A border withaminimum left side margin of 1.5".
I I .Names of all adjacent roadways.
12.Plan legend.
C.For new construction and additions,the applicant must stake and tape the project sitetoindicate
property lines.proposed buildings and building comers.All trees tobe removed must be taped.The
applicant must ensure that staking done during the winter is not buried by snow.Allsi te tapings
and staking must be completed prior to the day of the DRB meeting.
D.Applicants who failto appear beforetheDesign Review Board on their scheduled meeting da te and
w ho have not asked in advance thatdiscussi on onthei r item be postponed.willhave their items
removed fromt he ORB agenda untilsuchtimeasthe item has been repub lished.
E .Ifthe ORB approves the application with conditions or modifications,all conditions of approval
m ust be r esolved prior t o the issuance of ab uilding permit.
5 Updated 6/97
MA R 1 3 •0 I 9:51
.0 3 /1-"/2001 10:(:.I
FR.LEAD IJ I LLE OPS
FAX 9iO~2237 JOES G ~~TI N •PA GE.00 2
IilJ 01
UTII,I1Y LOCATION VERIFICATION
This fOITTl isto verii)'serviee availability and location for new constructicr;and should be used in conjunction
.with preparing your utility plan and scheduling insialhlt10ns.The location and availability of'utilities,whether
t~ey be main trunk lines or Ilro/lOlied lines.mustbo approved and vcrified by the following utilities forthe
accom~nying site plan,
Aulborized 51 !!narurc
us .West CQmmunicario~
1-800-922-1987
468~6860 or 949-4530
Ho Iy ross Electric Assoc.
949-SR92
'red Husky/John Boyd
r.c.r.
949·5530
Floyd SaI<l7M
EagLe River WatCf
&.Sanitation District "
47f,-741l0
Fred Haslec
DW ~J:>)£)1
I
~PICOS$D bring a :lirc plan.floor pllU1.and elevations when obtltining Upper ~lc Valley Watw &Sanitation
signatures.fire flow needs must be addressed...~-
NOTES:
I .If the utiliey verification form has siif\StUTC.'l from cach ofthe ytllily companies.andno
comments arc made direclly on the forot.the Town will presume that there lII"C no problems lII1d
the <k:Vclopmcnt can proceed,
If a utility eompany has CQJll;Oft1S with thg proposed conlllnJclion.the utility reprcsc:ntarivc shall
note directly on the utility verification form that there U II problem which needs to be resolved,
The issue shO\l.ld thCQ be detailed in ...uacl1ed Idtcr to the Town of Vail.However.please
keep in mind Iliat it is the R5JlOnsibility of the utility company and the;appliCMl to n:solvc
identified pc'Oblans.
3 .These verifications do not relieve the conlnlC1Ol'of the rcsponsibilit,yto obtain a Public Way
Permit ttvm the Department of Public Works at the Town orVal"Utility ID!dltlons mmstbe;
obtained bcfO!J<diuiru:in 8fI)'public riglrt·of~WBYor cascmcntwithin tho Town of Vail.A
huildjDJ,!pennil;1 not a Public Way permtt and must be gbtained ieslRl'iteh.
4 Upc1lced 6/9 7
970 47 72237 PR GE.0e l
MAR .13 .2001 12 :S9PM .HOLY CR OSS VAI L•I
UTI'-<ITY I .QCAIlON YERlpCATION •NO.9 99 P.2
This formisto verify service availability and location for new eonsiruction and should be usedIn conjunction
.with preparing your utility plan and scheduling installations.The l ~cation and availability of utiliries,whether
t~ey bernain trunk fines o r proposed lines.mustbe approved and verified by the followin g utili ties for the
aeeomp~ying site plan .
.!AuthQm:cd SllltJaturc
u.s.West Commun ications
I -SOO-922-1987
468-6860 or 949 -4530
Public Service Company
949 -5781
Gary"H all
Hol y Cross Electric Assoc .
949-5 892
Tcd Husky /Jah!l Boyd
T .C.!.
.949·5530
Floyd Sal w.ar
Eagle River Water
&Sanitarian District ..
476-74KO
Fred Haslcc
3-13-QI
i
..Please bring asiteplan.tloor plan .and elevations when obt ainink Upper Eagle Valley W ater &Sanitation
s ignatures.Fireflow needs must be addressed.......
N OTES:
.I
I .If th e utility verification form has s ignatures fi'om :each of the utility companies,and no
comments arcmilde directly on the form.the Town will presume that there arc no problems and
t he development can proceed..
i
2 .If a utility company has concerns with the proposed construction.the utility representative shall
no te directly onthe utility verifi cation formthatt hereIsa problem which needstobe resolved.
The issue s ho~ld thenbe detailed inan attached letter to the Town of VaiLHowever,please
keep in mind tliat it is the responsiblllty of the utility company and the applicant to resolve
identified problems..
3.These verifications do not relie ve the contractor or the responsibility to obtain aPublic Way
Perm it from the Dep artment of Public W orks at toc Town ofVaiI.Utility locationsmust be
obtained before diogjng in anypub lic right -of:wa ~or easement within the Town of Vail.A
building permit is not a Public Wsy pennit and njust be obtained senarately.
4 Updated 6197
!-Dc I.g~o&i(H /'FIIANer .2 VJ4/t.-PAs'5ew;.!£.
2Lf~7 GPlNrY1/~h Dr.-tJ,;w 5/(~C,L{E':"'rAf.-(IL-Y HoH"::'·
UTILITY LOCATION VERIfICATION
-JgJ-,/l s I0Arh/l q7c7 1.1 77 -2 '-17&
'Jk FAX 477 -'22 '$7
This fonn is toverify service availability andlocationfornew construction and should beusedin conjunction
.with preparing your utility planand scheduling installations .The locationand availability of utilities .whether
theyhemaintrunklinesor proposed lines.mustbe approved andverifiedbythe following utilitiesforthe
accomp~nying siteplan .
Authorized Signature
U.S .West Communications
I -800-922-1987
468-6860 or 949-4530
Public Service Company
949-57!1 I
GaryHall
HolyCrossElectricAssoc .
949 -5892
TedHusky /John Boyd
(J.z ;~···"..
949 -5530
FloydSala 7.ar
EagleRiver Water
&Sanitation District ..
476-7480
fred Haslcc
..Please bringasiteplan.floorplan.and elevations when obtaining Upper Eagle Valley Water &Sanitation
signatures.Fireflow needs mustbe addressed.
NOTES :
I.Ifthe utility verificationformhas signatures fromeach of the utility companies,andno
comments arcmade directly ontheform,the Town will presume thattherearcno problems and
the development can proceed.
2 .Ifautility company has concerns withthe proposed construction.the utility representative shall
note directly ontheutility verification form thatthereisa problem which needstobe resolved.
Theissue should thenbe detailed inan attached letter tothe Town of Vail.However,please
keepin mind that itisthe responsibility of the utility company and the applicant to resolve
identified problems,
3.These verifications donotrelievethe contractor ofthe responsibility toobtainaPublic Way
Permit from the Department of Public Works atthe Town of Vail.Utility locations mustbe
obtain ed before digging inanypublic right-of-way or casement within theTown of Vail.A
building permit isnotaPublicWaypem1itandmustbe obtained senarately.
4 Updated 6/97
•
I.PRE-APPLICATIONCONfERENCE
•
A pre-application conference withTownofVail stains required .No application canbe accepted unless the
mandatory pre-application meetinghasbeen completed.It isthe applicant's responsibility to sehedule this
meeting by calling 970-479-2128 .
II.TIMEREOUiREMENTS
TheDesign Review Boardmeetsonthe1st and3rd Wednesdays of eachmonth.A complete application
formandall accompanying materialmustbe accepted bythe Community Development Department a
minimum ofthrce anda half(3 1/2)weekspriortothedate of the ORB publichearing.
III.REVIEWCRITERIA
Your proposal willbe reviewed for compliance withtheDesign Guidelines assetforthinSection18.54 of the
Municipal Code.
IV.NOTETOALLAPPLICANTS:
A.Ifa property islocatedinamappedhazardarea(i.c,snow avalanche,rockfall,floodplain.debris
flow,wetland,etc).ahazardstudymustbe submitted andthe owner mustsignan affidavit
recognizing thehazardreportpriortothe issuance ofa building permit.Applicants are encouraged
tocheckwiththe planning staff priortosubmittalofa ORB application to determine the .relationship
of t he property toallmappedhazards .
B.Basic Plan Sheet formal.Forallsurveys,siteplans,landscape plansand other site improvements
plans,all or the following mustbeshown .
I .Plan sheet sizemustbe24"x36".for large projects,larger plan sizemaybe allowed.
2.Scale.The minimumscal e is I"=20'.Allplansmustbeatthe same scale.
3.Graphic bar s cale .
4 .Northarrow .
5.Titleblock,project name,projectaddressandlegal description.
6 .Indication of planprcparcr,addressandphone number.
7.Dates of originalplan preparation andallrevisiondates.
lI.Vicinity maporlocationmapatascale of 1"=1,000'or larger.
lJ .Sheet labelsand numbers.
I U .A border withaminimum left sidemarginof1.5".
II .Names of alladjacentroadways .
12.Planlegend .
C.Fornew construction andadditions,the applicant must stake andtapetheprojectsiteto indicate
property lines,proposed buildingsandbuilding comers.All trees tobe removed mustbetaped.The
applicant must ensure thatstakingdoneduringthe winter isnot buried bysnow.All site tapings
and staking must be completed prior tothe day of the DRB meeting.
D.Applicants whofailtoappearbeforetheDesignReview Board on their scheduled meeting dateand
whohavenot asked inadvancethatdiscussionontheiritembe postponed.willhave their items
removed fromthe ORB agendauntilsuchtimeastheitemhasbeen republished .
E.Ifthe ORB approves the application with conditions or modifications,all conditions of approval
mustbe resolved prior totheissuance of a building permit.
5 Updated6/97
••
DESIGN REVIEW CHECKLIST
OSURVE/
Scale
V Benclunark
I --V Legal description
;V LotSize
/'-'rv".c _V BuildableArea =""V'-'
./Easements 1-F.,DtJ (S)6T t:£
./Topography
N IA>100yr.floodplain
'"IA -Water Course Setback
~Environmental Hazards
N CP (~~Tre~UJI MN f/)CPEftrj
./Utilitylocations VrJ .9 T£rpUtrJ.
o FLOOR PLANS
Scale
GRFA
250 additional GRF A
Crawl\Attic Space
EHU
o BUILDING ELEVATIONS
Scale
Color-Materials
RoofPiteh
o LAt~DSCAPE PLAN
Existingtrees
Proposedtrees
Spot elevations
o SITEPLAN
.,/'Scale
.,/BuildingHeight
-,
Legend
MISCELLANEOUS
Condo Approval
Titlereport(A &B)
Utility verification form
V Site Coverage
/'Eaves/Overhangs (4')
./(N \~iDli-'Decks/BalconiestSIr\i~
,/Garage connection
4 QR.>'fS Ey..Cffii)~'.\
,/~I.
\-lD __
N If.><-.Fences
Barking/Garage Nor $/'tU.,,)rJ
Turning Radius
Driveway (accessand grade)
/SnowStorage
Photos of site
Buildingmaterial samples
C.O.Verification
SWI\Shade Angles
Utilities (underground)
View Corridors
Variances
Plat restrictions
••
ZONECHECK
Phone _
Phone __---'-_
Proposed usc
Buildable arca,_
Date:MA/1t tI 'tl /Q /
Legaldescription:Lot 11-BJoek _.:.u-_F i lin g_--,!!..L:~....rl..!.L.~::!:::::~~c:J..'::L">L4..!...~::::""
Address Q431 4Aem i ~L H D2 .
Owner [V/&J(I.ik.
Architect .1')HN MfMrrA:
Zonedistrict £..1.5L
Lot size Uii 5-D 't:;[
Allowed
Total GRFA 2>1\3f\+lfJ-C;=3lo/5
ExistingProposedTotalRemaining
5~0r~l .£i f .
Primary GRFA +(425)(675*)=_+----=----
tJ /be .SocGIlGary GRfA __+(425)(675*)=_+----=----
*675 =425credit plus250addition
Docsthisrequestinvolve a 250 Addition?__~_
Howmuchoftheallowed 250 Additionisusedwiththis request?__...l...:.!..!::~_
Site Coverage D;;;.)Iq /~tJ/A +rq t3 =¢
Height (30)(33)
Setbacks Front 20'
Sides 1-,\'.)
Rear 15'
'.
Landscaping Minimum ?fle W
RetainingWallHeights 3'/6'
Parking Required 3 Enclosed
(300)c@9Y(900)(1200)Garage Credit
Driveway
10m I
7
Permitted Slope %ProposedSlope %
Complies withTOVLightingOrdinance Yes,_No,_
Arc finished grades lessthan 2:1 (50%)Yes,_No,_
E nvironmental/H azards I )PercentSlope «>30%)'7 ~/.
2)Floodplain _...!.N""'L:.I A.::::.......;·_
3)Wetlands /JIb.-.
4)WaterCourseSetback (30)(50)'_.L..:N'-!.'I""'A-""--''--_
5)GeologicHazards -,-.::....-_
a)Snow Avalan che__..c.N.::..c.;1 f:>..::..-.;..'_
b)Rockfall _·---;__
c)DebrisFlow _
Previo us conditionsof approval (check property fi le),~'_
Isthe property non-conforming?Describe:_
+1-~
~t.-"CN 1SF .
rv\t\l'~:I ~~'2.-~.F .
WpcQ..;~q S.F.
~l1e5(.
.j..~2...--'Zo S'D
I)ale;09-21-2000
L.ardTltle GararteeOJmnt
<IBJt:J.r&lDSJRBinQ..l -6 ~
Our Order Number:V27OS114
Property Address:
LOT 12,BLOCK H,VAlL DAS SCHONE FIL~G NO.2
I'Rt:nENTIAI.GOllE IlA'I;GE PROI'ERTlK~-EDWAllOS
POBOX llOJ
EDWARDS,C O 81632
A 1ll'l1 BllL CAYNOSlO
Pho",,:97().92G-s.wo
1'..:970·926·6503
~nl Vb.COUl"M:~*
JOHN MA(."Ll!A!Ii FAMD.Y J'A){TIiERSIIU'
11 MAl!\:ST .
CI.FBlJRl\"E,TX 70031
Aan:JOHN ~lACLEA:'"
PM",,:817-645-3700
Fas:,817·~·3788
Scnt VI.US l 'osbll S<,,1~
L\NU TiTLE CUARA:'I:TIiE CO"lPA:"'Y
65 MARKET ST It4,p.n HOX 4420
EAGLF~CO 81631
A ttl.;~e ao."inM Group
J>bonr:9'1l).318-504S
Fu:'J10-328·S0/i4
F.ASTV,\Il.RJo:AI.IT.-
POBOX IOJ3 •
3Y71 BIGHORN ROAQ .
VAlL.CO XI6iS,.
AlU1:I'll.TRlClA DRANCA
1'00111::'J70-476-6663
~'a"970-416-6007
Sent Via Fax
W1LUA:14 Mt~>;n ,m.
6(K)S.AVE.W.I
WE!>"TFIF.I.D,NJ 011fO
gem Via Unliro Plon:cl Service ·
I
,,~
",',"
'I '"~~F~'!',!'f "
i ~i!.
i j
"I':W 'llfiH """","'1 ,1 I r"'".'r,'.'·,"~",l\r '!'l!'"
"',I ',!.;,!."I'.'j I'I ",,i I I II ~I ,'I .I;:
,,
r
I
I
I,
I,,
(
1
\
\
I,
\
L_
:.
i !;
::.
"i ,
Mar ~2 01 05:17p E ~l Realt~/Bi~horn M~mt
.From L~~d Tit le Guarantee Company Thu Sep 21 16:31:09 2000
IzdTrtleGa'atee CbrlJnj
'ttl.RCDlTACTS
9 _476 -6007
Page2 of 8
•ft .
p.2
n"le:09-21-2000
Property 1\ddre&S:
LOT 12,BLOCK H,YAIL DAS SCHO:-lE FILIN(;xo,1
BuyerlBorrower:
WILLL.\M MENTUK
..,...
Our Ord";'NU!D~~'.:.v #~~.·e '
.~:',',\
.'
.""'"
Seller/Owner:......'.t
JOH:-i AND CAROL MACLEAN FAMILY PAR:r"'~RSHIP,.LTD .,A ll!XAS LlMn'ElJ P 1NE~HI1'
-'i>,#..'.....':-~..."
.~!
If you have Ilny inquiries or ""'lulre'[urlher assistance,please cont'!-cl one of the.nmnbers below::...·~.i·.~
For Closing ,uslstance:For Tille Assistance:
Engte Closing Group .Vall Tide Dept.
6S MARKET ST1/4,P.O.BOX4420 Trida K£lIogg
EAGLE,CO 81631 108 S.FRO:'llTAGF.RD.W.11203
Phone:970·328-5065 P .O.BOX 357
Fa'<:970-328·5064 VA"~<"'0 81657..
.Phone:970·476·21'11
Fu:9704764534
-;EMIliI:pkf:J1ogg@lIgc.com
ESI1MAlEa=l1n.EFB5 .
..
Alta Owners Policy 1().17·92
Deldloll of SIDndanI Jo}<""pdon(s)(Owner)
TllX ReportR013387
TOT'AL
THANK.YOU "'OR YOllR ORDERI
:"
~.
$809.O'tl
$40·t.$15.£
.'...
t~
:Is,
"
$864 .oet
•
....
•l i e •I
I I I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
JJ
I
I
I
I
I
I
.II
..
r
••..
·
","••..
...•i ;,~
I I
I ~.
I I
Mar ~2 01 05:17p E~l Realt~/Bighorn Mgmt
.Fro mLandTitle Guarantee Company ~Thu Sep21 16:31:09 2000
Chic"ll0 'nu"Insunmce Company
A LTA COMMlTM ENT
9 _476-6007 .
Page3 of 8
p.3
Schedule A
Properly Address:
L Or 12 ,KI.lX":K H ,v xn,DAS ~HO:-:E FILING NO.2
".
Our Order No.V270584
Cust,Ref.:
1.Effeclive Dale:SqJtcmbo.T 07,2000 III 5:00 P.M.
2.POliCy 10 be Issued ,and Proposed Insured:
"ALTA "Owner's Policy 10·17-92
Propo.<ed Insured:
WILLIAM MENTLIK
$191 .2S0.00
3 .The estate or interest in lhe land described or rd'errcd tointhtsCOll1l1lihncnl and covered herein is:
A Y""Simple
4.Tille to the estate Or Interest covered herein Is lit the effeclln dale bereof vested In:
JOHN AND CAROL MACLEAN FAl\onLY PARTNERSlln'.LTD.,A TEXAS LIMITED PA"R11'IERSHIP
5.The land referred to ill Ihis Ceimutrment ts described fL_follows:
t.or 12,Ill.OCK H,vxn,DAS SCHONE FU.IN(i NO.Z,ACCORDING TO THE RF..cORDED PlAT
TH\i:Rl<:<W,COCNTY OF EAGLE,STAn:n¥COI.oRA no.
l i e:!
I :
!~•I :
I :
:I,I
".
'..,.
."
~:..
.'.'"
,.".'
",:-a,
i i
Mar
•From
~2 01 05:17p E ~1
Land Ticle Guarantee Company .
Realt~~Bighorn Mgmt
Thu ~cp 21 16:31:09 2000
9 _-476-6007
Page 4 of 8
p.4
AL "I'A COM:\1 IT MEN T
Schedule B-SecUon 1
(Requirements)
The following are the requleements 10 be complied wllh:
Our Order Nu .V270584
ttem (8)Pa)-ment 10 or fur the RccolDll of !he g~1Iurs or mortgllROrs of \he full cOffildel"llUon for \he """""or
hllerest to be insured,.
Hem (b)Proper Insirumelll(s)creallng Ihe eslllie or inleres1to be IlI5UI'Cd tml<1 he executed Bnd duly filed for record,
1fl-w1I:--...•.
Item (c)Pay""''''or ai,taxes,charges or """"ss menls levted and assessed ngllllWt lhe snltjeci premlsCJl which are due
and JlIlYable.
Hem (d )AddlUolllll requiremenlS,if BOY disclosed helow:..
\.EVIDENCE SATlSFACfORY TO mil.<:()Ml'ANY 'lllAT TID:TK~L",CONDITIONS i\ND
PROVISIONS OF THE TO~01'VAn .TRANSFER TAX IIA V~;HEENSA T1Sl'iED .
2.WAR1L\NTY D!':E1)!''ROM .JOI1N A1'\I)CAROL M1\CLl<:AN FI\MILY PARTN\<:RSIUP,LTD.,A TEXAS
UMITED PARTNERSHIP TO WILLIAM MENTpK CONVEYINC;SUBJKCr PROPERTY.
NOTF..:CERTIFICATE 0"-LIl\UTED PARTNI<:RSHIP NF.c.oRDED JUNY.14,19%INKOOK ft97
AT PACE 380 DL'iCUlSK'i .JOHNR.~fACl.EAN TO BE 1'111\.CENRRAl.PARTNI';R OF.JOHN
AND CAROL MAl:U:AN FAl'onLY PARTNERSHIP,LTD'.,A n;XAS UMITHD PARTNERSHlP.
"'-.
!'lOrE:THlS PROPERn'MAYBE SUBJF,(-r TO AN ASS~'i"'lli~TBY THE VAIL I>AS SCHOOK
HOMEOWNERS ASSOClATION.PLEASE CONTACI'THE ASSOClA nON TO ENSURE TH"r THE
ASSESSMENTS ARE CURRENT.
NOTE:ITEMS 1-3 OF TIIE GENERAL EXCEmONS AREHEREBY DELETED FROM 1HE
OWNKR'S POUCY.
..).
UPON THE APPROVAL OF THE COMPANY AND THE RECEIPT OF A NOTARIZED FIN"L ~
AFI'1DAVIT.ITE.'l.f 1"0.4 OF THE GENERAL EXCEPTI()lI;S WILL aE.AMEl'>DEJ)AS
FOLLO'''''S:
n"."'!NO.4 OF THE GJo:N";RAL EXCEJ7110NS IS DELETED AS TO ANY UENS OR FUTURE
URNS RESULTL"iG FROM WORK OR MATERIAL FURNISHED AT THE REQUEST OF JOHN AND
CAROL MACLEAN "FAMILY PARl":'iERSHlP,LTD.,A TEXAS UMlTED PARTJliERSHlP.
CHICAGO'IITLE lNSURA!'lCE CoMPANY SHAll.HAVE NO [..lABILITY "'OR A:'>Y L1~S
ARISING FROM WORK OR MA 1ERlAL FUR."IISUED AT THE REQUEST 'OF WILLlAM MENTUK.
NOTE:n"KM 5 OF THE GI!:.\'ERAL EXCEPTIONS WILL BE DELETED IF LAND rrnz
.1
1
I
I
I
~lfTTT"TlT'n
I
1
I
I
I
I
..
II
I I
~II .
II
:
"
f
'.~
,.
~
I '..
:'
I ,
I
!I .0'
I --!r ,
:..
·.":.i ~I -",;'·'.·,:·.
I '."~.:
I ·',
,.;,,
I .:;".,·.
:".:
I
I I I ,
Mar J2 01 05:18p E ~l Realt~/Bighorn M~mt
Fro~land Title Guarantee (ompany~Thu5ep21 16:l1:09 2000
ALTA COMMITMENT
Schedule B-Seclion 2
(EYceptlolls)
9 _"176-6007
Page 6 of 8
,.'~
Our Order llio.\'270S84
I
p.6
T he policy or p"li";""10 he i.,~ucd will conl.ll.ln e<""ptilln.~III Ihc rllllllwlnl:un'."..lhe ""me "re diHpl ~""d
ofIn thl':s H*faction of Ihl':Company:..;
I.
2.
s,
4 .
5.
6 .
,.
B.
9 .
10.
11.
u,
ltights or claim;of parties In possession nol shown by the public records .
j(.asemenlS,or clllim.of easements,not Shown,by lhe public n:cords.
D1s<:"'paneles,conflic1S In boundary lines,shortage in area,.elX'n>aelm",nIS,and 'lIIlY faClS WIdell a COIT«t surV<y and
insptttion or the prmi.'l15 would disclose and whlch are nol shown by the pUbik """lrds.
Any lien,or right to a lien,for scm....,labor or rnalerial Ihtretofonl or hereal'ler-f1JmI.hed,impaled by law and
not shown by u.,public recerds,
Defects,liens,encumbrances,adverse claims OT otlter motters,if any,c",""d,nlSt l1JlPl'arlng in the pubUc records or
atlaChlng sullsequent to d.e efl'ecl1ve dale hereof bul Prior to Ihe dale the proposed Insw-ed a.oquIre..of record for
YIllue U",estate or tuterest ur murtgage UteROll covered Ily tills COllunllmtnL
Taxes or sp.:cial assessmems which an:oot shown ....exi.ti~liens by the public records.
Uens for unpaid waler and sewer cllarRes,If allY.
In addldon,the owner's polic)'will be subjecllD the mortg&g~,If Illty,noled In Section 1of ScbeduJe B bereot,
RIGlfl'OF PROPRlETOR OF AVEINOR LODE TO EXTRACr ANI)REMOVE HIS ORE
TI1ERI<:l<'ROM SHOULD TIlE SAME B":FOIJNIl TO PI<:NETRATE OR INTERSE<....T THF.PRI<:MISK'i
AS RFBERVF:D IN l:NITEJ)STATES PATE."IT R":COR.I>F.D ·AlJGUST u,1900,IN BOOK 48
AT PAGE2J6....
RESTRICTIVE COVE1"ANTS WHICH DO NUl'COi\TAI~A FORFEITURE OR REV":RTER Cl.AUSE,
BUT osirrrrxc A7\Y COVENANT 0)1.RFSTRlCfrO:'ll BASED ON RACE,l-'OLOR,RELIGION,
SEX ,HA/'llDlCAI',FAMILIAL STA IDS OR NA'nONAL ORIGIN UNLESS ANDONLY TO THE
EXTENT THAT SAID COVENANT (A)L'.EXEMPT UNDER CHAPTER 42,SECTION 3607 OF
TIIE L"NlTED STA'mS CODE OR (B)RELATES TO IL\ND£CAP BUT DOES SOT
I>ISCRIl'I'll~ATl!:AGAINST HANDICAP PERSONS,AS CONTAINED iN INSTRUMENT Rj(,(:t)RDED
OCTOBER 10,1%9,IN BOOK 216 AT PAGE 15.3'ANDAS "AMENDED IN I"'STRUI\lE'iT
RECORDED OCTOBER 211 ,1969.IN BOOK 216 At PAGE 2lI4 AI'D AS AM~DED IN
lNSTRUME..-T RECORDED FEBRUARY 16,1970 IN BOOK 217 AT PAGE 77 .
RESERVA '110'"OF AN UlliDIVIDEDU2 INTEREST INA'ND TO THE on,GAS ASD MINERAL
RIm ITS TO TIm ABOVE DR..s CRIDED LAND AS .SIIT FORTI I IN WA RRA NTY DEED RECORDED
DECEMBER 30,1959 rx BOOK 16S AT PAGE 133.
A PHRPETUAL EASEMENT FOR TIlE CONSTRUcrrON MAINTENANCE REMOVAL AND
REPLACEMENT 01'GAS UN"S ALONG ALL DEDICATED ROADS L"VAILDAS SCHOi\";
1:•',
:I .II~I::!::::':::::::::::=JI Ii II I
!
...,.
'..,.
:'•J:I::!:::!:!:±::::::!:¥11.'..
~I -.»
~:
:..
"."'.~~'.;..,
,.:
,.',."
i .:
,..;
~
0
.~.",
:
:,:
I I ,,
•
,
!..
Mar 12 01 05:17p E ~l Re alt~/B lghorn Mgmt
f rom Land Title Guarantee Company ""Thu >ep 21 16:31:09 2000
9 _476-6007
Page S of 8
p.5
A LT A COM ~t IT MEl':T
Schedule B ..Seellon I
(Requirements)Our Order No.V270584
Conl1nued:
TAXES A NlJ ASSI',ss,,"IENTS FOR THE YEA 2000 A ND SUBSEQl Jt;ro;T YEARS.
rrs..M 7 UNDER SCHEDlJLt;B-2 W BE DEl.ETF.D UPOIIi PR()()!l1'1'lA T TH\O;W,\TER AND
~ER CHARGES AREPAIDUPD TE.
RECORDS THE DOC CMEl':TS REQUIRED U ND'IED ~LE B·I.
:'IIOTE:CI'O:'II PROOI'OF PA YMENT OFAL ES..l11':M 6 \'HLL BE AMENDED TO READ::.
•
/-\;;11iii,
f,
I,
\,
\,,
'-,
,,
I,
•
Mar 12 01 05:18p E~~l Realt~/Bighorn Mgmt
Fr~Land Ti tle Gu~rantee Company~Thu Sep21 16:31:09 COOO
A LTA COM [1.1 IT ~1 ~:N T
Schedule B-Section 2
(Exeepttons)
9 _476-6007
Page7 of S
Our Order No.V:170S84
p.?
T hepolicy or policies 10 be issued will cuntain exception.10Ihe followh'l\unlessIhe same are disposed
of 10 the satisfaction of the Company:
FlUNG :"0.1.AS DE'5CRlBED IN INSTRUMENT RECORDED SEPTE.'WIER 6,1968 IN BOOK
213 AT PAGE .~44,
13.EASEMK"'TS,RESERVATIONSA:-;n RHSTRlC11O:,\S AS SHOWN OR RF.SRRVlm ON THE PLAT
OF VAIL DAS SCHONE loiLL"IG NO.:1 RECORDED JUNE zs,1969 IN BOOK 215 AT
PAGE482;LNCLUDI1'iG B UT NOT LD.urED TO:
UT ILITY F..ASK\fE:"iT ALO:"lG THE SOUTHERLY WT LINE OF S UBJECT PROPERn",
•T •..
I
I
••,I
Mar )2 01 05:18p E ~l Realt~/Bighorn Mgmt
from land Title (;uarantee Company "ThuSep21 16:31:09 2000
9 .-476-6007
Pag"8 of 8
p.8
L.AND TITLE G UARANTEE COMPASY
DISCLOSURE STATEMEN1'
Required by CR.S.10-11-122
A)1M 5111tiecl real propeny lIlay be localed Ina sPecial IllXing districL
B)J\C"r1iDcale of Taxes Due listing each l:JX\ng jurisdiction may be olllllined from Ihe Counly
Treasurer's QUlhorized agent
C)T he inlonnalion rqlardlng sp:cilll dislI1cls and the holllKlwies of such dlslricL~lIlay
be olUfncd fromlhe Board of COlmly Connnlsslo""rs.the COlmly Ocri<Bnd Recorder,or
the COIBlIy Assessor.
Effective September I ,1m,CllS 30-10-406 requires Ihat all documents received for recording or "ling In II",
clerk and recorder'5 ornre shall contain a IDp margin ol atle....l oneInch III"..left,right and bottom margin of
at lease 0111'bllIr or :on inch.The cieri<tIlId .nonkr rmsy rcr.....,ID ",cord or file lilly document thai dlles nol
contorm,exc"P!lhat,Ihe requiremenl for die top IlI8l'!lin .dlallnol apply ID documents us~fonns 011 which
splice is proVided rill'fttording or "ling Infonnarion at the IDp margin of the documenL
So~:Colorado DlvlslGn of lnsurance Regu1at1ons 3-5·1,Paragrllph Cor Article Vll requires that "Every
till"end!>'shall be respomlble for all rnalleJ'S which appear or record prior 10 the lime or recordJlII:
whenever the title endty conducLo<the cl'L<tng and is respo",lhIe for recording or nling nf legal
docWnellL<resullll1R I'rom the lJ'lIJ"'BCdon which wa.<closed".Provtded dial T.snd lllle t.uaranlee
Compmy ronducls the etos ing of the Irmm:d Ir1IRRu:llon and Is ~ponslble for recording the
1Cl!1II documents from the transaction,excepdon number 5 "ill not appear on llle Owner's Tide
l'ollcy BIId tile Lenders IVUcy when Iss~d.
Nole:Amnnallve mechanic',lien proleelion ror IfIe ~r may be a\'llllable<t"l'Ically ~deleUoD
or Exccpllon no.4 or Schedule B,seenon 2 or the Conunltment rrom the Owner's \'olley 10 be
Issued)upon colll)lliance ,,1t11the following conditions:
A,The land described in Sehednle A or tfIi..col1WlitmcnlllJlISt be..single family residence whicb '
includes a condominium or IDwnhouse ....L
R.N o labor or material,han been l'urnt.bed by Ineel1Hncs or ltlllerilll-rnen ror purposes of
eonslJUcdon on the IBIId described In Schedule Aor Ihls Conmibnelll within the pest 6 months•.
C.The Co~1ItI1<'reeerve an lIf'P"Opri.....aClldavU Indenmll'ylng Ifl4'Company aglll ...,tm·ftled
mechan!e's and materilll-men'5 liens ,
I),T he Company IIIml recetve pa)-mem of the appropt1ale premilDll.
E.If UIo:re IlllS been cOll!llJUction,11IIIlIVfemt."'l~or l1ll\lOr repBi,.,.under1aken on the .propKly 10
be purcms"d wldlin six IIIlJrnm prior ID the Date or the Comrnilment,IIIe requi~rnenlS lD obWn
coverage ror unrecorded liens will Include:dlscJo~of cer1llIn l'OnslJUcdon 1lIfonnallon;
nllllndal Inlonnallon as to die seller,the builder and or die conttae\Or;ptlyment or tile
appropriate premlulII fully executed Indenmlly Agreements sadsfactory 10 IfIe company,and,
any adtlltlonal requlremenL....may he neeessmy ur"'r an n1Utllnallon nf lhe uforesald
infonlllliion by the Company..
No coverage will be ginll under any circumstances fur labor'or material ror whkh Ihe imun:d
has contracted for or agreed tn pay.
!'."olhing herein conl8ined "ill be deelned to obligate die company ID p1'Ovtde any of UIP
covenlgl:S referred to herein IDIIeois the above conditions In:fully sali!llied .
••
\
\
\
"\
/
/
'-....I
--""1=';-,
I
I
I
I
I
I
II
~-.J~-"H
",,---,I
I
I
I
II
-LJ,-:L.=.-~_II
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
Ir-
I
I
T
r
I
I
•I ••
KI CHlER LIGHTING 237
CaSI aluminum wittl brass bound,be\leled gloss
panels .1-lIgnt 75-W.Max.(M)Hgl.13W
WIOItl4:r.:Extension 6 ~·.Hgf.fron can/er of
WOII opening 3 ~·.U.l.lislecJ for we,lOCO/ion .
K -9 2 60 Ol OE B RICK ftI
Cost aluminum'HIm brass boUnd.seedy glass
pone ls I-lighl,)5 ~W.lola,.(M)Hgi.1311'.
Widfh 6 ~:ExtenSion n~:Hgr.from center of
wall ;og 3 W.u t listed for weI roc cnon
K -9 261 O lO E BRICK ~
Costaluminum wiltJ brassboUnd.seedy glass
panels .l·light,lOo-w.Malt.(M)Hgl .16!.1 :
Wid1t18 1i:Exfens joo8W.Hgf from ceolef 01
wall opening 3 W u.t.lisl9l1 IQf werlocation .
Costaluminu m w ith brass bound,clear bevelad
glass.3·lIghl.60 ~W.Max.eC)Hgi.22:
WIOfh BW,Extension S*".Hgr.fromcenler 01
wallopenmg 19',ll.L 115100 for Wet location,
K -996 1 OlO E B RICK iSI
Oleor beve lea glass.J.li ghl,60 ~W.lola,(C)
Oia.8~:Hgl 19 -W U L.lislad for wet IOCOHon
T US k..
IOAT[,3~12-o 1
JOHNG.MARTIN,ARCHITEC T
P.O.Box 52 1 Yall.Colorado a l~
Phone,(170)4n-2471
r a",(170)4n-22J7
jmortln_.com .......lahn.rnartln•••m
A Per*lI ..ReeIdence for.
Mr.William L Mentllk
Lot 12,Block H,V Schone FIlIng 2
20437 0IrriItl Dr.,val Colorado 81857___----I
IDATE '3 -12 -01
JOHNG.MARTIN,ARCHITECT
P.O.80.821 Van.Colorado 81858
Pl>ano,('70)477-2478r"",(970)477 -2237
JmortlnOcttve.com ....Johngmorfln.com
A PeraonaI Residence for.
Mr.William L Mentlik
Lot 12,Block Ii.Vall 088 Schone fling 2
2437 GarmI8h Dr.,Val,CoIarado 81857
EDC£Pl[M:D ROAD
BASIS OF ELEVAT ION
@ --SE ilER MH
---RIM ELEV =80~2.6
INVERT EIEV •e039 e
]c ")
/
-:
-:
/
I
/'c
/
/
I
)
1=36·01'06'
R=125.00'
L=78.58'
T=40.64'
CLEN=77 .29'
BRG=N 34·50'27'E
/
/
I
o
4
SURVEYOR 'S CERTIFICATE
I.MichaE'I J .Post,a ProfE'ssional Land SurvE'yor rE'gistE'rE'd undE'r the laws of
the Stote o fCo lorodo,do hereby certify thot this topogrophic survey was
Made by Me and u n der My supervision.and tha t the survey is accuro te ond
correct to t he best of My kno wledge.
/!.!:.~"/,~~Ll~_Mic h a E'l~
Cotor-o e o PLS.30lf6
BUILDING OUTLINE
/
l '1
I
/
1
//
DIICH I /eo "o 1
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
I
,/
f I RE.HYD
I
/
/J
/1 2
/
o 292 7 AC
I
/
///
////
/II/
//LOT 13A
/
/
/I /
//
//I/
//
I S/6<"..1 I
"0 ,,,e
(/
/
/11 /
/I///LOT
/I
/
I
/
/
/
LOT 11
I
I
II
//
///
/
/---J
I
/
/
/
//
N 83"01 '16"W
/
/
/
/
I
/
/
/
/
/
I
/
/
/
/
/
~7.0'/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/4..
I
I
10
--
LOT
UNPL ATT ED
--r HD .5 RE:IAR
'11\wASt£R
I)DATE OF SURVEY 2 /2 /01
2)SURVEYOR HASMADENO INVESTIGATION DR INDEPENDENT SEARCH FOR
EASE MENTS OFRECORD (OTHER THAN PLATTED>.E NCUMBRANCES ,
RESTRICTIVE COVENANTS,OIoiNERSHIP TITLE EVIDENCE.DRANYOTHER
FACTS THATAN ACCURATE AN D CURRENT TITLt SEARCH MAY DISCLOSE .
3)NOTICE 'ACC ORDING TOCOLORA DO LAIoiYOUMUSTCOMMENCE ANY LEGAL
ACTION BASEDUPONANYDEF ECT IN THIS SURVEY IoIITHIN THREEYEARS
ArTER YOU FIR T DISCOVER SUCH DEFECT .INNO EVENT ,MAY ANY
ACT ION BASEDUPONA NYDEFECTIN THIS SURVEY BECOMMENCEDMORE
TH AN TENYEAR FR OM THEDATEOFTHE CERTIF ICATION SHOIoiN
HEREON
4)2-3'OF SNOIoi ONLOTATTI ME OF SURVEY;SOME FEATURES MAY EXIST
BENEATH SNOIoiTHATARENOTSHOIoiNON THIS DRAIoIING.
5)BASIS or ELEVATION>SEIoiER MH APPRX .SO 'EAST or EAST CRNLOT12 (SEE DRAIoIING)
6)BASIS or PRlFERTY LINE LOCATION,IoIEST PROPERTY LINE LOT12 (SEE DRAIoIING)
7)BEARINGS AND DISTANCES ALO NG PROPERTY LIN SHOIoiNHEREONARE
ASSHOIoiNONTE SUBDIVISION PLAT ONLY .ABOUNDARY SURVEY IoIDULD
BE NECESSARY ·0 DETERMINE THETRUE DIMENSIONS OFTHELOTAND
SET BACKS .IoIHICHMAY VARY FROM THE PLATTED DIMENSIONS
NOTES·
41199 HIGHWAY 6 '"24.
P .O.sox 1230
EDWARDS.CO.61632
970 9 49-1406 M.POST 2/9/01
TOPOGRAPHIC SURVEY
LOT 12 )BLOCK H
VAIL DAS SCHONE FILING No.2
TO'w'N OF VAI L)EAGLE COUNTY )COLORADO
z."t "?7 6..4 I2-Hl<7H p~.
JOB No.1587