The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About1988 DRB Agenda & Minutes plus sign variances~ ~~, ~i Iowa of ~a~l 75 south frontage road vail, Colorado 81857 (sos~a7s-7ooo office of community de~elapment VAIL TRAIL ~ 1 DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA FOR JANUARY b, 1988 ROSS RESIDENCE ADDITION Lot 1, Block 3, Vail Valley 1st Filing TOWN OF VAIL ADDITION Vail Municipal Building K-CITE SIGN Vail Run Resort VAIL VILLAGE INN PLAZA SIGN Vail Village Inn, Vail, Village DICKENS PESIDENCE ( New Lot 5, Block 1, Lions Ridge 4t1~ Fi7.ing Project Application Date ~'~'roject Name: ~ a/~ `-' ~ P ~~~~- . Project Description: ~ ~`~~ ~, = ~+ oAn~.J[ t c~~r'tzsv~ ~~v- Contact Person and Phone ~~ ~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone; l ~~~ \,-~~ ~`J`'~ 3Z~ ~ COQ °~ Legal Description: Lot ,Block Fil9ng Comments: Design Review Board Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL Summary: n ~ ~~ ~~ ._' - ~M own f~1'anner Date: Date DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Zone the prlrtterywail 'DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA FEBRUARY 3, 1988 3:00 p.m. SITE VISITS ].:45 p.m. 2 1. Wendy 's Sign Request Motion-Leary Second-Donovan VOTE 3-0 L Abstention Ned Gwathmey. Sign Variance withdrawn only reviewing sign application approved as submitted with conditions. 3 2. Ross Residence Addition o~ a Unit to Single Family Unit. Lot 1, Block 3, Vail Valley 1st Filing Motion-Leary Second-Donovan VOTE 3-0-1 1 Abstention Kathy Warren 7.). All Aspens will be relocated or replace. 2). Title report must be submitted. 3). Ned recommends putting the wall around the west deck to maatch the east deck - up to applicant's discretion. 1 3. Pickens Residence Lot 4, Block 1, Lionsridge Filing #4 Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary VOTE 4-0 Approved with conditions. 4 4. Skall Hus Addition - part of Lot D, Vail Village 2nd Filing Conceptual MEMBERS PRESENT Kathy Warren Dan Leary Ned Gwathmey Diana Donovan ST F PRF.~ENT ~' it ist n ritz, ~ ts~Ro olack icy Pyl ri STAFF APPROVALS: MEMBERS ABSENT Roy Sante S~AFFr'A SENT f ~ - l~f • Up The Creek Bar & Grill Sign Heli-Ski Signs at One Vail Place v, ~,~ Project Name: Project Description Project Application Date r~`y ."1~~~ W~~~ ~~ Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone Architect, Address and Phone Legal Description: Lot Comments: Block Filing ,Zone Design Review Board n Date ~` Motion by: L....Cl~'~~ Seconded by: , y~"~ ^ 'r~~" "" APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL ~~~ ~! ~~ ~ ti ~~4`t-1-~ VIII. ~'~ ~. ''J 5 ~~~ C~~ Summary ._ ~ ii -- ~ cc ~ ! 1 `I ~`~V` J C.~G ~ ~ f Cn C„~C.~~~- [ ~ t~ ~ ~ i ~ t 1/L+r? l't_ C1.~3)! C.~ CJ~ C~ (, l7[~ ~ ~ 1'-~ af'ttN` D '~- c!,..~' c, .,P.`~' ~ ~i~e . 'Q'~ I--C,,/ la~ ~ ~ ~ Town Planner ^ Staff Approval Date: ~' the prinleryiv0il Project Application Date Pro'ect Name: ~_~1 ~~~~~ ~~_~ ~~I,~1~ ~I) ~t ' ~. Pro}ect Description: ~ 1 Contact Person and Phone ~~~~ `,t`~~~ Owner, Address arid Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: 1 ~ ,Zone Legal Description: Lot ` Biock ~ „Filing ~ ` Comments: Design Review Board Date Motion by: t~~~ Seconded by: ~" !++V ! x"' ` APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL ~ o ? `~ Summary: ~a~~ 8 ~ ~~ n ~e ~.~ c~e..~. M~ ~ Q r o ~ by ~ `~ +~ ~~ `~ ~ r ,_ -~n ~~ ~~ _ o`t hl~.Uv UVI1~ ~ I~L~.1 L~ ~r?Y . [M><~ '~` ~"1 ~ ~C~~.1~ ~' ~~ ~Y t Town nner ^ Staff Approval ~.~~ ~ Date: the prlnlary~~ail 'Project Name; ~ ~ ~"~ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone i• ~• Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: ~~ ~~ Project Application ~~~ ~~ Date ~ ~~ 5 / ~~ f ~ r ~ Lam? (~' ~..{ `:~ ~ `© I ~ ~ ~ ~~.~-~ce.~ ~.~ ~~ Legal Description: Lot ~~ ~L~ .Block Comments: Motion by: J Seconded by: ~ a ~ ~~ APPROVAL ~- '® Filing ~v ~~ Design Review Board Date Zone c ` DISAPPROVAL Summary: S ~ U C~ U ~ ~~ ~ /h.~ ~ ~ ~ ~P C5 4 ~( ~ s C U -~/! ~ /~~ Date: ~ ` /~ ~ ~~ Town Planner ^ Staff Approval 7ha Drinleryrya+! Project Application ~-' Date Pro'ect Name: ~ ~ ~~ 1. Project Description: ~ ~~-~ ' - -' `" Coritact Person and Phone + r ~ ~ L ~~ ~° - =` ~ ~ ~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~~` Block Comments: i~ ~\yn -\~~ ,Filing ~ ' Design Review Board Date Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL tr` C YI. ~ ~ et C.~ ~.T ~.~CJ, ~ Summar d ~ v ~~ Date f~ ~~; ~~~ ~~ - -- -- . . Town Planner DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Zone ~~ C the prinleryruae :] DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA FEBRUARY 17, 1988 3:00 p.m. SITE VISITS 1:45 p.m. 2 1. Cabbage & Kings Sign Landmark Building, Lionshead Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary Approved 5-0 with conditions. 1 2, Marriott Mark Temporary Summer Tent Marriott Mark Resort, Lionshead Motion-Gwathmey Second-Danovan 5-0 Lighting will be dawn lighting: June 1 to Sept 30th - 2 year approval. Sides will be up when weather permits 1988 - 1989 summers. 3. Cascade Village Conference Center Design Modifications to Approved Plans. Motion-Gwathmey Second-~Leary (1) Changes to Plaza Conf. sidewalk on North elevation. (2) Removal of terrace on Plaza Phase 1 North elevation. 3 4. Bossow Duplex Residence Lot 9, Block 2, Vail Village 3rd Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary Approved 4-1 preliminary w/conditions Diana Donovan opposed. • ~D~bi6; Project Application Date ~ ~~~ ~~ Project Name: `. r:~~ ~ `~ ~ ~1~~}S ~1~Y1 Project Description: ~~r~r, ~° Contact Person and Phone (r~~'11G~~~ ` 1~~~-n~ ~~~~~~y ~ Owner, Address and Phone Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Descripttion: Lot ,Block Comments: [~~~ ~~ ~~~~~~ ra'rt~ ~lln 3 2®) Filing ~ r~ ~~ Zone Design Review Board Date ~ ~~ ~~ 1 /UI l 1/l~ iY YJ.V.! f Motion by: h Seconded by: ~,~~! APPROV L DiSAPPFiOVAL ~~ ~~ Summary: ~ ~A ~~~~ r - INa ~ ma~-~ f~.'(~i~~ mr~ucfina ~l~ok, IBS mill l~ ~c~ ~~an~ I.,oM L ~M; I~-~ ~o,~n~ will h~-~ l~. s5 ' ~' ~~ ~~ Tow tanner Date ^ 5taff Approval Iha prinlarywail Project Application Project Name: I' W C~D~ `" Vr ~~ M~~ ., Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~l i~ t~i]1t7~~~~~ ~~ ~~~ Owner, Address and Phone: i• Architect, Address and Phone: Date i• APPROVAL Legal Description: Lot ,Block ,Filing ,Zone Comments: ~ 3D ~~1~` l~i~ ~Q~i uhf? ~ Lt~~ll1{ ~ ~'b.~ ~aC . ~' ~ Design Review Board Motion by: Seconded by: Summary: ~ ~ ~~~~ Date Date DISAPPROVAL ~~o ~ ~~ .~ -~ ~~~ ~ ~~~~ Town Planner ~~ ~~ ^ Staff Approval Sha prlnleryrv2il Project Application "-Project Name: ~~~i:~U - ~ 1'' Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: ~~`a~S ~~e~. Legal Description: L{{}}o``t ` , ``Bloc~k-1 { ,1Filing 1 , Zon1e _ Irt,,- ~ Comments: ~ 1'1~. 11~~h 11C4~ - 11~}(4.~K~ s"~ i ~ 1/t ~i~ 1WYW r t~~Q. ' tP~rn ~ ~~ CI CID 1' lrr,L~s .~ fin- l ~ ~ ~t~ ~~ - ~• 1X1I~A) aCPN1LP . Design Review Board Motion by: ~N~YL Seconded by: ~ W'~ APPRa VAL j Y Summar _' ~' ~~ ill Town Planner Date: ~ ~ ~~ Date ~~ l~l~ DISAPPROVAL L ~!' ~l~v. ^ Staff Approval the prlniary+vail DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA MARCH 2, 1988 3:00 p.m. SITE VISITS 1:15 p.m. 6 1. Vendetta's Awning & Sign Vail Village (Final) Motion-Santa Second-Leary 4-0 Approval 3 2. Bossow Duplex Residence Lot 9, Black 2, Vail Village 3rd {Final} Motion-Leary Second-Santa 3-1 Approval Diana denied - does not meet intent o~ one ~ structure. 1 3. Kaltman Residence Spa Addition Lot 11, Block 1, Vail Potato Patch (Final) Motion-Leary Second-Santa 4-0 Approval 4 4. Williams Addition - 2 Deck Enclosures -f~ `~~~ Lot 7, Block 1, Vail Village 1st (Conceptual) No Motion 2 5. Day Residence Lot 9, Block 1, Lions Ridge 4th (Conceptual) Conceptual approval - tabled. No Vote. 5 6. Gold Peak Nursery Gold Peak Ski Base (Conceptual) No Motion 7. Ford Park Master Plan - Final Design {Review) Motion-Diana Donovan Second- Dan Leary 4-0 Approval. Condition on bring back landscape detail and light fixture. MEMBERS PRESENT Kathy Warren Roy Sante Dan Leary Diana Donovan STAFF PRESENT Kristan Pritz Rick Pylman MEMBERS ABSENT Ned Gwathmey STAFF ABSENT Betsy Rosolack Tom Braun • STAFF APPROVALS: Holiday Inn Window Addition - add four new windows. ~owo o~ uaill~ 75 south frontage road nail, Colorado 87857 (3fl3) 476-7000 office of communhy development DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA MARCII 2, 1988 ----------------------------------------------------------------------- WILLIAMS ADDITION -- 2 DECK ENCLOSURES LOT 1, BLOCK 7, VAIL VILLAGE 1ST (CONCEPTUAL} KALTMAN RESIDENCE SPA ADDITION LOT lI, BLOCK ~., VAIL POTATO PATCII FORD PARK MASTER PLAN - FINAL DESIGN (REVIEW) GOLD PEAK NURSERY, GOLD PEAK SKI BASE DAY RESIDENCE LOT 9, BLOCK 1, LIONS RIDGE 4TH (CONCEPTUAL) VENDITTA'S AWNING & SIGN VAIL VILLAGE VAIL TRAIL Projec# Application Project Name: ~~~~ ~ ~ ~- ~~ 1 r~ j. Project Description: Contact Person and Phone !~~~ ~~~~~ Ownor, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Block a SR- X164 ,Filing done ~+ Comments: ,Design Review Board ~[('/~(~/ Date ~ ~ s_, v Motion by: (~ Seconded by: ~ ~~ APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL Summa. Q~ ~ '~11~~v7 `~1~X~~~ . I,~~~UIy~,VLf~ 1 ` j ,~ ra~~ l~n '~ - - own .Ian r Staff Approval Date: ~ the prlnlaryivad Project Applica#ion Project Name: ~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~11~~ `r~ ' ~1 Project Description: ~~~~ ~~~ Contact Person and Phone ~~~ ~~~ Owner, Address and Phone: 0 ~l~ '~l~t~ ~ ~r~~ ~ {~~ i Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Block ~ Filing Comments: i~ Motion by: _ Seconded by: ~ _ ^~ ~ APPROVAL ~~ ~;71~~-- ~~ -~ ~ Summary: w ~~ j Town Planne . Date: ` , ~ ~ ~~ _t Date rl~~ ,Zane Design Review Board Date >/ DlSAFPROVAL ~, ~ ~ ~ sue, Q Staff Approval Ih9 prinleryrvail Project Application ~~ ~ ~/~- Date / ~ Pro'ect Name:. ~ ` ~~~~ ~.`~ >>~~`2'G~ Project Description~~ `"~~ j r ~~ ~~ ~'~'"~ ~ ~'" '" ~ ~ ~~ ~~~ ~ Y~ °~~ ontact Person and Phone !-'.~~~~''rr~ ; ~l~' ~~ ~ r_~ ~'a ~~ ~~ ~ ''~~~ `f~~ _- ~ / ~ ~ Owner, Address and Phone: ~ ~w/`- 4~" ~' \ ~ /~ C / ~ ~ Y Architect, Address and Phone: ~~~ "Y ~~~ ~ '~ ~ ~~ 'L Legal Description: Lot O~ Block ~ Filing ~~ ,Zone /~ Comments: .Motion by: ~" Seconded by: ~ ~ ~ -~ Design Review Board APPROVAL _r' ~ ~~~ ~ Summary: i• o n Planner Date: Date ~` ~ ~~ D15APPROVAL ^ Staff Approval the prlntarywail DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA MARCH 2, 1988 3:00 p.m. SITE VISITS 1:15 p.m. • 6 1. Vendetta's Awning & Sign Vail Village (Final) Motion-Saute Second-Leary 4-0 Approval 3 2. Bossow Duplex Residence Lot 9~, Block 2, Vail Village 3rd (Final) Motion-Leary Second-Saute 3-1 Approval Diana denied - does not meet intent of one ~ structure. ~ 3, Kaltman Residence Spa Addition Lot 11, Block 1, Vail Potato Patch (Final) Motion-Leary Second-Saute 4-0 Approval 4 4. Williams Addition - 2 Deck Enclosures ~~ ~`~ Lot 7, Block 1, Vail Village 1st (Conceptual) No Motion • 2 5. Day Residence Lot 9, Block 1, Lions Ridge 4th (Conceptual) Conceptual approval - tabled. No Vote. 5 6. Gold Peak Nursery Gold Peak Ski Base (Conceptual) No Motion 7. Ford Park Master Plan - Final Design (Review) Motion-Diana Donovan Second- Dan Leary 4-0 Approval. Condition on bring back landscape detail and light fixture. MEMBERS PRESENT Kathy Warren Roy Sante Dan Leary Diana Donovan STAFF PRESENT Kristen Pritz Rick Pylman MEMBERS ABSENT Ned Gwathmey STAFF ABSENT Betsy Rosolack Tom Braun • • STAFF APPROVALS: Holiday Inn Window Addition - add four new windows. • • town ofi vai~V 75 south frontage road veil, cotorado 81657 (303) 476-7000 DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA MARCH 2, 1488 WILLIAMS ADDITION _ 2 DECK ENCLOSURES LOT 1, BLOCK 7, VAIL VILLAGE 1ST (CONCEPTUAL) KALTMAN RESIDENCE SPA ADDITION LOT li, BLOCK 1, VAIL POTATO PATCH FORD PARK MASTER PLAN - FINAL DESIGN {REVIEW) GOLD PEAK NURSERY, GOLD PEAK SKI BASE DAY RESIDENCE LOT 9, BLOCK 1, LIONS RIDGE 4TH (CONCEPTUAL) VENDITTA'S AWNING & SIGN VAIL VILLAGE VAIL TRAIL o##ice of communHy development ~J Project Application pr 'ect Name: ~1~m~- ~ } ~ o~ _ j Project Description: ~j Contact Person and Phone __ '.`Y~~ ~~~~_ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: • Motion by Seconded by: ~ ~ t~k"~ ~or~. APPROVAL Block Da)e S;~ l~ ~~a~ l ~~U ASR'- ~1b~1 ~.~-~a~ Filing Design Review Board Zone Date DISAPPROVAL Summa. -'t~. q ~ ~~~~~ `-'l~~ : ~~`~~~(.JIT~~,Vt7111~' F ~ ,, ~ 1. ~~ , ~~~~, :- '~'~ t~X~ l ~ ~ ~i r m 1 ~~~~..~ i ~c~ ~v 541( r~'+ t ~ ~. l~Cl~ :~ ~- ~ ~~~o ~i own lanr~ r ~ Staff Approval 1~Cri Date: ~ the priniery~~ail ,. Project Application Project Name: 1 ~ ~ f ~~ r~ ~ ~ ~~~~~ Project Description: ~~~ ~ ~~f f ~` D Contact Person and Phone ~~~ ~r~ Owner, Address and Phone: ~ ~ 1 «~ ~ ~'~~ + ~~~ Arct-itect, Address and Phone: Lega! Description; Lot Comments: Date r Biock ~ Filing ~~ r`~~ Motion by: Seconded by: ~ _ APPRQVAL ~~- .~~ ~' ~~~ Summary: • Date: ~,r _1 Town Planne ~ ~~ Design Review Board Dats Zone a~~ ~ DISAPPROVAL mzhr A~ ^ Staff Approval - ~ ~ ~ the prinleeywai{ r / r Project Application Date ~~° ' ~/~ p/'~ / /`a - lp ~ Project Name: .. ~ ~ ~ / ~ ~ Project Description /// ontact Person and Phone ~ ~ - ~ S'G~7 -~.~?'3~ h S~ Owner, Address and Phone: ~~~7 r ,.~ O Architect, Address and Phone: ~/~ ~ ~~`~ ~ •~~ ' Block ~ Filing j ~~ ~ ,Zone Legal Description: Lot ~ ~ ,/' Comments: • Motion by: Seconded by: Summary: Date: Design Review Board ~~~ ~~nn ~ APPROVAL o n Planner D Date ~~ ~~ t DISAPPROVAL ^ Sta#f Approval the prlnlerywail DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA MARCH 16, 1888 3:00 P.M. WORIiSESSION 12:00 = 1:00 p,m. Primary Secondary Revisions 1:00 - 1:45 p.m. Vail Art in Public Places Program: Review Final Draft SITE VISITS 1:45 p.m. TABLED 2. Golden Peak Nursery • 1 1. McDaniel Garage Lot 4, Bighorn Sub. 4 3. 3 4. (Final) Motion--Gwathmey Second-Donovan Approved as submitted and revised. ~ ~~ Hurtt 250 s.f. Addition to existing Residence Lot 9, Vail Village 2nd Filing {Final) Motion-Gwathmey Second-Santa VOTE 5-0 Applicant to submit to staff landscape plan to screen addition from bike path - possibly 3, 10-12' spruce. Toymaker's Trail Facade Improvement & Awning Village Center Bldg, Vail Village 1st, Block 5E (Commercial Bldg. 122 E. Meadow Drive} (Final) Motion-Gwathmey Second-Santa Approved with changes 5-0 (Final} 4057 Lupine Drive • 2 5. Ansel Residence Addition {Final) Lot 2, Block 2, Vail Village 13th Motion-Donovan Second-Gwathmey Consent approval 5-0. Approved with conditions that Town Engineer review plans before building permit. 6. Alpine Garden Ford Park Motion-Gwathmey Second-Saute Preliminary approval 5-0 7.- Williams Addition 2 Deck Enclosures {Final Lot ~., Block 7, Vail Village 1st Motion-Gwathmey Second-Saute . 4-0 Kathy Warren abstained. FORD PARK LIGHTS MEMBERS PRESENT approved by DRB. MEMBERS ABSENT Kathy Warren Ned Gwathmey Roy Santa Dan Leary Diana Donovan STAFF APPROVALS: NONE ~~ ~J lowo of nail ~~ ~~ 75 south frontage road vafl, Colorado 81657 ~soa> a7saaoo VAIL TRAIL DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA FOR MARCH 16TH MEETING WORKSESSION ON VAIL ART IN PUBLIC PLACES PROGRAM PRIMARY' SECONDARX REVISIONS WILLIAMS ADDITION 2 DECK ENCLOSURES (FINAL) LOT 1, BLOCK 7, VAIL VILLAGE 1ST MCDANIEL GARAGE 4057 LUPINE DRIVE LOT 4, BIGHORN SUBDIVISION ANSEL RESIDENCE ADDITION LOT 2, BLOCK 2, VAIL~VILLAGE 13TH TOYMAKER'S TRAIL FACADE IMPROVEMENT & AWNING VAILLAGE CENTER BLDG. VAIL VILLAGE 1ST, BLOCK 5E ALPINE GARDEN FORD PARK HURTT 250 s.f. ADDITION LOT 9, VAIL VILLAGE 2ND FILING • Project Application Date Project Name: ~t ~~LI l ~"~~ 111 ~ .~_~ ~ a~~~ vV • 1 ` Ulw~ ~~Ji~ ~11~ , Project Description: ~ Q ! ~~yn ~ ,~,n r Contact Person and Phone ~~~ ~ V~ ' L^.~ I~~~~~ ~l~ fS,~' '_'" Cf ~ll~ /- Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: CndD.~O ~~14~ Legal Description: Lot ~ t3lock Filing ~1~ ~'R~ ,Zone _1~~~-' Comments: Design Review Board Date ' ~ ~~ a Motion by: ~~~ Seconded by: ~..``~?~-/ ~~ APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL V Summary: ~G~In~C~..j? ~C ~2.4~ ~e^~ ~t~~ 1n1~o c..~I ~ ~ ~. ~ 6 -` j~ _ ~ ~ ~1 Town Planner (~~ Date: ~ ~ ~~ V U ^ Staff Approval the prlnlarp~eil Project Application ~A ~(~ Date Pro'ect Name: ~~~~~ ~ '~ "`"`" "`t -r ~ "~,~ ~~~1 1 Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: ~~ -~` - ~~~~~~ i• ~• Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lo# ,Block ,Filing Comments: yy ~1 ~~~~ a. ~~ ~1 n. Design Review Board Motion by: ~ ~~ _ ~, Seconded by: APPROVAL ~~ Summary: ~ !'~. Date 9ii Town Planner 1 3~~~~~~ Zone ~- Date ~i ~~ ~~~ DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval ~~ 1 J the pdnteryrygi~ Pro~ec# Application Project Name: Project Description: ~~1 ~a~ ~+;~ -~D Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone Date p~1ws~ RnseQ 330th ~ti~~~a_ ~ ~- ~fDZ ~ ~QU~a Ca ~y~,~~ (41st ~-~3 - a~63 Ts2 SiMmm~S U33-bb~,~ legal Description: Lot ~ Block ~ ,Filing Y b' {~~ ,Zone Comments: r ~~~ ~'~ , ~LIL ~I~'~ ~~ Q~ A'1 l5 .~ J 0 T~_~. • Motion by: ~~~~~ Seconded by: APPROVAL Design Review Board Crmsem~' a.~rwr~~. S' DISAPPROVAL 5ummaryO ~ MQQT ~1fiD~ ICUUI~jn~ ~- ~J~,1~ ~A51 ~ ~ A~(~~ t _~l ~ ~ ~1~ ~ ~1~~- ~~ ~~ ~ I nf~ n~ ~. l~ o~ s ~ ~ r 4 . ,~~rnr~-a~ • S, Town Planner Date: ^ Staff Approval Ih0 prlnleryrvaii Project Application ~It~N. SAC Project Name: ~~ ~~` - - Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Date Owner, Address and Phone: ~u~~ ~" "'`~ and Phone: ~- `~~ ~ ~ - r ` ~'' ` ~` ~~ ~~` Architect, Address ..._ ~v~ Legal Description: Lot Comments: • Motion by: Seconded by: Block ~~ . APPROVAL Filing Design Review Board Zone o.,~ 3116~K~ DISAPPROVAL ` , 1 ~P~„N`n,~ (mil fl~ 31~~ ~ ~ ~, ' ~ ` It~l l~L -' Surnmar : =il1'~~ .e~~ 1 /I'(,(1~10.~C1 Gr1 L~I~-~ ~ ~ ~ ~ Date ~~°~~ ~~L lam. c-}~~ r~ ^ Staf# Approval tha pdn~Orywail Project Application Date ~j~ Project Name: ~~~~~~~~'~'~~~ [.JVJ~ ~~~" ` ~ll~ ~11t ~~-'~ ~~~rCXk Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~~~ ~~~~ ~ '^ Owner, Address and Phone: ~i~t~f\~ ~ ~ ~~~~'' •*' , ~~ + ~ ~ 5~ ~ ~~~ Architec#, Address and Phone: . Legal Description: Lot ~~ Block ~ ,Filing ~-~- ~~ ~ ,Zone Comments: • Design Review Board Date / ~ ~~ ~~ Motion by: ~~ ~ L ~ ~¢ Seconded by: _ APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL i ~ 7 Summary: ~y ]}own Planner ~ 0 Staff Approval Date: ~1 1~ ~~ ~~ Iha prinlaryrvail .1 .:. Project Application Date March 30, 19&$ Project Name: SKAAL HU$ Project Description: Addition o'F three condos and remodel of existing exterior Contact Person and Phone John Perkins 9~9-],585 Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: • Block Filing Design Review Board Date Motion by: GWathmey Seconded by: LEARY APPROVAL 4- d DISAPPROVAL Summary: Conditions: detail of trash dum~ster must Abe submitted to staff, an evergreen must be added to northeast corner landscaae materials list must be updated • ' Town Planner ~` Date: ~ /~ ~ /~ u Zane the prinMryrvaii Project Application Project Name. Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Gary McDaniel Marter Architect,. Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~ .Block Comments: Pitch of roof to match house, Date ~ I ~ t°~~d r Filing ~ ~~°h ~ ~ ° ,Zone • Motion by; Gwathmey seconded by. teary APPROVAL Summary: s 4-0 Town Planner 3/30/$8 Design Review Board 3/30/88 Date DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Project Application Project Name: Ford Amphitheatre Sky k.ights Project Description: Sky ~1ght5 over S@atlnq area Contact Person and Phone Rudi Fisher 949~5624 Owner, Address and Phone: Vail Valley Foundation Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lo# Comments: • Mot;on by: Gwathmev Seconded by: Lea.rV APPROVAL 4-0 Summary: Block Filing Design Review Board • ~ ~~ ~'7 Town Planner Date: 3/~r1,/s~Q gate March~30, 1988 Zone Date DISAPPF30VAL ^ Staff Approval the prlnla{ywaiV Project Application D t ~ ~ ~~. a e ~. 'Project Name: ~ ~'~ `"~~`"~ `~ ~~~ ~>r-~ t/`~ f ~~ Project Description: '",~~~~1 ~ ~`~ ~~ Q ~ ~~ ~ ` ~~~` i_ti~~' Contact Person and Phone ~ ~~ ~ t ~'"`p ____ ~~ ~~~ ~~S Owner, Address and Phone: ~ -~ ~~~ ~-~ ~"'~~ ~~~~ ~Sgl--~ - Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: 'Lot Comments: i• Block Filing Zone Design Review Board Date Motion by: - S.~conde.d,:by: APPROVAL ~~~~ Summary: i• Date: ~ ~ ! /~, L Town Planner •. DISAPPROVAL r ~ ^ Staff Approval tha priMeryrvad DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA APRIL 6, 1988 3:00 p.m. SITE VISITS 2:30 p.m. 1 1. Village Center Landscape & Dumpster Improvements 124 Willow Bridge Road A Part of Tract C & Lot K, Blk 5-E, VV 1st CONTINUED TO APRIL 20TH 2. Hurtt Landscape Change Lot 9, Vail Village 2nd Filing Motion-Gwathmey Second-Same 4-0 to approve size change - 3 evergreen trees 3. Lauterbach Duplex Lat ~, Glen Lyon Subdivision TABLED TO APRIL 20TH 4. Vail Gateway (Conceptual Review) CONCEPTUAL - NO VOTE STAFF APPROVALS; Cascade Banners, Cascade Village Ford Park Storage Lockers, TOV Recreation Department Helgas at Vail Sign approval, VVI Phase V MEMBERS PRESENT MEMBERS ABSENT Kathy Warren Dan Leary Ned Gwathmey Roy Sante Sid Schultz • `~ J ~owo ofi ua~~~% 75 sauih frontage road vail, Colorado 81857 (303476-7000 ~. VAIL TRAIL DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA APRIL b, 1988 office of community development VILLAGE CENTER LANDSCAPE & DUMPSTER IMPROVEMENTS 124 WILLOW BRIDGE ROAD - A PART OF TRACT C & LOT K, BLOCK 5-E, VAIL VILLAGE 1ST VAIL GLO.LO~DGE SIGNAGE LIONSIiEAD ~.. • Project Application /~ Date ~ ~~ ~" i ~/~,,/ - Project Name: ~~ ~~ ~~i `~- ~~ ~''~l'~' ~ `_'.~ '' ~~,i Projeck Description: ~" ~'~ C--~`~~~ C~ J Contact Person and Phone ~ ~ ~ ~. Owner, Address and Phone: i~y Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ,Block ,Filing ,Zone /~ r filar ~?~~ /jr-~rt~ G~_./~ C1~ ~U ~v ~? ~ /.h~ S o of Comments: _ ~/ .. ~ J ~ avT~--. ~ ; f Motion by: Seconded by: Design Review Board ~~ ~~ Date DISAPPROVAL APPROVAL I# Summary: ~/'~~Q~P~ ~ Gv/,~/ ~ j /~-Gt~f` Lv~~,// ~_ ~ ~ ~~_~ ` Town Plann r ~ ^ Staff Approval Date: ~~~ ~~~ Iha priMerywail Project Application Date Project tVame: Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~° I• It Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone Legal Description: Lot Comments: ~l~ /~~ r "! ,Block Filing ~` {~ t ~ ~ ~~ ,Zone r Design Review Board ~~~~~~ Date ~ / ! Motion by: ~~'~'" ~~- ~" Seconded by: ~ ---~~G ~ ~~-~ APPRO~~]VAL i]iSAPPROVAL Summary, ~'?'~-- ~~ izu" ~ p,r,-C.c.-~/tzn icy B / Z~ ~ .~~--~ To~ tanner , Date: ~~ r ~ , ~ . ~- ~ ^ Staff Approval lfte prlnlery+vail ~J DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGEI~FDA APRIL 20, 1.988 3:00 p.m. SITE VYSITS 1.2:45 p.m. 1, Village Center Landscape Final Motion-Gwathmey Second-Schultz • V~7.'E 4-0 2. Pickens Residence, Revision Lot 5, Block 1, Lionsridge 4th Filing Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary VOTE 4-0 approved. Retaining wall 6~ max. 8 3. Mill Creek Court Building - New Roof Vail Village TABLED to May 4th 6 4. Crowley Addition Lot 9, Block 2, Vail Village 12th Filing Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary VOTE 4-0 Consent 1 5. Larch Re-paint (color Change) Lot 4, Potato Patch 2nd Filing TABLED to May 4th 7 6. Gastof Gramshammer Entry and Sign Vail Village Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary Consent approved 3-0-1 Sid Schultz abstained 5 7. Katz Addition Lot 13, Vail Village 13th Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary Consent approved ~-Q 4 8. Upper Eagle Valley Sanitation Dist. Chlorination Building TABLED to May 4th 10 9. Vail Gateway Let 12, Vail Village lst Filing TABLED to May nth 3 10. Vail Glo Sign Variance Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary VOTE 4-D not recommend approval of variance. 2 11. Marriott Mark Sign Variance ~ ~ ~~ Motion-Gwathmey Second-Schultz VOTE 4-0 approval as submitted. MEMBERS PRESENT Ned Gwathmey Kathy Warren Dan Leary Sid Schultz MEMBERS ABSENT Roy Sante STAFF APPROVALS: Heather at Vail - New Deck Railing Sandstone Creek Club Golden Residence ~ Smal1 Addition to House • • -- ~~~ ~ ww nn ~ 7~ ~Oflll 0~ ~~~~ 75 south lrontage road nail, Colorado 81fi57 (303) 476-7000 DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA FOR APRIL 20TH MARRIOTT MARK SIGN VARIANCE VAIL GLO SIGN VARIANCE office of cammtJnity development S CROWLEY ADDITION LOT 9, BLOCK 2, VAIL VILLAGE 12TH FILING GASTOF GRAMSHAMMER ENTRY VAIL VILLAGE PTCKENS RESIDENCE, REVISION LOT 5, BLOCK 1, LIONSRIDGE ~+TH FILING MILL CREEK COURT BUILDING NEW ROOF VAIL VILLAGE KATZ ADDITION LOT 13, VAIL VILLAGE 13TH UPPER EAGLE VALLEY SAN DIST CHLORINATION BUILDING LARCH RE-PAINT {COLOR CHANGE) LOT ~+, POTATO PATCH 2ND FILLING VAIL GATEWAY LOT 12, VAIL VILLAGE 1ST FILING • _ y ~~ TO: Design Review Board FROM: C~~~LL«unity Development Department DATE: April 20, 19$$ SUBJECT; Sign Variance Request for the Marriott's Mark Resort Applicant: Marriott's Mark Resort: Mr. Michael Robinson Z. THE REQUEST The Marriott's Mark Resort is requesting a sign variance for the number of signs and total sign square footage. The sections of the code which relate to the variance request are listed below: 16.20.054 Signs, Single Business Use B. Size. One square foot for each five front lineal feet of building with a maximum area of 20 square feet, with a horizontal dimension no greater than 10 feet....combined maximum area for more than one sign shall not exceed 20 square feet. D. Number. One sign per vehicular street or major pedestrian way which the business abuts as determined by the administrator, with a maximum of two signs, subject to review by the Design Review Board. According to the sign code, the Marriott's Mark is allowed a maximum of two signs having a combined total square footge of 20 square feet. The development's existing signage includes: One 19 square fact wall sign on the east elevation One 12 square foot free standing sign at the entry Total square footage existing: 3]. square feet. * A variance was granted in 1987 to allow for the additional 11 square feet above the allowed total square footage of 20 square feet. The applicant is requesting one additional Sian and 22 square feet of signage above what is allowed under the sign code. The proposal includes: One new 20 square foot wall sign on the west elevation. One new three square foot freestanding sign at the entry that is built into the existing freestanding sign. The existing sign square footage is merely decreased from 12 square feet to 3 square feet. * Please note that the existing 12 square foot sign at the entrance to the Mark would be removed and that the existing 19 square foot sign on the east elevation remains. Total square footage, 42 square feet. Please see the attached drawings for descriptions and specific locations of the signage, as well as the applicant's rationale for the variance. II. FINDINGS AND STAFF RESPONSES Before the Board acts on a variance application, the applicant must prove physical hardship and the Board must find that, A. There are special circumstances or conditions, applying to the land, buildings. topography, vegetation, sign structures or other matters on adjacent lots or within the adiacent right-of-way • which would substantially restrict the effectiveness of the sign in question; provided, howeverL that such special circumstances or conditions are unique to the. particular business or enterprise to which the applicant desires to draw attention and do not apply generally to all businesses or enterprises. Staff Response The Marriott's Mark does have an identification problem due to the largeness of the building and the fact that for the entire project, they are allowed only two signs having a combined area of 20 square feet. Similar large hotel projects such as the Raintree Inn, Holiday Inn, and Doubletree have also received sign variances due to the size of their projects. Staff feels that the Marriott has similar special circumstances that warrant an increase in the combined square footage and number of signs. The existing sign at the entry way (12 square feet) will be removed and a three foot sign added. Staff believes that the three square foot sign is reasonable and necessary to indicate that this is the entry for the project. • 2 B. That special circumstances were not created by the, applicant or anyone in privy to the applicant. Staff Response: Special circumstances were not created by the applicant. C. That the granting of the variance will be in general harmony with the purpose of this title and will nat. be materially detrimental to the persons residing or working in the vicinity, to adjacent nroperty, to the neighborhood. or to the public welfare in general. Staff Response: Staff feels that the proposed signage is in harmony with the purposes of the sign code which states that the "sign location, configuration, design, materials and colors should be harmonious with the majestic mountain setting and the alpine village scale of the town." Section 16.16.010. The proposed sign wall be back lit so that the silhouette of the letters is visible on the west elevation. The lighting effect will be similar to the Holiday Inn wall sign in that light will not shine through the letters. The small . sign at the entryway is subtle in its design and is also compatible with the sign code's general purpose. The scale of both signs is appropriate for their purpose and location within the project. D. The variance applied for does not depart from the provisions of this title any more than is required to identify the applicant's business or use.. Staff Response: The applicant is requesting an additional 22 square feet beyond the allowable 20 square feet. The Town Council approved a variance for the Marriott Mark which created an additional 11 square feet beyond the allowable square footage. Staff believes that one 19 square foot sign and one 20 square foot sign are not unreasonable square footages to request for a building of this size. In addition, the three square foot sign at the entry is necessary to identify the entry point for guests. The applicant is not requesting a departure from the provisions of the sign code any more than is truly required to identify the business. • III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: The staff supports the variance request for one 20 square foot sign and one three square foot sign. Staff believes that the sign is harmonious with the sign code's requirement that signage not call undue attention to itself. The square footage request also does not depart drastically from the allowed signage. We recommend approval and feel that the applicant has made a strong attempt to work with the staff to develop an acceptable sign variance request. Due to the recent increased number of submittals for sign variance requests for large lodges, the staff feels it will be appropriate to adjust the sign code to allow for same additional signage for these types of projects. In reviewing these variance requests, staff has tried to maintain continuity in our decision making and rec~~~~~~.endations to the Design Review Board and Council. However, in the long term, we feel that the best solution is to adjust the sign code so that it is in tune with the needs of these types of developments. This approach will avoid a series of individual reviews of sign variances which are time consuming for the applicant, Design Review Board and Town Council. • 4 !t !'ruE~ ~:+tiiur)<tl [;t7 rl~ur ~lb~n • ~~~:3 ~ :f ~( ry~[~ii~1171V 1)fE4 ~. V.;:!, Cnfori~l~o R1fi!,7 i!)a ~111s~5106 MORTERARCH ITE~CTS RE: Sian Variance Request: Marriott"s Mark Resort 755 Lionshead Circle Vail, Colorado 81657 • Dear Kristen, March 2, 1988 Kristen Pritze c/o Town of Vail Department of C+~,~~~"unity Development 75 S. Frontage Road Vail, Colorado 8165"7 Please accept this submittal for review during the March 30th Design Review Board Session. Our client is requesting a variance to allow him the rights to install an additional 2~ square foot back-lit sign to be located an the west face of the Phase II addition directly across from the Marriott parking structure. (See enclosed documentation.) This request for variance stems from our client"s desire to gain visibility from both the east-bound frontage road and the proposed Lionshead off-ramp. The Mark is a large property stretching along west Lions- head Circle. Its frontage road visibility is largely obsc- ured by the Vail Spa Condominiums. Existing signage lends identification from Lionshead Place only. As illustrated with the enclosed photographs, the proposed sign would be the only one visible from the west, imposing no more than the Town"s prescribed 2Q square foot sign lim- itation from any one vantage point. It is expected that the proposed interchange will be a major access paint into Vail and this new signage would limit confusion to visitors' seeing the hotel and hopefully limit traffic congestion at peak periods. ~ MH/lmh Enclosures Since 1y, ~ //, -~~~/i ichael ar M~RTER CH ECTS / .r -_~~.__.-.r-..._ rr , -- .,. t , . .. ~, i i I i ~ ~ '4 :. ...... ... ' , ,, ti ~ ~: `~ C ,,-: y ~j ~I ., , t ~~1. ; ~ .1 I I I i , O t '' it lYV ' S ~ 1 I i ~ .-~ I ' • i~ i 1 , i I i I r 1l ~ ~` +i f ~. i ,i III ~ i , I f ; `t n ~~°~-,ail \` ~ i ~, ~ :, + r I 1 ri +tm Ah~n t~ ~j j I c~ I~r . I'~I 7 ~ I ~ ~ I I .~ 1 ~xyS .: 'f::i•:~f:~, ~. .'` ~I 1 .. .- II i ! I i ' I~• ~ J t G ~ra~,g +~ $g +3 k'• f ji i! I I i I ~! ~` ~ ~_ I ~ '~ P~ I $ I ~7~ ; i r13 -I ,r i i~"'S ? ! 1 r i I~~t~v~q fQ'1~, }fl~}'+I :ij_ .~~ I ~r~i ~) e ~5 t ~ IY I. ~'' r•I . .l 'I ,'j ~ ; i ~ , _ ~ .h " I7~° •.-I~l~• it It tl i I'r ff ~, t ~ _ - '~ ._. 1 k:b~ ~I' S' ) fI 41 ,S~ ; 1t. 'I 4 .5 J ~!, r .. .~i. ~,~ l,. ,~.',I~ , ' t ~ / Ik i,.rJ~:~'i '1 ,. 1 _ -1 ~t. I f ~ ~ I i. - 1 ~ ~,, ixl :--~' '.I SF: 'Ar f l 1! ,1'7rj .~~L7! '~4 t ... .I.~~I,,`~~ X11.± ._ __...~ - -f~~-: __. ' I '~~~+ ~ ~ , _ ,.,.. + ~ n 8YN k~.~ Irp r ..j1 • 1 r ~ rs' I ~t ! ~ ,~ I it I .~' 'f ~;',; :-1 r _ --~ ~~ I ! ~ n m ~ -,. . ~ r r - ~~ ' , ~ `~~ ~ ' . Z .Y j;~ ~ t r 7 r s ? ~~ ,' •~' x" ~ ' _ i.~~~v ~~ ~ • ~~ ~... ~~~ ~ `~. ~~ ~~ `~ I 4 1 ~..4~ 1 ~~. 4 ~ '~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ _ , -=~ ~ ~ _ _ _ ; . , ,u ~f~ ,t ~ ~ 'I.~~ ,I ' ~J~ ~ !; , ,1 , f ~`~ t ~..,J ~ '~'_ 1 ~ ~~--ff " ~ 4 ~ ~. _ = i- , 1 :, 4~. ," -,mil {~ y ~~ N , (J~; ~ --\ ~.. ~~ ~ _ i k' i~. ~_ F :; ~. R9 C'" ~ ~~ / ~ / /~/~~~ ~'/ Cyr `, I~ . ~ w •• cn ~ ~ ._.._:-_.... --- ~ ~ - ~ Z . .._.._ .. _.._ . ~o w ~ ~ 2$__5/8" ~~ C ~ a T a 3. ~ 5 ~ .,. c ~ 3 ~ .. w M ~- A w~ n~ ~~ _, o w• nM~ °l ~ ~ n 1 ~ a ~~ _~ ~ :~ ,..,, a ~• ro _, a ~' w S~ C ... C ~( N ~ G c ~~ c c- ,~ ~3 ~3 ,o V ~. a ;' ,;;. ~Q a ist~' i ~~\ _ ' . ~.-_.-`1. i t t ~',a kl. ... -_ i,l, ~~ r' ~ ~ ~ ~~ i i . ~~ rn ~, ._ ~ _ -~._- , ._ ,~ - _ ~; --. - . c~ ,. ~ ~ - 'i ~ ;~ ~ II ~ ~~ ~i ~' 'a~ I _ ..J m ~ -~ __. ~ ~ _---- 1' c~ _ ~ t~~ n r I ~ k .,~ ~ --;--~. , - - ~~~~.~; ~~ n ~~ ~, ,fir ~~ ~N~ _ ~~U. - ~, ;fi O s i ~ i' ~-~ ~ - - fem. ,~ ~ ~yti€~~., ~_:--- _ ~ .i s ~~ ~~ ..- _ . - ~ ~ ~~ _ _ ~__! . - ~-- ~ - 4 - F ~ ~ I N'g _ 1 kJIR ~.'E. I L'~h '~ Y . - ~~f ]]~ I Ch F _.~. ,, ~ r=._ _ _ ~ w ;T~ Tj5^- ~y~' ~, PSi~q~ ~ij ~ ~ t ~: ` CIS ~.. i:;'. Tl ' O Ly xr~~. is {: ~~f~+i Iz ;.. .~ , r'::: ,~ ~,~3~ ~}c~~ ' r ~ i,'s ~v~~ .. _..._.-- Vi`i'; ~' ~~ti ',. i ';"~ ~ ~aay~ _ -? .r '-_ ,`•..yr; ,.. - - _- - --- -- -~~ I ~~ E ._ .~a. Architect, Address and Phone: ~. Project Name: VILLAGE CENTER TRASH E fl 1 A~lDSf'ApFNr Project Description: ~'IRl Mo.rter Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone; i• i• Legal Description: Lot Comments: Project Application 4/20/88 Date Block ,Filing ,Zone Design Review Board Motion by: Seconded by: Date 4/20/88 Gwathmey Schultz APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL 4-0 Summary: Jim f:~P hack with a rpvicpd rlrawin~~-.-~hc trash andr,~lro Tn frnnt of tho trash enclosure will be two evergreens 8'-10' high.. c Town Planner Date: ~/2'l~ I~ 'l ~ ^ Staff Approval Iha prlnleryrval Project Application Project dame: PTCKENS NEW RESIDENCE Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: [~ Architect, Address and Phone: Date 4/20/88 Legal Description: Lot ,Block ,Filing ,Zone comments: change of .location from previous design which was approved by DRB on 2/3/88. Design Review Board Motion by: GWa'~hi11eV Leary Seconded by: Date 4/2Q/RR APPROVAL /~- 0 i• DISAPPROVAL Summary: /~-"C.. ~^Cc : G_- ~*--G-7 1~ L,9 t u2~ G-'- ~r ~ ~ r / ~ ~/ / (/`- ~To/wn Planner Date: ~/` ~ /~~ C~' e7 u ~ ^ Staff Approval !ha prlnleryrvad Project Application Date 4/22/88 Project tvame: CROWLEY ADDIT T01V Project Description: Add7t7011 to residence Contact Person and Phone Gi nny Crawl ev 476-5008 Owner, Address and Phone: Same Architect, Address and Phone: swlf- an~inpar_ Legal Description: Lot 9 Comments: i• Owathmey Motion by: Seconded by: Eedry APPROVAL 4- 0 i• Summary: Town Planner Date: ~/ ~ „ Block 2 Filing V Vi l l 12th Design Review Board pate Zone P ~S 4/2o/8s DISAPPROVAt ^ Staff Approval the plinlarywail Project Application ` 1~f 1r C, 1..4111 kC~.JV l.J[~~ J ~ ~ ~~~' .Project-Name: ~`~ ~~ _ 1 Project Description: '~ Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: t_ot Comments: i• Motion by: Seconded by: Block I~'MD .t n ~ ~~ APPROVAL Filing Design Review Board Date Zone o,,. ~~~~ DISAPPROVAL i• Summary: 1 ~ ccJu~~ ~I ~~P/? ~~ -~iJ~ ~i ~~ Town Planner Date: ~ ^ Staf# Approval 1ha pNnteryivail Project Name: ~~~~~`~~ iT~ Project Descriptian: Contact Person and Phone Project Application I Date ~~ ~~~~~~ Owner, Address and Phone: ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~ ~--~ ~~ 1 ~. . 6av~-e.. ~ Architect, Address and Phone: ~,}l ~ ~~ U~~,~ Legal Description: Lot 8iock ,Filing Comments: • Design Review Board Motion by: ~~~~ Secpnded by: ,,~,r-~. APPR©VAL J i ~~~~ ~~ - Date DISAPPRC}VAL Zone ~ ~~ 5;~. Stiul~ ~»„od Summary: . ~ ~~_ ~" Town Planner Date: a ^ Staft Approval the prlnlery~rail Project Application 1 Date ~~ ~!~ Project Name: Project Description: ~~~~'?t~ Q~~ ~ ~-~~'^` Contact Person and Phone ~ ~~ ' ~~, "1'~r~ " 1 I ~ I ~~ ~ ~~ i ~. Owner, Address and Phone: (y t 1 C~ ,~C~J 'T Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~~ Block Comments: 1 .Filing Zone ~~~ Design Review Board Date I• Motion by: Seconded by: ~--~~~ APPROVAL ~l -c~ Summary: G.5 SJ~tM.~~ ~ ~_~_ ~~ ~ To n Planner L~ Date: t ~ ~~ DESAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Iha prlnterywaii Projec# Application Project Name: ~~r~r "' r \'~ ~W E . ,11 ~~~t ]f t' ! L](_ Project .Description: Contact Person and Phone i• ~ -6 - Owner, Address and Phone: ~~ X-- ~~ ~ -~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal pescription: Lat Comments: Date III ~~~ m~-~_ r ~~~~~ ~~ Block .Filing l ~~ ~;~ Design Review Board Motion by: ~~~-'~~ Seconded by: j~ APPROVAL 1'~ ~_ 1- Summary: (' Town Planne Date: ~u ~ Zane Date ~L r DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval k~a prlnlpryrvatl ~, Project Application Date ~ ~ ~~ roject Name: ~~~b~-- C ~ C~^~ ~~ ~t%~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 Project Description: ~ ~~_~`~ ~ .~~'- /~ Contact Person and Phone ~P~~ ~~~~ ~1P~ -- ~ ~c~ t,. Owner, Address and Phone: ~?+~ ~ ~~ C~'~";~ .~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Block Filing ,Zone Comments: ~~~~ ~~ ~ --~~~~ Design Review Board Motion by: ~~.1.rc -`~~s ~ Z.~~~~2_.:~ r Seconded by: APPROVAL Summary; 1~ ~1[!l ~ 'E-own P! nn~r Oate: ~ ~? ~ Date DiSAPI'ROVAL ~ ~~ r -- in~~- ~~ ~~~~~ G ~ A~ 1 11 n C ~C] ~T\ L t~f.,,>K~.' V Q Staff Approval Iha pfinlerywad s UESTGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA MAY 4, 1988 LIBRARY COMMUNITY ROOM 3:00 P.M. SITE VTSYTS 7,2.30 p.m. 11 7,. Water District Well House Vail Village 11th Filing Motion-Saute Second-Schultz VOTE 4-0 Approved as submitted & amended. 2 2. Walker Residence ~'\~~~ Lot 33, Potato Patch ~~'~~`~' ~~~~ Mation-Leary Second-Santa VOTE 4-0 Approved with addition of 2 spruce trees. 7 3 . Resort Duplex ~ ~~~~-~`'~ Lot 4 , Glen Lyon s \ l `~ ~~~ - ~~~~ Motion-Leary Second-Schultz VOTE 4-0 Approve Building only. 9 ~. Gillette Residence Remodel ~~~ Lot 33, Block 7, Vail Village 1st ~~~ Mation-Saute Second-Schultz VOTE 4-0 Approved as submitted. 1 5. Gruidel Residence, site 3 Casolar Vail, Lionsridge Sub. Tabled for further study. ~~~~~~~ 8 6. Rose Primary/Secondary Lot 4, Block ~, Vail Village 3rd ~~~ No Vote taken, conceptual review only. no site 7. Mill Creek Court Building visit Re-Roof Motion-Saute Second-Leary Approved 4-D 1d 8. Cerisola Color Change, Lot 4, Potato Patch 2nd (site visit to Sage Residence) TABLED 5 9. Lionshead Gallery Sign Treetops Plaza, Lionshead Motion-Leary Second-Santa VOTE ~-0 ~~~ ~~~~~ 4~ 10. Meagher Residence Lot 30, Glen Lyon Subdivision v~~ ~~ Motion-Leary Second-Saute VOTE 4-0 Motion of approval of building subject to approval of landscape plan. 6 1Z. Vail international Carport, Lionshead TABLED TO MAY 1$TH MEETING r • • 4 3 12. Detrick Residence t--~ Lot 3, Block 2, Lionsridge 4th Filing ~~~~~ ~~~~~~- Motion-Leary Second-Sante 4-0 approved w/landscaping to be reviewed by staff. 13. Appoint 2 DRB members to serve on Sign Improvement Project Task Force. Motion-Leary Second-Gwathmey 13 Site Visit Only - Sepenzis Garage Lot 4, Block 1, Vail Village 13th . MEMBERS PRESENT MEMBERS ABSENT Roy Sante Ned Gwathmey Kathy Warren Dan Leary Sid Schultz STAFF APPROVALS: McDonald's Repaint Project Application Project Name: ~.. Project Descrip#ion: ~~~{~~~~ Contact Person and Phone ~- - -"" I• Date Owner, Address and Phone: ~~•~ ~t ~ ~~ - - ~~. ~,~ Architect, Address and Phone: , Bloclc ~ Filing ~~+~ ~ ~~ Legal Description: Lot ._,K Comrrtents: Design Review Board Date Motion by: ~~°`,~~ Seconded by: `~~~-V ~~~-~ APPRbVAL DISAPPROVAL ~~ ~p,~a ~, =~,~4~c i. Summary: r ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ' ~ Town Planner ~ Staff Approval Date: ,Zone the pdnleryrvaa DESIGN REVXEW BOARD AGENDA MAY 4, 1988 LIBRARY COMMUNITY ROOM 3:00 PM Mill Creek Court Building, reroof Cerisola color change, Lot 4, Potato Patch 2nd Filing Lionshead Gallery Sign, Treetops Plaza, Lionshead Meagher residence, Lot 30, Glen Lyon Subdivision Breakaway West Condominium ~ 345, window change Vail Gateway Building (Amoco site) Water District Well House, Vail Village 11th Filing Walker residence, Lot 33, Potato Patch Gruidel residence, site 3, Casolar Vail, Lionsridge Sub Gillette Residence remodel,Lot 33, Blk 7, Vail Village 1st Rose Primary/Secondary, Lot 4, B1k 4, Vaii Village 3rd i Detrick Residence, Lot 3, Blk 2, Lionsridge 4 Vail Lnternational Carport, Lionshead • Project Appiication Project Name: ' J {.~ t ~-~ Project Description: C ~'f~1+~-~~~"1d ~' , Contact Person and Phone ~/~~~ +r" ~ t ~ Owner, Address and Phone: i• i• Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: c_~~~ Date ~; ~~~- lit,[ ~ Black Filing v ~t t- V1 ~ ~-',ham-~'~= i7esign Review Board Motion by: ~~ Seconded tay: ~'r ~~.~~~ APPROVAL rr~~ ~~v ~t'V`~ Ga Uv'"~z~ • Summary: .~ ~~ Town I r Date: ~ ~~ ~u ~~+ Date DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Zone Ehe prlnleryrva~l Project Application Date ~ _ -~ } g Project Name: n"l . ~~ L'n- ~ ~- ~ ~- n ~'a- T ~ "' ~ rY ~ "`°~ Project Description; ~ o n~ ~ ~ ~A ~ m. S '1" ~ c. `~ " ~ ~ A c. ti "^°, 3 0'~ ~' n~ a '~k,~$!C ~vk, Contact Person and Phone ~ - ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~-'v ~ S X11 L a °Z a, ~ Owner, Address and Phone: rn ~ l ~ C n ~ ~ K C 0 u ''~- ~ C o ~'+~X n ,•., ~ n. i ~, ,,.. ~ c. s ~, r_ . Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Block ,Filing ,Zone ~ + ~! Comments: ~ ~'` ~ s ~ o o~ j ~, ~. S ~ s ~ t +~ ~ ~ ~ ~- s C~,~ s s ~ ~ r. 4~. ~ w ~ vti ~ N ~ s {{~~ a 'T ~ ~., n .. ~ rX ~ vac' ~ YL O u ~ ~~ Io,~ ~ R-A n] ~ ~ o~ ~ .J ~ 1 rY ~ -+ a i ~ O 1 D ~2 r• A i.l 9 ! T -~•~ ~ t+ ,n , Design Review Board Date ~ ~ ~~ r i~ Motion by: Seconded by: APP~ROVA DISAPPROVAL ----~~ iJ Summary: ~/ ~ ~~ ~ ~~. Q L ~h ~~~1' ~ J+C.-L~ / , / /c~ G~ ~G~ ~ ~~~~ ' Town Planner ^ 5taf# Approval Date: ~ ~/~~ r/ the prinlerywa~i Project Application .~-^ Date Project Name: ` ~ Project Description: " ~ ~ ~ ~ ' r ~ ~ ' Contact Person and Phone i• Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: ,S /S (~Q ~~~ ~~ ~~ t Legai Description: Lot ,Block Fil/i~ng Zone Comments: /' ~, o /I~ ,, ~ ~ ~ Design Review Board ~~ ~ r~ Date ~/ ~" ~` , Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL Di5APPAOVAL c.~C~ Summary: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ C~ ~''~~Town Planner Date: --' L~ ~r/ ~~ ^ Staff Approvai kha prinlery~ vail Project Application Date 0 ~' ~_ ~/ t ~. Project Name: ~ "' "` ~ ~ ~ ~ Project Description: f Contact Person and Phone ` ~~~ ~ ~'~ 1 Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: /fl~ t° n ~~ Legal Description: Lot ~ V .Block Filing ~~ Comments: Design Review Board Motion by: ~ `~ ~ Seconded by: ~""' APPROVx1L J ""~ cJ ~~ o ~ ~~ 4 ~~~ d ~j ~u Summary ti!' L 4 / t/e7"l7"'r.~ [~~-~. G'' e 7~~ . ~` .~,-r/L--z~ s ~ ~.~- 0 ~ ~~~~ ~~, ~ I• /~.~ Town Planner Date: ~ ~y~~~ «<<!! ,Zone Date "' ~ /" ,y DISAPPROVAL ~~ ~r ~,~ ^ Sta#f Approval 3 ~/ a' /~~ / / the ptlnteryivail Project Application Date Project Name: '~-~ _ ~~~ ~ ~_ Project Description: ~~ r n ~ : Contact Person and Phone ~,.~. ~_UL~ ~!~~ ~~ ~~~' `x ~~C~~~- gwner, Address and Phone: i• • Architect, Address and Phone: Lega! Description:.Lot v Comments: - (~ Block ~• ,Filing ~~~~ Q ~ ,Zone Design Review Board Motion by: ~(~ Seconded by: ~~~`-~~ APPROVAL 1~~c ~~~~ -~ ~. ~~' ~ Summary: r\ ,~ I n Plaren r Dato: ~Q~~ _. ~. o,.~u~u~ ~~ DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval the pdrtlaryweil • ~5 j DESIGN REVIEW ROARD AGENDA MAY 18, 198$ VAIL LIBRARY COMMUNITY ROOM 3:00 p.m. 11:30 a.m Discussion of Primary/Secondary Ordinance & Select two DRB members far Signage & World *Kathy Championship Street Decor. Committees. *(Sid Schultz, Dan Leary, Kathy Warren possibly) SITE VISITS 12:30 p.m. 1. Vail International Carport -NO SHOW 2. Village Center Sign Consent Gwathmey & Sante Approved 4-0 :. 3. Cerisola Color Change 740 Sandy Lane NO SHOW 4: Meagher Residence Lot 30, Glen Lyon Landscape Motion-Sante Second-Schultz 4~0 to approve landscape plan. 3 5. Vantage Point Sian Variance ~~ J Motion-Gwathmey Second-Saute . Vote 4-0 to approve. 7 6. Gruidel Residence Casolar Vail Motion-Saute Second-Gwathmey Vote 4-0 For approved with added Landscape on northeast 2" minimum size of aspen. Primary Concerns: (1) Landscape northside (2) Mirror image (3) Aldg. envelope issue must be resolved bef, bldg. permit, RC zoning. 4 7. Cascade Village Temporary Entry Sign & Cascade Club Landscape along Frontage Road. Tabled to June 1st for Landscape Plan. 1 8. Fitzpatrick Garage Addition Lot l0, Block 7, Vail Village 1st Filing Motion-Gwathmey Second-Saute Vote 4--0 consent approval 9 9. Vigor Duplex • Lot 20-4, Bighorn Motion-Gwathmey Second-Schultz Vote 4-0 Aproved with understanding that landscape sizes verified, and that detail be approved be staff. 10. Resort Duplex Lot 4, Glen Lyon Motion-Saute Second-Gwathmey Vote 3-d-1 Approve as submitted (landscape). 11. Beaudin Residence • Consent see #8 2 12. Vail Gateway ~- Amoco Station Preliminary Approval 8 13. Traylor Landscape Plan 797 Potato Patch Motion-Sante Second-Gwathmey Vote 4-0 • 6 14. Talon Roof - Lions Ridge Tabled to June 1st meeting 10 15. Gordon Residence Landscaping Lot 1, Block 4, Bighorn 5th Tabled to June 1st meeting 5 16. Rapson Residence Lot 3, Block 4, Vail. Das Schone Motion for approval-Sante Second-Gwathmey Vote 4--0 MEMBERS PRESENT Ned Gwahtmey Kathy Warren Roy Sante Sid Schultz STAFF APPROVALS: MEMBERS ABSENT Dan Leary (Baby) Sonnenalp Cosmetique - Storefront Remodel Park Meadows Lodge - Portable Spa Breakaway West Unit 345 - Enlarge Window Vail Associates Real Estates Signs Chocolate Factory Awning - Red Lion Building i • • f r town of ua~ll% 75 south frontage road vail, coiorado 81657 (303) 478-7000 office of community development DESIGN REVIEW BORAD AGENDA MAY 18, 1988 VAIL LIBRARY COMMUNITY ROOM 3:00 P.M. MEAGHER RESIDENCE - LOT 30, GLEN LYON LANDSCAPE VANTAGE POINT SIGN VARIANCE VAIL INTERNATIONAL CARPORT VILLAGE CENTER SIGN RAPSON RESIDENCE - LOT 3, BLOCK r, VAIL DAS SCHONE VIGOR DUPLEX - LOT 20-4, BIGHORN 30HN GALT MOUNTAINEERING FASCIA 193 GORE CREEK DRIVE FITZPATRICK GARAGE ADDITION - LOT 10, BLOCK ?, VAIL VILLAGE 1ST FILING TALON ROOF - LIONS RIDGE TRAYLOR LANDSCAPE PLAN - 797 POTATO PATCH CASCADE VILLAGE TEMPORARY ENTRY SIGN & CASCADE CLUB LANDSCAPE ALONG FRONTAGE ROAD CORDON RESID. LANDSCAPING - LOT 1, BLOCK 4, BIGHORN 5TH RESORT DUPLEX - LOT 4, GLEN LYON VAIL GATEWAY - AMOCO STATION CERISOLA COLOR CHANGE - 740 SANDY LANE GRUIDEL RESIDENCE - CASOLAR VAIL BEAUDIN RESIDENCE • ... . T0: Design Review Board FROM: Community Devel~~~«ent Department DATE: May 18, 1988 SUBJECT: A request for a sign variance for the Vantage Point Condominiums Applicant: Vantage Point Condominium Association I. THE REQUEST The Vantage Point Condominium Association is requesting sign variances for the total sign square footage and required height of wall signs. Vantage Point has 27 square feet of signage in three signs, one of which is a logo. They are proposing to remove all existing signs and replace them with two signs totalling 28 square feet. One sign containing 8 square feet would be located above the garage entrance on the east side of the building. The other sign containing 20 square feet would be on the north elevation at a height of 38 feet from existing grade. The sections of the code which relate to the variance request are Listed below: • 1.8.20.210 Wall Signs B. Size. One square foot for each five front lineal feet of the building, with a maximum area of 20 square feet. C. Height No part of the sign shall extend above twenty-five feet from existing grade. According to the sign code, the Vantage Point Condominiums are allowed a maximum of 20 square feet of combined total square footage. Vantage Point is requesting a total of 28 square feet of signage in two signs, 8 square feet above the allowable. The sign code restricts the signage to be located no more than 25 feet above grade. The request is to place the sign on the north elevation 38 feet above Grade, 13 feet above the allowable height. * Please: see attached drawings for location and detail. • • II. FINDINGS AND STAFF RESPONSES Before the Berard acts on a variance application, the applicant must prove physical hardship and the Board must find that, A. There are special circumstances or conditions, applying to the land, buildings, topography, vegetation, sign structures or other matters on adjacent lots or within the adjacent right-of-way which would substantially restrict the effectiveness of the sign in question ,• provided, however that such special circumstances or conditions are unique to the, particular business or enterprise to which the applicant desires to draw attention and do not apply generally to all businesses or enterprises. Staff Response • The Vantage Point Condominiums do have an identification problem due to the size of the building and the tact that for the entire project, they are allowed only two signs having a combined area of 20 square feet. Similar large projects such as the Raintree Inn, Holiday Inn, Marriott Mark, and Doubletree have also received sign variances related to total amount of signage due to the size of their projects. Staff feels that the Vantage Point Condominiums have similar special circumstances that warrant an increase in the combined square footage of signage. The staff does not feel, however, that the Vantage Point Condominiums should be allowed to place one sign at 38 feet from grade, There are no special circumstances or conditions that are unique to the project that do not apply generally to all businesses. Tt is true that the Doubletree Hotel was given a variance to place their sign facing the Frontage Road at a height of 55 feet. The reasons for granting the variance as indicated in the memo dated June 17, 1987, was that the size of the sign was in scale with the rest of the building and the fact that the building was situated below the grade of the Frontage Road, mitigating the height of the sign. To the west of the Vantage Point Condominiums is the Landmark Hotel whose sign is 15 feet above the required 25 feet. When the Landmark constructed this sign in 1984, they were replacing an existing sign with a new one at the same height as the old sign. l.J The Enzian is another building along the Frontage Road which has signs higher than 25 feet above grade. The records do not show approval of these signs, so the staff must surmise that these signs were painted onto the building at a very early date; this would make the signs legal nonconforming. The staff feels that, in general, the circumstances the Vantage Point condominiums face are not unique to other buildings along the South Frontage Road, and therefore the height of the Vantage Point signage should not exceed 25 feet above grade. B. That special circumstances were not created by the applicant or anyone in privy to the applicant. Staff Response: Special circumstances were not created by the applicant. C. That the granting of the variance will be in general harmony with the purpose of this title and will not be materially detrimental to the persons residing or working in the vicinity, to adjacent property, to the neighborhood, or to the public welfare in general. • Staff Response: Staff feels the proposed signage with respect to size is in harmony with the purposes of the sign code. The signage will be lit by a light source separated from the sign. The 8 foot sign above the garage entry is also compatible with the sign code's general purpose. The staff feels that this sign is important to help motorists identify where to enter the garage. The scale of both signs is appropriate for their purpose and location within the project. The staff does not feel that granting the height variance is in harmony with the sign code. There are many buildings along the Frontage Road whose signage conforms to the sign code with respect to .height and whose signs are adequate to identify the buildings. D. The variance applied for does not depart from the provisions of this title any more than is required to identify the applicant's business or use. • Staff Response: The applicant is foot sign beyond believes that one square foot sign to request for a requesting an additional 8 square the allowed 20 square feet. Staff a 20 square foot sign and one 8 are not unreasonable square footages building of this size. The staff does feel that the 20 square sign on the north elevation will identify the building adequately when placed 25 feet from grade, and that a height variance to place this sign at 48 feet is not warranted. XI2. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: The staff supports the variance request to allow an additional 8 square feet over the 20 square feet allowed in the sign code. Staff believes that the signs are consistent with the sign codes requirement that signage not call undue attention to itself. The square footage request also does not depart drastically from the allowed signage. We rec...«r~.end approval of the request for a variance from the amount of total signage allowed. However, the staff does not support the requested sign . height variance. We feel the Vantage Point Condominiums will be adequately identified with two signs that are placed no higher than 25 feet. Due to the recent increased number of submittals for sign variance requests for large lodges, the staff feels it will be appropriate to adjust the sign code to allow for some additional signage for these types of projects. Tn reviewing these variance requests, staff has tried to maintain continuity in our decision making and recommendations to the Design Review Board and Council. However, in the long term, we feel that the best solution is to adjust the sign code so that it is in tune with the needs of these types of developments. This approach wi11 avoid a series of individual review of sign variances which are time consuming for the applicant, Design Review Board and Town Council. i• ,, •, ~~. l/AMAGE POINT•I/AIL April 2l, 1988 Ms. Betsy Rosolack Town of Vail Community Development 75 So. Frontage Road Vail, Colorado 8165$ Dear Betsy: • With regard to the height of the Vantage Point sign on the north side of the elevator shaft, we feel that 25 feet above ground level will not be high enough. Since Vantage Point sits well below the level of the So. Frontage Road, we feel a minimum of 38 feet above ground level is necessary to make the sign clearly visible. We have recently planted a row of cottonwood trees along the south side of the frontage road that wi11 grow quite ta11 over the years. As it is now these trees wi11 block the view of a siwn mounted at 25 feet above ground level. After looking at some of our neighboring condominiums namely the Landmark to our west and the Doubletree to our east, we do not feel 38 feet above ground level is at all unreasonable. Since this wi11 be our only sign on the north side of the building we do feel it should be clearly visible from I-70 and the So. Frontage Road. I would like the opportunity to have soneone from the sign review committee and/or the design review board to come out and look at our situation in order to make a fair evaluation. If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me. Sincerely, VANTAGE PAINT/ AIL CONDOMINIUMS ,~,~ ,.~, Michael D'Anci, General Manager • 508 East Lionshead Circle, Vaii, Coiorado 81657 (303) 476-4364 /~ ...-- ~i~'r ~ _. `~ 4 ~`` ~~~G~ , i 1 ~~ V~Yv`rr~J ~y~~LG~ u /~'~~~~ r • R.p U C-Yy - Sri u~ 1 ,< _ ~ i 8 - ~~--~ ~'.4~T1 O rJ ._ 5 d i ~~~ ~~~ iS,T ll d 1..---~-~ L7 ~ ^ ,1 / ~^~ C-,~ , s r ~ ~v ~ --~ S r G >v ~ ~2 LLy~~u Qc~~ \~ i ~l l+ N ~ H~ ~ ~_ ~~ c~ r N ~ ~. Ian- r~--z~ i r5• Z- S l i ~. ~L-,Alm - ~ ~ .--.- - 4 is F- P>~ ~r'o . ~ G,~s~QC_;-~ ~~ ~ r ^ ~ ' rbEnsTt~~~..~T"e c~rJ ~J ~ t3 a ~ ~ ~ N ~- rz_~` ~~ .. L ca ~ c~ ~ N ~~ ti ~.N c,...cac~4 ~-t owl ~~ 2c~ nq vv~ n i• s • • • r 0 V lr h -• 1 ~~ t - ~~ I :~ ~r ~` - i ~.~_ ,,~ , :~ .Ici ~ f~Z~ . . ~((!!II € U~ 1~x~ --~ ; , .., 4~,.yi+. }N 4 e .t . '.i Y~~~'1y.~i'~l~w~i+' ~ •n'u ~' ~~. _ n'l C. i ` K~r~r fi ~..' 1~ (.s'{i~:~ 1~i nI~'~ ~h~{~ Jj,' , y'~I 1 t' Imo' ~ ~•\~ ,~ '; ~ .l~ ', -~• y' ~. ~'r--• .~ ~ ~~. f! 1,.~;~~~~1'~j.`.i' y•~.'~ '-' ~;}. :.pi}It .r. ,~' ~V~S ~' '~.;V P~ ~~UJ ~:' ~'~ry Iii ..~I\7 t'tMkX,7 i' r,,.,4. ry"' ~ ~ •~ x,; •]F 4~ :~1-p~. ay; 'P'. ~~ II€i+ ~r ~.~, r;: ..'~.~~w,:t:y~.••a''"1. •r1et~ `, a - ~.sr'. ~~ ~t~-~v v"i -.Y_ ;~- .r,..~ €j~~i '~mR ~~; - ~, ;~I I ~J' Sri i:f t~ .iV. :€ F j I M ~ ~'. ca - --~ I _~Y € ~. I ~ w .+ - I f 1. ~ ~~~'j f ~ ~ € ,X .~ -~;~ __ h ,} 1 ~ ~ ~'~ ~ ~ i.. ' I '.f s, • ~' ' ~ k'~ , r. ~ .. ~4 # "~ ' ti ..' i i ~, ~ €if `,~ € Ili ~ ~ ~~~ 3Y i . _.' I ~, , ~ - . L- =~ ~I .r f. IN.~'~ 1 i l l -~ a. ~ ~ I..~.I ~ .~ ... I. ~ ~.~ T ! ' I ' f IJ • h ~~ Project Application C. ! l ~-- ~ Q~ ~ Project Name: ~ Project Description: __. Contact Person and Phone pwner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: ~ ` ~ `~~ ~~~~ Legal Description: Lot Comments: i~ li Motion by: Seconded by: Summary: Block Filing Design Review Board ~, g ~ )'~ hA~PPROVAL ~" Town Planner Date: ~ - ~ ~ ~~ Date ~,~~~ ,Zone Date ~ ` { DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Iha prinlerywdd Project Application Date ~/~ '. Projeci fume: ~~ Q ~-- ~v _ Project Description: ///~ Contact Person and Phone ~~ / ~ i l~'~'~ r Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~ ~ Block Comments: I• Motion by: ~~ ~ ~'~ Seconded by: ~ ~' ` ""~`' ~~ APPROVAL. ~`'W- Summary: Tpo~wn Planner Date: ~~ a /~~ (riling I~~ ~"1 ~ ~ Zone Design Review Board ~~ S~ ~/~ Date / L DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval tha prlnferywad Project Application ~j ~~" J ~~t-~ J ~ ~ Project Name. Project Description: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~"~~~ Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: I• Motion by: ~q. n 1~~ Seconded by: APPROVAL "~ (} Filing Design Review Board p~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ Summary: ~ ~ ~ s Town Planner ~f ~ ~~~` Date: ~ Block .~~ ~ g I ~~ Date / ~ Zone Date DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Ihp prlnleryrva~i Project Application ~ ~ Date Project Name: ~ . ~~~ f"~ ~~~ ~'~ ~~~~~ Project Description: Contact Persan and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: ~~~ ~~~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~~~. Comments: Block yu~3 Filing ~~'~ `' ~ . ,Zone . Design Review Board Date l~ Motion by: `~ ~~~`~~~ C ~ Seconded by: !~, " APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL ~~~~ ~: ~~ Summary: _ ~~ ` ~o n'.:~ann ^ Staff Approval ~~ Date: _ the prlnlaryweii Project Application Project Name: ~~~ ~ - ~~ ~~ ~~ .Project Description: ~~f Contact Person and Plane ~ ~~~ ~~•~~~~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: legal Description: Lot ,Block Filing Comments: Da#e ~~~~~~ Zone Design Review Board .~/,~~~~ Date / ~ ~ h ~- Motion by: Seconded by: ~~ APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL y `~ `-' Summary: ~ ` Town Planner Date: ~~~Q ~~~ ~ ` ^ Staff Approval Iha prlnlery~vg~l Pro'ect Name: ~-~I/s ~ ~ 1 G Project Description: Contact Person and Phone i~ Project Application ~/ Date ~ Z' /~U /' ~.,~ ,, ~ f / Owner, Address and Phone: "" `^` ~ ~~v ~~ Z U ` Architect, Address and Phone: ~ -J ~r~~" ~ ~a ~ Legal Description: Lot .Block ~ Fiiing ,Zone Comments: Motion by: ~~~~~~ Seconded by: ~~~-" j~~~ 11 APPROVAL ~~ U Design Review Board Date ~~~/~ DISAPPROVAL r ~ Summary: _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~. ~ ~ ,~ /~ '~ ~' Town Planner Date: 'S " ~~~~ r t ^ Staff Approval the pAnterpvad - ~K. _ ~ , i~ro~ect Application Date Project Name: ^ ~ ~~ ~ ~l 1 4 ~ ~~ j~ '~ -.~ ~"~'' Project Description: 0~ ... Contact Person and Phane ~~ .~ ~ ~~ Owner, Address and Phane: ,~t~-~~~. / f'~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~~ Block ~ Filing ~ ,Zone 1/._~ r Comrrients: Design Review Bvard Rate Motion by: ~~~~ ~ Seconded by: ~+~.~~""~ APfPJROVAL DISAPPROVAL "~ " 1 Summary: t^~ ~-- c~C ~ ,~ _ "awn Plan r ^ Staff Approval Date: Iha pdnleryivaa a ,. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA JUNE 1, 1988 2:DO P.M. COUNCIL CHAMBERS SITE VISITS 11:00 A.M. 1 1. Yashiro Marketing Sign, Branders Building Motion-Gwathmey Second-Saute VOTE 5-0 Consent agenda 13 2. Gombrich Garage, Lot 5, Blk 1, Bighorn 5th Motion-Gwathmey Second-Sante Consent agenda VOTE 5-0 $ 3. Vail International Carport NO SHOW & 4. Concert Hall Plaza color change TABLED TO JUNE 15TH 1 5. Lionshead Bar & Grill railing, Concert Hall Plaza Motion-Gwathmey Second-Sante Approved as presented w/color to match bldg. VOTE 5-0 2 6. Pine Ridge Townhome colors Motion-Leary Second-Gwathmey VOTE 5-0 4 7. Cascade Village landscaping TABLED TO JUNE 15TH MEETING 14 8. Klawiter/Distelhorst Duplex Parcel A, Woodridge TABLED TO JUNE 15TH MEETING 9. Gordon landscaping, Lot 1, Blk 4, Bighorn 5th Motion-Gwathmey Second-Saute Approved 4-1 10. Talon Roof change TABLED TO JUNE 15TH MEETING . 11. Cerisola color, 740 Sandy Lane Motion-Leary Second-Gwathmey Approved 5-0 11 12. Blu's awning, Gore Creek Plaza Bldg. Motion-Gwathmey Second-Sante Approved 5-0 12 13. Subs & Spuds Sign, Village Transportation Cent. TABLED TO JUNE 15TH MEETTNG • 9 14. Holiday Inn satellite dish TABLED TO JUNE 15TH MEETTNG 15. Nilo D'ard Sign, Vail Village Inn Plaza NO SHOW 3 16. Remey Remodel, Lot 8, Blk C, Vail das Schon,e #1 Motion-Gwathmey Second-Sante Consent agenda VOTE 5-0 5 17. Vail Chevron sign variance TABLED TO JUNE 15TH MEETTNG 15 18. Victorians at Vail, Units 1,2, and 3 Motion-Leary Second--Gwathmey Units 1,2,&3 be approved as submitted, rear deck changed to align with window, details must be more carefully executed during construction. Units 4&5 in reference to details. VOTE 5--0 19. Gateway at Vail, Amoco Station TABLED TO JUNE 15TH MEETTNG OLD BUSINESS Alverde Windscreen Revisions STAFF APPROVALS: Gore Creek Plaza - Storefront Remodel Cadmus Addition - Lot I7, Block 1, Vail Village 11th One Vail Place - Deck Westview Condos. - upgrade paint Railing on NW corner of Plaza Conference Center - Cascade Vill. Villa Cortina Unit 360 - 250 s.f. bedroom addition Scandinavian Depot of Vail Sign - Crossroads Mall Sonnenalp Parking Lighting Sonnenalp Flagstonejlandscaping proposal - Swiss Chalet MEMBERS PRESENT Kathy Warren Sid Schultz Roy Sante Ned Gwathmey Dan Leary NEW BUSINESS MEMBERS ABSENT • ~~ y~7 down of nail 75 south frontage road nail, Colorado 81657 (303) 47B-7000 VATL TRAIL office of community development DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA FOR JUNE 1ST 3:Q0 P.M. TDV COUNCIL CHAMBERS ~J VAIL CHEVRON SIGN VARIANCE NILO D'NARD SIGN - VAIL VILLAGE INN PLAZA HOLIDAY INN SATELLITE DISH MOLLOY ADDITION - COTTONWOOD TOWNHOUSES TASHIRO MARKETING & ADVERTISING SIGN - BRANDESS BUILDING GOMBRICH GARAGE - LOT 5, BLOCK 1, BIGHORN 5TH CONCERT HALL PLAZA COLORGHANGE - LIONSHEAD MALL PINE RTDGE TOWNHOUSES COLORS KLAWITER/DISTELHORST DUPLEX - PARCEL A, WDODRIDGE TOWNHUMES SUBS & SPUDS SIGN - VTLLAGE TRANSPORTATION CENTER LIONSHEAD BAR & GRILL RAILING BLU'S AWNING - GORE CREEK PLAZA BUILDING RAPSON REMODEL - LOT $, BLOCK C, VAIL DAS SCHONE 1ST CASCADE VILLAGE LANDSCAPING TALON R40F - LIONSRIDGE GORDON RESIDENCE LANDSCAPING - LOT 1, BLOCK 4, BIGHORN 5TH VATL GATEWAY - AMOCO STATION VATL INTERNATIONAL CARPORT CERISOLA COLOR -- 74O SANDY LANE Project Application '' Project Name: ~i~f~~~~~ ~~vl`t "`--~~ lill l_~~~ ~~~ 1l ~~ U (~ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~` f~~ ~ ~ ~~v Owner, Address and Phone: C~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Block Filing Zone Comments: Motion by: Seconded by: Design Review Board APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL Summary: ~11~~!n (~/ ~ ~~~ ~v'~L c, ~. ~~ ~~~~1~~ Q , ~~~ `(BPD ~ e ~~~ ., r~~ ~~ T~ o~n Ian ~ ` ^ Staff Approval Date: thg prinl0ryivail Project Application Date ~ 1 ,~,,A, /~ r1,~ } Project Name: Y _ rr~M, ~{I ~ 1• 1~/1/1~1 ~ ~ v" Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: ~l~~v ~L~C1~1 ~ ~~~ _'~~r Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot comments: i• Motion by: Seconded by: Block ~-~~~_ ~~ ~~ Q_ APPROVAL Filing ~~~ ~~~ Zone Design Review Board o.,. ~~~~ DISAPPROVAL Summary: ~ ~~' ~ .rte ~~ I• Date: ~ ~ Town Planner ~I ^ Staff Approval the prinleryira~l Project Application bate Pro'ect Name: 4~~`~~~~' ` ~~~\~ 1 ~`~~~-~`~.C`iS2~~. ~~~"k\`4~\~~~ 1 Project Description: c, ` Contac# Person and Phone 11 4j`}~1~~ 1 Owner, Address and Phone: ~~~, ` •~l I• i• Architect, Address and Phone: Legal bescription: Lot ~= .Block \ Filing `~~\~~~~. v~~~ Zone ~~ Comments: Design Review Board Motion by: ~' y~~~~~ Seconded by: ~r APPROVAL Summary: ~~ down Planner Date: Date 6~~~~ DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval the prlnleryivail Project Application Pro'ect Name: 1~1Q~~L1 ~ - ~{~+-~~ ~ ~+i~t`~u-~ 1 .. Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~~ ~+` ~ ~ , `~~ -_ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: Block Filing Date Zane . Design Review Board Date Motion by: ~s! Seconded by: ~~~+~ APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL ~' J Summary: ' ~ ~ To n Planner ©Staff Approval Date: ~ ~ t' the pdnhry~~all Project Application ~te r Project Name: ~ ~~~..' i-~~ / ~~~~~~~~~ ~` ~~ J ~ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone i• Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: ,~ l ~ Legal Description: Lot ~ ~~, Block ~ Filing ~ ~! ~~ ` ~ ,Zone Comments: Design Review Board Date Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL Summary:~~~, ~ ~~` ~lu~`~1 ~U.~f Gt~b ~~1- 'I1~it~'C~ l MA i ~; ti To PI n r ^ Staff Approval t Da e the prlnlarywad -~, Project Application Project Name: ~ i dnr4 ~ ~ ~" Projeck Description: :~~ ~' ~'~" C Contact Person and Phone - ~`~ rP~^ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: ~Q'`-~ r~°"""`~~~d~ Legal Description: Lot ~~^ ~ t4.~k-!~ ~~A-2.f~ ,Filing Comments Design Review Board Motion by: Seconded by: `APPROVAL • ~L. Summary: i ~~ ~~- ~ .,~ ~I Town Plan Date: ~ / /g a i ner Date Date ~/~/P~ Zone DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval me ar~n~erywad Project Application Project Name: Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: ~v~IG~O n! ~,~s ~ pFN~ E S~/~ /,~ F,er~~/y ~Qic~i ARV Jr3.~a mid Architect, Address and Phone: .~~~,~N ~ ~~~~ ~.4vil~ ~-~ut/~N Date 5~ia~~"~ ~N.Pr~rwS! /CXi9 5 `doX 334 z ~¢7d -~~a / f ~7 {~ Legal Description: Lot ~ ,Block ! Filing 1~ ` , ~~ ,Zone Comments: Z-pNEl7 l.~rllJl.EX ~"D ~~~~ /~~ ~~~0 /n~"X . ,~4~ ~i~~i$ ~ ~ S'~ir~ J ~~ ~ /YI/N. / /r/G~F_ ~B S~ ii/ .A S A~r s~! 9' i4 R,E~ ~ ~ i fro ~ir~ E J3~N,~~~ ~~ !~ f3~~/~i ,~~ y`' ~/!'~~v''ie~ /Er~ ~iQ~yi .~~ ~r' . ~~ ~ Design Review Board Date ~_/r I Motion by: ~~ ~ rI`-~- Seconded by: ~~~~~ ~AP~PR~OV~AL DISAPPROVAL I C7 ~-- i~ c~t~~ ~ h ~J u-~. ~ r r- cw ~ ~~ ~,t , Summary: ~ ~-~'~ l..s 6 H~+' _._ 7~' Town Pl/an~r ^ Staff Approval Date: _ „ ~~~v / / Ihr prinlery~aail Project Appiication Project Name: ~ ~~ Z ~ ~ Project Description: ~ `-~ "o ~ C?/ •~~ Contact Person and Phone ~ - I i~ ~ 1~~~ Owner, Address and Phone: ~~"~' t `~ ~ ~ ~~ Date ~, f ~~~ Architect, Address and Phone: I 1~ Legal Description: Lot ~ Block .Filing ~ ~ ~ft/T~ ~~~ t/ ,Zone Comments: rl ~Qp~ ../l dCc.(' ! Design Review Board Motion by: Seconded by: Summary: ~e-~.~.- G ~.- ~.,.,.~ APPROVAL ~ ~ ~s~~~ f Town Planner Date: ~ + ( /~ ~ l Date ~ ~ r DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval the prlnteryrvaii Project Appiication ~~U ` Project Blame: '~ Project Description: ~t''x ~'I^°'~~`" ~~ Contact Person and Phone '~ ~ a"'` ~""'~~0~~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone C ~ ,a~ ~ Vcn ..,.~a ~ - - Legal Description: Lot ~~`~ ,~~ ~` "~~ ~~ Comments: I ~ Design Review Board Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL ~~. ..~. J"~ ,Zone Date DISAPPROVAL s.1 ~ ~ ~',r.rs1 iA.G Summary: ~ ~'' ~ ~ ~~ } ~- ~ ~~ d ~ , (" ~ ' ~ ~1 ~~ n ~ Tow nn Date: ~' I! ~~~ Date G -3 Its ^ Staff Approval Iha prlnlarywail project Application ~i Date s~~~- U k~~ ~ ~ Project Name: f`-~'~"" ~~1'`~ ~I~ -I't7 ~1 Project Description: ~~"~~'~- ~ ~O~` ~` Contact Person and Phone ~"~. J v ~ ~/ ~^ ~ ~ ~~~ Owner, Address and Phone: -~/ ® /tJ .~ L °(~ r `-~"~.-~'~ Architect, Address and Phone: ~ lG ~Q ~ ~ '~-~ Legai Description: Lot ~ Block ~ Filing ~~~-+" ~~ ~~Zon~ J Comments: Design Review Board ~~~`-'~_ Motion by: G Seconded by: APPROVAL ~} ~'"~ V Summary: r .,~ ,~~ i Town Plann{e~~r/ Date: ~ ~~ ~~` Date '" /` ~" DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Iha pdnlarywad 3 .} DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA JUNE 15, 1988 COUNCIL CHAMBERS 2:00 P.M. SITE VISITS 3.2:30 p.m. 1. Talon Re-Roof Motion-Leary VOTE 2-1-1 Second--Schultz 3 2. Concert Hall Plaza building color. Motion-Santa 4-0 approval Second-Leary 3. Subs-N--Spuds Sign Vail Transportation Center Motion-Sante 3-1 approval Second-Schultz 4. D'nard Fur Sign Vail Village Plaza TABLED (No Show) 8 5. Sweet Basil Awning & Sign Motion--Riva 4-0 Second-Schultz Consent approval 4 6. Gala Jewelers Awning Lionshead Mall Motion--Leary ~-0 Second-Sante i• t 7. Cascade Village landscaping & entry sign. Sign Motion--Santa 4-d approval -- • Second-Leary Landscaping Motion-Santa Tabled Second-Leary 8. Distelhorst/Klawiter Duplex Woodridge Townhomes TABLED 6 9. Treetops building retail expansion. Motion-Santa Second-Schultz far approval w/modifications 4-0 7 10. Iialiday Inn satellite dish. Motion-Santa 4-0 on roof Second-Leary 1 11. Mo11oy Addition Cottonwood Townhouses TABLED •i i r 1 12. Langer Addition .Lot 28, Matterhorn Village Motion-Leary Second- an building only - landscape must comeback 4-0 2 13. Marquez Addition Lot 9, Vail Village West #2 Motion-Riva consent 3-0-1 Second-Schultz (Dan Leary abstained) 14. Vail Chevron Sign Variance. ~~..c.~ Motion-Leary Second-Saute Based on staff findings. Height not to exceed 1.4' logos removed, 4-0 i 10 15. Vail Village Information Baoth Remodel TABLED TO JUNE 29TH MEETING 16. Born Free Express. TABLED TO JUNE 29TH MEETING 9 17. Gorsuch Building Vail Village Motion-Leary 4-~ Second-Saute LJ 5 Vantage Point roof stacks {site visit on7,y} STAFF' APPROVALS: Cascade Viilage Banners Spring/Summer, Fa11/Winter B1.u's - Greenhouse Addition T'Lame' Sportmode Sign MEMBERS PRESENT MEMBERS ABSENT • Kathy Warren Ned Gwathmey Dan Leary Roy Santa Sid Schu~.tz • town o~ ~ail~% 75 south ironiage road nail, Colorado 81657 (303) 476-7000 DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA JTJNE 15 , 1988 SWEET BASIL AWNING & SIGN MARQUEZ ADDITION - LOT 9, VAIL VILLAGE WEST ~~2 GORSUCH BUILDING - VAIL VILLAGE VAIL VILLAGE INFORMATION BOOTH REMODEL LANGER ADDITION - LOT 28, MATTERHORN VILLAGE BORN FREE EXPRESS - LIONSHEAD MALL MOLLOY ADDITION - COTTONWOOD TOWNHOUSES GALA JEWELERS AWNING - LTONSHEAD CENTRE BUILDING TALON RE-ROOF office of community development HOLIDAY INN SATELLITE DISH VAIL ASSOCIATES RACING & TIMING BUILDINGS FOR WORLD CHAMPIONSHIPS CASCADE VILLAGE LANDSCAPING & ENTRY SIGN TREETOPS BUILDING RETAIL EXPANSION DISTELHORST/KLAWTTER DUPLEX - WOODRIDGE TOWNHOMES CONCERT HALL PLAZA BUILDING COLOR CHANGE D'NARD FUR SIGN - VAIL VILLAGE PLAZA SUBS-N-SPUDS SIGN - VAIL TRANSPORTATION CENTER ~ ~: JLT • TO: Design Review Board FROM: Community Develo ment De artment p P DATE: June 15, 1988 SUBJECT: Sign Variance Request for Vail Chevron APPLICANT: GTS,2nc. I. THE REQUEST The Vail Chevron station is located in the Arterial Business District just west of Lionshead and the Marriott Mark Resort. The current signage far the Chevron station consists of a 17 square foot Chevron logo sign. The sign is free-standing and Less than eight feet in height. This is currently in compliance with the Town of Vail Sign Code. The operators of Chevron are requesting a variance from total square footage allowable, number of signs, and height provisions of the Sign Code, in order to raise the Chevron sign to 18 feet in height, and to add a 17 square foot price sign mounted below the Chevron sign. Total size requested is 34 square feet. The Sign Code allows for single business use signage up to 20 square feet. As in the case of this building having only one pedestrian or vehicular way, only one sign would be allowed. Afree-standing sign is restricted to eight feet in height. This request, as a variance from size, height, and number of sign criteria of Section 16.20.050 of the Sign Code, is similar to the request made by the Vail Conoco station which was approved in July 1987. II. FINDINGS AND STAFF RESPONSES Before the Board acts on a variance application, the applicant must prove physical hardship and the Board must find that, A. There are special circumstances or conditions applying to the land, buildings, topoaraphv. vegetation, sign structures or other matters on adjacent lots or within the adjacent right-of-way which would substantially restrict the effectiveness of the sign in question; provided, however! that such special circumstances or conditions are unique to the particular business or enterprise to which the applicant desires to draw attention and do not apply generally to all businesses or enterprises. • Staff Response Gasoline service stations as businesses directly oriented to vehicular traffic traditionally display signage above and beyond what would be allowed through the Vail Sign Code. The West Vail area, in particular, consisting of the Phillips 66 and the West Vail Texaco stations display signage is grandfathered into the Vail Siqn Code. That signage greatly exceeds the allowances as described in the Sign Code. The Vail Conoco station, located in West Vail, has received a variance for a request very similar to that made by the Vail Chevron station. The request basically consists of raising the existing Chevron sign to a height of 18 feet so that it may be more visible from the Frontage Road and adding below that a price sign indicating products available and prices. During the variance review of the Vail Conoco station, the staff recognized the importance of a price sign to a gasoline station, as well as the ongoing enforcement problems that previously existed at Vail Conoco and currently exists at Vail Chevron. We feel the best way to handle this situation is to properly legitimize, through a review process, these price signs. As a staff, we feel the applicants have responded to their needs and the Town of Vail Sign Code by presenting a responsible request. B. That special circumstances were not created by the applicant or anyone in privy to the applicant. Staff Response: Staff feels that the traditional signage display of a gasoline station includes product price information. We also feel that the precedent for approving a price sign has been set with the action of Vail Conoco. We feel that was a good solution to a signage enforcement problem on that location. We feel that it is also a good solution to a signage problem at the Chevron location, and feel that any circumstances involved were not created by the applicant. C. That the granting of the variance will be in general harmony with the purpose of this title and will not be materially detrimental to the persons residing or working in the vicinity. to adiacent property, to the neighborhood, or to the public welfare in general. • Staff Response: Generally, the Town of Vail Sign Code is oriented to pedestrian and slow moving local vehicular traffic. The Sign Code does not really address the needs of a specific automobile oriented business, such as a service station. The existing signage at the site is in compliance with the Sign Code and is, according to the applicant, proving to be ineffective for their business needs. The parking of automobiles and design of the adjacent bridge restricts the visibility of the existing sign. We feel that the request for raising the sign and adding a price sign is reasonable and, therefore, harmonious with the purpose of this title. D. The variance applied for does not depart from the provisions of this title anv more than is required to identify the applicant's business or use. Staff Response: We feel that the applicant has presented a proposal that is sensitive to the environment of the Town of Vail, to the Sign Code, and to the design restrictions of the c~..,.~.unity. While this is a substantial variance from the Town Code, we do feel that this does not depart from the provisions of the title any more than is required in order to meet the applicant's needs. IIZ. STAFF RECONfMENDATION: Staff supports the variance request for size, number of signs and height. Staff feels that two signs, with a total of 34 square feet and a total height of 18 feet above grade, is harmonious with the Sign Code requirements. The nature of this business dictates somewhat of a departure from the Town of Vail Sign Code, yet, the proposal maintains harmony with the intent of the Code itself. Staff recommendation is far approval. • ~' Y ~~ ~:. i• ~.'. 3• :,.:;. ;, Y° ~. PRICE S1G~lS Pole Mount Lighted Price Sign ~~ ~~~ TYPE Chevron s u~o "~~5TT+~-~G ~St~~~l'7~ tJ~-J ~ c~ 5+~ ~l ~ f `7 ~' C44LPS Cli9LPS C77LPS `~ vJ4 P4ST5 CW cx~ ~~ ~r4~-n~- L.vca4Ta~}J ~j ~CrSTt ~G S 1 ~ ~.1. AREA WIDTH HEIGHT' SQ: ~T. 5'-1" 6'-0" 30.5 •. 8'-t3" 7'-11" ~2.t3 Section 3.Q ltame: Pale Maunt Lighted Price Sign Type: See below Drder: Frpm Division Engineering! Purchasing Representative SizelArea: See below Material: Plastic panels --- metal frame, internally illuminated. Gulors: Message panels - white capylblua background Price panels -- black copy) white background Mutes: • To be flag mounted 1 '-0" below ern ID hallmark of the same size, • Panels for C59LP5 &C77LPS are changeable. Pease see page 3.1.2 for selection, • C44LPS uses aone-piece face. Graphics change require a com- pete face change. • For use at all new and recon- structed stations. • May be used at CSS and other high thruput stations that operate at night. • if the need occurs, the next smaller size l.1 S may be used with the Ip Sign, fi.e, a C77LPSw1C991.D., or a C~i4LPS w1C59 f.D.l. • Contact H.Q. Engineering for addi- tional installation information and drawings. Retail Sign Guide 6185 -- Page 3.1,1 Project Application Project Name; ~'~" +~ Qr~ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Block Filing Zone Legal Description: Lot Comments: i• ~• Design Review Board Date Motion b ~~^ Y Seconded by: ~.l f t ! ? "- DISAPPROVAL APPROVAL ~J S Y ~ ~ ~ ~ n Q ~l~rn. ~ Date: ~ _ TowJn Planner ~l ~~~~ t L Na~19- Pla}a Cnbr (lamGe ~,,. 0 lkus2 .'(~~~tl~ ^ Staff Approval {fie pOnleryrvaA Projec# Application Date ~~Project Name: Project Description: Y`L- ~ Contact Person and Phone ~'] i~!°" ~~~-~~ Owner, Address and Phone: i~ Architect; Address and Phone: 6G s~,~ ~ Legal Description: Lot ,Block cling ,Zone Comments: _~.~- Gv C--~ ~ A !•- ~ ~... 7MA ~ 5 L ~! 1x P ~~~x~ t~_ r ~ `, Design Review Board Motion by: Seconded by: `~ C- ~~ APPROVAL • Summary: ~`~ a~~ ~~~~- Town Planner Date: ~1 ~~ Date ~ ~! ~ ` / / DISAPPROVAL Q Staff Approval Iha pdnleryw8~l Project Application Project Name: Project Qescription: Contact Person and Phone • ~• Owner, Address and Phone: ~ Date ~'~ J ~~ ~ ~ ~ ti ~ ~ Architect, Address and Phone: Comments: ~ ~ /} ~~ ~s /~d' I Legal Description: Lot ~ ,Block Filing ,Zone Motion by: ~ ~ ~ `-`" -- Seconded by: _ ~ ' ~ ~ APPROVAL 3 -! Summary: ~S ~ ~~ Design Review Board r Town Planner Bate: '°'~ ~~ (- ~ 6 1. ~ ~ Date DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Iha pelnterywaii Project Application ~ / ~ s /~~ ,Rate , S Pro'ect Name: ~ " _ -" ~ a ~ ~` / ~ r 1 Project Description: ~~~ ~ ~ - t Contact Person and Phone ~`-~"" Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: l ~ 3 Gj' v ~-~- ~-~ %1~ Legal Description: Lot ,Block ,Filing ~ ~~•r-,c.. 01'1 Comments: ' ` ~~ /~ L `~- ~'~`~~ i e~-r1'1 [/yf~ J I ~ Design Review Board Mo#ion by: Seconded by: Summary: ~. ~ v ~ G~ e~ ~~ APPROVAL ~} ~'~ U S a ~ ~~lr' Town Plann~/er Date: ~!~/ -s ~ ~4 . ,Zone ~~ ~` u,~~ n /L Date ~ , ` r pISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Iha prlnlaryrvaVt Project Application . ~~ . Project Name. ~ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~~""~ U o~~.P ~ c-~, h • Owner; Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Date 6 ~~ 5~~~~ / ~ ~°~_.. .~.,. Legal Description: Lot ~ ,Block ~ Filing ,Zone Comments: r~^'~ '°ti ~ ~ /`~+, ~ ~ ~ ~0 L~ r 9 i~'J L'n~ Design Review Board Motion by: ""`~~"` `r Seconded by: ~~ ~ ~'~~' APPROVAL / ~ Summary: "~Yd~-~ ~ ~ T~o G ~~ CJ ~ ~ ~-~ , Town Planner Date: ~ ~I '~~~ s Date ~ Jf S I U DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval the printerywail Project Application (~ ,~ ate i Project Name: j ~ ~ _ ~f 11 -' ~ {~V[ ~ SL° l~ 15 ~ ` J}vlU ~` ! ]~ ~ A~~' y Project Description: t~ f tai Contact Person and Phone ~rn~~ ~~ `A ~ bll[~~ Owner, Address and Phone: ~'~ _ ~1~~r1 S • • Architect, Address and Phone: Legak Description: Lot Block ,Filing ,Zone Comments: ~. ~~ ~~ Design Review Board ,. Date ~ ~ ~~~ ~~ Motion by: Seconded by: ~' - '~" APPROVAL ~ DISAPPROVAL `" ~' Summary: ~ ~ c~- k~n r Date: ^ Staff Approval fhe prlnlaryrvad . r Project Application D to Project Name: ~1 ~ WIN tit V ~ 7~ , 1 ` ~~ `~R~~~ IA~Y 1 _r Project Description: Con#act Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: • Legal Description: Lot Comments: Block Filing ~~~ ~ ,Zone ~~~ tl1 1 f o„~ b/~s1b~ Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL Design Review Board =.mm., '~~Vo -fin 1~MO a~~19K~ • ~~ To n Pla r Date: ~ ~ ~~ DISAQPROVAL ^ Staff Approvai i ~ ~ the pHnlerywa~l Project Application Date ~~/~ 7-~ ~ ~ - Project Name: _/],~ / ~ ~ ~ w ~ ~~ Pro'ect Descri tion: ~Q ~~ ~ ~' ~ ~ Iti ~ T r 'v 1 P -`s--~-'~-t;' Contact Person and Phone -~~~~~ ~C~~/( ~?~" ~~~•~ / Owner, Address and Phone: -~~~/f T.Ut~G"S fm~:-~,~ ; :~Q~J/l1r~,~!"v S'T cJUi f' 7d ~sT ~/, /U~a,va/ Ilr/~(~ Ll(l.~l~~ ,r ~r ! GSQ ,,~~.Jl. ~l/~'~a ~ ~t ~~~ ,~~33 - a~ y~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot G Block ~~ ~f ~ C Comments. ~~`e-- Motion by: Seconded by: c ~ C ~c~ ~~ ~~ ~ f -~~. ~~ Filing llp' - 1~!-.'/~ ,~i ,Zone ~~ ~d ~ ~ ~~~~ ~ o ~~~ l ~ r~ ~~ c ~a ~~ r < Design Review Board APPROVAL r ~ ~~ d Summary, ~- ~-~~ J Town Plan~n/er Date: ~ ! ~ S /~ /J Date ~'~~ DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval iha pd~rarywea Project Application Date Project Name: ~ ~ v ~~~ ~l ~~' Project Description: _/ ~r/~ Contact Person and Phone ~~ f '7 ~ ~~-'" /~ ~ ~` Owner, Address and Phone: i• Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Z II Comments: Block Filing! r ~ ~~~~~ Design Review Board Motion by: Seconded by: '~ APPROVAL ~. ~ ~~ ~ i• Summary: ~~` v ;! ~ 2~e~ c i {/ V [ ~~ TownfPlanner Date: ~ /~ '~` ~~ ~ l Date DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval ~/~s /~6' i ' ~~~~ asp ,Zone the pdnlarywaii Project Application S Project Name: Project Description: __ ~~~~~~~ - ~ Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: i• ~. l v ~ Motion by: Seconded by: ~ ~''t'"- ` ~ APPROVAL/ . ~ - ~ "-` i~ 6 r` S" ~ (f7 Y Architect, Address and Phone: Date ~ /! `~ ~~~ ~ ~-~~..~ Legal Description: Lot ~ ,Block ,Filing V " ` G~ vV~s~~ Zone I ~ ~/ ~` ~ ~ ~ C'r-~~C_ l~v Comments: Design Review Board Summary: ~°°" ~~~ `r /c l ~ " ~ Town Planner Date: ~ `l S~ ~ s Date ~j /~ S r DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval the pdnteryrvad Project Applica#ion _ Date ~ /~ ~ ~~~ r Project Name: ~-/ ~ (f lam) ~ ~ { ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ C'e'' . Project Descrip#ion: Contact Person and Phone ~ t Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments; i• Motion by: Seconded by: ~ ~.~-~ APPROV,,A/L~ ~--- [:/ ~~ ~ ~ Black ~~ Gi9 --~ Filing Design Review Board Date ,Zone ~O /~ 5 /O d DISAPPROVAL 5umm ry: !T' c9 ~ ,~ ~(G '~~ ~~-~[' .~ I7 f.~ .. ~ ./cx-F%C ft-~~ t 'T ~O / ! / tYl~_ ~ ~~ ~i Co ~ / ~ i ~ ~ , ~s ~C /' Town~Plyanner Date: '" ~ S / ~' ^ Staff Approval the pdnleryivail Project Application Date Project Name: ~ ~~~~ Project Description: ,(~ f Contact Person and Phone ~ "e-'! ~- `''~'v~--~ ,r~ (S ~.k] h ! ~ ~ ~(./ t - Owner, Address and Phone: ~ ~`~ ~ G-' `"~ r Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: • Motion by: Seconded by: ~~ S ~ APPROVAL --- (~ /! S ~s~~3 3 DISAPPROVAL Zone Summary: ~ ~""~ ~ I ~-C ~-~ ~ -s ~ C [ r~ nn , f ~i/ 1 /l_JI in ~ W t 12 ~j r9 G~ l C tir3 `1 p /~-- ~/ !'F - v n p~ ~J~ ~M A l~"~f C.v [ ~~1 oC.l ~ ~-- /'i fir- jet ._ _. ~ ~~ ~- Town Plann r Date: ~ I ~ ~,~~ t ~ Block Filing Design Review Board bate ^ Staff Approval r.J c~ ~~ the prlnterywad DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA JUNE 29, 1988 3:00 P.M. SITE VISITS 1:30 p.m. 1 1. Distelhorst/Klawiter Duplex Woodridge Townhomes Motion: Leary ~~~ Second: Santa Approved 4-0 with conditions . ~- -~- ---~---- 2 2. Zadeh Residence Addition Lot 2, Gore Creek Meadows 1st Filing ..~ -~_ ~'~Motion: Santa Second: Leary Consent approval, 4-0 6 3. Langer Landscape Lot 28, Matterhorn Village w-~---~ Motion: Schultz Second: Leary, approval, 4-0 with pitch of gazebo roof no higher than 9:12 _...... - 4 4. Vail Village Information Booth, Transportation - Center zdAled to 7/20 ... _...._~ _...~. __ . ...._. 3 5. Vail Ski Rentals paint 254 Bridge Street --_._ Motion: Leary Second: Santa, vote for approval, 4-0 5 6. Lamont Addition, Lot 2, Blk 7, Vail Village lst fiaoled to 7/20 MEMBERS PRESENT Gwathmey Leary Santa Schultz MEMBERS ABSENT Warren STAFF APPROVALS: Vail Mountain Medical - new sign in back. Pepi Gramshammer Balcony Addition - west elev. Pizza Express - new patio. town of ~aill% 75 south frontage read vail, cotorado 81657 (303} 478-7000 DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA .TUNE 29 , 1988 VAIL TRAIL LAMONT ADDITION - LOT 2, BLOCK 7, VAIL VILLAGE 1ST VAIL SKI RENTALS PAINT - 254 BRIDGE STREET MOLLOY ADDITION -- COTTONWOOD TOWNHOUSE LANCER LANDSCAPE - LOT 28, MATTERHORN VILLAGE D'NARD FUR SIGN - VAIL VILLAGE PLAZA DISTELHORST/KLAWITER DUPLEX - WOODRIDGE TOWNHOUES VAIL VILLAGE INFORMATION BOOTH REMODEL BORN FREE EXPRESS - LIONSHEAD office of community der-elopment MCDONALD'S PAR COURSE SIGNS - LIBRARY TO DONOVAN PARK ZADEH RESIDENCE ADDITION -- LOT 2, GORE CREEK MEADOWS FILING 1ST T.O.V. EXERCISE PAR COURSE LIBRARY TO DONOVAN PARK ALONG THE GORE CREEK BIKE PATH. • Project Application J ~y Date ~ ~n /~ /~ Pro'ect Name: ~} ~~~~+ ~~~~r~ _ ~~~~f t~ Q,~~JU+-~~ll,/ 1 1 ~ ~ - Project Description: Gontact Person and Phone ~.p a ~p ~ r Owner, Address and Phone: ' tom' ~11~`"'~ ~ ~~~f~~ `~'`~~1 Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~, ~J Comments: Motion by: Seconded by Block Filing Design Review Board lpn ~_ AP OVAL ~ - Zone Date ~~ ~ }' k~ C}ISAPPROVAL f ~j,~ ~. Ski ~ .G~ a0 Vi0u5~~ a ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~~~ Summary: l~+ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ _ 1l~ 1 ~ ~ l 1 1 ~nu~~ - . ~yrlm~ f r1DU~ ~ ~ n c~PG~- I n ~ t ~._ ~ ~- ~1 h~_ s~t~t.~N . -- ~~rn~ 'Pla~~~ ~~ T wn Planner ^ Staff Approval Date: ~ ~~ Ih~ prinleryrvatl Project Name: Project Description: Contact Person and Phone r Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Project Appiication ~~ ~ .~ ~ ~ ~~ l C t r I C ~ I !~ ~ ~~-~'e~ri Legal Description: Lot ~ ~ 81ock Comments: Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL i• Summary: ~q Town Planner Date: C~~ ~ /~ Date ~ /~ ~ /~ 6 ~ ~ Filing ~~ ^~/t ~ r~ ,Zone Design Review Board Date ~ /Z ~ /~ t ~ DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Iha prlnteryrva+s h' ~` S • ~ /n .! C~ Project Application Pr 'ect fume: Of Project Description: ~ r'~ # ~'~ Contact Person and Phone __ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: Motion by: ~ '~-- Seconded by: ~ ~ APPROVAL Filing Design Review Board Summary: ~ ,l~s ~~~ Town~/P'l'anner Date: ~,~~ ~ `J r ~~ ~r ~~ /~ Date ~ ~~ ~~Q i ~~fi~ ~ ~e ~..e~rti.~ P .~~' r.~--~--- ~- l .one Date DISAPPROVAL ^ Sta## Approval the prlntary~Vail Rroject Application June 28, 1988 (May 31, 1988, I Date PEC Variance submission.) Project Name: ZADEH ADDITION Project Description: Two level addition to existing duplex unit. Contact Person and Phone David M. Peel, PEEL/WARREN ARCHITECTS, 303-476-4506. Owner, Address and Phone: Firooz E. Zadeh, 5016 Main Gore Drive, Vail, Colorado 81657, 303-476-6559. Architect, Address and Phone: PEEL/WARREN ARCHITECTS. P.O. Box 3370. Vail. Colorado 81658 303-476-4506. 2 Townhouse Site 2, Gore Creek Meadows 1 Res. Cluster Legal Description: Lot ,Block Filing ,Zone Comments: Bower level master bedroom and upper level kitchen/dining area expansion. Addition will add a total of 3 SF of additional GRFA. All exterior finishes, , materials and detailing to match those of the existing building. f•~ Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL Date June 29, 1988 DISAPPROVAL ;~~„~ ~w~ ~~ ~mr~ Summary: (.> ~l 1 Town Pla per Date: Design Review Board ^ Staff Approval the prlnlary+vad DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA JULY 6, 1988 3:00 P.M. 12:30 to 1:30 Public Art Worksession SITE VISITS 1:30 p.m. 8 1. Alverde Residence - remodel details Approved as build - no motion required 6 2. Barn Free Express Tabled 3. D'nairi F Sign ~ -~~ail Village Inn Plaza Motion: Leary Second: Riva Approved 3-0 1 4. Molloy Addition c:o~tonwood Townhomes ~~ Motion: Second: 7 5. Motion: Second: 9<- ~ - Leary Riva Aproved 3-0 Wisenbaker/Hamilton Addition Lot 3i, 131ock 7, Vail Village 1st Leary Riva Approved 3-0 Gralino Residence Lot 1, Block~l, Bighorn 1st Motion: Leary Second: Riva, Approved 3-D 7. Corona Cafe Awning & Signage, Mountain Haus, Vail Village Motion: Leary Second: Riva, Approved 3-0 3 8. SQL ar va; 3_- repaint of building ~` Lot 8, Potato Patch Tabled to 5/20/88 LJ 5 9. Lions Pride - repaint of building Lionshead Motion: Leary Second: Riva, approved 3-0 2 10, Meyer Residence Garage Addition Lot 1, Potato Patch (conceptual review) Cancelled 10 il. Berger Remodel & Garage Addition Lot 5, Block 2, Gore Creek Subdivision Consent approval 12. Betty Ford Alpine Garden: Phase IT Mountain Perennial Garden, Ford Park Consent approval for garden design Sign: Motion Leary, second, Riva, 3-0 approved with condition that staff review final design r 1 LJ MEMBERS PRESENT Leary Riva Warren STAFF APPROVALS: Charlie's T-Shirts - New Window MEMBERS ABSENT Gwathmey Sante • Project Application `'] Date ` ~~ ~~~ I~ Project Name: _ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~'" Project Description: ~~ E ~ ~ ~" ~ ~~~ ~~ r Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: Biock Filing Zone i• ~-~. ~ Motion by: / Seconded by: ~ fl '~ r APPROVAL ~~ ~ Design Review Board Date ~ /~~ DfSAPPROVAL ~ ~C.C~~ L.,, ~- 0~ Summary: ~~?^ ~ f Lei '~ C a7 Ge ~-' -/!'1„~~' ~, _,._ ~ ~~~~ /~ Town Planner bate: ^ Staff Approval the prlnlary~ya~f VAIL TRAIL DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA 3ULY 6, 1988 PUBLIC ART WORKSESSION GRALINO RESIDENCE -- LOT 1, BLOCK 1, BIGHORN 1ST BERGER REMODEL & GARAGE ADDITION - LOT 5, BLOCK 2, GORE CREEK SUBDIVISION SOLAR VAIL, REPAINT OF BLDG. - LOT 8, POTATO PATCH LIONS PRIDE, REPAINT OF BLDG. - LTONSHEAD WTSENBAKER/HAMILTON ADDTTION - LOT 37, BLOCK 7, VAIL VILLAGE 1ST D'NARI FUR SIGN - VAIL VILLAGE INN PLAZA MOLLOY ADDITION - COTTONWOOD TOWNHOMES MARRIOTT'S MARK BUILDING COLOR CHANGE - LIONSHEAD TOWN OE VAIL PAR COURSE MEYER RESIDENCE GARAGE ADDITION -- LOT 1, POTATO PATCH (CONCEPTUAL REVIEW) • Project Application Project Name: MOLLOY ADDITION Project Description: __ COIpT'ONWOOD TOWNHOMES Contact Person and Phone _ ~1ICI1:~Y ;1idPf1:I UNIT 6 Owner, Address and Phone: GAIL MOLLOY 476-2266 Architect, Address and Phone: MI(:~AEL S~tE:R 9l~9679(] Legal Description: Lot .Block Comments: i~ Motion by: LEARY Seconded by: RIVA APPROVAL 3-0 i• Summary: _ Rf1SfIT,A(;K n n Planner Date: ~ /s2/Rg Filing Design Review Board Date 7~~6~88 Date DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Zone lfie prlnlary~vail Project Application Date ~ f t 1,'€'3 Project Name: WISENBAKER ~ HAMILTON Project Description: ADDITION Contact Person and Phone MIKE TENNANT, BOX 1203, AVON 81620949-5640, 949-3098 Owner, Address and Phone: 30HN D WISENBAKER, 5 HERITAGE RESOURCES, INC. 3131 TURTLE CREEK BLVD, SUITE 1.200, DALLAS, TX 75219 r Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot '~~ .Block ~ ,Filing ~r 'iITT.T t em ,Zone Comments: nnnTmTnN 4T MTt1i17.F T.F.SJRT. Design Review Board Date 7 / 6188 Motion by: LEARY Seconded by: RIVA APPROVAL 3-0 , MUST MATCH ~XI STr1~IG Summary: ~ ~~~~ l~ ~ ~~_ f Town Planner Date: ~ /,o ~~~ l DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval the p~lnteryivail Project Application Date Pro'ect Name: ~° ' r ~ ~ 1 Project Description: ~~~ S ~ Contact Person and Phone ~ ~~~{ ~ n ~"' ~`~ n ~- ~~ ~ ~ C~ Owner, Address and Phone: i• Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot l Comments: ~i6i~~ ~ .~/~ ~sfi Bloch Filing Design Review Board Date Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL i• Summary: ~ ~~ Tow~nner Date: ~/~~~ DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval ,Zone the prlnl6rywail Project Application s D to 4,~ Project Name:. ~r~~~-~w ` . - ~ ~. - Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~ ~~ ~ ~~~~ ~f 1 f T~' ~~~ Owner, Address and Phone: i• I• Architect, Address-and Phone: Legal Description: Lot .Block .Filing Comments: ~ ~ ~' ~~ ~ i~~ ~~ ~ - Motion 6y: Seconded by: Summary: Date ~~~~ . 1 --_ APPROVAL Design Review Board Zone Date ~~ DISAPPROVAL ~~ ri.~c~~ ~P~ ~~ ~i~-2 ~~nq it ,O~flr~c1 U ~~ Town Plan ~~ ~ ,~ ^ Staff Approval the prlnleryrvad ' Project Application Date ~!~~! ~g Project Name: ~~~ ~~ ~ ~[- ~>u ~6 r ~ i As~ Project Description: R~ v~}ter ~-' 1 ~ i~~ Contact Person and Phone r~t ~ ~ ~ ` l r i `gv'~ s ~,- ~ 6 • o ~a6 -- Sv ~6 ~3 2 ~ v~ ~~ r ca Owner, Address and Phone: ~UB[n_T ~ L/92l~2 P~ ~r~er ~ l 6 .~' ~ ~1 ? 6 -- S6 f~ Architect, Address and Phone: N!I"} S'po € Laous/~o Irt~J+ V~srt CO ~i6~ Legal Description: Lot .Block ,Filing ,Zone Comments: S~i ~"~ t r-- ~ ~~~ur~ 1~2ow,v S~~~Qd CJ1r2 ~n ~ 5~+ ~ r~s r~~eurs•..~ G~s~t Fs~ lr ~'kt~-1 K N.9~.b ~,a;1 -- S~Te i~,e~y Design Review Board Date ~ 1 ~ ~~~ ~ 6 Motion by: ~ QQ+ Seconded by: ~ ~,'~ ~i ~ APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL ~ ~~ ~~ Summary: 1 1 ~n~~1r~~ ~ tN~- ~~(~~ C ~ W~l~ ~. ~It~~ s ~~~~~, a, ~~- ~~„il ~-1 - ~' • n ~, ~ Town PI nner ^ Staff Approval Date !fie prinlerywa,l Project Application /J I Date 4. `-~ _ ~. ! ~~ ~ aP~ ~~mo~ . Project Narne. f c ` Project Description: ~ ~~Qr' .~ ~ "} IpG~S~a~1?En-I J /~D,~if~ ; ~~ ~i>!/1 ~ f Contact Person and Phone ~- ~~'~~ '`Je Cry r~~~ 7~ ~ 7 f~' ~`f 1(} N Owner, Address and Phone: ~ ~ ~~~ P ~ .~ 113 ~~ ~~ _r ~ ~-iv P_ ~~~ C~.~ ~ ~ ~~' ~ ~ ~ ~ I !~ Architect, Address and Phone: ~ ~~ ~C K ~ ~ 11.x..,1 ~I~,~-~3 ~~ , Legal Description: Lot Comments: • Motion by: Seconded by: ~~~ 4 ~.L~U APPROVAL f3iock Filing Design Review Bvard r~~,c~. ~,~~QR Summary: Date Tow Planner , ~~ ~ (~/(7U,/ Zone Date ~~6~~ DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval the prinlerywail Project Appiication ~~ P.roject Name: ~~~ ~ ~~~~ ~"~ Project Description: Contact Person and. Phone Owner, Address and Phone: ~~ t~ Architect, Address and Phone Legal Description: Lat Comments: J Block i Date ~ ~,~ ~ ~ LiV 3 S~ ~ 1~~ Filing Zone Design Review Board Date f t Motion by: ~~~~~_ Seconded by: ~}``~~ APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL I ~ ~. ~~~~J Summary: S1 Tpwn Plan r ^ Staff Approval Date: ~ ~~ the pAnterywail Projec# Application Project fvame: ~~ ~ ~ ~ J Y ~~ r~ Project Description: - Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: pate / /~ /~~ / ~ y Legal Description: Lot ~ ~ ,Block I ,Fling Comments: ~~ ~ ~ / 0 • Motion by: Seconded by: Design Review Board ,~ w APPROVALy' / , Zane Date ~ ~~ /~ ~ / l DISAPPROVAL Summary: fi"""r ~ ~ ~ Town Planner ti Date: 7 ~~ ^ Staff Approval the prln!®rywait • DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA JULY 20, 1988 3:00 P.M. SITE VISITS 1:45 p,m. - . 2 1. Upper Eagle Valley Water & Sahn. District Gaging Station. Tract B, Vail Lionshead 3rd. Consent Approval Gwathmey 3-0 Sante [7 2. Vail Information Booth Village Transportation Center TABLED 3 3. Food & Deli Awning Vail Village Tnn TABLED TO AUGUST 17, MEETING 5. 4. Willows Exterior Addition Lot 8, Block 6, Vail Village 1st Motion-Gwathmey Second-Sante VOTE 3-0 Approval. 5. Lamont Addition Lot 2, Block 7, Vail Village 1st I ~ Consent Approval Gwathmey 3-0 Sante 4. 6. Sonnenalp Satellite Dish 20 Vail Road Consent Approval Gwathmey 3-0 Saute 7. Chair 8 - Born Free Express Vail Lionshead TABLED TO AUGUST 17 MEETING 1 8. Siverly Garage 27A, Matterhorn Village Motion-Gwathmey Second-Saute VOTE 3-q Approved as submitted with materials close to existing as possible. Site plan to come back to board - siding to match. • 6. 9. Gwopam Residence Cluster Lot 6 & 7, Block 1, Bighorn 3rd No motion necessary Conceptual approval granted. 10. Terrace Wing revised landscape plan Cascade Village Motion-Gwathmey Second-Saute VOTE 3-0 11. Solar Vail Repaint Lot 8, Potato Patch Applicant did not show. i• MEMBERS PRESENT MEMBERS ABSENT Kathy Warren Dan Leary Ned Gwathmey Grant Riva Ray Santa STAFF APPROVALS: Gillette Residence Remodel & Addition Town Residence Re-paint - Lot 5, Block D, Vail Das Schone 1st One Vail Place Remodel • • • Project Appiication Date Project Name: I IIIJJJ Project Descnption: ~~-~'` ~] - Contact Person and Phone ~... i` }~' { t -`~ ~~~ , Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~~~~ 1 }Block ~] Filing t ~ ~1+ ~< ,Zane r + ~` Comments: ,~f1D~`~ ~ Ir~U_ ~G`_!, ~~!)1~~ ~ U~~ W j ~~ _ ~ 1. I1pQd~__vr\ Design Review Board Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL l.~ 1, `~ • Summary: .,~ - `~~~ ~'~ ~r ~ ~~. ~~ ~/ 1~~.. ~~ ~~ own Planner Date: ~ ~~ v Date ~ ~~ DISAPPROVAL ~~ ~ ~t~ ~ 4 ~' ~ ,~. ~, 4 ~ -~.~~,~~ l,r~~~- ~~~ - -~ a n . ~~~ uJ~-~~ '~ ~1- L ~~ C n~ 1 ~In _ ~al~ - - - ^ Staff Approval the prlnlery,va,l Project Application ,Q Date ~ ~~~- ~ ~u Project Name: ~~ ~ ~ ~` I~P~lr ~~ ~ ti ~' ~~~ ! n 4f I ~,J Project Description: Contact Person and Phone • Owner, Address and Phone; Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Block Filing ,Zone Comments: ~ ~`~' ~ l ~. ~ ~ I ~ ~~' ~ II ~1 ~ ~ Design Review Board Date 7 ~~" ~ ,~ r ~ Motion by: 5ecanded by: APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL Summary: ~ /~~ ~~1~! ~ t~+'~c 'S'..~.. ~ ~-~.-~-(f'~~ ~~ w~-c.~ s ~a ` Town Planner Date: ! Z~~ ~~ 7 ~ 1 ~~~ ~. J r sl~~w~J ~ ~ Staff Approval iha printery~~ad SG° ~ Project Application ~~' l~ _ Date ~ / a~ ~~ Project Name: ~~ Project Description: ,-.~ ~.-e-40Ii ~~ I}G ~~ c ~~ ~' Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: v"~ "~ U " ~ ~~ `~~~ /~ ~ / Legal Description: Lot Comments: Block Filing ,Zone Design Review Board ~~ Date ''~ r ~'~ ,/~ /~~ ~~ Motion by: " ~ ~ ~~.~ ~ Seconded by: APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL --- (7 Summary: { ~ ~ v~ ~.~ w r ~~ ~ ~ e~ b ~.~Pi+ti Cam. Y'/~ ~-'S l~-._. a ~, m /.V~' ~4'~ e-v _~~ ~s ~ ` Tawn Planner Date; ~ ~'~ O /~ / 1 / ^ Staff Approval the prlnleryiva;l Project Application Project Name: ~ ~ '~~ti ~ ~ ~~~~ ° r ~ r r ~~~~"~ ~ t s~ h Project Description; ~,~ /'~ ~ /j "~L f 1/ ~ t ~x ,L.. ~l Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Date ~ ~~ ~ ~~~ r< i ~~ Z i Architect, Address and Phone: ~ v ~ ~~' ~ ! ~~ Zl ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ (,~ i rlil I ~ Legal Description: Lot ~ ,Block "~ Filing v V ~ l ` ~ s ~ ,Zone Comments: ~ ~ r• ~~ ~ h ~ m a ~ ~ ~ .~ • Motion by: Seconded by: Design Review Board Date '7 I~-v /U ~~ / ~W N`e- ~a~f~ APPROVAL Summary: Town PI~ er Date: ~ ~ / d DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval Iheprinterywan Project Application , ~ ~ Date ~~~~ ~~~~ Project Name: ~~~ ~v ~~-`~ r T i ~! ~Ar i "-'~ ~L.t~~ ~ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone an~ ~ ~~l + Owner, Address and Phone: ~~ J ~` a~t1.~' - ~ ~ ~ iQ ~ ~~ ~~` '~--- Archi#ect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: n L.J Motion by Seconded by: ~u~ti,~y APPROVAL ~- n Zane Date ~~ ~~ ~~v DISAPPROVAL Summary: ~ • iV6,(~~-. ~~J4-, il(3 C' , h T l ,~i /) ~ll'~ ~ 11~ ~ (`{~M~ 1 ._ ,~~ • ~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~a ~~ ~C~~ ~ ~} ~U~n~ ~ 1 i Town Planner ~n /~~ ~ ^ tact Approval Date: ~~_ \\'~~~~~~ t~'~ \ LtN 1 - u ~~~ w ~~ ~~~, - ,a tt Block Filing Design Review Board ;il 1~ DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA AUGUST 3, 19$8 3:00 P.M. SITE VISITS 2:00 p.m. Art in Public Places Update 2 1. Treetops Condominium Bldg. Exterior Improvements Lot 5, Block 1, Lionshead 1st Filing Motion-Gwathmey Second-Riva VOTE 3-0 With contingency that south facing tower will be stucco. 3 2. Born Free Express Lionshead Tract B TABLED TO AUGUST 17 MEETING 4 3. Hill Building Window Vail Village TABLED TO AUGUST 17 MEETING 4. Siverly Site & Landscape 27A, Matterhorn Village Motion-Gwathmey for approval Second-Riva VOTE 3-0. Contingent upon: 1) 8 trees drawn as "new" shall be new. 2} Final determination as to whether need for drive to be paved will be made by staff. 5 5. Christiania Fence Lot D, Block 2, Vail Village 5th Motion-Riva for approval Second-Gwathmey VOTE 3-0 in favor. 1 6. Working Garage - Conceptual Lot 13, Block 1, Vail Village 6th Conceptual MEMBERS PRESENT Kathy Warren Ned Gwathmey Grant Riva STAFF APPROVALS: MEMBERS ABSENT Roy Sante Dan Leary Marriott~s Mark Resort -Exterior Painting o~ Building Guenther Residence Exterior Repair - L 2, B 7, Bighorn 5th Whitehead Penthouse Gate & Paint - Red Lion Building Upper Eagle Valley San. District - New Fence r • Project Application Date ~r~,, Project Name: ~.ro fin} ~~~ ~~~ - ~.1 VaJ ~~~ ` ~Gf~ ~ , Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~~~, ~l~ 41!"A't'~ ~l - ~~ 4 Owner, Address and Phone: ! ~ )~~~ ' Architect, Address and Phone: t_egal Description: Lot Comments: Block Filing Qesign Review Board Motion by: Seconded by ~~~~ APPROVAL Date DISAPPROVAL Zone Summary:...~~~~~`h ~~~141~' 'f'~' 1~ ~1 ft ~~ . Town Planner Date: ~~~~' ~ ~~ `~ ^ Staff Approval thv prinlery+vail Project Application ~~ Project Name: Project Description: Contact Person and Phone r e 1.3 ~~~Ot ~~ r~ ~~ ~~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~ ~ ,~ Comments: • Motion b ~~ ~~_ ~~``~""~ Y / Seconded by: ~`^ ~ ~ APPROVAL °-'- [~ Date `~ /`-~ ~~~ ~~ ~ ~ .cam ~~~ r i ..~ Filir~ ~t'~-_~~ ,Zone Design Review Board Summary: ~`~~~f 7~- '°S 'e ~` ~ ~~/~~,G~ / S L~--~-C~ tf'"~- 1, ~ ,~ F... ?^ ~ a~v-~ tee,. t- , ~ ~-,~ ~. ~~ ~ ~a ~ J ~ . Town Planner Date: ~ /~ ~~~ 1 Block Date D4SAPPROVAL ~~. ~.~ ~7~'cll., /p' lit r .~ v `-~ ^ Staff Approval the yrlnfsryrvad Project Application ~f~-,~/ Date ~ ~~ ~r'1 Y i ~ ~ r Project Name: ~ ~ [ .S'7`~'~ r~.~ f r r ~':~ ^ !/tJ !1' ~~ ~'"" ~~'~Q.~'~(, ~ ~ Project Description: ~ G~-g`el' ~-~_-~~~`~ F:~ Gt .~ i ~ ~ ~~ U Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: yr' , ~/ ~ ~'~~ ~ !'• Architect, Address and Phone: ~~ ~ ~• Legal Description: Lot Blo ck ,Filing Comments: ~' ~ ~ / ~-~ / ~ ~ ~" ~ .?~-~h~ ~-- r~ , Zone . Design Review Board Date ~r3 /~~ Motion by; ~ ~ ~ ~ Seconded by: ~ ~-% ~- ~ APPROVAL``Si DISAPPROVAL --- V Summary: ~-- /,~i'~ ~ f ~~ ~--f`3 ~,! y /_~ s ~~_ -- 1 Town Planner ^ Staff Approval Date: ~/ ~ ~~~ ! ~ the Arlnlar7fwaiV DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA AUGUST 17, 1988 3:00 p.m. SITE VISITS 12:00 p.m, 10 1. Sonnenalp Beauty Spa Awning Sonnenalp Hotel Motion for approval: Gwathmey Second: Leary Vote: ~-0-1 12 2. Anthony Vernon Sign and Awning Vail Village Inn Phase IV Motion for approval: Gwathmey Second: Leary Vote: 4-0 U 13 3. Smith Residence Pool and Deck Lot 1, Block 2, Vail Village 6th Tabled to August 31. 8 4. Plaza Lodge Repaint Vail Village Motion to allow staff to make final decision: Riva 2nd: Leary Vote 5-0 7 5. Hili Building Expansion Vail Village Motion for approval: Gwathmey Second: Leary Vote 5-0 16 6. Chair 8, Born Free Express Lionshead Motion for approval: Gwathmey Second: Riva, Vote 3-0-2, Leary, Sante abstain No signage approved • 1 7. Williams Residence Lot 5, Bighorn 4th Mation: Gwathmey Second: Riva, Vote 5-0, conceptual approval i• 14. 8. Working Garage Lot 13, Block 1, Vail Village 6th Mation for approval: Gwathmey Second: Riva with condition that blue spruce will be replaced. Vote 3-0-2 (Leary & Sante abstaining) 15 9. Bachrach garage Lot 13, Block 9, Intermountain Mation for approval: Riva Second: Sante Vote 5-0 17 14. Mountain Tees Sign Placement Lionshead Motion for approval: Sante Second: Gwathmey, vote: 5-0 2 11. Davis Residence Lot 17, Block 2, Gore Creek Subdivision Motion for approval: Riva Second: Gwathmey, vote, 5-0 4 12. Buckley Residence Addition Lot ?, Block 2, Vail Village 13th Motion for approval: Riva Second: Sante Vote: 3-0-2 6 13. Averch Addition Lot 12, Block 6, Vail Village 7th Motion for approval: Gwathmey Second: Sante, vote: 5-0 • i• 3 14. Ammer Deck Lot 19, Block 5, Bighorn 5th Motion far approval: Gwathmey Second: Leary vote: 5-0 11 15. Food and Deli awning Vail Village Inn Phase II applicant did not show 9. 16. Information Booth Vail Transportation Center Motion for denial: Riva second: Gwathmey, vote 5-0 5 17. Town of Vail Bus Barn Town Shops Motion for approval: Sante Second: Gwathmey, vote 5-0 18. Town of Vail Signage Program Motion for approval: Riva Second: Sante vote: 3-2 {Leary and Gwathmey against) 19. Gore Creek Stream Improvements (discussion only) Tabled MEMBERS PRESENT A11 present STAFF APPROVALS: MEMBERS ABSENT Mountain Tees Sign - 42 x 16 double sided 42 foot frontage total Maui Traders Sign - painted wood, 24" D circle Seasons Sign {formerly Rudolph's) - 35 x 15 white background navy letters Halpert Residence - all exterior finishes to match existing Project Application Date ~~ ! roject Name: JJ ~~3 ~ ~~ f3~~ ~~~'' Project Description: ~ ~~ ~ !~ ~ c-~' ~`'~L 4 C~~ Contact Person and Phone !._i4'~ t ~~`-""~ Owner, Address and Phone: i ~r ~'~T'~ ~ S ~~~ ~~ ~~' Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~~ Block °~' Filing ~ l _ ~R~ b ~~ `Zone Comments: Motion by: ,~ Seconded by: ~~t-.%~-i.~/t~ APPROVAL Design Review Board ~~ Summary: Date: Town Planner Date DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval the prlnlaryiva~l Project Application C~~ ~ Date ` Pro'e t Name: ~~~~~ ~~ ~ '~ ~''"' 't ~ ` t ~ ~~`~ Project Description: n ~J Contact Person and Phone ~~~{ t! - ~ ~10~~ Owner, Address anti Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ,Block ,Filing Comments: ~ ~ ~v~-N~~~ %~ ~~ ~ g~ r ~~ ~ ~~ -~ ~~ ~ .~ Design Review Board otian b " ll~"` ~ ` ~~~%~ M y Seconded by: APPROVAL ~~ Summary: ~~~ I~~1~~. ~ ~f~ ~~ ~ ~~ ~' _ ~~, Town Planner Date Zane DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval the prlnlerywai~ ~;: Project Application } l Rate . ~l ~~ 1~1 ran I~`i ~'~ _ ~ ~lV~ ~~rl1~Cl~ ~-e~~ ~C~ r Project Name. ~ , ~ ~ ~ _ Project Description: ~-~" r ~11t'~ ~ ~ ~. 1 - . Contact Person and Phone ~~ y~ ~~~~ ~ T ~~~_ ~~• ~ Owner, Address and Phone: ~~~~~ -- ~t y~~~~ - ~'~ ~ ~ ~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: 111 i• Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL Block ~ Filing ~~~ ~~ ~ ~ - ~ ,Zone Design Review Board Date ~~ E~ ~l f DISAPPROVAL ~l ~~ ~~~,a~Q ~~~00 ~~- ~ Sumrrmary: r. ` ~ - - ~~ Y ~~~ - ~. !~ , _, ~fl _ Town PI er ^ Staff Approval Date: K ~ ~ ~~ ma wmrorr: ve~i Project Application ~Cjr/C ~ ~ Project Name: ~'% ~~~`~-~ ~ // U ~' Project Description: ~' ~' / ~ Contact Person and Phone ~ F~~ ~ ~~ N ~~ Owner, Address and Phone: i• I• Architect, Address and Phone:' Legal Description: Lot Comments: Block Filing ~~ Date ~~ Zone Design Review Board Date Motion by: l`~ ~~'"~_~"~ Seconded by: ` ~ '~'~~ , APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL Summary: ~ C ~~ ~~j^ f~ (l 1 ..5' C D~1 ~~. ~ ~- ~..1 ~ ~ l l ~ f~ ~o ~-~~ U U ~/ ~ s ~~~ ~ Town Planner Date: d I ~ 7 / " r / ^ Staff Approval the prlnlerywa~~ Project Application Date Q / r ~ I" r Project Name: Project Description; ~~ l~~ Contact Person and Phone ~hJ ~ IE~ ~ P C~~Q'. G' ~ 7` 7 (`~ '- Z ~ .3 Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: ~,,c,_ r Legal Description: Lot 1 ~ ,Block ~ Filing ~ rn®C.~/,.~lGt ~~ne Comments: Design Review Board Da#e Motion b ~~ ~`~~~ y ~ Seconded by: ~~ ~ ~-- APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL .~ Summary: ~ ~ ~ ~ Town Planner ^ Staff Approval Date: ~/~ ~ ~/~~ !fie prlnlary~ vaJ Project Application Date ~~~ ~ /~~ Project Name: ~~- ~ 'r't ~ ~ ~ ~ / Project Description: ~ L ~~"' l Gontact Person and Phone !'"~ ~ ~Yr`t ~ '~ " `~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ,Block / Filing ji /~ done Comments: ~1~re--i~ ~ LG G~- C-°-t:~-d.~ A~ f ~ 'TC~ ~ r yJ .~ Design Review Board Date ~~ ~/ / ~~ `e1 f ~ Motion by: Seconded by: ~{'1r APPR©VAL DISAPPROVAL -~ Summary: r%~ S f~~ f~- Town Planner ^ Staff Approval Date: she prinlerywaVt Project Application Project Name:. ~ ~ _ Project Description: /~~ ~~ ~4 ~ I ~~ "_ (':,i n+fl r+ 17d~enn anrl-~i?hnna ~fl~f ~~'~~~IV_~[/L.IP_-_f filing . r.~ m~. ~''~~ , _ Design'Rer-iew Board.. G ` p f/ ~~ a ~ -' ~ Date 0 I ~~ I d v r ~~ 4~ Date ~~~ ~7l s . ~ 1 /~.~ ~' Project Application ~~ Project iVame: U~c C ~ ~( ~f' ~ ~/ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~~h ~c , ~ . ~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~ ~ Comments: bate Block S Filing ~ ~ S Design Review Board Motion b ~~" ~J "~ 1w-~`~1 y l Seconded by: ~ ~ ~ ~t-- r APPROVAL ,S--C7 Date DISAPPROVAL ,Zone Summary: ~ 6~1 ~ Gt' r Z 2~ Ut ~ L~ / ~_ d lam` D C-~ 1 ~ ~ ~ ~ /~? 'E'_ y/ ~( ('S G22t Town Planner ~ Date: ~/~ ~ , ~~ l ^ Staff Approval o/~~~~e' the prin[eryrvail Project Application j ~i'~ Date ~ ` ~ ~~1 Project Name: ` / ~I ~t~ ~ ,1~ ~/~" I (~ IV ~ c 1 1"~ ~ I!~' Project Description: _ v- ~~~!' ~- [/ ~ I ( ~. ~, ..-~.~_. i Contact Person and Phone ~• i~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: Filing Design Review Board Motion by: ~~ t ~- 6`' Seconded by: ~ ~ "" ~ ' L ~~ APPROVAL Summary: ~ { - Town Pl~an"ner Date: ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ U r t Block Zone Date d ~` f ~~~1 I DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval The peinteryivad Project Application ~ Date -~ ~~~Q ~~ v~~~ ~~ t Name. ~t"" ` '~'^'~ - Pro~ec .Project Description: Contact Person and Phone , [~'~ ~ r'`~ _. ~~~ ~~Y ` Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ,Block Filing Comments: i• Design Review Board ~- Motion by: ~~ Seconded by: APPROVAL S~' Zone DISAPPROVAL Summary: n_ I• Date: .z Town Ian r © Staff Approval fhe prlnteryrvad Project Application ~R ~ ^, ~~ Dat~ Project Name: ~ !~ ~~ ~ld~ ~i i, -'^"` 't W~C_~IV~' Project Description, - Contact Person and Phone ~Q~~ ~ `~ . Q ~• .~,v~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Desc~tio`~~~ Comments. ~ L Block ~i ~ ~ S ~ ~ ~I~~_ Filing ~~ z ~~~~ Zone Date : ,. Design Review Board Motion by: Seconded by: ~C1_1~Q `:~~ , APPROVAL M DISAPPROVAL ~, r~yi { { )~ ~~'m.•~~ aU~;~ YeUaulu~~~~ S~~c ~A11 ~~l»ls 91~..-~1~ ~~s ~~, . ~. • ~... o.. ~r~j~ ~_ ranmw } 9wt FamI~p ^ Staff Approval the prirtteryrvail i• i• 1:15 P.M. Work Session: 1. World Championships approval process 2. Vail Information Booth 1:30 PM Site Visits DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA August 31, 1988 3:00 PM 1. Vail Information Booth, Village Parking Structure Motion for approval, Gwathmey. 2nd, Sante, vote 5-0. (Windows on north side as submitted. Recommendation that swinging doors be strongly considered. 10 2. Smith Residence Pool & Deck Area, Vail Village 6th, Block 2, Lot 1 Gwathmey. 2nd: Sante Vote 5-0 Motion for approval: 5 3. Cascade Club North Elevation Landscaping Plan Motion for approval: Gwathmey, 2nd, Leary, vote 5-0 7 4. Lionsquare Lodge, Lionshead, Color Change Motion for approval: Sante, 2nd Gwathmey, Vote 5-0 9 5. Galt Entry, Gore Creek Plaza Entry Motion for approval: Riva. 2nd Gwathmey. Vote 5-0. i• 2 6. Eve's Print Shop Sign, Vail Das Schone Motion for approval: Gwathmey. 2nd: Sante. Vote 5-0 i~ 8 7. Vail Village Inn Directory Sign, Vail Village Tabled i• i• 1 8. Talon Reroof & Color, Lionsridge Motion for approval: Gwathmey. 2nd: Sante. Vote 5-0 3 9. Raub Reroof, Lot 5C, Vail Ridge Tabled 4 10. Anderson Residence, Lot 8, Block 9, Yntermountain Conceptual only. 6 11. Montaneros Repaint, Lionshead Motion for approval: Gwathmey. 2nd: Riva. Vote, 5-0 12. Williams residence, Lat 5, Bighorn 4th Motion for approval: Gwathmey. 2nd: Sante. Vote, 5-0. MEMBERS PRESENT MEMBERS ABSENT Ned Gwathmey Dan Leary Grant Riva Roy Sante Kathy Warren STAFF APPROVALS: Hank Outdoor Ropms Maitland duplex, repaint Cleaver's sign, LH Center Amphitheatre bike racks Freedman rood repair Clark residence, 586 Forest, repaint i• • DESIGN REVIEW BOARD :~...I+,lil' i ~ . ~; ~ ~ .~: 1:15 Work Session: World Alpine Championships approval process Vail Information Booth 1:3.0 PM Site Visits 3:00 Public Hearing 1. Vail Information Booth, Village Parking Structure 2. Smith Residence Pool & Deck Area, Vail Village 6th, Block _ 2, Lot 1 3. Cascade Club North Elevation Landscaping Plan 4, Lionsquare Lodge, Lionshead, Color Change 5. Galt Entry, Gore Creek Plaza Entry 6. Eve's Print Shop Sign, Val Das Schone 7. Vail Village Inn Directory Sign, Vail Village 8. Talon Reroof & Color, Lionsridge 9. Raub Reroaf, Lot 5C, Vail Ridge 10. Anderson Residence, Lot 8, Block 9, Intermountain 11. Montaneros Repaint, Lionshead Rroject Application Date _ ~~1(1i~~ Pr~i ~~ ~- Project Name: ~' ~~~~ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~} `~ ~ ~ Owner, Address and Phone: l't`d' ~ !~~~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: l_ot ~ Block ~ Filing ~l~ ~ ,Zone Comments: S Design Review Board < Date ~ ~ ,l~ Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL Summary: ~n~~ ~ ~( ~Il l?al~ll~ N ~~ ~I~ r V 'Town tanner ^ S1aff Approval Date: IM prinlary~ vap Projec# Application 'Project Name: ~~![~ ~~~~ ~ ` ~~""~'"' Project Description: L rj~ Contact Person and Phone .{ ~ ~~ ~ ~~ ` 4~.~..~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: Black Filing r1 Motion by: ~ .1 yl Seconded by: ~„ APPROVAL ~~ Summary: t -- . , ~j wn Plan er Date: Design Review Board ~ ~~d Date Date DISAPPROVAL ~ Staff Approval done 1ha prlnleryrcalf i~ , . ~~ Project Name: Project Description: Contact Person and Phone 3 i• i• Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Project Appiication ~ 13> ~~ Date / ~ Legal Description: Lot Block .Filing ,Zone Comments: Design Review Board Date ~~ Motion by: ~~ Seconded by: ~Q ~ ~~~ APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL Summary: r0 a ~ ~L C ( ~ (~~ i-t1~ ~--~J~ /~ tf , ~ ~{ r h,,/ !~ ..rz_s.-~G- -e--v~ lam, o ~ ~~ C~ ~ ~ a ~ ,lU[ Q 1~! S G r ! ~ri ~~~ ~ ~_ Town Planrre~ri i ^ Staff Approval Date: ~/ ~ f `~ the prlnlerywa4l ~~ {~, Project Name: Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Project Application Date ~/~ / /~~ L ~ /'~! yl. fi ~~ ~ C ~ ~ ~ Architect, Address and Phone: ,r- ~~~ ,Zone Legal Description: Lot 61ock ,Filing Comments: . Design Review Board ~l/U ~%l f7~h~~ Motion by: ~ Seconded by: ~~ ~~~ APPROVAL ~`~ ~~' V e Summary: ~ ~~~~ ~~~" ~ ~ ~' ~~.~' ~-~ _ Town Planner Date: ~ ~'~ ~ ~~~ l l Date DISAPPROVAL /~ ~ ~ ® ~ 1~'-!L fi~.r~! ..SAC 9 /n_ 1 ^ Staff Approval the prlnleryivad Owner, Address and Phone: Project Application p~ ~i Date a ~-3 ~ o ,~v.m. Lianlywa~ No~f~ ~~~ ~,L.,a.. Project Name: ~ U- Project Description: ~o~.~P..oo,.aP~o~o J<-fI 8,a1~.,~~ Contact Person and Phone ~'- ~ ~"~~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ,Block Filing Comments: Design Review Board Date Motion by: ~ ~ ~ ~'p~ Seconded by: ~ f'`J a"~ ~`~ APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL .~ (~ Summary: ~~~^ ~ ~`~ ~~ ~~~~ Zone ~-~ L o~~ v ~ ._ r ~l `L.., 0 ~'L. ~U !~ _ ~2 o~A GAT ~, rG~ /"~~,. ~JL . 11 ~ ~ ~ ~ f/ / ~:- s ~~ Town Planner ^ Staff Approvai Date: u I ~ / /~~ the prlnlery~~ad Project Name: Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: • Project Application Date ~ ~ ~ Black Filing Design Review Board Date Motion by: !5.,~. Seconded by: ~ ~ ~~-e APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL ~"'_.~ zone Summary: +~ t U l L ` ~-~i~/~ ~ Cam' 1~1 ~ ~ ~e~t 4~~ ~.a-~/l v ~ L f C L.Li2~~ ~: ,/~ ~ ~; /~ S r~- Town Planner ~] Staff Approval Date: ~ ~ lha prinlarywaJ Project Application ~ /~ Date Project Name. ,/ Project Description: ~~ v` ~ ~~~'~'1 `~~ d ~ ~ ~ -' Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments; 6 ~z 9 ~d~d~ ~ ~ ~~ l Block Filing Zone Design review Board Date ~Gu ~-~)'1'~ L Motion by: _ l Seconded by: ` ~~ ~ ~'~- APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL ~~ _ Summary: d%J /J GL 0 ~'L 4~ f'~-' c ~ t,(~- C n-dl[--v ~.I' J' ~C1t`~7trr .~ W ! ~ ^,T [ .~/~t ~ G'~-e~ V f^..1 Cc J s 9 r/~7 et ~! jj~ ,~ i` ~ U ,f l/U ' '1~ J7 ~C.....~i ' [ cl r J , Town Planner ^ Staff Approval i r ~ ~ ~- ~--/ Date: 6 ~/ /~ /f} f~ Ihp ptlntery,va~i ,~~ DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA SEPTEMBER 7, 1988 3:00 P.M. SITE VISITS 1:15 P.M. 7 1. Lund, primary/secondary, conceptual review of a request to separate units, Lot 4, Block 4, Vail Village 3rd. Conceptual. No separation warranted due to lack of site contraints. 2. Piper/McKibben Duplex Motion-Santa Second-Riva VOTE 4-0 Changes to Bldg. permit plan elevations. see bldg. permit drawings for approved elevations. 3. Gwopam, cluster subdivision site plan and architectural review. Motion-Santa Second-Leary VOTE 4-0 Approved as revised - add 3 spruce, 10'-12' one south side each building (1,2,3) 4. Gold Peak Nursery - color revision Motion-Riva Second-Leary VOTE 2-0 (2 abstentions) Approved as submitted. 5 Anderson Residence Lot 8, Block 9, Intermountain TABLED F 3 6. Raintree Sign Variance TABLED 5 7. Lot 13, Block 7, Vail Village 1st, Residence Motion-Riva Second-Leary VOTE 3-~. Approved as submitted and revised. b 8. Lot 26, Black 7, Vail Village 1st, Residence Motion-Leary Second-Saute VOTE 3-1. Appprove as submitted. 8 9. Tivoli Lodge Hanson Ranch Road i• Motion--Saute Second-Leary For approval with siding on stair enclosure. Landscape lighting to come back. Details on railings & rock cap. ~U~ v-o 2 7.0. Ricci Addition Lot 5E, Vail Das Schone Motion-Saute Second-Riva VOTE 3-1 ~ 11. Colorado Insight - Color Change Vail 21 Building MationwLeary Second--Sante VOTE 4-0 consent i• 1 12. Domino's Pizza Awning & Signage Vail Run Building Consent 13. Raub Re-Roof Lot 5C, Vail Ridge TABLED MEMBERS PRESENT: Kathy Warren Dan Leary Rcy Sante Grant Riva STAFF APPROVALS: MEMBERS ABSENT; Ned Gwathmey Bishop & Company Display Case - Mill Creek Court Building Beard Residence, Revised Landscape Plan - Lot 46, Glen Lyon R • • • Project Applica#ion Rate Project Name: ~+~~~ ~~~` ~~ ~" ~ ~ ~ ~n~~ 1 Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Ownor, Address and Phoner~/_~ -' ~~, ~Y ~Q~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~, Comments: I• Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL ~ ~ Filin ~' ~~ ~~ ,Zone ~~ ~ Bloc 9 Design Review Board rn~~l~c~c~~~ . Summary: "" dKy~~~"~ ` W ~ PUNS ~~ yTown Planner Date: o.,. al ~ DISAPPROVAL lark at nd~ ^ Staff Approval tho pdnlaryiva~l Protect Application Project Name: ~~~t~' ~ ~~ - ~~~~ y ,~ V l~~ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone • Date DISAPPROVAL } Summary: ~D Q - ~~' ~~~~~` ~ _ ~ ~ , ~ 1,~"~~" ` 1 f 1 • Owner, Address and Phone: ~ - ~~ ~~~ - - ~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: ;~~ v,~im~b~ ~o~~w,~ Block Filing ~~~~~~~~~ ~ ,Zone Design Review Board Motion by: ~~~(4 ~ Seconded by; ~j~~ y APPROVAL l ~ Date ~~ ~ To n. a ner ~~ j ^ Staft Approval the prinleryrveu ._ ~h Project Application Date C _/ ~ / ~~ t ~ ~} V ~ Project Name:~~IIVOS ~ ~ Z ~n"~- /~/K?/fj/~ "~ ~t~ /V ~.!~ p Project Description: ~~R'F ~~~ ~~ ~ ~~ V~ ~ Pf-rc1 N 1 ~V r` ~~{ ~ r, ~~ ~~~ ,, y • Contact Person and Phone ~ ~ ~~ ~ • ~~~~~ "' ~~~~ ~ ~~ ~ ,~~f ~ u.~ ~d l~ y68'-- ~ 7 sq Owner, Address and Phone: ~~ v/p ~0 /~ ~O• !~~ ~ ~ ` ~~~ . ~f /V~ ~QQ/VE- • r Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Block Comments: ~~~` • i• Motion by: Seconded by: Summary: ~5~~ APPROVAL °~ Filing ~~ Design Review Board ~'S Town Planner Date: ~ ~ ~ ~~~ r~ Zone O,J/~~ Date ~ ~~ ~~~ C ~ '~ DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval the prinlerywail Project Name: Project Description: Contact Person and Phone i• i• Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Project Application Date /~ l~~ ! C.~ ~ ~- L°.~ Legal Description: Lot ~ ,Block Comments: Motion by: Seconded by: Summary: ~~.h~~ ~ t l G\ APPROVfAL ~' ! Filing , Design Review Board ~ ,~.~ ~. ` Town Planner/~ Date: ~ ~ ~ ~'~/ ~" ~ ~ Date DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval iha prlnlerywad Project Application Project Narne: t r ~ V t~~ f ~~ ~ yI Project Description: r ~ lc ~.-~ Contact Person and Phone ~ ~ L- ~"'~ y Owner, Address and Phone: U '" GI ~-- /`-C /i Architect, Address and Phone: Date r ~ Legal Description: lot Blnck Filing /~ ~. ~-~, fZone Com ents: ~t ~-~~f J yj ~~l .1'v7 ~CS~" c~'L,~,~/L-e.~,G,...~ ~. ~ Design Review Board Date Motion by: ~ ~ ~ Seconded by: ~--~" `' APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL }f 7 Summary: '~ ~ ~s~ _ _ Town Planner ^ Staff Approval Date: ~/ /~~ ~j r tha prlNeryrvad Project Application Date Project Name: ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ c_) //" Project Description; Contact Person and Phone ~ CR.~C Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot /~ ,,, ~ ,Block Filing Comments: ~'/ `~-'b't--,C_ % - ~..-f~-C.~ ~ C?~(1 ~ 3 ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ Design Review Board Motion by: f Seconded by: ~ ~~"~,~~ APPROVAL r (~ Summary: S To1wn Planner ~/ Date: ~ / ~ Z'/ ~4 Date DISAPPROVAL ^ Staff Approval ~1~~~ Zone tha pAnlery;vall I` • SITE VISITS 1:00 P.M. 5 1. 8 2. 3. 4. 3 5. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA SEPTEMBER 21, 1988 s:ao P.M. Antlers repaint Antlers Condominiums Lionshead Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary VOTE 3-0 Approved change. Casino Building Sign and Accent Paint Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary VOTE 3-0 Approved as submitted. Anderson Residence Lot 8, Block 9, Intermountain Motion-Leary Second-Gwathmey VOTE 3-0 Approved as submitted and revised. Born Free Express Sign Variance - ~ .~ Motion-Gwathmey Second-Warren VOTE 2M0-1 Approved with 14' letters an wording. Raintree Sign Variance ~ S~- Motion-Leary Second-Gwathmey VOTE 3-0 Denied due to noncompliance with sections 26.16,020 & 16.16.040 of the Town of Vail Sign Code. ` i ~s 6. Raub Re-Roof 2680 Davos Trail Motion-Leary Second-Gwathmey VOTE 3-0 Approved as submitted. 7 7. Colorado Insight Sign Consent - letters pre fob & applied. 10 8. Kennelly Duplex Color Change Lot 3, Block 1, Vail Village lst TABLED TO OCTOBER 5 MEETING & 9. Lionshead Center Bay Windows Motion-Leary Second-Gwathmey VOTE 3-0 Approved. 4 10. Cheney Residence Design Change Lot 3, Block 3, Intermountain Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary VOTE 2-0-I {Kathy) Approved. 9 11. Tivoli Landscaping Motion-Leary Second-Gwathmey VOTE 3-0 1). Landscaping (Tabled to October 5th) 2). Design change re-rock on building ~~ 2 12. Wilson Addition Lot 11, Block 1, Potato Patch Consent 1 13. Plattner Addition Lot 3, Potato Patch 2nd Filing Consent Landscape plan submitted & approved later. 12 14. Hansen Addition Lot 12, Block 2, Vail Village 13th Motion-Leary Second-Gwathmey VOTE 2-0-1 Contingent upson submission and approval of landscape plan. 11 15. Chester New Residence Lot 19, Block 1, Vail Village 1st Conceptual only. MEMBERS PRESENT: Dan Leary Kathy Warren Ned Gwathmey STAFF APPROVALS: MEMBERS ABSENT: Roy Sante Katz Residence Re-paint - Lot 13, Block 1, Vail Village 13th Vail Racquet Club - Clubhouse addition/restaurant remodel Moritz Addition - Lot 13, Block 1, Potato Patch 1st Forget-Me-Not Sign formerly Dranbui - Bell Tawer Building • n LJ T0: Design Review Board FROM: Community Development Department DATE : ~ ~ t~mber~2~1 f ~;19~8~, SUBJECT: A request for a sign variance for the Born Free Express APPLICANT: Vail Associates, Inc, T. THE REQUEST Vail Associates, Tnc. is proposing to locate the Born Free Express at the base of Vail Mountain,at the location of the old Chair 8. Due to the fact that the Town of Vail sign code does not specifically address this type of structure, it is necessary for Vail Associates to request a variance to the signage on the lift structure. The signage for the Vista Rahn in Vail Village went through a similar variance process. Vail Associates requested a total of 47 square feet and the Design Review Board, due to concerns expressed by a neighboring property owner, approved a reduced signage program that consisted of 32 square feet. The proposal for the Born Free Express is identical in size to the signage that was requested for the Vista Bahn, with the inclusion of three Vail Associates logos. The request is for 3 each Born Free Express signs of 16 inch letters, for a total of 42 square feet, 3 each Vail Associates, Inc. logos, for a total of 12 square feet, and 3 each numeral 8 16" letters for a total of 3 square feet. When added up, these signs create a total square foot signage request of 57 square feet. The east, west and north elevations of the Born Free Express would each contain one Vail Associates logo, one Born Free Express sign, and one numeral 8 for a total signage of 19 square feet per elevation. II. FINDINGS AND STAFF RESPONSES Before the Board acts on a variance application, the applicant must prove physical hardship and the Board must find that, A. There are special circumstances or conditions applying to the land, buildings, topographer vegetation, sign structures or other matters on adjacent lots or within the adjacent right-of- way which would substantially restrict the effectiveness of the sign in question; provided, however, that such special circumstances or - conditions are or enterprises draw attention businesses or Staff Response unique to the particular business to which the applicant desires to and do not apply generally to all enterprises. Staff does feel that the Born Free Express deserves special consideration due to the fact that it is a structure and use that is not addressed in the Town of Vail sign code. The Barn Free Express must be easily identified by many visitors to Vail who are often unfamiliar with the layout of the ski mountain and the base area. Staff considers the Born Free Express to be a special circumstance that is unique to the business of running the ski resort. The new signage communicates effectively the name of the lift without drawing undue attention to-the structure. The proposed signage is in scale with the lift structure. Staff believes that there are special circumstances which justify allowing this signage for the Born Free Express. B. That special circumstances were not created by the applicant or anyone in privy to the applicant. Staff Response: Some type of variance is necessary in order to allow any type of signage for the Born Free Express. Staff does feel that the Born Free Express is a special circumstance. C. That the granting of the variance will be in general harmony with the purpose of this title, will not be materially detrimental to the persons residing or working in the vicinity, to adjacent property, to the neighborhood, or to the public welfare in general. Staff Response: The 57 square feet of signage is compatible with the intent of the sign code. Distribution of 19 square feet per elevation is in scale with the building and presents the information adequately. The code states: Section 36.16.010 Harmonious with Town scale. Sign location, configuration, design, materials and colors should be harmonious with the majestic mountain setting and the alpine village scale of the Town. Section 16.16.020 Not dominating. The sign should not visually dominate the structure to which it belongs or call undue attention to itself. Section 16.16.140 Architectural Harmony The sign and its supporting structure should be in harmony architecturally with the surrounding structures. Staff feels that the signs are in harmony with the purposes of this title. D. The variance applied for does not depart from, the provisions of this title anv more than is required to identifv the applicant's business or use. Staff Response: Staff agrees that the proposed variance is within the general intent of the sign code. Signage must be visible from several sides of the structure, as skiers are arriving at the lift from many different _ directions. The Signage is also in scale with the size of the structure. TII. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: The Community Development Department recommends approval of the 57 square foot sign variance for the Born Free Express. Staff agrees with the applicant that there are special circumstances unique to this particular structure due to the fact that the name of the lift must be clearly identifiable to skiers in the general vicinity of the Born Free Express. Staff believes that the Signage on the Lift is in compliance with the Town of Vail sign code and provides necessary identification for skiers. • TO: Design Review Board FROM: Community Development Department DATE : ~ ~~~ 8 8' .~ SUBJECT: A request for a sign variance for the Raintree Inn APPLICANT: Vail Holdings Group, Inc. I. THE REQUEST The Raintree Inn is requesting a sign variance in order to amend the design of the existing signage currently displayed at the hotel. The current signage was approved through a variance procedure by the Town of Vail several years ago. The variance received was for size (90 square feet allowed}, height (as existing} and number of signs (2, one "Raintree Inn", one "Best Western"}. The Raintree Inn has now ended their Best Western affiliation and therefore is eliminating that sign from the building. They are requesting to maintain the existing height allowance, and existing size allowance, and amend the design to a double-sided projecting sign as is shown on the attached drawing. ' II. FINDINGS AND STAFF RESPONSES Before the Board acts on a variance application, the applicant must prove physical hardship and the Board must find that, A. There are special circumstances or conditions applYinq to the land, buildings, topographer vegetation, sign structures or other matters on adjacent lots or within the adjacent right-of- wav which would substantially restrict the effectiveness of the sign in question; provided, however, that such special circumstances or conditions are unique to the particular business or enterprises to which the applicant desires to draw attention and do not apply generally to all businesses or enterprises. Staff Response The circumstances that apply to the Design Review Board and Town Council's original findings in the granting of a variance of size and height for the size for the Raintree Inn have not changed. The Raintree is not proposing r~ to increase the size or • the design. So we fees apply and feel that the these criteria. B. That special circumstan~ the applicant or anvone applicant. Staff Response: the height, merely amend that these conditions do application responds to yes were not created by in privy to the Special circumstances were not created by the applicant. • C. That the granting of the variance will be in general harmony with the purpose of this title, will not be materially detrimental to the persons residing or working in the vicinity, to adjacent property, to the neighborhood, or to the public welfare in general. _. , Staff Response: - While this application represents`signage that is grossly above and beyond the allowances of the sign code, staff feels that the granting of the previous variance for size and height laid the ground work for this change in design. During the original variance application for the Raintree Tnn, there was much discussion involving the size and scale of the building, its highway orientation and the general business orientation and climate for the West Vail area. Staff and Council at that time discussed amending the sign code and adding a special section for the West Vail area. A subsequent de-annexation alleviated the urgency of this project. Staff feels that many of those conditions discussed at that time are still valid, and therefore the staff is comfortable with the proposal. D. The variance applied for does not depart from the provisions of this title anv more than is required to identify the applicant's business or use. • Staff Response: Again, this application does greatly exceed the provisions of the sign code, yet, in previous discussions of the Raintree Inn and the West Vail area in general, we have felt that this size and height of signage is not more than is required to identify the applicant's business or use. III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Several years ago, the staff spent a great deal of time working with the West Vail businesses and the Town of Vail sign code. A lot of time and discussion was involved in the original Raintree Tnn variance that was subsequently granted by the Design Review Board and the Town Council. This variance determined the allowable size and height of the existing signage at the Raintree Inn, This application does not amend the height, or size but changes the design. The staff is therefore supportive of this request. We would like to note, however,.. that in our review of the application, we did feel that the original variance approval was, in part, based on the design of the existing sign as a wall sign. It is our belief that a wall sign is much less obtrusive that a projecting or hanging sign, especially at the magnitude of size that is being currently requested by the applicant. While the • criteria for a sign variance does not address this specific design, we would like to point that fact out to the Design Review Board and remind you that that is a legitimate factor in your review of this application. • ~oject Name: Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Project Application ~ ~ ~ ~ l Owner, Address and Phone: i Architect, Address and Phone: t ~c'1~ 4 `p-'i ~ ~``~ Legal Description: Lot Comments: ~=~ ~~~ ~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ 9/z 1 ~~y Date ____ ~sL~ Block ,Filing ,Zone ~ ~ ~o ~~ ~ Design Review Board Date Motion by: Seconded by: !' f ~ ~-~ ~'`Q APPROVALp DISAPPROVAL s.-1- / Summary: ~~ ~ Town Planner ^ Staff Approval Date: ~~~~/ ~~ -` Iha pdnlerywad Project Applica#ion ~~ Date ~ /~ ~ / r ~ ~ . lect Name: ~~ ~ ~ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~ _. ~ h- ~~~ ~ ~~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot .Block .Filing ,Zone Comments: r1 f~J Motion by: Seconded by: `-~~-'~-, APPROVAL Design Review Board Date ~l Z ~ /~~ DISAPPROVAL ~~~ Summary: ~~ 'e•~ ~`~ e~-~I ~~ s Town Planner Date: ^ Staff Approval the pdnlary+val Project Application jest Name: ~U ~ ~ ~ ~ L f~ l Project Description: ~~ * ~ ~~ .~"~'-~~ Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: Date ~ /~~ /" c i ~. 4) ~ -~i ~~ UQ ~ ~-f ~~~~ . Block ,Filing/ / O ~` yC ~ ~ ~ G~ ~ L ~"G • Motion by: s ~ ~ ~`-e~ Seconded by: "`- APPROVAL Design Review Board Summary: ~ ~~ ~--/~ C~ C c~ GJ ~ ~ ~ ~`~.~~ o~ ~- ,~~~! n ~' ~~ .~ -~. Town Plan{n~er Date: ~ ~~ ~ /~v l ~ Zone Date 4 ~~ /~` biSAPPROVAL J ^ Staff Approval the prinlerpvad Project Application Date 'ect Name: ~` + ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ c;~C ~1 ! 0 ~ ~~ ~ ~ Project Description: ~ ~ ~"` / ~ ~~ ~" ' ~'y Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: ~~ ~ti ~v ~ ~ ~~ `~. Architoct, Address and Phone: ~ ~2 ~ ~~` G f f~ Legal Description: Lot ~ { .Block ,Filing ` D ~ ~~` ,Zone Comments: fti.r Gt,/~j j~~ Motion by: l ~, _ r Seconded by: ~-~"--~ !~. -~ f APPRO~AL -~ CJ Summary: ~! ~ ~~ Town PI ner Date: ~ ~~'~ ~~ Design Review Board Date D 15APPROVAL ©Staff Approval the prlnlerywaJ Project Application Date ~~ /Z ~ ~~~ .~ i ~oject Name: -~ ~ r ~ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ~ Block ~ ,Filing ~~~ ~ l Comments: Design Review Board Date Motion b ~~~--~ ~.-.:T ~U+...~.- Y ~ Seconded by: .~ APPROVA~ DISAPPROVAL Summary: ~'{'N1 ,t ~~{d ~--'~~ "7'ir~~l ~ I c~R Town Planner Date: ~~ /~"` ~' .~ ,Zone ~. ^ Staff Approval the yrlnlrrywail •oject Name: "~I~~ /l ~~ Project pescription: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Pro}ect Application Date ~ ~2 ~ ~" ~~ Architect, Address and Phone: f fr'~`~`~ Legal Description: Lot I ~ ,Block 2~ Comments: _/~.~-- r rc9-~ ~~ ~ S--v ~~i ~ e ~ ~ ~/~ ! ~ ~ Filing ,Zone design Review Board ~'~"~ Motion by: Seconded by: ~"" -~ / APPROVAL ~!' mac.-- ~--.` ~ """ ~ Summary: 'y ~~ /~ _,/ /I ~'i vC_ . r~L c9 i1 ~/ /~ ~'e p~ ~fiCJQ ~t~-e.'? ~ w ~~Fas~ i ~; q ~ s<~ ~ Date DISAPPROVAL ~-~ c 7 .cam ~c ~C o n ~~ - - ~ of _ ~~ ~ Town Planner Date: ~r ~' ~ ~~! -6 ^ Staff Approual the printeryrvail DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA OCTOBER 5, 1988 3:00 P.M. SITE VISITS 2:00 P.M. 1 1. Town of Vail Parking Lot: Ford Park 4 2. Slifer Deck Mill Creek Court Building TABLED TO OCTOBER 19TH MEETING • 5 4. Holiday Inn Satellite Dish TABLED TO OCTOBER 19TH MEETING 2 5. Kennelly Color Change Lot 3, Block 1, Vail Village 1st TABLED TO OCTOBER 19TH MEETING 0 3. Appeal Staff interpretation; Banner for Vail Hockey Club. Motion-Gwathmey - overturn staff interpretation with understanding that time & schedule be as described in applicant letter, 1988-89 season only, banner not take precedent over previously approved or displayed banner. Second-Santa VOTE ~-0 ~r VAIL TRAIL DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA OCTOBER 5, 1988 HOLIDAY INN SATELLITE DISH KENNELLY COLOR CHANGE - LOT 3, BLOCK 1, VAIL VILLAGE 1ST TIVOLI LODGE LANDSCAPING CHESTER RESIDENCE - LOT 19, VAIL VILLAGE 1ST TOWN OF VAIL PARKING LOT: FORD PARK SLIFER DECK - MILL CREEK COURT BUILDING APPEAL STAFF INTERPRETATION; BANNER FOR VAIL HOCKEY CLUB * NEW BUSINESS: DRB REPRESENTATIVE FOR WORLD CHAMPIONSHIPS • COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT DEPT. JANEIL TURNBULL SEPT. 29, 1988 i "~roject Name: Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Project Application / ,p~ Date ~ 6 / 5~~11 ( t' G~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: 81ock Filing Zone Design F~eview Board Date ` d / S /~ r Motion by: ~ ~ Seconded by: ~~ ~~'~ r r APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL `"~ ~ Summary: Y~ ~ ~~ ~ (x~ .~''s r G[_ ~7 ~.J Yh't ~C If ~~a? -3 ~ -~' ~~-c~ ^ Staff A / / To/wn Planner pproval . Date: C ~/ Sam/ C ~ Nepdptery~~a~~ ~roject Name; Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Project Applica#ion _/~ Date ~ ~~~~/ ~~ _ - - - Architect, Address and Phone: r Legal Description: Lot Comments: Motion by: Seconded by: _" Block / Fling ~~ t~~! ~ f 5 7 Design Review Board ~ ~ '7~~ C// GtJ' Cv~'~1 h-~ C APPROVAL ,Zone Date l a~~`~t~d DISAPPROVAL 4~. Summary: ~ ~ ~"l~1 G~ ~T f~ ~ /~ t ~ I ~ ~~~ ~ Town Planner Date: ~ O / S~~d f ^ Staff Approva€ tha prinleryrvail i • SITE VISITS 1:30 P.M. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA OCTOBER 19, 1988 3:00 P.M. 1.. Ford Park Parking Lot Motion-Sante Second-Leary 5-0 approved July ].st meeting. 1 2. Gruidel Re-Roof Lot 3, Casolar Motion-Leary Second-Santa Consent 5-D approved. • 3 3. Ricks Cafe Sign Lionshead Parking Structure Consent 4. Kennelly Color Lot 3, Block 1, Vail Village 1st Tabled to November 2nd meeting 5 5. Ferdows Residence Lot 3, Black 4, Bighorn 5th Consent • 2 6. Baskins Addition Lot 4, Block D, Vail Ridge Motion-Santa Second-Leary VOTE 5-0 Approved as submitted and discussed. 7. Mill Creek Court Building Facade Amendments Consent, Ned Gwathmey abstained. 4 8. Gramshammer Temporary Austrian Ski House far the 1989 World Championships, Vail Village Withdrawn • MEMBERS PRESENT Kathy Warren Ned Gwathmey Roy Santa Dan Leary Pam Hopkins STAFF APPROVALS: MEMBERS ABSENT Bryan Hobbs Berkowitz Residence small addition - L 2, B 1, Vail Village 1st Halls Residence stair repair - L 10, B E, West Vail Paul Johnston Resid. remodel - L 2, B 2, Vail Village 1st Zadeh Deck Addition & Stair - L 2, Gore Creek Meadows 1st Vail 21 Rooftop Spa (new} • VAIL TRAIL DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA FOR OCTOBER 19, 1988 FERDOWS RESIDENCE LOT 3, BLOCK 4, BIGHORN 5TH KENNELLY CDLOR LOT 3, BLOCK 1, VAIL VILLAGE 1ST RICKS CAFE SIGN LIONSHEAD PARKING STRUCTURE GRUIDEL RE-~RDOF LOT 3, CASOLAR GRAMSHAMMER TEMPORARX AUSTRIAN SKI HOUSE FOA THE .1989 WORLD CHAMPIONSHIPS, VIAL VILLAGE BASKINS ADDITION LOT 4, BLOCK D, VAIL RIDGE FORD PARK PARKING LOT 3aneil Turnbull Community Development Dept. Oct. 11., 1988 ~J Rroject Application Date Troject Name: ~~~Qr~~ ~~1~,~ L_U~- ~ f~(} ~~ Project Description: ~ ~>"~n~Q.~ Contact Person and Phone 4~ ~~~_ ~ ~. Owner,. Address and Phone: ~ ~' ~• Architect, Address and Phone: legal Description: Lat Block Filing Zone Comments: r S ~ Motion by: ~~~ Jan Seconded by: APPROVAL Design Review Board Date `~~+ I ~ ~ DISAPPRQVAL ~~ ~~+~~ ~• Summary~~~' ~ S rn~~ ~ ~~4~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ a ~~ ~~ in ~ ~ ~ v~~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~ ' ~ 15~ -~~ nr ~~~~ l R ~tit~- 1~~~ ~~ ~~ ))Town Fanner ^ Staff Approval Date: ~~11~ She prinleryrvail Project Application / Date ~C ~ ~~~ Project Name: //~~ j~ j Project Description: v'~u~-b~ ~^" v~~° tek Contact Person and Phone ~D C~~1A 1 0'l G 1 v'L ~ 8+^~ ~~3 '' 1013 Owner, Address and Phone: r'`D C71R„ ~i" ~ ~ J~S~ ~~~~ ~-~" ISO Ul.i-a~YL Co F i J j PY7 U~ Architect, Address and Phone: V ~C'.VC ~O~ ~~S `! ~ 3 ' 7533 ~~` g ~ ~`KSU ~ ~ X03 ov Legal Description: Lot `-~ .Block ~ Filing Comments; Design Review Board Motion by: ~U Seconded by: r~~'t"' ~` APPROVAL ~~ ~ ~ c~ _ ~~ 4 Summary: s Date: l~ _ Town Plariner done Date- ~ ~ ~ _ 4. D15APPFiOVAL ^ Staff Approval ~" Iha prinlery~vail 8 1. Scandinavian Depot Flags Crossroads Center Motion-Leary Second-Hobbs Approval 4-0 6 2. Currents Awning Casino Building, Vail Village Motion-Leary Second-Gwathmey Consent approval 3--0--1, Kathy Warren abstained. 7 3. Gasthof Gramshammer Deck Enclosure: Temporary for World Championships. Motion-Gwathmey Second-Hobbs Approved with conditions ~-0 5 4. Tivoli Lodge Fire Escape Consent DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA NOVEMBER 2, 1988 3:00 P.M. SITE VYSTTS 1:00 P.M. 1 5. Vail 21 Signage Lionshead Consent r 2 6. Banner Sports Storefront Gondola Building Consent 3 7. Banner Sports Awning Sunbird Lodge Consent 4 8. Jewelry Warks Awning Sunbird Lodge Consent 8 9, Brown Residence Garage Addition Consent :7 MEMBERS PRESENT Ned Gwathmey Kathy Warren Dan Leary Bryan Hobbs STAFF APPROVALS: MEMBERS ABSENT Roy Sante Smith Resid. Entry Gate / Lot 1, Block 2, Vail Village 5th Sonnenalp Gate House - West Bldg. Parking Lot Skall Hus Minor Landscape Destination Resorts - Sign on Awning The Talon Trim Color Change Landmark Planter/Sign West Vail Liquor Mart Awning Tech Sport Red Awning / Lionsquare Lodge VAIL TRAIL DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA NOVEMBER 2, 1988 GRAMSHAMMER GASTHOF DECK ENCLOSURE TEMPORARY FOR WORLD CHAMPIONSHIPS CURRENTS AWNING, CASINO BLDG. VAIL VILLAGE LODGE AT VAIL SIGN VAIL 21, SIGN LANDMARK, SIGN SCANDINAVIAN DEPOT FLAGS: CROSSROADS CENTER JANEIL TURNBULL COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT OCT. 26, 1988 s Project Application ~oject Name: ~r-~t 1~~~1~ ~~^" ' Project bescription: " ~~_ ~~ Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: ~~~ `~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: • Motion by: Seconded by: Block (r~v~~ rxLuS2~io ra,Ama Gan~i e$ StdQ y~~-1~33b u) 4~1q- 'i~~-ISSIn - Filing Design Review Board l~{l ~~~ ~ APPROVAL ~~ l l Zone Date ~"" ~ ~~'~"" DISAPPROVAL SummaPry: 1 1_ 1 n t~ L 00 `f1 T ~y, 10lQa~tl, ~I100M d. QDISL~ In ~fU(~l A~K S`~tq~~ ~ ~1pb145 will l02 a-~ ruv~~ t ~ u~ ~~ ~ ~~`~ ,Town Planne ^ Staff Approval Date: ~ L~~ IhB pYInlBrywail Project Application ~Foject Name: LI-~`~~~ ~~~~ "' l ~1~~'(1~/t. Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~`~ ~~~~ ~~+~ `~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: • Motion by: Seconded by: Block Filing Date Zane ~~Sc- ~~ ~cvw ~~n ~1u~1 .- C ~vic~ ~~~C _ ~ Design Review Board ~~ ~~~ APPROVAL ~~ .. Summary: Date: r ~:~ Town Plan r ~~l ~~ Date DISAPPROVAL ~ ~~~ ^ Staff Approval the pNnicrywail Project Application ~oject Name: Project Description: Contact. Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: • D to '~ f~rr~r~t~.~ _ ~v~ ~'n ~st.~ - ulw-l~. ~ ~`~. S~~(uv~i ~V1s~ q Chin-. ~~~ ~~ Motion by: ~~_#~~~ Seconded by: ~~~~~ APPRbVAL Block Piling ' Design Review Board Zone oe~e ~,j~v, a, ~~~~ DISAPPROVAL f ~`~ ~. i~ac~ ~~ ill 1 e ~r,~~_~~~~ ~~~~. ~ ~ r~- ~, i l` ~ Y , f ` .Y 1 U Summar~y:n ~ ~p ~l1, ~1 ~~lA~ 1Cl_ ~ 1 \~~I ~~ 1 Sl~C_. V 111 N~~~ ~`~, p'R )~ ~'~ ~!C k 1 4~ ~ \_I[/I! 1 1 ' ~ 1 ~i~~ ~ ~~-~ t • 3, ~ -~ ~~ Town Planner Q(~ '~^ Staff Approval bate: ~ l ~, y ~ ~ ~ ~ {~,~, ~ Project Application Date 10~21~88 ~oject Name: VAIL 21 ~'SI~f~ Project Description: Sign On south wa11 and sign in~' planter on north side of bldg Contact Person and Phone Geoff Wright 476-1350 Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal bescription: Lot Block ,Filing ,Zone Comments: SOUth sign, 14' high, 23" x 46" = 7.33 sq ft north sign, 3d" x 6d" = 12.5 st~ letter coming of approval from Rosenquist and Srown (~/~ • Design Review Board Motion by: ~~ O ~ 1 Seconded by: - 'r",}l APPROVAL -~- ~! Summary: ~ ~ ~s~~a ~.1~ Town Planner ~ Date: ~ ~ ~ /~~ r' Date ~/~~ DISAPPROVAL ~ Staff Approval 1ha pr~nteryrvail ~u n b ~ ~- ~oject Name: Project Description: Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: ~~.,~'~ e~ t'~-' ~UL n ~1t~-~9 ~~~~++ , [X- L`rn w~ ~,v • Design Review Board Date Motion hy: -~~ Seconded by: ~~ ~'L-~-- APPROVA~ DISAPPROVAL Summary: • g,~sx // Town Planner ^ Staff Approval Date; f ~ ` ~/~ t ~ Project Application Date U ~ ~ /Z/~a t ~ c~,sry~ C~r-~ .$ Block ~? ,Filing ~Zo`ne `ilia-.~ Y~-~ ~-`i~ 6 !~, ~/'~r°. ! L} the priMeryivail ~'ax ~ /~ Project Application Date ~'~ /~`',~ ~rojectName: ~ ~~~'~~ ~~ ~~~~~ ~ ~~ ~~~ ~~ ~- , Project Description:.-~~--~ ~ ~-- ~ ~ h O `T S t Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: ~ ~ ~ ~~ '~ ""~"~ Architect, Address and Phone: G~~~ , I_ Legal Description: Lot Bloclc~f Filing ~'~' ,Zone r Comments: ~~ O i^ S G~K-rE GV car-~L~W ~~ /~- t /! , ~ Gi G-eJh ~ Cs_~ • Design Review Board j / Date Motion by: ~ ~~"`~"~ Seconded by: ~ ~'`~"r~`~'" ~ ' v APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL j~- c~ Summary: ~~/ v f Town Planner ^ Statf Approval Date: ~ ~ / Z/~ Rhs prlrllsry~vail Project Application Date 1 ~ ~ ~/~~ ~/~ f ~ ~ ~ject Name: '~ ((~'Q-, ~~''~L- vt/ ©f'~c~ ~~/1~- vJti-, J /~` .s 1 ~ /1~.~ ~ Project Description: ~ p, c/ Contact Person and Phone ~'_~ ~~ ~~~ i.P~-P. ! ~"a~ `~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legai Description: Lot Comments: Block Filing Zone • Design Review Board Date /~ ~;-~ Motion by: r ~~ ~ ~ ~~'~ Seconded by: l '~ / APPRO1V/AL ~) DISAPPROVAL 7 "~ (~ Summary: ~~ l Town Planner ^ Stafi Approval Date: the prlnts.ywail DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA • NOVEMBER 16, 1988 3:00 P.M. SITE VISITS 2:30 p.m. 1 1. McCue Addition Lot 3, Bighorn Estates (Final) Motion-Gwathmey Second-Leary Vote 3-0 on kitchen addition & deck & trash enclosure. 2 2. Brawn Roof Lot 16, Blnck 1, Vail Village 1st (Final) TABLED 3 3. Hong Kong Cafe - Minor Addition (Final) TABLED MEMBERS PRESENT Kathy Warren Ned Gwathmey Dan Leary MEMBERS ABSENT Bryan Hobbs Roy Sante STAFF APPROVALS: . R & R Barbeque Sign - Vail Run Building Westwind Awning Vail Valley Medical Center New Incinerator Location VAIN TRAIL C J DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA FOR NOVERMBER 16, I9$$ McCue Addition Lot 3, Bighorn Estates (Final) Brown Roof Lot 16, Block 1, Vail Village 1st (Final) Hong Kong Cafe -- Minor Addition (Final) • ~oject M1lame: Project Description: Contact Persan and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Project Application Date t ~~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot `~ Comments: ~. (~6/~~ ~~ ~~~~ h Block ,Filing ~ ~ ~"Y~r ,Zone Design Review Board Date i c ~1 ~ I ~" I / ~ w ~: ~- Motion by: j ~ ,~ ,~ Seconded by: "'`"~ ~ APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL --~-~ Summary: Town PEanner Date: ^ Staff Approval the printeryrva~I • 1. DESIGN REVIEW BOARD FOR NOVEMBER 30, 1988 3:00 P.M. Sign Code Revision TABLED SITE VISITS 1:45 p.m. 1 5 6 2. 3. 4. Koplin Deck Enclosure, Woodridge Townhomes #4 Lots 3,4 & 5, Block 1, Bighorn (Final) Motion-Ned Gwathmey Second-Roy Sante VOTE 5-0 Red Lion Restaurant Signage (Final) Vail Village Consent Ned Gwathmey VOTE 5-0 Second-Dan Leary Lodge at Vail. Sign (Final) TABLED TO DECEMBER 7TH MEETING VAIL TRAIL • DESIGN REVIEW BOARD AGENDA FOR NOVEMBER 30, 198$ KOPLIN BECK ENCL05URE, WOODRIDGE TOWNHOMES UNIT 4 LOTS 3,4, & 5, BLOCK 1, BIGHORN SIGN CODE REVISION SAFEWAX SIGN VARIANCE (FINAL) BROWN ROOF LOT lb, BLOCK 4, VAIL VILLAG 1ST (FINAL) HONK KdNG CAFE VAIL VILLAGE WICKED WEST SIGN LIONSHEAD RED LION RESTAURANT SIGNAGE VAIL VILLAGE GOLDEN PECK CHILDRENS CENTER SIGNAGE GOLDEN PEAK SKI BASE LODGE AT VAIL SIGN VARIANCE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT JANEIL TURNBULL NOV. 22, 1988 • _, ~ a TO: Design Review Board FROM: Community Development Department DATE: November 2$, 7.988 SUBJECT: A request for a sign variance for the Safeway market Applicant: Safeway Stores, Inc. T. THE REQUEST The Safeway Stores are requesting variances from the sign code with regard to the allowed number of signs and the amount of square footage permitted for signage. Safeway would like to add the word, "Marketplace" under the word, "Safeway." At present, the Safeway building has 3 signs. One sign is the "Safeway" sign of 19 square feet and two are logos of 32 square feet each for a total existing square footage of 83 square feet. Safeway proposes to remove one logo of 32 square feet with the addition of "Marketplace" of 19 square feet, thereby reducing the total square footage by 13 square feet to a total of 70 square feet and reducing the number of signs from 3 to 2. In June of 1985, Safeway replaced a rooftop sign with the present "Safeway" wall sign. The application for the new wall sign contained a statement from the Town staff to the • effect that the two remaining logos would require a variance approval or must be removed by December 31, 1985. Before the end of 1985, this area of the Town was de- annexed and was re-annexed on January 28, 198. At present, the number of signs and amount of square footage are nonconforming. In January of 1991, the signage must conform to the Town of Vail sign code, or a variance must be obtained. TI. FiNDTNGS AND STAFF RESPONSES Before the Board acts on a variance application, the applicant must prove physical hardship and the Board must find that, A. There are special circumstances or conditions applvinc~ to the land, buildings, topography1 vegetation, sign structures or other matters on adjacent lots or within the adjacent right-of- way which would substantially restrict the effectiveness of the sign in question; provided, however, that such special circumstances or conditions are unique to the particular business or enterprises to which the applicant desires to draw attention and do not apply generally to all businesses or enterprises. • Staff Response s The Staff feels that the size and location of the Safeway building are special conditions. The staff does feel that when the new sign is in place, it would actually be reducing existing signage and thus visibility. B. That special circumstances were not created by the applicant or anyone in privy to the applicant. Staff Response: The Safeway store was deannexed and then reannexed to the Town of Vail. These circumstances were not created by the applicant. The store will be permitted 2 signs and 32 extra square feet until January 28, 1991 when the sign amortization will end, at which time Safeway must apply for a sign variance or conform to the sign code. C. That the granting of the variance will be in general harmony with the purpose of this title, will not be materially detrimental to the persons residing or working in the vicinity, to ad-iacent property, to the neighborhood, or to the public welfare in general. Staff Response: The following section of the sign code relates to the harmony of the sign: Section 16.16.010 Harmonious with Town scale. Sign location, configuration, design, materials and colors should be harmonious with the majestic mountain setting and the alpine village scale of the Town. Section 16.16.020 Not dominating. The sign should not visually dominate the structure to which it belongs or call undue attention to itself. Section 16.16.140 Architectural Harmony The sign and its supporting structure should be in harmony architecturally with the surrounding structures. Staff feels that the sign change becomes more in • harmony with the purposes of this title, D. The variance applied for does not depart from the provisions of this title any more than is required to identify the applicant's business or use, Staff Response: The amount of signage is being reduced substantially, and will identify the business adequately. Although the staff does feel the other logo should be removed, this will happen when the sign amortization ends. III. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: The staff recommends approval of the sign variance. We feel this request is a step in the right direction, making the Safeway store more easily identifiable, while at the same time reducing amount of signage and number of signs. • • Project Application Date oject Name:. ~. ~1 ~ ~(~ ~11~JI~~I~~~ Project Description: Contact Person and Phone ~l ~Ylv~1,~ll~J~ ~ ~A' ~~!!~? ~~~' ~~~~ ,~/~/1 ~~ 0 Owner, Address and Phone: ~~~~, ~~~`~~ ~~'n ~a8 ~ ~`~ t~ ~ 3 S5~ ~ ~~?~ ~ ~~r ~~ ~ Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ,Block Filing VU~[.~[l ~ one Comments: ~~~ ~~ ""v" f • r.. Nl of i c~n'~'hy: Seconded by: OIL. ~la~~ ~ ~ YV~GC}r~ ,~,~i ~) n , r~l~-!~' ~ma~ r Design Review Board j Date ~ l ~~~~ ~~~~~ ~ NAJV{,~ APPROVAL DISAPPROVAL ~~:o,~ r)~t ~ ,o~ Summary: • Date: r . ~~ t Town Planner ^ Sta#f Approval the pdnlerywa~t Project Application l , ~ Date oject Name: "`~ Project Description: (~}, Contact Person and Phone `~+,'S't~~ ~~~~~ ~~` ~~~ Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot ,Block ,Filing One Comments: ~~ ~~ ~,~~~_~I~ ~ ~ ~~~~~, ~ ~ ~, ~~s ~ _ M Design Review Board w Date Motion by: Seconded by: APPROVAL pISAPPF30VAL cnrco~ n~nuo.4. ~~ ~_ o , Summary: Town Planner Date: ~~ r~~ ^ Staff Approval the prinleryrvail Project Application Project Name: ~ ~ ~'"~ ~~~~~ ~ f ~ `? C Project Description: ~ ~ fSk--~ Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Rrchitect, Address and Phone: Date r j /~ ~! ~~ l , Legal Description: Lot ,,, ~ ~C Slock Filing ,Zone Comments: - ~^-''~ ~ ~~ ~ L~°vz`' ~- C._c~ '~ 'T L b .~-lE h ~L.. ~ r 7~ ~/~V x . ~) - Design Re~iewr Board Motion by: Seconded by: 1 APPROVAL C ~~~~ Date DISAPPROVAL Summary: ~~ ~` ~ Town Pla ner ~U ~~ Date: ~ f ~ .. Q Staff Approval the DriMerywail Project Application . ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~ ~~ s Project Name: Project Description: ~~ ~ ~ ~ Y ~ ,7 - ~~ - ~ ~ !!// Contact Person and Phone Owner, Address and Phone: Archi#ect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot Comments: Block Filing Design Review Board Motion b ~~ Y Seconded by: ~~ ~-°' - ' , APPROVAL --- T] f i~ ~~' r 1 ~l l~ ~ C r ,~ [, 6 ~.. Q Summary: ~~~ ~~ s ~ /~ ~ ~, ~_ Town Planner Date Date C Date DISAPPf~OVAL °I~~~--- ^ Staff Approval Zone Iha priMery,vae • DESIGN REVEIW BARD AGENDA DECEMBER 7, MEETING 3:00 P.M. SITE VISITS 2:30 P.M. 1 1. Borne Duplex (Final Approval) Lot 18. Block 5, Bighorn 5th TABLED TO DECEMBER 21ST MEETING 2. Lodge at Vail Sign Variance (Final} TABLED TO DECEMBER 21ST MEETING C] 2 3. Vail Gear Awning {Final} Village Center Building TABLED TO DECEMBER 21ST MEETING MEMBERS PRESENT Ned Gwathmey Kathy Warren Dan Leary Roy Sante STAFF APPROVALS: MEMBERS ABSENT Bryan Hobbs Zoo-Z-Q Sign - Sunbird Lodge Bridge Street Photo Lab Sign - Otto Stork Building Pizza Bakery Awning - Lifthouse Building The Plaza Lodge Painted Design Around Windows Project Application Date DECEMBER 7, 19$$ sect Name; BORNE DUPLE . PRIMARY/SECONDARY RESIDENCE Project Description. Contact Person and Phone MARVIN LANGER ~+7b-5839 Owner, Address and Phone: Architect, Address and Phone: Legal Description: Lot 18 Comments: ROBERT BORNE 4.108 PINAR DRIVE BRADENTON, FL Block S Filing BIGHORN 5TH Zone PS Design Review Board Date DECEMBER 7, 1958 Motion by: Seconded by: TABLED UNTIL FEBRUARY 1, 1989 ~~~ r3~r~r ~~~~ The Design Review Board had the following comments: 1) The minimum size of shrubs sha11 be 5 gal. 2) Further consideration should be given to reduce the mirror image design. ~n~} Revise elevation drawings to accurately portra9 design intent. !~} Modify parking/drive area - Unit A earace does not have a,~~~iate ar•~P~~- 5) Open area above the storase units would be better utj.,li~Pri ac ,icaii1P f7nnr~,roa (GRFA) and should be enclosed. 6) Rendered elevation drawings should clearly show proposed extenior finishes.. 7) Chimmey stone grace is needed for a=eview (photo of sample}, pattern 8) Please verify that your proposed sb,ingles meet the minimum requirement of 300 Town Planner ^ Statt Approval pounds per. square foot. Date: Pl~~/~~se~//'~~~a///lllse respi/oy~)nd to the above c/~ofmmen//at~~,s~i by 5:00 p.m. ,Tanuary 23, 1989. he rime rv